havok579257 Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 Ok, as I continue to grow and learn about my faith, new questions arise. So I understand in marriage for sex we are called to: Glorify God Be unnitive Open to Life Now I know not doing any of those willingly is a sin but the question I had is, what if its not willingly. Like during oral/manual stimulation, lets say a man gets a little TOO excitied and does not end the right way. Is he sinning then and if so is it a mortal sin or a venial sin. Any help answering this is much appriciated.
Ziggamafu Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 It would almost certainly still be a sin, though very likely a venial sin. Any sin that is not committed with full knowledge (read: full awareness & full faculties of reason) or full consent (read: deliberation & advertence) is not mortal. Period. Remember that to sin mortally is to deliberately reject Christ by means of violating his moral truths, thereby destroying all charity within your soul. That does not happen by accident or by weakness. [i]Which is not to say that sins of weakness / ignorance are not serious[/i] - venial sin is indeed a serious thing; it can even destroy your life here in this world. But the difference between venial and mortal sin is that venial sin can only "weigh down" your life in the next world - not destroy it completely. Find a good moral theology book and take advantage of it.
havok579257 Posted September 2, 2008 Author Posted September 2, 2008 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1645225' date='Sep 2 2008, 08:45 AM']It would almost certainly still be a sin, though very likely a venial sin. Any sin that is not committed with full knowledge (read: full awareness & full faculties of reason) or full consent (read: deliberation & advertence) is not mortal. Period. Remember that to sin mortally is to deliberately reject Christ by means of violating his moral truths, thereby destroying all charity within your soul. That does not happen by accident or by weakness. [i]Which is not to say that sins of weakness / ignorance are not serious[/i] - venial sin is indeed a serious thing; it can even destroy your life here in this world. But the difference between venial and mortal sin is that venial sin can only "weigh down" your life in the next world - not destroy it completely. Find a good moral theology book and take advantage of it.[/quote] Ok, see this is where I am confused. A priest who I talked to, to help me learn more about my faith said something like this is not a sin. He said someone would not need to go to confession for this. He said since intent was to end correctly and it was an accident, there is nothing to feel ashamed about. So which is it. Any help would be appriciated.
Vincent Vega Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 Well, you [i]don't[/i] need to go to confession for venial sins. It doesn't hurt to mention them while you're in there, but they are absolved at the beginning of every mass (Kyrie), unless I'm mistaken.
havok579257 Posted September 2, 2008 Author Posted September 2, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1645645' date='Sep 2 2008, 06:01 PM']Well, you [i]don't[/i] need to go to confession for venial sins. It doesn't hurt to mention them while you're in there, but they are absolved at the beginning of every mass (Kyrie), unless I'm mistaken.[/quote] but is this a sin or not? venial sin or not?
Vincent Vega Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 Well, I have an opinion, but I wouldn't want to mislead you, because I wasn't able to find anything in the CCC to back it up. Maybe ask the priest to clarify what he meant, or get a second opinion?
havok579257 Posted September 2, 2008 Author Posted September 2, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1645656' date='Sep 2 2008, 06:20 PM']Well, I have an opinion, but I wouldn't want to mislead you, because I wasn't able to find anything in the CCC to back it up. Maybe ask the priest to clarify what he meant, or get a second opinion?[/quote] Here's what the priest told me. He said the man should not be ashamed if that were to happen and it is not something one needs to confess about. As long as the intent was there, then it is not a sin. He said accidents happen, escpecially when dealing with things like this and there is no wrong in an accident happening. He says God looks at your intent here and as long as the intent was in the right place, it is not a sin. I just wanted to ask on here because before, people have said this constitutes a sin but then the priest said it didn't. So I am confused.
