Krush2k2 Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 Why doesnt the Catholic church excommunicate Nancy Polosi and declare it publically?
CatherineM Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 My best guess would be that they feel like it would be viewed as interfering in the affairs of a foreign government.
Krush2k2 Posted August 28, 2008 Author Posted August 28, 2008 thats retarted-the Church cant allow people at her position to make such false claims and recieve communion
kujo Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1639771' date='Aug 27 2008, 05:34 PM']My best guess would be that they feel like it would be viewed as interfering in the affairs of a foreign government.[/quote] Word. Is excommunicating her the best way to bring her back to the Truth?
mamalove Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1640314' date='Aug 28 2008, 10:13 AM']Word. Is excommunicating her the best way to bring her back to the Truth?[/quote] I see your point, but if that's the case, why excommunicate anyone? You could call it tough love. Maybe it's the [i]only[/i] way to bring her back to the Truth.
kujo Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='mamalove' post='1640355' date='Aug 28 2008, 12:20 PM']I see your point, but if that's the case, why excommunicate anyone? You could call it tough love. Maybe it's the [i]only[/i] way to bring her back to the Truth.[/quote] I'm just asking if this is the best way. I think excommunication is fine, but as a last resort. Everything should be done in order to prevent the exiling of a brother or sister in Christ.
CatherineM Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 We aren't the only country with Catholics in positions of authority where abortion is legal. The church would be in the position of having to excommunicate more people than you can imagine.
kujo Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1640398' date='Aug 28 2008, 01:25 PM']We aren't the only country with Catholics in positions of authority where abortion is legal. The church would be in the position of having to excommunicate more people than you can imagine.[/quote] Word.
CatherineM Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 These things could be done, but they should be done by the politician's home ordinary, or parish priest, not by the Vatican. That way it is pastoral, not political.
dUSt Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1640470' date='Aug 28 2008, 01:20 PM']These things could be done, but they should be done by the politician's home ordinary, or parish priest, not by the Vatican. That way it is pastoral, not political.[/quote] I agree until we come to the point where said person has world influence, such as a president, vp, or leader of a country, etc, etc. When their influence is "universal" then it should be handled by Rome.
atheling Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='Krush2k2' post='1639750' date='Aug 27 2008, 02:22 PM']Why doesnt the Catholic church excommunicate Nancy Polosi and declare it publically?[/quote] Pelosi [i]is[/i] under excommunication, although it is [i]a jure latae [/i]vice [i]a ferendae sententiae[/i]. I wonder why her bishop, who shepherds the radically leftwing San Francisco area, has failed in this regard - and it is his responsibility - not the Vatican's.
Madame Vengier Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='atheling' post='1640490' date='Aug 28 2008, 12:40 PM']Pelosi [i]is[/i] under excommunication, although it is [i]a jure latae [/i]vice [i]a ferendae sententiae[/i]. I wonder why her bishop, who shepherds the radically leftwing San Francisco area, has failed in this regard - and it is his responsibility - not the Vatican's.[/quote] You answered your own question when you said "who shepherds the radically leftwing San Francisco area". Nancy has already bragged that her Bishop and "community" knows of her abortion stance and that she receives Holy Communion "and I have encountered no problems with that there".
atheling Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1640653' date='Aug 28 2008, 01:18 PM']You answered your own question when you said "who shepherds the radically leftwing San Francisco area". Nancy has already bragged that her Bishop and "community" knows of her abortion stance and that she receives Holy Communion "and I have encountered no problems with that there".[/quote] Yes, and I wonder why the Bishop has not moved in light of his work being done for him by Chaput et al. It makes his omission quite glaring.
jkaands Posted August 29, 2008 Posted August 29, 2008 [quote name='Krush2k2' post='1639750' date='Aug 27 2008, 03:22 PM']Why doesnt the Catholic church excommunicate Nancy Polosi and declare it publically?[/quote] Why? Because she's pro-choice? The vast majority of Catholics in the US, let alone Europe, support a woman's right to an abortion at some stage. Should they all be excommunicated?
CatherineM Posted August 29, 2008 Posted August 29, 2008 [quote name='jkaands' post='1641831' date='Aug 29 2008, 03:42 PM']Why? Because she's pro-choice? The vast majority of Catholics in the US, let alone Europe, support a woman's right to an abortion at some stage. Should they all be excommunicated?[/quote] There are a lot of things that I could hold in my heart, but as a Catechist, I am not allowed to publicly state anything contrary to church teaching. It could cause scandal. That's why public people have to be held to a higher standard. It is not as if they accidentally became politicians. I may have been elected president of the women's group because I was stupid enough to miss a meeting, but that's not how senators and congressmen get their jobs. Yeah, they should be excommunicated, not when they say they are pro-choice, but after the first time they vote that way.
mamalove Posted August 30, 2008 Posted August 30, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1641873' date='Aug 29 2008, 06:19 PM']Yeah, they should be excommunicated, not when they say they are pro-choice, but after the first time they vote that way.[/quote] AMEN
Krush2k2 Posted August 30, 2008 Author Posted August 30, 2008 Why does Rome not come down on these liberal Bishops?
rachael Posted August 30, 2008 Posted August 30, 2008 [quote name='Krush2k2' post='1642625' date='Aug 30 2008, 06:52 PM']Why does Rome not come down on these liberal Bishops?[/quote] where did you come from!?!?!
pan!c139 Posted August 30, 2008 Posted August 30, 2008 [quote name='Krush2k2' post='1642625' date='Aug 30 2008, 04:52 PM']Why does Rome not come down on these liberal Bishops?[/quote] I been wondering that for a long time.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now