Roseoftherese Posted August 27, 2008 Posted August 27, 2008 I would really like an explanation of this thread. I know God was taking his revenge on his enemies, but why did innocent babies have to pay for it? This is really bothering me.
StColette Posted August 28, 2008 Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='Roseoftherese' post='1639856' date='Aug 27 2008, 06:34 PM']I would really like an explanation of this thread. I know God was taking his revenge on his enemies, but why did innocent babies have to pay for it? This is really bothering me.[/quote] Psalm 137 for context sake 1 1 By the rivers of Babylon we sat mourning and weeping when we remembered Zion. 2 2 On the poplars of that land we hung up our harps. 3 There our captors asked us for the words of a song; Our tormentors, for a joyful song: "Sing for us a song of Zion!" 4 But how could we sing a song of the LORD in a foreign land? 5 If I forget you, Jerusalem, may my right hand wither. 6 May my tongue stick to my palate if I do not remember you, If I do not exalt Jerusalem beyond all my delights. 7 Remember, LORD, against Edom that day at Jerusalem. They said: "Level it, level it down to its foundations!" 8 Fair Babylon, you destroyer, happy those who pay you back the evil you have done us! 9 Happy those who seize your children and smash them against a rock. [9] Happy those who seize your children and smash them against a rock: [b]the infants represent the future generations, and so must be destroyed if the enemy is truly to be eradicated.[/b] Haydock Bible Commentary The lamentation of the people of God, in their captivity, in Babylon. Ver. 1. For Jeremias. For the time of Jeremias, and the captivity of Babylon. (Challoner) --- Or "of" (Jeremiæ.; Haydock) Jeremias; on which subject he composed his Lamentations, as the Septuagint thus insinuate. (Worthington) --- The title may be a later insertion, and is not the same in all the Greek or Latin copies. It is wholly omitted in Hebrew, &c. Theodoret blames those who have written the name of Jeremias, as he was never at Babylon. (Calmet) --- He might send the psalm to the captives, (Grotius) though it were written by David, (Gerer.) who was a prophet. See Psalm lxxviii. (Berthier) --- The captives express their sentiments at Babylon, (Bossuet) or at their return; (Calmet) and thus, under the figure of the earthly Jerusalem, (Berthier) aspire to heaven. (St. Augustine) --- Rivers. Euphrates, &c. The Jews retired to such places to pray. (Philo, con. Flac.) (Acts xvi. 13.) (Haydock) --- Sion, and all the ceremonies of religion. (Worthington) Ver. 2. Willow. With which the Euphrates was lined, Isaias xv. 7. It passed through the city, which was adored with trees, and contained extensive tracts of land for cultivation. (Calmet) --- Babylon may also include all the territory. (Berthier) --- Instruments. Hebrew Kinnor means properly the ancient lyre, but here it is put for all instruments of music. (Calmet) --- In grief, music was laid aside, Isaias xxiv. 8., Ezechiel xxvi. 13., and Apocalypse xviii. 21. Yet Christians may unite spiritual canticles with holy compunction, Colossians iii. 16. We must not expose the word of truth to the ridicule of infidels. (Berthier) Ver. 3. Sion. The Levites were trained to singing from their infancy, at the expense of the nation. Under David, there were 288 masters, and 8,000 Levites who played on music, 1 Paralipomenon xv. The Babylonians wished to hear them, (Calmet) or (Worthington) spoke insultingly, (Theodoret) as the pagans asked what good Christ had done? (St. Augustine) Ver. 4. Land. they were oppressed with grief, (Ecclesiasticus xxii. 6.) and unwilling to expose sacred things to profanation, though there was no prohibition for them to sing out of Judea, for their mutual comfort. (Calmet) --- They excuse themselves on both accounts. Ver. 5. Forgotten. May all that is most dear to us perish, if we do not serve God, (Worthington) and seek to procure the welfare of Jerusalem. (Haydock) --- Yet they knew that the joy of their earthly abode in that city could not satisfy their desires. They allude, therefore, ultimately to heaven. (Berthier) Ver. 7. Day. When Jerusalem was taken, or when it shall be re-established. (Haydock) --- The Idumeans incited the Babylonians to destroy it entirely, and even cut in pieces such as had escaped, Abdias v. 11., and Jeremias xii. 6. --- But Nabuchodonosor punished them five years afterwards, and Hircanus forced them to receive circumcision. (Josephus, [Antiquities?] x. 11., and xiii. 18.) (Calmet) --- Isaias (xxi. 11.) denounced their ruin, as the psalmist does here. (Worthington) --- St. Chrysostom thinks that the latter expresses the vindictive sentiments of the Jews: but he rather desires that God's cause should be maintained in the manner in which He should judge best. The illusions of our own imagination and vanity are most dangerous and domestic enemies, as the Edomites sprung from the same stock as Israel. (Berthier) Ver. 8. Daughter. Citizens. --- Miserable "plunderer," (Symmachus) or "ruined," (Aquila) or "which shalt be given up to plunder." (Theodoret) --- Cyrus reduced the city to a state of abjection, and it has since experienced other miseries, (Calmet) so that its situation is now unknown. (Haydock) --- Isaias (xiii.) foretold this destruction. (Worthington) [b]Ver. 9.[/b] Dash thy little ones, &c. In the spiritual sense, we dash the littel ones of Babylon against the rock, when we mortify our passions, and stifle the first motions of them, by a speedy recourse to the rock, which is Christ. (Challoner) (St. Augustine) (St. Gregory) (Psalm l.) (Worthington) --- We do not read that Cyrus treated Babylon with this rigour; but such practices were then customary, (Osee xiv. 1.; Homer, Iliad xxii.) and Darius cruelly punished the revolted city. (Herodotus iii. 159.) (Calmet) --- God will reward those who execute his decrees (Haydock) against Babylon. (Worthington) --- The psalmist contrasts the felicity of the conqueror, with the misery of the citizens, without approving of his conduct. (Berthier) Wish I had more time go in depth with this, but this will have to do for now. And it's not God acting here, but the people who are being captured and kept within Babylon.
Roseoftherese Posted August 28, 2008 Author Posted August 28, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1639930' date='Aug 27 2008, 09:17 PM']Wish I had more time go in depth with this, but this will have to do for now. And it's not God acting here, but the people who are being captured and kept within Babylon.[/quote] Hi St. Colette, thanks a lot for your answer! So you mean that God didn't order the dashing of the babies' heads? I thought he did. It was the people, then?
journeyman Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 arguably, this verse fits within the Jewish concept of an "appropriate" response . . . outside the context of the captivity, it appears to be simple vengeance. Since their children were dashed upon the rocks by the Babylonian conquerors, that is "an eye for an eye." The author is probably a temple musician, forcibly uprooted (perhaps with, perhaps not, his family) and transported to Babylon. The captors ask for songs (for entertainment purposes) and all he knows are worship songs (a denigration of his faith). The earliest part of the psalm reflects sorrow for the loss of God's favor (the loss of Jewish independence, the destruction of the Temple, the forcible removal from Jerusalem) . . . one of St. Collette's references suggests that the children of Babylon are a "symbol" of the future generations of Babylon (future captors) who must be destroyed in order to return to Jerusalem (it actually worked out differently, in that the Jews were given safe conduct and a voucher to rebuild in honor of their faithful service - but who knew?) The second reference suggests an even more symbolic interpretation, one in light of the Christian interpretation of the Old Testament, that the children of Babylon are our passions, our temptations, our sins . . . which are vanquished when we have recourse to Christ (and His Church . . . Peter - aka the rock) (or I could be extrapolating well beyond the meaning of the text)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now