Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Abortion Issue Again Dividing Catholic Votes


Recommended Posts

Posted

With all due respect, you shouldn't judge my statement either. Who are you to judge anything I say? Anyway, you implied that I don't give a hoot about babies just about documents. So, I'll regurgitate no further to you.

Posted

with all due respect, this forum is open to debate, which means we can judge each others statements.

You said that [i]since[/i] Roe v Wade, abortion is THE ONE ISSUE.. Am I not allowed to judge that this is incorrect? Even if my opinion is merely that it has always been the most important issue?

You also claim that McCain and Palin will do what they can against abortion. I also disagree with that as well. Can I not judge that statement?

I never intended to upset anyone. I felt the need to comment on your original post, and when someone WRITES LIKE THIS, it makes me feel as though they are attacking me from the get go..

Posted

also I never said anything about you not caring about babies before Roe v Wade. If that's what you feel implied, then I apologize. It was not my intent.

My intent was to point out that the genocide, as KoC, called it, began long before Roe v Wade, and that in our attempts to incite a just and moral conscience in the hearts of the voters, we shouldn't leave out those who suffered before the day the feds approved of it..

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659363' date='Sep 19 2008, 03:01 PM']with all due respect, this forum is open to debate, which means we can judge each others statements.

You said that [i]since[/i] Roe v Wade, abortion is THE ONE ISSUE.. Am I not allowed to judge that this is incorrect? Even if my opinion is merely that it has always been the most important issue?

You also claim that McCain and Palin will do what they can against abortion. I also disagree with that as well. Can I not judge that statement?

I never intended to upset anyone. I felt the need to comment on your original post, and when someone WRITES LIKE THIS, it makes me feel as though they are attacking me from the get go..[/quote]

Life is the one issue which all others flow, without life no other issue matters. Every since Roe v Wade mass genocide has been legalized, until it is made illegal again it is the one issue that matters. Sure your 'allowed' to disagree, but in the same way your also 'allowed' to disagree that grass is green and the sky is blue. McCain vs Obama, McCain would be the prolife ticket hands down, not perfect by no means, but lets face it Obama will destroy the gains by the prolife movement over the last 8 years. McCain will not and the prolife movement will be able to grow under his leadership.

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)
:shutup:

Didymus, you don't want me to continue to regurgitate do you?

...

I think I've said enough. You have completely misread my statements and judged me wrong......


...by the way, thanks, KofC! You, on the other hand, read me correctly! 100%! At least my point got across with some of you, (I hope!) I thought I was clear enough, I guess I was wrong! I won't say anymore on this subject. I think I have said enough... Edited by dominicansoul
Posted

I think so too..

and KoC doesn't exactly read you correctly, he just pretends to be infallible on these issues.

all the while no one is really listening to anyone. Thank God lives aren't actually at stake through all this... oh wait.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1659378' date='Sep 19 2008, 04:43 PM']Life is the one issue which all others flow, without life no other issue matters. Every since Roe v Wade mass genocide has been legalized, until it is made illegal again it is the one issue that matters. Sure your 'allowed' to disagree, but in the same way your also 'allowed' to disagree that grass is green and the sky is blue. McCain vs Obama, McCain would be the prolife ticket hands down, not perfect by no means, but lets face it Obama will destroy the gains by the prolife movement over the last 8 years. McCain will not and the prolife movement will be able to grow under his leadership.[/quote]

1. I merely disagreed that it has been the most important issue only [i]since[/i] Roe v Wade...

2. What gains have we made in the past [b]8 years[/b]? Are not 3000-4000 women still getting abortions every day? What has happened in the last eight years to help these women? Anything?

3. McCain's platform is pro-life at least by name of course. Whether we will be able to grow under his leadership is reasonably debatable..


