atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 (edited) From Dominicansoul: [quote]Haven't we had presidents in the past with fewer "experience?"[/quote] Excellent point! Harry Truman was a bank clerk, farmer, National Guardsman and HABERDASHER! (The last which was his own business, giving him some executive experience - but it proves that he was NO DC insider and part of the good ole boy network). Thankfully, not a lawyer! Edited September 1, 2008 by atheling
kujo Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 I will cede the point: Palin's executive experience (2 terms as mayor of a town of less than 8000 people as well as her 2 years as governor of Alaska) is more than Obama's, who experience is [b]zilch[/b]. And yeah, Palin is an attractive candidate (pun SOOO intended); however, I don't think her time has come yet. Her pro-life record is AWESOME and she seems like a good woman. But she, like Obama, is simply far too inexperienced to be president or vice president. I haven't done research to substantiate the claim that Hillary supporters will not support McCain and Palin. I base my decision on an old adage that my high school civics teacher told me: 9 times out of 10, party affiliation is the indicator of who people vote for. Thus, the majority of her supporters being Democrats, they will eventually come home to Obama...or simply not vote at all.
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1643669' date='Aug 31 2008, 07:16 PM']I will cede the point: Palin's executive experience (2 terms as mayor of a town of less than 8000 people as well as her 2 years as governor of Alaska) is more than Obama's, who experience is [b]zilch[/b]. And yeah, Palin is an attractive candidate (pun SOOO intended); however, I don't think her time has come yet. Her pro-life record is AWESOME and she seems like a good woman. But she, like Obama, is simply far too inexperienced to be president or vice president. I haven't done research to substantiate the claim that Hillary supporters will not support McCain and Palin. I base my decision on an old adage that my high school civics teacher told me: 9 times out of 10, party affiliation is the indicator of who people vote for. Thus, the majority of her supporters being Democrats, they will eventually come home to Obama...or simply not vote at all.[/quote] Well the Veep position is an understudy one, and she will learn about being President while she serves at VP. It's interesting to note that Margaret Thatcher had NO foreign policy experience when she became the Tory leader. She immediately surrounded herself with historians and advisors who were well versed in foreign policy and experience. She was a quick study, and proved herself to be a formidable Prime Minister, particularly in foreign affairs. I think Sarah Palin is similar, in that she is smart, capable, and willing to learn. When you consider her rise - from PTA member, to City Councilwoman, to Mayor, to State Governor, that's a meteoric rise for a person who NEVER was involved with insider politics or the "network" in DC. She always ran on a platform of reform, and she accomplished that by going after corruption within her OWN party, as well as the opposing ones. She cut taxes, cut wasteful spending, and dumped pork projects in her state. We need a mover and a shaker to reform DC. That's why I'm excited about her. She has a proven track record for [b]change[/b], instead of just talking about it.
kujo Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='atheling' post='1643694' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:41 PM']Well the Veep position is an understudy one, and she will learn about being President while she serves at VP. It's interesting to note that Margaret Thatcher had NO foreign policy experience when she became the Tory leader. She immediately surrounded herself with historians and advisors who were well versed in foreign policy and experience. She was a quick study, and proved herself to be a formidable Prime Minister, particularly in foreign affairs. I think Sarah Palin is similar, in that she is smart, capable, and willing to learn. When you consider her rise - from PTA member, to City Councilwoman, to Mayor, to State Governor, that's a meteoric rise for a person who NEVER was involved with insider politics or the "network" in DC. She always ran on a platform of reform, and she accomplished that by going after corruption within her OWN party, as well as the opposing ones. She cut taxes, cut wasteful spending, and dumped pork projects in her state. We need a mover and a shaker to reform DC. That's why I'm excited about her. She has a proven track record for [b]change[/b], instead of just talking about it.[/quote] I can't help but be amused at the quick turn around in the mindsets of conservatives who were screaming that Obama was inexperienced. I don't think of the VP as an "understudy" or apprentice...they are a vital member of the President's administration, a person who is literally 1 heartbeat away from being the President of the United States. While it's true that they will learn the ins and outs of the White House during their tenure as VP, they'll also be the President of the Senate and be second in the line of presidential succession. It's not an internship. I am not putting her down...it's just not her time. Peace.
