Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Anybody else REALLY like Metallica's new CD?

THRASH IS BACK!!! :D WOOHOO!!! :D

Posted (edited)

I went ahead and downloaded it last week, its just so amazing. I wanted to go buy it at best today, the album + guitar hero download but...hurricane

Edited by Fixxxer
Posted

After St. Anger, I had lost faith that any of those bands could actually come out with a decent album. I have regained my faith. :cool:

Posted

[quote name='Sparky' post='1654192' date='Sep 12 2008, 07:27 PM']THRASH IS BACK!!![/quote]

Really? I gave up on Metallica after the black album.

Posted

The new one is really good. Actual guitar solos reminiscent of their albums before Black. Of course there are also the softer parts in the album, but definitely musically better than Black album.

Posted
:rolleyes: giving up on them after the black album.
Posted
:rolleyes: at :rolleyes: giving up on them after the black album.

:blink:
Posted

So basically its their first thrash album in 20 years.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1656576' date='Sep 16 2008, 03:07 AM']So basically its their first thrash album in 20 years.[/quote]

:yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes: :yes:

Edited by Sparky
Posted

Hetfields voice still sounds like croutons, and I can't stand the sound of the Lars' drums, I still here a garbage can instead of a snare.

IMO Metallica will never be what it was before the black album ever again.

Posted

[quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1656752' date='Sep 16 2008, 12:30 PM']Hetfields voice still sounds like croutons, and I can't stand the sound of the Lars' drums, I still here a garbage can instead of a snare.

IMO Metallica will never be what it was before the black album ever again.[/quote]
Too true, too true :nocomment:

Posted (edited)

I hold a reserved, but positive opinion of this album.

Everything said by St. Olaf holds true.

Nevertheless, the overall attempt (as well as the sound produced) is by FAR the best we've seen of this legendary band since the [i]Black Album[/i] or even - dare I say it - [i]And Justice For All[/i]. The band managed to do this by finally gathering the courage to replace Bob Rock, their old manager, who led them down the dark path of "pop-evolution".

At least their songs have finally drifted back into the epic-length categories of six to eight minutes. Kirk has finally returned to wailing out great solos (although his lack of practice shows), rather than taking a back seat to the rest of the band. Moreover, the overall "mood" of the album returns once again to the dark-but-intelligent attitude of the classic albums.

Even with reservations, I am exceedingly happy that Metallica seems pointed back in the right direction. I am hopeful that the success of this album (its first week looks to net more than 500k copies sold) will convince them to push even harder, back into the thrash-speed metal of their youth. They are not too old to pull it off one more time.

...and oh, how wondrous a finale that would be.

Edited by Ziggamafu
Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1656576' date='Sep 16 2008, 04:07 AM']So basically its their first thrash album in 20 years.[/quote]

Death magnetic really isnt a thrash metal album. Metallica wasnt really a thrash band ever, Kill Em All was there only thrash album they did. I really dont think lars' snare is bad on this one. As for hetfield's voice, he is getting nothing but praise about it. I saw them at ozzfest and man, his voice is on fire.

Posted

So what was Metallica's genre in the 80's, progressive metal?

Posted

I would say they were just straight up heavy metal and some speed thrown in there but really whatever. If you compare them to thrash bands like exodus, slayer, testament, anthrax or today like municipal waste or soilent green you would get why i dont think they were really a thrash metal band too much.

Posted

[quote name='Fixxxer' post='1657459' date='Sep 17 2008, 03:52 PM']I would say they were just straight up heavy metal and some speed thrown in there but really whatever. If you compare them to thrash bands like exodus, slayer, testament, anthrax or today like municipal waste or soilent green you would get why i dont think they were really a thrash metal band too much.[/quote]


Metallica, in their day, were the kings of flawlessly intricate speed.

Now days, Dragonforce may have best them on the speed - but not in the complex beauty of the arranged melodies. Metallica - especially in Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, and Justice - might as well have been modern day "classical" compositions.

Posted

wooo! getting the album as we speak, though i have heard a few songs of it. i liked them, but wasnt impressed with the unforgiven 3.

nahh, their riff were still thrashy after kill em all, just well produced and recorded is the main difference in sound. and if intricate and flawless makes you not a thrash band, then what about Testament? (i still say the far superior band, certainly holding on to the roots better.)

pretty good work by metallica, definitley a few big steps in the right direction. it is unfortunate that the band is run by Lars, because even in this album, he is the weak link musically.

Posted

Ouch, the disdain goes from Newstead to Ulrich.

I ca understand where you are comming from Fixxer. IMO they had enought speed thrown in to put them(Pre-black) in the same league as Megadeth, Anthrax, and Testament especially when compared to the "straight up heavy metal" bands of the 80's. I mean if you call them regular heavy metal than their contemporaries would be all those Euro and hairspray bands like WASP and the Scorpions. (They did tour and do concerts with such bands though)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...