Resurrexi Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 I seriously wish that the Index would be brought back. It would be so much easier to know what books you shouldn't read.
princessgianna Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643299' date='Aug 31 2008, 11:56 AM']I seriously wish that the Index would be brought back. It would be so much easier to know what books you shouldn't read.[/quote] oh who took it away? can't you go on the vatican 's website and find it or did phatmass take it off?
Innocent Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643299' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:26 PM']I seriously wish that the Index would be brought back. It would be so much easier to know what books you shouldn't read.[/quote] But with the sheer number of books being brought out these days, it would be impracticable to read them all and compile a perfect list, wouldn't it? Also, it would give the anti-Catholic elements in the press a good target to aim their distorted news-stories at. Moreover, those authors who wrote the books would get instant notoriety. Who knows, once they hear their book is on the Index, I wouldn't be surprised if the next edition that came out had "Newest Addition to the Vatican's Index of Forbidden Books" written on the cover, just as they now write "#1 NYT Best Seller" or "Over 1,000,000 copies sold" or such similar things.
Paddington Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643299' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:26 PM']to know what books you shouldn't read.[/quote] What is the criteria for "shouldn't read?"
prose Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 If a book has the potential to cause you sin - through eroticism, false gods, etc. Then you shouldn't be reading it. A book that may not affect me a certain way, may lead you into mortal sin. They would have to index the books: For those who struggle with lust... For those who struggle with false gods... For those who struggle with greed.... Yeah, wayyyy too complicated. If you think the book will have a negative effect on your soul, don't read it.
Resurrexi Posted August 31, 2008 Author Posted August 31, 2008 [quote name='Paddington' post='1643331' date='Aug 31 2008, 10:35 AM']What is the criteria for "shouldn't read?"[/quote] Before prohibitions on specific books were listed, the common law of the Church forbade: 1. Editions of the original text of Sacred Scripture published by non-Catholics; likewise, translations of the same made or published by them. 2. Books that in any way defend heresy or schism or that tend to undermine the foundations of religion. 3. Books which, of set purpose, attack religion or morals. 4. Books of non-Catholics which professedly treat of religion unless .it is clear that they contain nothing contrary to the Catholic faith 5. Books published without due ecclesiastical approval which treat of Sacred Scripture, or contain annotations and commentaries thereon or translations thereof into the vernacular; books containing new apparitions, revelations, visions, prophecies or miracles or which seek to introduce new devotions. 6. Books which attack or ridicule any Catholic dogma, or defend errors proscribed by the Holy See; books which disparage divine worship, or seek to undermine ecclesiastical discipline, or avowedly defame the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the clerical or religious state. 7. Books which teach or approve of superstition, fortune telling, divination, magic, spiritism or other such practices. 8. Books which declare duels, suicide and divorce to be lawful; furthermore, books that treat of freemasonry and similar secret societies, maintaining that they are useful or that they are harmless to the Church and civil society 9. Books which, with avowed intention, treat of, describe, or teach, lewd or obscene matters, such as methods of birth control 10. Liturgical books containing unauthorized changes so that they no longer agree with the authentic editions approved by the Holy See. 11. Books which contain apocryphal indulgences, or such as have been condemned or revoked by the Holy See. 12. All images, however reproduced, of Christ, the Blessed Virgin, the Angels, the Saints or other Servants of God that are not keeping with the sentiment and decrees of the Church.
princessgianna Posted August 31, 2008 Posted August 31, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Innocent' post='1643327' date='Aug 31 2008, 12:31 PM']Moreover, those I wouldn't be surprised if the next edition that came out had "Newest Addition to the Vatican's Index of Forbidden Books" written on the cover, just as they now write "#1 NYT Best Seller" or "Over 1,000,000 copies sold" or such similar things.[/quote] unfortunately that would be true!!! but it is still funny to think about! Edited August 31, 2008 by princessgianna
Resurrexi Posted September 1, 2008 Author Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 12:08 PM']Before prohibitions on specific books were listed, the common law of the Church forbade: 1. Editions of the original text of Sacred Scripture published by non-Catholics; likewise, translations of the same made or published by them. 2. Books that in any way defend heresy or schism or that tend to undermine the foundations of religion. 3. Books which, of set purpose, attack religion or morals. 4. Books of non-Catholics which professedly treat of religion unless .it is clear that they contain nothing contrary to the Catholic faith 5. Books published without due ecclesiastical approval which treat of Sacred Scripture, or contain annotations and commentaries thereon or translations thereof into the vernacular; books containing new apparitions, revelations, visions, prophecies or miracles or which seek to introduce new devotions. 6. Books which attack or ridicule any Catholic dogma, or defend errors proscribed by the Holy See; books which disparage divine worship, or seek to undermine ecclesiastical discipline, or avowedly defame the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the clerical or religious state. 7. Books which teach or approve of superstition, fortune telling, divination, magic, spiritism or other such practices. 8. Books which declare duels, suicide and divorce to be lawful; furthermore, books that treat of freemasonry and similar secret societies, maintaining that they are useful or that they are harmless to the Church and civil society 9. Books which, with avowed intention, treat of, describe, or teach, lewd or obscene matters, such as methods of birth control 10. Liturgical books containing unauthorized changes so that they no longer agree with the authentic editions approved by the Holy See. 11. Books which contain apocryphal indulgences, or such as have been condemned or revoked by the Holy See. 12. All images, however reproduced, of Christ, the Blessed Virgin, the Angels, the Saints or other Servants of God that are not keeping with the sentiment and decrees of the Church.[/quote] Ya... that was from [i]Moral Theology[/i] by Jone, BTW.
