Kirisutodo333 Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [url="http://www.takimag.com/blogs/article/last_chance_for_life/"]Link to article[/url] Above is a link to an article a pro-Obama Catholic co-student of mine pointed me to. It's an article by Pat Buchanan. Unfortunately, my friend believes that Republicans are just pandering to the pro-lifers to get their vote and that any Catholic that votes McCain-Palin is just plain stupid. This was my friend's response to the article: [i]Buchanan yanks some more pro-life chains. (A pro-life veteran reminded me at my parish this weekend that pro-lifers are to the GOP what blacks are to the DNC -- a vote you can take for granted. At least, that used to be the case... )[/i] [i]What is edifying are the replies. Sorry Pat, the days of the pro-life single issue are closing. More and more conservatives are waking up to the fact that life issues are not about just abortion and it's not about expecting the state to do anything other than murder people. Obama supports grisly murders through partial birth abortions, but is bombing Iran any less grisly? We know white single chicks under 40 dig partial birth abortions -- it's the milieu of our time, of Sex n' the City and all that. But there are others who are questioning. I heard a call into Fr. Pavone's show on EWTN in which a woman gave a very articulate summary of 40 years of voting Republican because she was pro-life. Her question: What's it gotten the movement? Diddly. There are fewer restrictions today on abortion than ever. Thinking Christians are not going to continue for another 40 years of playing the patsy to the GOP -- the same party that mocks them behind closed doors while also supporting economic policies that are destructive of family life can no longer rely on pro-lifers showing up like cattle to the voting booths to pull the lever for bloodthirsty warbots like Palin and McCain. (And yes, Palin made her profession of faith to the god of war. She's no pro-lifer.) War + Murder. Whether it was Clinton in Bosnia or Bush in Iraq, all American politicians can do is murder people and quibbling over the age of the victims is as grisly as casting dice for Christ's garments at Calvary.[/i] Do you agree with the above analysis that Catholics are just plain dumb to vote for the pro-life Republicans? Any advice on how to counter this argument?
cmotherofpirl Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1654982' date='Sep 13 2008, 10:49 PM'][url="http://www.takimag.com/blogs/article/last_chance_for_life/"]Link to article[/url] Above is a link to an article a pro-Obama Catholic co-student of mine pointed me to. It's an article by Pat Buchanan. Unfortunately, my friend believes that Republicans are just pandering to the pro-lifers to get their vote and that any Catholic that votes McCain-Palin is just plain stupid. This was my friend's response to the article: [i]Buchanan yanks some more pro-life chains. (A pro-life veteran reminded me at my parish this weekend that pro-lifers are to the GOP what blacks are to the DNC -- a vote you can take for granted. At least, that used to be the case... )[/i] [i]What is edifying are the replies. Sorry Pat, the days of the pro-life single issue are closing. More and more conservatives are waking up to the fact that life issues are not about just abortion and it's not about expecting the state to do anything other than murder people. Obama supports grisly murders through partial birth abortions, but is bombing Iran any less grisly? We know white single chicks under 40 dig partial birth abortions -- it's the milieu of our time, of Sex n' the City and all that. But there are others who are questioning. I heard a call into Fr. Pavone's show on EWTN in which a woman gave a very articulate summary of 40 years of voting Republican because she was pro-life. Her question: What's it gotten the movement? Diddly. There are fewer restrictions today on abortion than ever. Thinking Christians are not going to continue for another 40 years of playing the patsy to the GOP -- the same party that mocks them behind closed doors while also supporting economic policies that are destructive of family life can no longer rely on pro-lifers showing up like cattle to the voting booths to pull the lever for bloodthirsty warbots like Palin and McCain. (And yes, Palin made her profession of faith to the god of war. She's no pro-lifer.) War + Murder. Whether it was Clinton in Bosnia or Bush in Iraq, all American politicians can do is murder people and quibbling over the age of the victims is as grisly as casting dice for Christ's garments at Calvary.[/i] Do you agree with the above analysis that Catholics are just plain dumb to vote for the pro-life Republicans? Any advice on how to counter this argument?[/quote] Not at all, since there are no other viable candidates to vote for. The Democratic Party has a prodeath platform so they are not even on my slate of options.
