Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

...which McCain avows he doesn't understand too well

...will decide this election.

Posted

I'd much rather have someone admit they don't know something and ask for expert advice, than to bumble through and screw things up rather than admit they don't know something.

Posted

So that's why he has a cabinet. And we should appreciate his honesty on that topic.

At least McCain doesn't hate Capitalism. The same cannot be said about Obama. It bothers me that a man like Obama wants to be president of a country that is founded on principles that he detests.

Posted

Whether he says so or not, I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that Obama is no economic genius either...

Posted

obama doesn't hate capitalism. he's all about the free market, as a way to drive down costs for things.
he wants to use it for insurance companies. etc.
[url="http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/07/magazine/07letters-t.html?_r=1&ref=magazine&oref=slogin"]http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/07/magazine...amp;oref=slogin[/url]

Lisieux Flower
Posted (edited)

edit..

my bad, i forgot to log in
-Didy

Edited by Lisieux Flower
Posted (edited)

Why is it that when we discuss any other issue in politics, someone usually likes to throw in what the Church teaches, but rarely does anyone do this when it comes to economy?

It is my understanding, and correct me if I am wrong, that the Church is not in favor of capitalism, but rather of a third way of economics that within itself contains the true answer to the failure of socialism and the greed of unbridled capitalism..

Edited by Didymus
Posted

trickle down is a terrible theory as an end all to solving the economic woes of the country. a lot of conservatives are duped into thinking it's the only way to fix things.
even if it worked, it'd only be helpful in creating jobs. and then dripping effects as the name says. maybe a little competition and innovation indirectly.
you can be better to give directed tax cuts who do things that advance the economy instead of blanket tax cuts. eg, brings capital to the US, creates jobs, creates innovation etc.

trickle down doesn't fix the fact that the market has failed, partly cause of our regulations but we can't unregulate health care compeltely. it doesn't fix the fact that education etc can be out of control.
if there's things that are more lucrative than health care and edation etc, then those are what's going to be invested in, as per competition.
markets fail all the time. in fact, it might be the rule more than they don't.
free market economics might help. obama's not against them. he talks about it with education, insurance etc.

Posted

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism[/url]

Posted

obama has mostly academics and former econ advisors for his advisors.

mccain has mostly CEO types.

i can provide evidence on this as i have before if anyone doens't believe me.

Posted

if mccain were really duped, he'd probably follow a lot of conservative rhetoric that says debt is better than paying for it, in the national government. depsite what greenspan etc say. despite a lack of explanation. despite the conservative idea that you pay for your expenses.... somehow that gets lost in politics.

if he desn't defend himself.... all he really stands for is an increase in taxes, and ultimately being less conservative than obama.

ie, massive tax cuts at the expense of not paying for them only menas more you're going to have ot pay for more later.

Posted

"you can be better to give directed tax cuts who do things that advance the economy instead of blanket tax cuts. eg, brings capital to the US, creates jobs, creates innovation etc."

and instead of giving preferential treatment to people who invest inways that are favored by the capital gains tax, target those other things.
ie, increased outside capital investments into the economy, innovation, and job creation. roughly in that order.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1656193' date='Sep 15 2008, 06:43 PM']I'd much rather have someone admit they don't know something and ask for expert advice, than to bumble through and screw things up rather than admit they don't know something.[/quote]

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1656204' date='Sep 15 2008, 06:54 PM']So that's why he has a cabinet. And we should appreciate his honesty on that topic.[/quote]
It's not whether McCain has a bunch of pointy-headed economic advisers around him, it's the underlying economic philosophy of the Republican party that's the problem, to wit, "I'm all right, Jack, I've got mine," "borrow [from the Chinese and the Saudis] and spend," "government isn't the solution, it's the problem," so let's cut regulatory oversight. Well, after eight years of Law of the Jungle Capitalism, we can all see how well [i]that's[/i] worked out. The US can literally not afford another four years of the past eight years.