Vincent Vega Posted September 2, 2008 Posted September 2, 2008 (edited) The only thing I see that's a bit questionable in that explanation is that it's possible to do things unwillingly or unknowingly and they still be sins. Not mortal sins, as willingly/knowing committing them is a prerequisite, but venial sins, yes. I'd agree with Zig and say that I think: No, it's not a mortal sin; it is a venial sin. But I'm probably wrong; I'd suspect the good reverend knows more on the subject than I. Maybe PM Fr. Cappy or Fr. Ponti and ask them? Edited September 2, 2008 by USAirwaysIHS
Ziggamafu Posted September 3, 2008 Posted September 3, 2008 Aye. My point, if not clearly conveyed, was that such a sin was likely venial. The choice to receive, by means of confession, a supernatural abundance of grace from the omnipotent Love-God of the universe is yours. You do not need, by confession, to be filled with supernatural empowerment to resist temptations, while simultaneously remitting some of your temporal punishments, if you don't want to. Because you are so persistent (you sound a bit haunted by the idea of mortal sin), I see a yellow flag for scrupulosity. Relax. God loves you. You cannot sin mortally by accident or by impairment. Mortal sin is deliberate rebellion, which amounts to a choice for Hell. Venial sin is an offense against God that hurts you and quite probably others. Venial sin should be struggled against and overcome. But it should not cause fear of Hell.
CatherineM Posted September 3, 2008 Posted September 3, 2008 I asked one of my theology professors who is a priest, and he said that such accidents aren't a sin any more than a wet dream is, but the danger comes when these kinds of accidents happen too frequently. It is an area that couples can fall into sin easily if they use it as an excuse to be able to do things routinely that aren't in line with the Church's teachings.
havok579257 Posted September 3, 2008 Author Posted September 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1646258' date='Sep 3 2008, 02:00 PM']I asked one of my theology professors who is a priest, and he said that such accidents aren't a sin any more than a wet dream is, but the danger comes when these kinds of accidents happen too frequently. It is an area that couples can fall into sin easily if they use it as an excuse to be able to do things routinely that aren't in line with the Church's teachings.[/quote] Thanks so much for helping me get a clear answer and asking another priest on this subject. I really appriciate the extra leg work you did on this question. Thanks
Don John of Austria Posted September 5, 2008 Posted September 5, 2008 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1645225' date='Sep 2 2008, 08:45 AM']It would almost certainly still be a sin, though very likely a venial sin. Any sin that is not committed with full knowledge (read: full awareness & full faculties of reason) or full consent (read: deliberation & advertence) is not mortal. Period. Remember that to sin mortally is to deliberately reject Christ by means of violating his moral truths, thereby destroying all charity within your soul. That does not happen by accident or by weakness. [i]Which is not to say that sins of weakness / ignorance are not serious[/i] - venial sin is indeed a serious thing; it can even destroy your life here in this world. But the difference between venial and mortal sin is that venial sin can only "weigh down" your life in the next world - not destroy it completely. Find a good moral theology book and take advantage of it.[/quote] I am not sure I agree with this, and I am not trying to start anything her, but I would contend a "sin of weakness" can indeed be mortal, unless you have a really tight definition of weakness. That said in this case, I would go with venial, as this lacks intentionality, and it is likely that the man would not be culpable regardless.
Saint Therese Posted September 13, 2008 Posted September 13, 2008 I think there would be culpability, because I tink that situation is preventable. The couple should learn to be sensitive to each other's limits. Just my opinion.
mommas_boy Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='havok579257' post='1645665' date='Sep 2 2008, 06:27 PM']Here's what the priest told me. He said the man should not be ashamed if that were to happen and it is not something one needs to confess about. As long as the intent was there, then it is not a sin. He said accidents happen, escpecially when dealing with things like this and there is no wrong in an accident happening. He says God looks at your intent here and as long as the intent was in the right place, it is not a sin. I just wanted to ask on here because before, people have said this constitutes a sin but then the priest said it didn't. So I am confused.[/quote] [quote name='CatherineM' post='1646258' date='Sep 3 2008, 02:00 PM']I asked one of my theology professors who is a priest, and he said that such accidents aren't a sin any more than a wet dream is, but the danger comes when these kinds of accidents happen too frequently. It is an area that couples can fall into sin easily if they use it as an excuse to be able to do things routinely that aren't in line with the Church's teachings.[/quote] I concur with these points. I've heard the same said by a VERY orthodox bishop, Daniel Jenky of Peoria in Illinois.
havok579257 Posted September 15, 2008 Author Posted September 15, 2008 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1654773' date='Sep 13 2008, 03:33 PM']I think there would be culpability, because I tink that situation is preventable. The couple should learn to be sensitive to each other's limits. Just my opinion.[/quote] so you don't believe in accidents?