Kirisutodo333 Posted September 14, 2008 Author Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1655004' date='Sep 13 2008, 11:09 PM']Not at all, since there are no other viable candidates to vote for. The Democratic Party has a prodeath platform so they are not even on my slate of options.[/quote] That's the thing. These independent Catholics think that Obama is more pro-life than McCain.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 mccain wanted had two prochoice running mates picked, they say. then at the last minute, the republican elders had been insisting on someone prolife, so he picked palin. i seriously question whether he's prolife, ie, whether he wants to rid of Roe.
Kirisutodo333 Posted September 14, 2008 Author Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1655013' date='Sep 13 2008, 11:27 PM']mccain wanted had two prochoice running mates picked, they say. then at the last minute, the republican elders had been insisting on someone prolife, so he picked palin. i seriously question whether he's prolife, ie, whether he wants to rid of Roe.[/quote] So is that a justifiable reason to vote for Obama?
eagle_eye222001 Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1655007' date='Sep 13 2008, 10:15 PM']That's the thing. These independent Catholics think that Obama is more pro-life than McCain.[/quote] How? The abortion issue is an obvious (isn't it?) Maybe they look at the general Republican support of the death penalty. There are some issues with this one which I do not think are dealt with correctly. The first is that the death penalty is meant for people who have committed bad crimes. Abortion deals with the murder of innocent human beings. So you have two groups, one group is innocent, and the other is guilty. The second is that there are a lot more abortions than people who are put to death. So if you want to save a larger group of people, you would vote on the abortion issue before the death penalty issue. I am against the death penalty for two reasons. One is my faith. The other is that the death penalty is not applied fairly. You can kill someone. You may get anywhere from 20 years to the death penalty. Plus. the death penalty tends to get applied a lot more to poor people and minorities and there have been cases where we look back now and we have legitimate reasons to think s[url="http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/texassouthwest/stories/050206dntexinnocence.1cf614f.html"]omeone innocent may have died[/url]. The Catholic Church teaches that the death penalty can be ok if it is the only method to basically make the community safe. Catechism of the Catholic Church # 2266 and 2267. However, since we have jails, we have the ability to make the community safe. In early Bible times they did not have the jail and justice system that we have today so it would be okay back then, but not now. I know some would cite the early old testament as a defense for the death penalty. From the CCC [i] Capital Punishment 2266 The State's effort to contain the spread of behaviors injurious to human rights and the fundamental rules of civil coexistence corresponds to the requirement of watching over the common good. Legitimate public authority has the right and duty to inflict penalties commensurate with the gravity of the crime. The primary scope of the penalty is to redress the disorder caused by the offense. When his punishment is voluntarily accepted by the offender, it takes on the value of expiation. Moreover, punishment, in addition to preserving public order and the safety of persons, has a medicinal scope: as far as possible it should contribute to the correction of the offender.[67] 2267 The traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude, presupposing full ascertainment of the identity and responsibility of the offender, recourse to the death penalty, when this is the only practicable way to defend the lives of human beings effectively against the aggressor. "If, instead, bloodless means are sufficient to defend against the aggressor and to protect the safety of persons, public authority should limit itself to such means, because they better correspond to the concrete conditions of the common good and are more in conformity to the dignity of the human person. "Today, in fact, given the means at the State's disposal to effectively repress crime by rendering inoffensive the one who has committed it, without depriving him definitively of the possibility of redeeming himself, cases of absolute necessity for suppression of the offender 'today ... are very rare, if not practically non-existent.' [68] [/i] An