Oh, and could you pass a "no hard feelings" message on to D-Soul for me? I don't think she wants to talk anymore. I would figure if someone made such a grave generalization like she did in her original post ("People on this forum don't seem to understand...") that we could perhaps respond to it. I guess it is inappropriate to question statements like that.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659442' date='Sep 19 2008, 05:29 PM']1. I merely disagreed that it has been the most important issue only [i]since[/i] Roe v Wade...[/quote]

Before Roe v Wade or legalized abortion, infanticide was not legalized and therefor rare, the personhood of the fetus was protected by the state and abortionist charged with murder. Also before Roe v Wade/legalized abortion legalized abortion mass amounts of people did not question the personhood of the child. Roe v Wade/legalized abortion was a fundamental change in how Americans respect life, or more correctly disrespect life.

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659442' date='Sep 19 2008, 05:29 PM']2. What gains have we made in the past [b]8 years[/b]? Are not 3000-4000 women still getting abortions every day? What has happened in the last eight years to help these women? Anything?[/quote]

The two that come to mind without looking anything up is the Born Alive protection act, and Partial Birth Abortion Ban, which Obama has promised to undo if he is elected. There are others, and if you would like I will look them up.

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659442' date='Sep 19 2008, 05:29 PM']3. McCain's platform is pro-life at least by name of course. Whether we will be able to grow under his leadership is reasonably debatable..[/quote]

Debatable perhaps, but at the end of that debate over all I believe it would show that McCain would be good for the prolife movement. But there is no debate that Obama would be very very bad for the prolife movement.

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659442' date='Sep 19 2008, 05:29 PM']Oh, and could you pass a "no hard feelings" message on to D-Soul for me? I don't think she wants to talk anymore. I would figure if someone made such a grave generalization like she did in her original post ("People on this forum don't seem to understand...") that we could perhaps respond to it. I guess it is inappropriate to question statements like that.[/quote]

Hum idk but sounds as if there is a little hard feelings.... but anyway I dont think her pm is broken.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1659378' date='Sep 19 2008, 03:43 PM']Life is the one issue which all others flow, without life no other issue matters. Every since Roe v Wade mass genocide has been legalized, until it is made illegal again it is the one issue that matters. Sure your 'allowed' to disagree, but in the same way your also 'allowed' to disagree that grass is green and the sky is blue. McCain vs Obama, McCain would be the prolife ticket hands down, not perfect by no means, but lets face it Obama will destroy the gains by the prolife movement over the last 8 years. McCain will not and the prolife movement will be able to grow under his leadership.[/quote]

Making abortion illegal is unenforceable. Didn't you every study Prohibition? Prohibition tried to make drinking alcohol illegal. Instead it promoted it. It could not be enforced. Speakeasies and illegal drinking were everywhere. The law was eventually repealed.

Making abortion illegal will drive it underground again. It will become like meth labs are--everywhere. The suction devices used in eastern Europe and Russia are easily obtainable. Any minimally trained health practitioner can learn to use one, get a hold of cheap antibiotics and set up shop.

In order to really prevent abortion, you would have to test all pre-menopausal women every month to identify the pregnant ones and then put them under surveillance for nine months. Aside from violating the Constitution, is this practicable ?

Abortion was never rare. It just wasn't detected and wasn't reported.

Explicit sex education and contraception are the only ways to reduce abortion. The lowest abortion rates are in Northern Europe and Scandinavia, where these policies are followed.

Regarding abstinence-only sex education, 26 states now refuse federal funds to promote this after seeing how this sort of 'education' increased illegitimate birth rates [i]and[/i] STD's. The federal government has spent 1.5 BILLION dollars in an attempt to promote this, with very little to show for it.

Posted

[quote]Making abortion illegal is unenforceable. Didn't you every study Prohibition? Prohibition tried to make drinking alcohol illegal. Instead it promoted it. It could not be enforced. Speakeasies and illegal drinking were everywhere. The law was eventually repealed.[/quote]Fallacious analogy, unless abortion is addictive now. People circumvented alcohol and illicit drug prohibitions because they had addictions. If abortions weren't a viable option, then women would either be taking a ridiculous risk with their own lives, or would have the baby.

princessgianna
Posted

well u are right! but then should we continue allowing a mother to kill her child legally?
or should we just make it legal to kill someone else and it is every man\woman for his\her self?

i see your point but then people can be prosecuted(as they should be) for killing another human person!

