Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Voting Pro-abortion


Recommended Posts

Kirisutodo333
Posted

I'm sure some have seen this maybe today, but it is a sensible defense on why not to vote for a pro-abortion candidate.

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/articles.cfm?id=265"]Link to article[/url]

And still some people will reason their way into voting pro-abortion...sad.

Peace

Kiris

princessgianna
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1648691' date='Sep 5 2008, 09:38 PM']I'm sure some have seen this maybe today, but it is a sensible defense on why not to vote for a pro-abortion candidate.

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/articles.cfm?id=265"]Link to article[/url]

And still some people will reason their way into voting pro-abortion...sad.

Peace

Kiris[/quote]
i don't get it either!
My parents have taught me that if you can't vote for life then with out life you have nothing and all the other
issues have no meaning because you don;t have life~! did that make sense?
EDIT: pax!

Edited by princessgianna
Posted

In some people's minds, the death penalty, just war, health care, fair wages, etc, etc, all combined, give them a proportionate reason that outweighs the abortion issue.

They think the difference between the candidates on those other issues is so great (which it is not, in my opinion), they are comfortable with voting for a pro-abortion candidate.

Personally, I have a real hard time understanding how they can make their brains come up with that type of moral equivalence, but they do.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='princessgianna' post='1648737' date='Sep 5 2008, 10:21 PM']i don't get it either!
My parents have taught me that if you can't vote for life then with out life you have nothing and all the other
issues have no meaning because you don;t have life~! did that make sense?
EDIT: pax![/quote]

Any system of government that completely denies either Life, Liberty or the Pursuit of Happiness to any individual is contrary to everything Freedom stands for. Good government should be devoted to balancing those three among all people. The Pursuit of Happiness last, because it is stifled without Liberty; and Liberty second because it cannot exists without Life. If you can't protect those three at the most basic level for everyone, then you are enjoying freedom at another's grave expense, which is not true freedom at all, but tyranny. Abortion falls short at every level for all three. And as Archbishop Fulton Sheen would probably say, legalized Abortion IS Anti-American.

I think that is basically what you are getting at. :)

Edited by abercius24
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1648914' date='Sep 6 2008, 01:45 AM']In some people's minds, the death penalty, just war, health care, fair wages, etc, etc, all combined, give them a proportionate reason that outweighs the abortion issue.

They think the difference between the candidates on those other issues is so great (which it is not, in my opinion), they are comfortable with voting for a pro-abortion candidate.

Personally, I have a real hard time understanding how they can make their brains come up with that type of moral equivalence, but they do.[/quote]
I suspect the primary rationalization would be thinking that the president does not have significant impact on the legality of abortion, but does have a very great impact on other things, like wars.

(I don't know that that's a correct assumption, but I can see some rationale behind it.)

There certainly [i]are[/i] elected political offices where a candidate's stance on abortion -- if I even know it -- doesn't play into my voting choice. Village trustees, for example.

princessgianna
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1648933' date='Sep 6 2008, 02:21 AM']I suspect the primary rationalization would be thinking that the president does not have significant impact on the legality of abortion, but does have a very great impact on other things, like wars.[/quote]
the president can veto bills and laws that congress wants to pass that would encourage and help women have a abortion.
and though the president can only send the troops anywhere in the world it is only for 90 days after that it is for Congress to vote and decide on what to do and if congress wants to get out of there then the troops leave.

Kirisutodo333
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1648914' date='Sep 6 2008, 02:45 AM']In some people's minds, the death penalty, just war, health care, fair wages, etc, etc, all combined, give them a proportionate reason that outweighs the abortion issue.

They think the difference between the candidates on those other issues is so great (which it is not, in my opinion), they are comfortable with voting for a pro-abortion candidate.

Personally, I have a real hard time understanding how they can make their brains come up with that type of moral equivalence, but they do.[/quote]

Unfortunately, this is a problem that I'm having with a Catholic friend of mine. He considers himself a populist-left moderate, very involved with social justice and is voting for Obama because he believes that Obama will do more for "life" than McCain. He believes that the Neocons have hijacked the Republican party and the abortion issue and to vote for McCain just for the "abortion" issue would be nonsense since nothing will ever happen to Roe vs. Wade. He also doesn't consider himself committing evil on voting for Obama. This is what he had to say in response to the article above that I posted:
[i]
[b]Interesting...so, if let's say Stalin or Pol Pot were running on a "pro-life" platform, and I use this term as lightly as the NeoCons do...we should vote for them over a candidate that does not rally to the "cause?"

The "pro-life" cause has been hijacked over the last 20 years to win voters through guilt, allowing a cart blanche exploitation of many other issues. My own views on abortion, etc are posted and open to all on my profile, but I still find it very hard to understand how a vote that is not a direct vote on the issue of abortion, can be "intrinsically" evil...perhaps I am slow, could someone explain it too me :)[/b][/i]

Would anyone have any advice on his comment and on how it can be "intrinsically evil?"