argument Democrats and Independents may make is that the Democrats are trying to stop wars while the Republicans are for the wars. Again this issue needs closer looking at. Again abortion deals with innocent human beings and the other is not-so innocent human beings. The Catholic Church teaches that you can have war. There is something called [url="http://www.catholic.com/library/Just_war_Doctrine_1.asp"]Just War Theory[/url]. I will just go over the bare details and then look at the current wars. The Just War Theory basically says that you can have war if and only if all the following apply. [i]The strict conditions for legitimate defense by military force require rigorous consideration. the gravity of such a decision makes it subject to rigorous conditions of moral legitimacy. At one and the same time: - the damage inflicted by the aggressor on the nation or community of nations must be lasting, grave, and certain; - all other means of putting an end to it must have been shown to be impractical or ineffective; - there must be serious prospects of success; - the use of arms must not produce evils and disorders graver than the evil to be eliminated. the power of modem means of destruction weighs very heavily in evaluating this condition. [/i] If you look at the Gulf War, this war appears to fulfill all of these mandates. The Iraq war? Not so much. It really does not fulfill [i]"damage inflicted by the aggressor on the nation or community of nations must be lasting, grave, and certain;"[/i] as the weapons of mass destruction were never found and the threat of them (if they existed) was not proved. The invasion of Afghanistan I believe was moral as it fit the Just War Doctrine. So on a moral level, it was incorrect to invade Iraq despite Saddam being evil as the mandates for Just War were not fulfilled. However, in the position that we are in now is the aftermath of war. If the U.S. were to pull out now, there would be chaos and there would be more civilian deaths. The U.S. needs to be there to keep it stable, however I also believe that we need to get Iraq to stand on its own legs and get out of there as soon as we can as our army is stretched too far and if another conflict arose that required our attention, we would be in trouble (draft?). Embryonic research. I will keep this short as it seems whenever this gets debated, no one really knows what they are talking about and end up having to do a lot of copying and pasting of terms that none of us know. First, while embryonic research sounds great with all the promises of treating diseases, it fails for a couple reasons. One, you cannot attain to reach a moral ending by means of immoral actions. Embryonic research is immoral. 2nd, it seems the promises are brought are super-hyped and I see is a political force for Democratic votes. I mean, who would stop your family member from getting a cure even if it is brought by immoral means? I may of rambled, however, I think that if you are looking at life, the R party wins.
philothea Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1654982' date='Sep 13 2008, 09:49 PM'][url="http://www.takimag.com/blogs/article/last_chance_for_life/"]Link to article[/url] Above is a link to an article a pro-Obama Catholic co-student of mine pointed me to. It's an article by Pat Buchanan.[/quote] It's a nice article. I think Buchanan is correct. [quote]Unfortunately, my friend believes that Republicans are just pandering to the pro-lifers to get their vote and that any Catholic that votes McCain-Palin is just plain stupid.[/quote] Of course they are. That's what political parties [i]do[/i]: try to get enough individuals with special interests together to be able to help each other's causes. Do the Republicans really "care" about the gun rights folks? Or any other special interest? So far the Republican platform has pushed anti-abortion causes, so much that the pro-abortion folks are extremely upset about it, and the Supreme Court nearly has (may already have?) an anti-abortion majority. I don't know how much more "caring" is required. [quote]This was my friend's response to the article: [i] (snip) Obama supports grisly murders through partial birth abortions, but is bombing Iran any less grisly? We know white single chicks under 40 dig partial birth abortions -- it's the milieu of our time, of Sex n' the City and all that. But there are others who are questioning. I heard a call into Fr. Pavone's show on EWTN in which a woman gave a very articulate summary of 40 years of voting Republican because she was pro-life. Her question: What's it gotten the movement? Diddly. There are fewer