Saint Therese Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 Yes, of course its possible. But both spouses should learn to be sensitive to each other to the degree that it doesn't happen. If they don't learn to do this then there might culpability.
Guest Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1645853' date='Sep 2 2008, 10:07 PM']You cannot sin mortally by accident or by impairment. Mortal sin is deliberate rebellion, which amounts to a choice for Hell. Venial sin is an offense against God that hurts you and quite probably others. Venial sin should be struggled against and overcome. But it should not cause fear of Hell.[/quote] Im sorta confused by this. If someone knows masturbation is a mortal sin yet they masturbate they commit a mortal sin correct ? Even if they had been to confession for it last week and intened when they woke up that day not to commit the act? I know this doesnt coexist with the original act by the original poster. But what im confused about is what is consdidered weakness ? Because If I wake up and say im not going to commit fornication in the form of masturbation then end up being tempted later by satan and commit it, I knew when I was doing it that it was a mortal sin so its a mortal sin ? Or Is it just a venial sin that I need to confess at mass but dont need to go to confession because it was a moment of weakness that I gave into my flesh ?
mommas_boy Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1657548' date='Sep 17 2008, 06:23 PM']Im sorta confused by this. If someone knows masturbation is a mortal sin yet they masturbate they commit a mortal sin correct ?[/quote] Masturbation committed in full knowledge and with free choice in the matter is indeed mortal sin. However, as is the case with most sexual sins, the psychological/pathological nature of addiction can play a part to mitigate the culpability of the sinner, but not remove it entirely. I would suggest in this case that the sinner, if suspicious that they are addicted, continue to treat the sin as though it is completely mortal, and to fly to confession at the earliest available time. The sinner should also refrain from receiving communion until after confessing. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1657548' date='Sep 17 2008, 06:23 PM']Even if they had been to confession for it last week and intened when they woke up that day not to commit the act?[/quote] Mortal sins must be confessed each time they are committed, unlike a venial sin which need not be confessed at all (but still should be). Whether or not a person intended to commit sin when they woke up is irrelevant; they still made that decision at the time. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1657548' date='Sep 17 2008, 06:23 PM']I know this doesnt coexist with the original act by the original poster. But what im confused about is what is consdidered weakness ? Because If I wake up and say im not going to commit fornication in the form of masturbation then end up being tempted later by satan and commit it, I knew when I was doing it that it was a mortal sin so its a mortal sin ?[/quote] This is correct, as I noted above. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1657548' date='Sep 17 2008, 06:23 PM']Or Is it just a venial sin that I need to confess at mass but dont need to go to confession because it was a moment of weakness that I gave into my flesh ?[/quote] It is grave sin, objectively. Whether or not it is mortal depends on the extent of one's knowledge (yours is complete, in this case), as well as one's ability to freely and willing choose to commit it. Addiction can play a part to decrease that culpability (guilt), but can't remove it entirely. The best advice that I can give is to treat an addiction-driven incidence of masturbation as though it [b]were[/b] mortal sin and to fly to confession, as well as to avoid communion before confessing it.
Guest Posted September 17, 2008 Posted September 17, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1657559' date='Sep 17 2008, 06:53 PM']Mortal sins must be confessed each time they are committed, unlike a venial sin which need not be confessed at all (but still should be). Whether or not a person intended to commit sin when they woke up is irrelevant; they still made that decision at the time.[/quote] what if someone puts them into a group when they confess them ? say they got drunk 3 times and they confess "getting druink" to the priest. are they confessing wrong ? should they say they got drunk three different times ? thanks for your help.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now