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1660198' date='Sep 20 2008, 04:53 PM']Fallacious analogy, unless abortion is addictive now. People circumvented alcohol and illicit drug prohibitions because they had addictions. If abortions weren't a viable option, then women would either be taking a ridiculous risk with their own lives, or would have the baby.[/quote]

Fallacious fallacious analogy.

People drank not because they had addictions, but because they liked drinking and saw no reason why it should be forbidden. People also sold bootlegged liquor because it was very lucrative, as are illegal drugs. Most drug users in this country are recreational users anyway, not addicts. There is no way to prohibit marijuana, meth or cocaine from being sold, no matter how hard the government tries; this is why the feds try to dry up the source.

If Roe v. Wade is overthrown, abortion clinics will spring up across the border in Canada and Mexico, plus the Caribbean, and probably in 'cruise ships', in addition to all the illegal abortions being performed in the states. If the decision is turned over to the states, many states will retain legal abortion and abortion clinics will start up along their borders with the non-abortion states, like states selling non-taxed alcohol, cigarettes, and firecrackers along their borders. Just as casinos are in rivers which abut states which forbid them, abortion clinics could do the same thing, or be started up on Indian reservations, which are sovereign land, where casinos are allowed, which are otherwise illegal in the surrounding state. Sound crazy? It's not. Women will always find a way to have an abortion and people will find a way to make money providing it. Because the business is unregulated, because it is illegal, it wouldn't require a licensed practitioner to perform it; any nurse, doctor, med-school dropout, MD's who lost their licenses could make a very good living being an abortionist in the settings I have described. As for illegal abortions, the states won't even try to shut down illegal abortions, as they have to divert so much of their money and personnel now to closing meth labs, illegal drugs and immigration.

If an attempt is made to amend the constitution with a constitutional amendment, this would require ratification by 3/4 of the US states, or 38 states, a virtual impossibility, as the population which wants to outlaw abortion is neither widespread nor numerous.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1658560' date='Sep 18 2008, 05:33 PM']I rarely vote for anyone. I typically vote against the other guy.[/quote]

Good show, Win.

I love that movie.

Posted

[quote name='jkaands' post='1660234' date='Sep 20 2008, 07:16 PM']Fallacious fallacious analogy.

People drank not because they had addictions, but because they liked drinking and saw no reason why it should be forbidden. People also sold bootlegged liquor because it was very lucrative, as are illegal drugs.[/quote]
I disagree on this point, but debating will not be fruitful, so I'll agree to disagree.

[quote]Most drug users in this country are recreational users anyway, not addicts. There is no way to prohibit marijuana, meth or cocaine from being sold, no matter how hard the government tries; this is why the feds try to dry up the source.[/quote]
Marijuana, perhaps not, but cocaine and methamphetamine are quite addictive. I'd think that there were very few cases in which repeat users weren't addicted.
[quote]If Roe v. Wade is overthrown, abortion clinics will spring up across the border in Canada and Mexico, plus the Caribbean, and probably in 'cruise ships', in addition to all the illegal abortions being performed in the states. If the decision is turned over to the states, many states will retain legal abortion and abortion clinics will start up along their borders with the non-abortion states, like states selling non-taxed alcohol, cigarettes, and firecrackers along their borders. Just as casinos are in rivers which abut states which forbid them, abortion clinics could do the same thing, or be started up on Indian reservations, which are sovereign land, where casinos are allowed, which are otherwise illegal in the surrounding state. Sound crazy? It's not. Women will always find a way to have an abortion and people will find a way to make money providing it. Because the business is unregulated, because it is illegal, it wouldn't require a licensed practitioner to perform it; any nurse, doctor, med-school dropout, MD's who lost their licenses could make a very good living being an abortionist in the settings I have described. As for illegal abortions, the states won't even try to shut down illegal abortions, as they have to divert so much of their money and personnel now to closing meth labs, illegal drugs and immigration.[/quote]
So be it, then. Certainly you've heard the old adage that "Just because everyone else is doing it, that doesn't make it ok." If every other country on the planet wants to allow the murder of the unborn, so be it. This does not mean that the US has to allow this evil to occur within her borders.
[quote]If an attempt is made to amend the constitution with a constitutional amendment, this would require ratification by 3/4 of the US states, or 38 states, a virtual impossibility, as the population which wants to outlaw abortion is neither widespread nor numerous.[/quote]
I guess we'll allow the results of this election to show whether the population which supports abortion is widespread and numerous or not.