restrictions today on abortion than ever. [/i][/quote] Errm? No... Abortions are no longer funded overseas with tax dollars. That's HUGE. The partial birth abortion ban was big, and it was passed by both houses and upheld by the Supreme Court. Protections for doctors and other health professionals who morally oppose abortion is a big deal too. No more fetal stem cell research. Is your friend not paying attention? [quote][i] Thinking Christians are not going to continue for another 40 years of playing the patsy to the GOP -- the same party that mocks them behind closed doors while also supporting economic policies that are destructive of family life can no longer rely on pro-lifers showing up like cattle to the voting booths to pull the lever for bloodthirsty warbots like Palin and McCain. (And yes, Palin made her profession of faith to the god of war. She's no pro-lifer.) War + Murder. Whether it was Clinton in Bosnia or Bush in Iraq, all American politicians can do is murder people and quibbling over the age of the victims is as grisly as casting dice for Christ's garments at Calvary.[/i] Do you agree with the above analysis that Catholics are just plain dumb to vote for the pro-life Republicans? Any advice on how to counter this argument?[/quote] Well, first off, the Republicans have done a pretty good job restricting abortion, to the extent that they are able, considering it was a supreme court decision, and no other branch of government has the power to directly overturn it. I, too, am [i]very[/i] upset about the pro-war, pro-capital punishment, pro-toture agenda that many Republicans (particularly the current president) push. I am extremely annoyed that we functionally get no choice of candidates at this point. I don't give Republicans a free pass, where they can do anything and as long as they pay some lip service to the pro-lifers. But. In [b]this election[/b] Buchanan has it exactly right. Abortion is the issue. Obama has been very clear where he stands, and we know what would happen.
Mercy me Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 I think that a candidate's respect for life is indicative of a lot more than just their stand on abortion. Among other things it shows me if they have sold out to moral relativism. I believe that there is right and there is wrong that apply universally.
Lounge Daddy Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1655013' date='Sep 13 2008, 10:27 PM']mccain wanted had two prochoice running mates picked, they say. then at the last minute, the republican elders had been insisting on someone prolife, so he picked palin. i seriously question whether he's prolife, ie, whether he wants to rid of Roe.[/quote] Actually, there is a liberal circle that had been advising McCain on many issues until recently. These liberals include some of the "powers that be" within the GOP that want the party to move to the left--not even move the party to the middle, but reach over to the left. Robert Novak briefly mentioned this liberal circle within the GOP in [url="http://www.creators.com/opinion/robert-novak/avoiding-a-lieberman-disaster.html"]an article[/url] that appeared on the last week of August. At the time they had been leaning on McCain to pick Lieberman for a running mate for some time. Interestingly, Lieberman was among the people who encouraged his friend John McCain to stop listening to the liberals within the party. Either Joe Lieberman is questioning the logic of this liberal circle that has infested the Republican Party, or he is questioning the shady motives of those scoundrels. The good news is this: John McCain is no longer listening to those liberals that had been whispering in his ear for the past several years. And that is a good thing. McCain has been making an effort to get back to conservative sensibilities. He is surrounded by a lot of people that will help him stay focused on the principles that made the Grand Old Party, well, grand. And Sarah Palin is now one of the people that will be there in the White House helping the administration keep that conservative focus. And that is the greatest news of all!
mommas_boy Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1655013' date='Sep 13 2008, 10:27 PM']i seriously question whether he's prolife, ie, whether he wants to rid of Roe.[/quote] He wants the question returned to the states. To many (but certainly not all) Republicans, it is not an issue of life as much as it is one of state's rights. What we need is a federal law prohibiting abortion, not a fractionating of the pro-life campaign by having to widen our scope to 50 battles, instead of just one.