abercius24 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 (edited) We also have to remember that Presidents and Vice Presidents are visible figureheads for the unseen leaders behind them -- those who are truly the ones with power. If those in power sought to trust someone like Palin with the work the intend to forge in the next 4 years, then that is a very encouraging future that should include positive change or moral overtones. We'll see just how much room they will give her to bring about those positives changes, but I don't see her as being someone who won't fight for the room she needs to make things happen. Edited September 1, 2008 by abercius24
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1643703' date='Aug 31 2008, 07:48 PM']I can't help but be amused at the quick turn around in the mindsets of conservatives who were screaming that Obama was inexperienced. I don't think of the VP as an "understudy" or apprentice...they are a vital member of the President's administration, a person who is literally 1 heartbeat away from being the President of the United States. While it's true that they will learn the ins and outs of the White House during their tenure as VP, they'll also be the President of the Senate and be second in the line of presidential succession. It's not an internship. I am not putting her down...it's just not her time. Peace.[/quote] Obama has no EXECUTIVE EXPERIENCE. Sarah Palin DOES. I put that in caps because that has been stated here over and over and over again and yet you [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod] simply don't get it. Do you know what executive experience means? Why are you so obtuse and contradictory? In one sentence you say that the VP position is not an "understudy" or apprentice, then in another you say that they will "learn the ins and outs of the White House during their tenure". What is that supposed to mean? Your contradictory statements make no sense and serve only to undermine your credibility, which is seriously strained as it is. Secondly, your perception of what the VP does is quite incorrect. The VP is NOT a vital member of the administration. As John Adams put it, when he served as VP to George Washington: "My country has, in its wisdom, contrived for me the most insignificant office ever the invention of man contrived or his imagination conceived". You first come to this board making flippant, unsubstantiated assertions, which you then admit. Next, you make nonsensical and contradictory statements. What next? And you claim to be a Catholic? We are formed by our conscience, reason and truth, not by lies and cavalier statements simply for the fun of it.
kujo Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='atheling' post='1643722' date='Aug 31 2008, 11:05 PM']Obama has no EXECUTIVE EXPERIENCE. Sarah Palin DOES. I put that in caps because that has been stated here over and over and over again and yet you Obamatons simply don't get it. Do you know what executive experience means? Why are you so obtuse and contradictory? In one sentence you say that the VP position is not an "understudy" or apprentice, then in another you say that they will "learn the ins and outs of the White House during their tenure". What is that supposed to mean? Your contradictory statements make no sense and serve only to undermine your credibility, which is seriously strained as it is. Secondly, your perception of what the VP does is quite incorrect. The VP is NOT a vital member of the administration. As John Adams put it, when he served as VP to George Washington: "My country has, in its wisdom, contrived for me the most insignificant office ever the invention of man contrived or his imagination conceived". You first come to this board making flippant, unsubstantiated assertions, which you then admit. Next, you make nonsensical and contradictory statements. What next? And you claim to be a Catholic? We are formed by our conscience, reason and truth, not by lies and cavalier statements simply for the fun of it.[/quote] Wow. So, I'm an "Obamaton?" I'm not sure what that means, but if it means that I am voting for Obama, you are mistaken. I haven't decided who I am voting for yet and will probably either vote for McCain or Bob Barr. Understand that just because I defend a candidate from stupid attacks [i]does not[/i] mean I support him/her. I think that Obama has some good ideas and some horrible ones. Secondly, I would ask you to check your attitude at the door [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod] Thirdly, I think we can certainly all agree that the role and responsibilities of the Vice President have changed since John Adams served the post. Finally, I would have to say that you have [b]no right[/b] to question whether or not I am a Catholic. You don't know me as anything more than an avatar on a screen. [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod]
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1643731' date='Aug 31 2008, 08:13 PM']Wow. So, I'm an "Obamaton?" I'm not sure what that means, but if it means that I am voting for Obama, you are mistaken. I haven't decided who I am voting for yet and will probably either vote for McCain or Bob Barr. Understand that just because I defend a candidate from stupid attacks [i]does not[/i] mean I support him/her. I think that Obama has some good ideas and some horrible ones. Secondly, I would ask you to check your attitude at the door [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod] Thirdly, I think we can certainly all agree that the role and responsibilities of the Vice President have changed since John Adams served the post. Finally, I would have to say that you have [b]no right[/b] to question whether or not I am a Catholic. You don't know me as anything more than an avatar on a screen. [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod][/quote] [mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod] Ad hominems. Inability to defend your position. Contradictions. As for "tough guy", you're the one blustering with the namecalling, not me. I simply pointed out your flaws in your arguments, which you don't even have the honesty to address or examine. Excuse me, but I thought you were a Catholic. Pardon my error.
kujo Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='atheling' post='1643737' date='Aug 31 2008, 11:18 PM'][mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod] Ad hominems. Inability to defend your position. Contradictions. As for "tough guy", you're the one blustering with the namecalling, not me. I simply pointed out your flaws in your arguments, which you don't even have the honesty to address or examine. Excuse me, but I thought you were a Catholic. Pardon my error.[/quote] Don't mistake my lack of motivation for inability. And, as I have said for the [b]THIRD TIME[/b] now, Palin has more executive experience than Obama, who has none. Finally, I am a Catholic. I don't need to prove that to you. I'm done with this thread because my next responses will either get me warned or suspended.