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[quote]this is a problem that I'm having with a Catholic friend of mine. He considers himself a populist-left moderate, very involved with social justice and is voting for Obama because he believes that Obama will do more for "life" than McCain. He believes that the Neocons have hijacked the Republican party and the abortion issue and to vote for McCain just for the "abortion" issue would be nonsense since nothing will ever happen to Roe vs. Wade.[/quote]

there's a difference between people saying that a bunch of non-abortion things like welfare etc can add up to an equivalence to abortion.... and saying they don't think abortion will ever change anytime soon.

if your friend is saying the later, he's not necessarily saying the former.

the former is not really an objection that works,,,, if it's assumed that abortion's going to change.
the later is an objection that works... if it's assumed that it's not going to change.

given that it's uncertain whether it will change,,, it's kinda muddlied. but, it's still wrong ot say that the two things are the same.
not that your'e saying they're the same,,,, it just looks like you're saying they are, or are confusing them.

Don John of Austria
Posted

Voting for a pro-abortion canadite is helping women procure an abortion plain and simple.

Last I checked that was [i]a jure [/i] Excommunication.

I'm just saying.

Posted (edited)

Even though a particular political office may not be directly involved in promoting or limiting abortions, that office is very much involved in the abortion issue. Apart from the actual public office any elected official holds, they also hold a position within their own political party in which they determine who else below them will have influence -- and financing. One of the problems we've been facing in the Rupublican party is the election of pro-abortion candidates. We tolerated a few, like California Governors Pete Wilson and Arnold Schwarzzenneger, and within years after each of their elections, the California Republican Party almost lost all of its Pro-Life candidates. Now the Pro-Life cause in California has no influence whatsoever in the Democratic Party and almost no influence at all in the Republican Party. Financing in the Republican Party now goes to financing pro-abortion candidates for local school boards who promote abortion for minors without parental notification. There is now no viable debate going on in the California Assembly and Senate when abortion funding is proposed as part of the annual budget. When these pro-abortion candidates get elected to higher offices, they make sure other pro-abortion candidates at lower offices get elected, as well. Really, the biggest goal for the Pro-Life cause is to ONLY support Pro-Life candidates who will not promote pro-abortion candidates within their own party. Think about it. If you get 1 Pro-Life Senator elected who then helps his/her party elect 5 other Pro-Abortion Senators, has not the Pro-Life Senator put the Pro-Life cause 4 votes behind??? This is really where we have been politically falling short on the Pro-Life movement.

Edited by abercius24
dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1650202' date='Sep 7 2008, 05:16 PM']Voting for a pro-abortion canadite is helping women procure an abortion plain and simple.

Last I checked that was [i]a jure [/i] Excommunication.

I'm just saying.[/quote]

if that's what the CC thought, that's what it'd say.
it wouldn't talk about weighing all the variables etc, as it does now.


if you think that change would happen if only people who didn't vote prolife but were prolife did..... then maybe what you are saying could be implied, arguably... but not because of anything that's been said by the CC very clearly at all.
and what you say seems to be a blanket statement that it never matters what the circumstances are.... even if all were prochoice except for five percent of the population for example, and it'd be surely pointless to vote on that issue. the CC clearly doens't teach it'd be wrong ot vote for but despite the prochoice person.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1650253' date='Sep 7 2008, 07:10 PM']if that's what the CC thought, that's what it'd say.
it wouldn't talk about weighing all the variables etc, as it does now.


if you think that change would happen if only people who didn't vote prolife but were prolife did..... then maybe what you are saying could be implied, arguably... but not because of anything that's been said by the CC very clearly at all.
and what you say seems to be a blanket statement that it never matters what the circumstances are.... even if all were prochoice except for five percent of the population for example, and it'd be surely pointless to vote on that issue. the CC clearly doens't teach it'd be wrong ot vote for but despite the prochoice person.[/quote]


I cannot adequatly respond to that without violating Forum rules, suffice it to say, I would contend that the Catholic Church does indeed say that, that that is the conclusion one must take from various documents and that the lack of such a formal declaration is not a matter of Theology but of Courage.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

no need to be upset, it's just a discussion.

at least you acknowledge that it's not explicit. that's much more than many catholics will admit.

i know i'm not catholic any more but. i strongly disagree with you that the CC teaches if there was five percent prolife and it wasn't going to change, tht they are essentially saying that you'd have ot vote on that one issue. this is precisely why they are vague, i'd argue, these sorts of situations. that you have to impute excommunications etc where there are none,,,, in fact is surely more grievous than that five percent scenario voting for the prochoice person, cause you're taking upon yourself speaking for the church.
and some could say if there's allowed discretion, that you're defiantly contradicting it.
(i realize you'd argue you're merely following it to where they want you to go,, but it could be argued the that you're contradicting it too)

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

"if you think that change would happen if only people who didn't vote prolife but were prolife did..... then maybe what you are saying could be implied, arguably... but not because of anything that's been said by the CC very clearly at all."

if it were surely going to change if only prolife people voted as they ought,,, then i agree that it's surely implied that you have to vote prolife.

what i meant was: some people wouldn't agree with you that it'd change were that the case etc. if they think this,,, then it's not very clearly the case that they are wrong.

what i didn't mean was: that if only they'd all vote prolife it'd change,,, that they still don't have to vote prolife.

i don't mean to be confusing. but if you misunderstood my lack of clarity, i can see why you'd be upset.