Kirisutodo333 Posted September 14, 2008 Author Posted September 14, 2008 [quote]So on a moral level, it was incorrect to invade Iraq despite Saddam being evil as the mandates for Just War were not fulfilled. However, in the position that we are in now is the aftermath of war. If the U.S. were to pull out now, there would be chaos and there would be more civilian deaths. The U.S. needs to be there to keep it stable, however I also believe that we need to get Iraq to stand on its own legs and get out of there as soon as we can as our army is stretched too far and if another conflict arose that required our attention, we would be in trouble (draft?).[/quote] This is arguable. One can say (at the time of the conflict-not knowing what we know now), all variables of the Just War theory were satisfied. Jus ad bellum 1. Just Cause - U.S. feared imminent attack from terrorist who were aided by Sadam, verified by intelligence reports. U.N intervention repeatedly failed. Sadam refused to give up WMD's (verified by intelligence reports at the time which all of congress saw). 2.Proportionality - U.S. believed future destruction via WMD's of American lives where greater than the casualties estimated to go to war. The prevention of this future American massacre outweighed the evil means. 3.Reasonable possibility of success - U.S. believed they could take Sadam within a few months with minimal casualties. 4.Competent authority - U.S. government (take it as it is). 5.Injury is real and certain - again U.S. believed of being in danger if Sadam sold WMDs to terrorists. 6. Right intention - To capture WMD's, take down Sadam and leave. 7. Last resort - U.N. sanctions and interventions were exhausted. So as you can see, one can argue that the Iraq War was a just war (not with what we know now of course, but at the time of the decision, which is what counts). I don't personally agree with this, but it is very arguable nonetheless. [quote]The Catholic Church teaches that you can have war.[/quote] It also teaches the Pacifist life in the paragraph above the Just War teaching in the Catechism. Thanks for the information, but here is the thing, these independent Catholics are not arguing that other issues take precedent of "abortion" per say, what they are arguing about is that the Republican party has pandered to the pro-lifers just to get their votes and really do not care about pro-life issues, and that under a Republican government, or any government for that matter, Roe v. Wade will never be overturned, and therefore the pro-life agenda will never be fulfilled. So according to them, it is better to go with Obama since he is supposedly going to bring about social justice and maybe curb abortions in that manner by reducing unwanted pregnancies. What do you have to say to this?
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 roberts said that he's bound to respect Roe out of precedent. if he wasn't fudging the truth, or as cahtolics say, holding out teh truth, then we should take him for his word, that that's what he thinks. alito simply ignored the questions. i'd like he's willing to overturn, but i don't know, but can give him the benefit of the doubt. without roberts, there's 6 who want to keep roe, and three who want to overturn. mccain said he doesn't want to get rid of roe, but recently has been pandering to the prolife folks. whether he'll proactively go with prolife, or even do what he said he liked,,,, ie people like alito and roberts,,,, is an open question. but even if he did the alito and roberts thing... it's only going to keep the status quo. there's many republicans who think he won't do the prolife cause any good. it's not just liberals who wnat to convince you to vote democrat. every republican for the last thirty years,,,, at least,,, as put just as many prolife as prochoice justices on the bench. that means that even with a republican president every election,,, it's even still questionable whether there'd be enough sway to rock the bench. wiht someone as questionable as mccain, i don't think you can expect any better. but really, ultimately, it's an open question. i can see it being argued that if there's a chance, you should vote prolife. but i can see it argued that it's just wishful thinking, and a wasted vote, allowing oneself to be manipulated against the facts.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 also, i think ginsberg said she's waiting till there's a liberal to get off the court. there's always that 88 year old justic though. it's truly an interestin situation.
CatherineM Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 When a justice won't say how they plan to vote, that usually means they are planning to vote differently than expected, or they are actually professional enough to believe they should wait until they see the case presented to them before making a decision. My biggest fear is that whoever gets in office will pick the best pro-life justice, the best female justice, the best pro-choice justice, the best minority justice, the best handicapped justice, etc. As a legal professional, I believe that the country deserves the Best jurist possible. I realize that everyone here thinks Thomas is a wonderful judge because he is pro-life, but people who actually know his work are pegging him for maybe the least qualified ever. That's the kind of justice we get saddle with when one issue is the only consideration in picking a justice. I will now duck from the expected onslaught.