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1643745' date='Aug 31 2008, 08:21 PM']Don't mistake my lack of motivation for inability. And, as I have said for the [b]THIRD TIME[/b] now, Palin has more executive experience than Obama, who has none. Finally, I am a Catholic. I don't need to prove that to you. I'm done with this thread because my next responses will either get me warned or suspended.[/quote] That's a good reason to refrain - fear of punishment rather than from some kind of Christian principle.
abercius24 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='atheling' post='1643722' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:05 PM']Obama has no EXECUTIVE EXPERIENCE. Sarah Palin DOES. I put that in caps because that has been stated here over and over and over again and yet you Obamatons simply don't get it. Do you know what executive experience means? Why are you so obtuse and contradictory? In one sentence you say that the VP position is not an "understudy" or apprentice, then in another you say that they will "learn the ins and outs of the White House during their tenure". What is that supposed to mean? Your contradictory statements make no sense and serve only to undermine your credibility, which is seriously strained as it is. Secondly, your perception of what the VP does is quite incorrect. The VP is NOT a vital member of the administration. As John Adams put it, when he served as VP to George Washington: "My country has, in its wisdom, contrived for me the most insignificant office ever the invention of man contrived or his imagination conceived". You first come to this board making flippant, unsubstantiated assertions, which you then admit. Next, you make nonsensical and contradictory statements. What next? And you claim to be a Catholic? We are formed by our conscience, reason and truth, not by lies and cavalier statements simply for the fun of it.[/quote] The Vice President in Adam's time did not have as much influence as he/she does today. (By the way, I think it's pretty cool that I can include "she" in that statement.) Today's Senators are members of committees and subcommittees that hold SUBSTANTIAL influence in foreign policy, national security and global affairs. They are responsible for (if not leading) those "covert government actions" you hear about after the fact. They are also overseers for all bureaucratic offices and the policies that are enforced therein. The current political infrastructure of the Senate is eon's more complex than in Adam's day. As Vice President, Palin will be very much involved in such ongoings of the Senate and will have McCain's ear on any issues that justify a Presidential veto. Be assured, Obama has more to lose than the Presidency if he later has Palin looking over his shoulder at the Capital building. Edited September 1, 2008 by abercius24
MakeYouThink Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='atheling' post='1643737' date='Aug 31 2008, 09:18 PM']Well, you certainly behave like an Obamaton. Ad hominems. Inability to defend your position. Contradictions. As for "tough guy", you're the one blustering with the namecalling, not me. I simply pointed out your flaws in your arguments, which you don't even have the honesty to address or examine. Excuse me, but I thought you were a Catholic. Pardon my error.[/quote] Kujo is my friend, and so, I would ask you not to be insulting. He is a Libertarian, like myself, and he has some morals. God wants us to live clean in this world, and it isn't what we put into our mouths that make us unclean, but what comes out of them. Your words sound very much like - [quote]Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, and have not charity, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing. And though I bestow all my goods to feed the poor, and though I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profiteth me nothing.[/quote] I consider you the Catholic Version of Budge. Do you have any love in your heart for the suffering people in the world Atheling? Do you not care that they are being destroyed more and more by governments who care more about business than the people? Can you speak any kind words to anybody?
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='abercius24' post='1643754' date='Aug 31 2008, 08:25 PM']The Vice President in Adam's time did not have as much influence as he/she does today. (By the way, I think its pretty cool that I can include "she" in that statement.) Today's Senators are members of committees and subcommittees that hold SUBSTANTIAL influence in foreign policy, national security and global affairs. They are responsible for (if not leading) those "covert government actions" you hear about after the fact. They are also overseers for all bureaucratic offices and the policies that are enforce therein. The current political infrastructure of the Senate is eon's more complex than in Adam's day. As Vice President, Palin will be very much involved in such ongoings of the Senate and will have McCain's ear on any issues that justify a Presidential veto. Be assured, Obama has more to lose than the Presidency if he later has Palin looking over his shoulder at the Capital building.[/quote] What??? You mean to tell me that our earliest Senators and Congressmen didn't have committees and subcommittees? Oh please! Right now, I'm reading a biography of John Adams, which gives detailed descriptions of the founding of our nation and the Continental Congress [i]had[/i] committees and subcommittees. The newly formed Congress of the United States [i]had[/i] committees and subcommittees. And they were all involved in foreign policy and national security! Goodness, they even had delegates and ambassadors! They had secretaries and cabinets! The only thing that has changed is that our government has become a bloated bureaucracy with LOTS more committees and subcommittees. But the essence has not changed. And why, pray tell, is the John Adams quote so well known? Because it still holds water! Anyone who knows history and American polity understands this! It's an ongoing joke in political circles.
abercius24 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 I think everyone may be taking things a bit too seriously here. Such a positive historical event should not be seen as a reason for Catholic brothers and sisters to fight among themselves.