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1650202' date='Sep 7 2008, 06:16 PM']Voting for a pro-abortion canadite is helping women procure an abortion plain and simple.

Last I checked that was [i]a jure [/i] Excommunication.

I'm just saying.[/quote]
I've been trying to get my thoughts around this for a few hours now. I can't see how this is true. If you vote for a pro-abortion candidate [i]because[/i] they are pro-abortion, certainly. That's what the USCCB says, if I remember correctly.

If what you say is the case, then how far does it go? Is the person who plows the snow from the street in front of Planned Parenthood excommunicated? What about plowing in front of the Democratic Party's HQ? The person who repairs the power lines to the half of the city where the clinic is? The taxi driver who takes the pro-abortion politician to the airport?

I really think you actually have to have the [i]intention[/i] to help a woman (or women) procure (an) abortion(s). Not, meaning to do an entirely different good thing, while realizing you might have inadvertently helped someone, someday, get an abortion.

Otherwise... considering that it's currently legal, doing anything besides trying to overthrow the government [i]right now[/i] is potentially helping women to get abortions.

Though maybe I shouldn't point that out to you... :P

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1650391' date='Sep 7 2008, 10:53 PM']I've been trying to get my thoughts around this for a few hours now. I can't see how this is true. If you vote for a pro-abortion candidate [i]because[/i] they are pro-abortion, certainly. That's what the USCCB says, if I remember correctly.

If what you say is the case, then how far does it go? Is the person who plows the snow from the street in front of Planned Parenthood excommunicated? What about plowing in front of the Democratic Party's HQ? The person who repairs the power lines to the half of the city where the clinic is? The taxi driver who takes the pro-abortion politician to the airport?

I really think you actually have to have the [i]intention[/i] to help a woman (or women) procure (an) abortion(s). Not, meaning to do an entirely different good thing, while realizing you might have inadvertently helped someone, someday, get an abortion.

Otherwise... considering that it's currently legal, doing anything besides trying to overthrow the government [i]right now[/i] is potentially helping women to get abortions.

Though maybe I shouldn't point that out to you... :P[/quote]


Plowing the snow in the street is just that plowing the snow, that is not analgous at all to voting for someone who is pro-abortion. Voting is an expression of will, and in a very real sense a violent action, where you attempt to impose your will upon others. By voting for a pro-abortion canadite you are supporting his agenda and actually helping to impose it on others. You are in a very real sense participating in the violence agiants the unborn.
This is substantially differant than doing your job in a normal capacity which might accedently help abortionist.

I will give you an analogy---- Hitler is a tired guy but he actually got elected so we will pick on him.... Take a german citizen in 1932, If this guy a previous knowledge of Hitlers intentions for the jews and for Central europe, would it have been okay for that person to vote for him, even if he thought Hitler would bring a better economy, stop inflation etc? Or would he be culpible for complicity with Hitler?
Like that German with previous knowledge of Hitlers plans, if you vote for a Pro- abortion Canadite you are complicit in his agenda, including the baby killing part of it.
But lets take your jobs for a moment... if the snow plower makes sure to plow infront of the clinic first so it can open up asap... yes he is guilty. If a policemen answers a call there as part of his duties of protecting the public, that is an accedent of his job... if he works there extra of his own free will.... he is guilty. Voting for someone is not an accedent of a normally harmless or even helpful service, it is an agressive act of will, to place that will behind someone who promotes the murder of babies ... how could that not make you guilty.

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1650511' date='Sep 8 2008, 01:19 AM'][-snip-]
Voting for someone is not an accedent of a normally harmless or even helpful service, it is an agressive act of will, to place that will behind someone who promotes the murder of babies ... how could that not make you guilty.[/quote]
It seems like not voting at all is the only safe path, in that case!

I will have to think about this more.

(This stuff is why I dislike democracy so much. Bah.)

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1650513' date='Sep 8 2008, 01:29 AM']It seems like not voting at all is the only safe path, in that case!

I will have to think about this more.

(This stuff is why I dislike democracy so much. Bah.)[/quote]


I too am not a fan of democracy.... that said you have some miniscule amount of power, use it. Just use it wisely.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...