dairygirl4u2c Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 (edited) i forgot to add.... mccain said he had no lithmus test. so it's only adding weight to the argument that you shouldn't expect any more than you've ever gotten from past republicans. justi9ce thomas only gives the appearance of qualified, cause he purports to be a strict constructionist. whatever that means. people fall into the mindset.... "no legislating from the bench" "the consttitution means what it says"... etc... even though both of those statements are a whole lot more complicated than what they appear. plus he hardly never asks questions, or engages during oral arguments. as if he's not capable. he doesn't purport to try to defer to precedent etc,,,, it's just easier that way than to try to conceive of a nuanced but consistent system where some things are givne precedent but others are not. etc. and then scalia's totally political. not nearly as neutral as he might claim. even a lot of libertarians will admit as much,,,, who usually like thomas. but don't get me started on scalia. the liberal hard core justices aren't any better though. the moderate justices, as usual, are the one who speak with true reason and impartiality and like real judges. Edited September 14, 2008 by dairygirl4u2c
FSM Sister Posted September 14, 2008 Posted September 14, 2008 Say what you want about Palin (keep in mind you profess to be a Christian!) but actions speak louder than words. Here's a woman who lives what she professes. I can't name another politician that has that kind of a record. Mr. Obama had to disown his own former pastor. Palin hasn't had to do that. Do you want a president or vice president that would have to disown their own pastor? BTW, what church did Obama join after that? (Oh... he didn't. He doesn't think religion is important at all. It's a cultural thing, and his mother exposed him to many of them: Muslim, Shinto, Christian, Atheist... it makes no difference. She treated alternative religious views like most people would treat ethnic foods.) Palin has been able to pass on her values to her children. Track could have had an easy life, gone off and partied through college. Instead he joins the military and is making his own way. Palin worked her way through college, too. When the difficult "push came to shove," Levi and Bristol were not afraid to tell this supposed "barracuda" that they were expecting a baby. That's trust. How many girls would have just run away from home or had an abortion, or both? Bristol knew that her mother would still love her and support her. They didn't try to hide Levi or pay him off to disappear because Sarah was now running for Vice President. Instead, they embraced him and brought him along to the RNC. That's forgiveness. Who would I trust more with my aging parent in a nursing home, Obama or Palin? I think we know the answer. Anyone who can murder the innocent without blinking wouldn't hesitate to pull the plug and enact all kinds of euthanasia and assisted suicide legislation. Then there is the whole homosexual question. While Obama embraces it, Palin supports a church that prays for them and tries to bring them back to healthy, heterosexual beliefs. While Sarah Palin was busy making life better for Alaskans and enjoying an 80-90% approval rating based on actual work, Obama was out making a name for himself while voting "absent" on most of the senate legislation. He did very little work at all in the senate. When asked about his experience, he didn't mention his work in the senate - he mentioned his community organizing and his campaigning! COME ON, PEOPLE!!!! That's like calling tooting your own horn actual work! Gee - I can run this country because I can promote my own image. Just think what wonders Palin might have accomplished if she had spent this much time and MONEY on self-promotion. Her Christian values and record of accomplishment rocketed her to becoming a household word - without the cost of millions of dollars that are better spent on real issues, like poverty, homelessness, health care... Don't even get me started on Troopergate. If he were not a former relative, and she had not fired him, then THAT would be the scandal. Are you saying she should allow an irresponsible trooper keep his job, after tazering his stepson (I don't care how "safe" he claims it is - Michael Jackson was holding his baby with both hands when he held him out over the balconey. Did that make it okay?) So should this trooper get a free ride because he's now untouchable? That would be what I would call an abuse of power - his! Before Sarah Palin was added to the ticket, I had never even looked at this political section. Now I'm even posting on it! I can hardly the interest I've taken in politics. If it gets ME this fired up (I, too, used to think that the GOP was just using us pro-lifers, and what had they done since '73 to show for it??) I can't imagine what it would do to people who are already political activists. I think this will get the pro-lifers really fired up, and that now it WILL begin to make a difference. More money has been pouring into pro-life groups since Palin was added to the ticket. So - when you go to your voting booth and prepare to pull that lever, are you going to be pulling [u]for[/u] or [u]against[/u] life?