Posted

it's not wrong to say you don't know something as president. then on the other hand, you should be expected to elite-ly good at everything you do to be president. if the other person can get you, then you shouldn't win on that issue.
no one knows everything, and needs people to surround them.

not to say obama's necessarily better. though i tend to think so.

whatever one's position,,, the question isn't whether he's ignorant or not, it's whether he's more ignorant than obama... and whether his ideas are better.

yeah other than my opinions on obama, i just stated a bunch of truisms...
but my point was to provide the counter balances to the ratinalizations of mccain econ ignorance.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[img]http://www.uclick.com/feature/08/09/18/tt080918.gif[/img]

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[color="#FF0000"][url="http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=washingtonstory&sid=aVPBaUbYV_qQ"]Democratic Congress May Adjourn, Leave Crisis to Fed, Treasury...

Reid: 'No one knows what to do'...[/url][/color]

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

that link about the treasure etc is very true.
i come to find more and more, that congress has no idea for the most part what it's doing. they're often no more versed in econ theory, health care etc, than someone who studies from afar on the interenet, a lot of people in this forum even prolly know more.

that's why the executive branch often has to fix things. that's why the supreme court said at first that the executive doing things was unconstitutional, but then the court changed its mind.

that's why good policy can't be found. they've lost the policy in politics. they've lost the nuance. not that they ever had it very well to begin with. it's pure politics mostly in the worst sense of the word.

a lot of times it just has to do with the sheer size of congress.
congress needs dispute resolution specialists, consensus builders. that's why bush jr smells of elderberries so bad, he's not a consensus builder by any means. he's not nuanced. he smells of elderberries where it matters.

but the executive branch is often skewed and messed up. maybe we need ot change our system. our representatives really aren't knowledgable as the theory of representative democracy suggests. we should just have ocngress, people who we can relate to and have our values but mostly are not knowledgable enough, elect the real decision makers.

that's of course taking a step that we shouldn't have to do. the elective should be knowledgable, but i'm just taking reality for what it is. if a politician tries to be nuance or specific, it's too easy to alienate people. so the good often are thrown out by our very population. that's why you can have bad politicans just as easy as good ones. it's better to be vague and let people project their ideas onto you. to let repub or dem stick with their party cause it's all so vague as to know what is stood for.

just some rants

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1658498' date='Sep 18 2008, 05:05 PM']that link about the treasure etc is very true.
i come to find more and more, that congress has no idea for the most part what it's doing. they're often no more versed in econ theory, health care etc, than someone who studies from afar on the interenet, a lot of people in this forum even prolly know more.


...

just some rants[/quote]
Which is exactly the point. Government don't know poo.

Posted

Anyone who buys into the theory that raising taxes for the rich but cutting taxes for 95% is 1. possible, or 2. going to put more money in their pocket, is living in la la land. Here's what happens when you "cut" taxes.

Rich people are going to stay rich. If you tax them more, they will recover their temporary losses by doing - gues what - RAISING PRICES.

Who do you think owns businesses? Poor people? Stop fooling yourselves. Say you're the guy in the $200,000 annual income bracket, subject to Obama's higher taxes. What do you do for a living? You either own real estate, operate a business, work in a corporation, or work on Wall Street. If your taxes go up, you raise the cost of the service you provide to cover your losses. Who ends up paying? The consumer... you know, the one that pays $1100 less in taxes per year, but needs to spend $1500 per year more on gas, groceries, medical care, insurance, clothes, utilities, and housing.

Unless he is going in to the counterfiet money business, Obama can't make money appear out of nowhere. The money has to come from somewhere. It will come from us.

All these people that have been shelling out contribution money to Obama are going to come looking for a reward for thier investment. What did he promise to do for them in return? (MAKE MORE MONEY FOR THEM!)

Pray that God will have mercy on us, and that McCain/Palin win the election.

Posted

BTW, the word is P=R=O=B=A=B=L=Y, not "prolly."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...