Posted

they didn't take the booze bc they were addictive.

i remember hearing that legalizing abortion caused it to increase ten fold.

he makes good points though about how it'd be legal in canada, etc etc, and might not reduce it. i really don't know. if my stat i heard is correct, i'd think it'd help.

if it's just outlawing someitng that's nto gonna change, i agree though, it'd be pointless to change it, or especially spending time trying to.

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1660249' date='Sep 20 2008, 07:48 PM']I guess we'll allow the results of this election to show whether the population which supports abortion is widespread and numerous or not.[/quote]
The results of this election won't show anything about abortion. Most people don't vote based on abortion views, so it's a fallacy in logic to assume that the distribution of votes accurately predicts views on abortion.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Pax' post='1660573' date='Sep 21 2008, 02:50 PM']The results of this election won't show anything about abortion. Most people don't vote based on abortion views, so it's a fallacy in logic to assume that the distribution of votes accurately predicts views on abortion.[/quote]

You must be out of touch with [url="http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/gerald_warner/blog/2008/09/19/joe_biden_loses_barack_obama_the_catholic_vote"]the real Catholic vote[/url] then...

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Terra Pax' post='1660573' date='Sep 21 2008, 02:50 PM']The results of this election won't show anything about abortion. Most people don't vote based on abortion views, so it's a fallacy in logic to assume that the distribution of votes accurately predicts views on abortion.[/quote]
Well, most Catholics do (and [i]all[/i] should).

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Didymus' post='1659243' date='Sep 19 2008, 01:34 PM']Of course I know better.. But I'm getting pretty sick and tired of folks unecessarily stressing a document instead of the abortions at hand..

We set ourselves up to buy into the campaigns of anyone who merely says they believe life begins at conception but never do anything for the women who walk into the abortion clinic everyday once we vote them into office.

If this truly is the ONE ISSUE at hand, then why the devil aren't we demanding more from our worthless elected "pro-life" officials then allowing ourselves to be duped by their rhetoric, all the while they do next to squat for us..[/quote]
Like it or not, the ruling Roe v. Wade is what has made abortion-on-demand the law of the land in America, and this will have to be overturned by the Supreme Court.

It is the job of the president to appoint Supreme Court justices. And oftentimes the efforts of "worthless" pro-life officials are blocked by liberal Democrats, and "moderate" Republicans.
And you tell me, why aren't [i]you[/i] demanding more from them (rather than just complaining how worthless all pro-lifers are)?

And why aren't [i]we[/i] doing more for women who walk to the abortion clinic? Helping pregnant women is primarily job of all of us in the pro-life movement, not of the government.
To quote that revered liberal president JFK, "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."

Edited by Socrates
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1660801' date='Sep 21 2008, 10:10 PM'](rather than just complaining how worthless all pro-lifers are)?[color="#FF0000"]My comment: I don't think she said that. That would be called "putting words in someone's mouth".[/color]

And why aren't [i]we[/i] doing more for women who walk to the abortion clinic? Helping pregnant women is primarily job of all of us in the pro-life movement, not of the government.
To quote that revered liberal president JFK, "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."[/quote]

I agree with this statement! We as prolifers need to do more. I do abortion clinic outreach when I can, but many prolifers I know have never been to an abortion clinic in their lives. :(

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...