fides quarens intellectum Posted September 15, 2008 Posted September 15, 2008 [quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1655007' date='Sep 13 2008, 09:15 PM']That's the thing. These independent Catholics think that Obama is more pro-life than McCain.[/quote] point them to NARAL's ratings
Socrates Posted September 16, 2008 Posted September 16, 2008 [quote name='Kirisutodo333' post='1654982' date='Sep 13 2008, 08:49 PM'][url="http://www.takimag.com/blogs/article/last_chance_for_life/"]Link to article[/url] Above is a link to an article a pro-Obama Catholic co-student of mine pointed me to. It's an article by Pat Buchanan. Unfortunately, my friend believes that Republicans are just pandering to the pro-lifers to get their vote and that any Catholic that votes McCain-Palin is just plain stupid. This was my friend's response to the article: [i]Buchanan yanks some more pro-life chains. (A pro-life veteran reminded me at my parish this weekend that pro-lifers are to the GOP what blacks are to the DNC -- a vote you can take for granted. At least, that used to be the case... )[/i] [i]What is edifying are the replies. Sorry Pat, the days of the pro-life single issue are closing. More and more conservatives are waking up to the fact that life issues are not about just abortion and it's not about expecting the state to do anything other than murder people. Obama supports grisly murders through partial birth abortions, but is bombing Iran any less grisly? We know white single chicks under 40 dig partial birth abortions -- it's the milieu of our time, of Sex n' the City and all that. But there are others who are questioning. I heard a call into Fr. Pavone's show on EWTN in which a woman gave a very articulate summary of 40 years of voting Republican because she was pro-life. Her question: What's it gotten the movement? Diddly. There are fewer restrictions today on abortion than ever. Thinking Christians are not going to continue for another 40 years of playing the patsy to the GOP -- the same party that mocks them behind closed doors while also supporting economic policies that are destructive of family life can no longer rely on pro-lifers showing up like cattle to the voting booths to pull the lever for bloodthirsty warbots like Palin and McCain. (And yes, Palin made her profession of faith to the god of war. She's no pro-lifer.) War + Murder. Whether it was Clinton in Bosnia or Bush in Iraq, all American politicians can do is murder people and quibbling over the age of the victims is as grisly as casting dice for Christ's garments at Calvary.[/i] Do you agree with the above analysis that Catholics are just plain dumb to vote for the pro-life Republicans? Any advice on how to counter this argument?[/quote] Buchanan is right. (And those familiar with Pat Buchanan will know he is[i] far[/i] from a rote Republican Party cheerleader, being a strong opponent of the Iraq war from the beginning, and having opposed both Bushes politically.) And the Church plainly teaches that war and the death penalty are NOT morally equivalent to abortion, and the Pope has basically said now that we need to finish what we started in Iraq, rather than leave the country in shambles. Such "pious" excuses for voting pro-abort in reality conveniently ignore the Church's actual teachings. Roe v. Wade depends on the SCOTUS makeup, and will probably need to be challenged by the states. I can honestly not for the life of me understand why ANYONE claiming to be pro-life would vote for a blatantly pro-abort pol like Obama. If pro-lifers who think the GOP is not pro-life enough rallied around a pro-life 3rd-party candidate, that would be one thing, but to vote for those who do all they can to perpetuate abortion (and block any pro-life political initiatives) is to truly be part of the problem, not part of the solution. If "pro-life Catholics" are content to vote for supporters of infanticide, this hardly sends a message to the GOP on the need to be more strongly or agressively pro-life, but merely sends the message to both parties that abortion is a non-issue for the "religious conservative" voter, and can thus be safely ignored. That's not voting for "hope,' but the politics of despair. An "Obamacon" is a contradiction in terms. God help the United States of America!
kamiller42 Posted September 16, 2008 Posted September 16, 2008 I think Pat points out this time in history provides a special opportunity, and I hope and pray it comes out on the side of life. I think he is a little drastic in saying this would be the only opportunity in history to over turn Roe v. Wade. The problem is that it might be long time before we get another chance. That is worrisome. If you haven't see the video at [url="http://www.catholicvote.com/"]catholicvote.com[/url], I suggest you watch it and pass it along.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now