Autumn Dusk Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']Before prohibitions on specific books were listed, the common law of the Church forbade: 1. Editions of the original text of Sacred Scripture published by non-Catholics; likewise, translations of the same made or published by them.[/quote] Fair enough [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']2. Books that in any way defend heresy or schism or that tend to undermine the foundations of religion. 3. Books which, of set purpose, attack religion or morals.[/quote] How in the world will we know what the heresy is if we don't know what they are saying? [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']4. Books of non-Catholics which professedly treat of religion unless .it is clear that they contain nothing contrary to the Catholic faith[/quote] by who's standard? Some would consider their mere existance a threat. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']5. Books published without due ecclesiastical approval which treat of Sacred Scripture, or contain annotations and commentaries thereon or translations thereof into the vernacular; books containing new apparitions, revelations, visions, prophecies or miracles or which seek to introduce new devotions.[/quote] now if only people on forums would stop discussing unaproved apparations..... [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']6. Books which attack or ridicule any Catholic dogma, or defend errors proscribed by the Holy See; books which disparage divine worship, or seek to undermine ecclesiastical discipline, or avowedly defame the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the clerical or religious state.[/quote] This sounds fishy to me. It could SO be taken wrong. Some people would see that p&w music and instruction on how to use it during mass would be heresy. I wouldn't [i]7. .....[/i] Does that mean fiction or non-fiction? [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']8. Books which declare duels, suicide and divorce to be lawful; furthermore, books that treat of freemasonry and similar secret societies, maintaining that they are useful or that they are harmless to the Church and civil society[/quote] Wel, skull and bones exists and I don't want to be forbade to research and understand what that's all about. It makes freemasontry into this giant cold-war style enemy. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']9. Books which, with avowed intention, treat of, describe, or teach, lewd or obscene matters, such as methods of birth control[/quote] Again, in the strictist sense, to some, this would include NFP. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']10. Liturgical books containing unauthorized changes so that they no longer agree with the authentic editions approved by the Holy See.[/quote] and poor, rural church are supposed to do what with their GRIM? [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']11. Books which contain apocryphal indulgences, or such as have been condemned or revoked by the Holy See.[/quote] Again...revoked? This has to do with things already printed and it seems like closing the barn after the horses have run off. There's so much that it seems to me that criticizing old material just makes the new material or "approved" material look subjective. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 03:08 PM']12. All images, however reproduced, of Christ, the Blessed Virgin, the Angels, the Saints or other Servants of God that are not keeping with the sentiment and decrees of the Church.[/quote] what about the internet? I guess "Buddy Jesus" is sacriligious.
Resurrexi Posted September 1, 2008 Author Posted September 1, 2008 If you have a problem with the books that were banned, take it up with the Congregation for the Index... oh wait... it doesn't exist anymore. Well buy a book about it or something if you want to hear arguments for why these books were banned.
MakeYouThink Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']Before prohibitions on specific books were listed, the common law of the Church forbade: 1. Editions of the original text of Sacred Scripture published by non-Catholics; likewise, translations of the same made or published by them.[/quote] I read the King James Version of the Bible. I must be going to hell for that. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']2. Books that in any way defend heresy or schism or that tend to undermine the foundations of religion.[/quote] I've read parts of the Jesus Family Tomb, to see what their argument was. In it, there are a large number of paintings with Free Masonry symbols in it. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']3. Books which, of set purpose, attack religion or morals.[/quote] I've read God is not Great, why religion poisons everything. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']4. Books of non-Catholics which professedly treat of religion unless .it is clear that they contain nothing contrary to the Catholic faith.[/quote] I have a book that talks about the Pre-Trib Rapture, because I want to see how wrong they are. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']5. Books published without due ecclesiastical approval which treat of Sacred Scripture, or contain annotations and commentaries thereon or translations thereof into the vernacular; books containing new apparitions, revelations, visions, prophecies or miracles or which seek to introduce new devotions.[/quote] I read books by protestants, because I am a protestant. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']6. Books which attack or ridicule any Catholic dogma, or defend errors proscribed by the Holy See; books which disparage divine worship, or seek to undermine ecclesiastical discipline, or avowedly defame the ecclesiastical hierarchy, the clerical or religious state. 7. Books which teach or approve of superstition, fortune telling, divination, magic, spiritism or other such practices.[/quote] Woot, I'ml safe. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']8. Books which declare duels, suicide and divorce to be lawful; furthermore, books that treat of freemasonry and similar secret societies, maintaining that they are useful or that they are harmless to the Church and civil society.[/quote] LOL, the free masons are about as safe as a bunch of Snakes on a plane. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']9. Books which, with avowed intention, treat of, describe, or teach, lewd or obscene matters, such as methods of birth control.[/quote] Unfortunately, I have. [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643382' date='Aug 31 2008, 01:08 PM']10. Liturgical books containing unauthorized changes so that they no longer agree with the authentic editions approved by the Holy See 11. Books which contain apocryphal indulgences, or such as have been condemned or revoked by the Holy See. 12. All images, however reproduced, of Christ, the Blessed Virgin, the Angels, the Saints or other Servants of God that are not keeping with the sentiment and decrees of the Church.[/quote] I don't keep any kinds of those pictures, because what did Jesus really look like anyways? And the other two, I'm safe, I don't read Liturgical books or anything about the Apocryphal!