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 I might add, that the role of the VP is delineated by the Constitution. Their powers have not changed since the Constitution was adopted.
abercius24 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='atheling' post='1643776' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:38 PM']What??? You mean to tell me that our earliest Senators and Congressmen didn't have committees and subcommittees? Oh please! Right now, I'm reading a biography of John Adams, which gives detailed descriptions of the founding of our nation and the Continental Congress [i]had[/i] committees and subcommittees. The newly formed Congress of the United States [i]had[/i] committees and subcommittees. And they were all involved in foreign policy and national security! Goodness, they even had delegates and ambassadors! They had secretaries and cabinets! The only thing that has changed is that our government has become a bloated bureaucracy with LOTS more committees and subcommittees. But the essence has not changed. And why, pray tell, is the John Adams quote so well known? Because it still holds water! Anyone who knows history and American polity understands this! It's an ongoing joke in political circles.[/quote] Call me foolish, but I believe the existence of the FBI, the CIA, the NSA, the UN, NATO, the Council of Foreign Relations, globalized markets, information warfare, and over 5000 domestic targets from Russian and Chinese nuclear ICBMs makes the business of our current Senatorial commitees and subcommittes a much more serious business for all of mankind, not just 13 former British colonies. But I believe for the sake of the thread, we can agree to disagree on this. Edited September 1, 2008 by abercius24
atheling Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='abercius24' post='1643794' date='Aug 31 2008, 08:45 PM']Call me foolish, but I believe the existence of the FBI, the CIA, the NSA, the UN, NATO, the Council of Foreign Relations, globalized markets, information warfare, and over 5000 domestic targets from Russian and Chinese nuclear ICBMs makes the business of our current Senatorial commitees and subcommittes a much more serious business for all of mankind, not just 13 former British colonies. [/quote] You're not foolish at all. And your point is well taken, regarding Congress. We've fallen off track here. The point is, the VP is not a "vital" role for the administration. The role of the VP is clearly defined in the Constitution and that has not changed. But I'm sure you're aware of that. It's just that others were trying to say that the role has changed from its inception, and it has not. Otherwise, the change would violate the Constitution.
abercius24 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 (edited) [quote name='atheling' post='1643807' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:53 PM']You're not foolish at all. And your point is well taken, regarding Congress. We've fallen off track here. The point is, the VP is not a "vital" role for the administration. The role of the VP is clearly defined in the Constitution and that has not changed. But I'm sure you're aware of that. It's just that others were trying to say that the role has changed from its inception, and it has not. Otherwise, the change would violate the Constitution.[/quote] I agree that most here do not completely understand the position of the Vice President. The Constitution clearly limits that role, as you mentioned. But I believe that position is more influential within the VP's own political party. And I do believe that party aspect is indirectly influential in the matters of the administration and Congress itself. Palin will have the political power within her own party to ask for previledged information (from other party members) within Senatorial committees that can help guide the party's influence in the Senate, and aid McCain in his decision making with regards to Congress. In my opinion, its the influence that the Constitution does not address that is ultimately the most pertinent. But I think you are right, we are way off topic. Palin is the subject. Edited September 1, 2008 by abercius24
Justin86 Posted September 1, 2008 Author Posted September 1, 2008 A question for kujo: When do you think someone has enough experience to be the President or the Vice President?
Deb Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 Personally, I think McCain's choice was brilliant. Not because he chose a woman, although I find that courageous and admirable, but because he chose someone who has not been living with the croutons that is Washington D.C. She is not owned by the lobbiests, which Obama, Biden and McCain certainly are. She has values, morals and she doesn't have to point them out and talk about them, she lives them. In a time when we can't trust anyone in politics, she is a breath of fresh air. If I have to choose between a man who thinks pregnancy is a punishment and a man whose VP chose to give life to a child she knew would be faced with difficulties and challenges in this world, it is a no brainer. I have never voted for a Republican in my 34 years of being able to vote. This isn't going to be as painful as I thought it would be.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now