Nihil Obstat Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1643680' date='Aug 31 2008, 08:25 PM']If you have a problem with the books that were banned, take it up with the Congregation for the Index... oh wait... it doesn't exist anymore.[/quote] I'd be relatively sure there's a good reason that this particular Congregation no longer exists.
dominicansoul Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 From what I understand, the books that were last listed are still prohibited for us to read, unless you get special permission from the Bishop. These books are dangerous, because they can cause a lot of confusion even among the holiest of holy people in the Church. One book in particular that I find to be a major cause of confusion and upheaval is "Poem of the Man-God" by Maria Valtorta. A brand new religious community I know is totally engrossed in this book, uses it in their formation program, and allows it to shape their spirituality. Yet, it was on the Forbidden Index and was never taken off. It breaks my heart because the people in this community are so very holy and I became very close to them and called them my family for a while. But I had to leave them and stay away from all their activities until the Bishop straightens this mess out... ...stupid book!
Nihil Obstat Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 What kinds of things are in this "Poem of the Man-God"?
dominicansoul Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1643948' date='Sep 1 2008, 12:41 AM']What kinds of things are in this "Poem of the Man-God"?[/quote] Stuff that isn't theologically sound. Fr. Groeschel and Fr. Mitch Pacwa have written about it and spoken out against it. The Daughters of Saint Paul don't believe there is anything wrong with it and actually publish it! (Which caused quite an uproar!) It's very controversial, in that, Valtorta has never been accepted as an authentic mystic by the Catholic Church. And much of what she wrote of is considered in her own words "Gospel" given to her by Jesus and Mary. There's a lot of strange phrases that would be too much for me to get into. I have never fully read it, because what I have read disturbed me greatly. And after hearing Fr. Groeschel and Fr. Pacwa continually speak out against it, (as well as Cardinal Ratzinger back in the day) I didn't want to waste my time with it.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1643951' date='Sep 1 2008, 12:46 AM']Stuff that isn't theologically sound. Fr. Groeschel and Fr. Mitch Pacwa have written about it and spoken out against it. The Daughters of Saint Paul don't believe there is anything wrong with it and actually publish it! (Which caused quite an uproar!) It's very controversial, in that, Valtorta has never been accepted as an authentic mystic by the Catholic Church. And much of what she wrote of is considered in her own words "Gospel" given to her by Jesus and Mary. There's a lot of strange phrases that would be too much for me to get into. I have never fully read it, because what I have read disturbed me greatly. And after hearing Fr. Groeschel and Fr. Pacwa continually speak out against it, (as well as Cardinal Ratzinger back in the day) I didn't want to waste my time with it.[/quote] Reminds me of the two times I tried to read Holy Blood Holy Grail. I actually bought it for some research... way back. Grade six or something. Actually thought it was a researched book. Wow, was I ever mislead. So yea, I have tried to read it twice since then. Both times I literally threw the book across the room because it was so ridiculous. Now it sits hidden in the shameful spot on my bookshelf.
Justin86 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 I think one of the problems with the Index is that it has become outdated by the internet. True, not every book is going to appear on the internet in it's entire form, but you can gather the same information repeated in a concise manner on every book out there just by logging on to your computer. Obviously, there's no way the Vatican can monitor the entire internet.
Resurrexi Posted September 1, 2008 Author Posted September 1, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1644010' date='Sep 1 2008, 02:25 AM']I think one of the problems with the Index is that it has become outdated by the internet. True, not every book is going to appear on the internet in it's entire form, but you can gather the same information repeated in a concise manner on every book out there just by logging on to your computer. Obviously, there's no way the Vatican can monitor the entire internet.[/quote] The index was abolished like 30 years before there was an internet though...
Justin86 Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 In either case, there's still no point for it in today's society.
Guest KevinSymonds Posted September 1, 2008 Posted September 1, 2008 I have been researching the Index of Forbidden Books for the past several months as part of a larger project. No Catholic whatsoever and for any reason is allowed to read a book that is harmful to faith and good morals. The Vatican declared as such. Episcopal conferences and individual Bishops are supposed to be keeping their own lists of forbidden books. Books on alleged private revelations are also required to undergo censorship before publication (against the common belief that they don't need such censorship). -KJS
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now