LouisvilleFan Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 Anything from the Archbishop of New Orleans about this? It's a bit concerning that 67% of viewers in one of the countries most "Catholic" regions are in favor of this. Not surprising, of course, but concerning.
StColette Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1664399' date='Sep 26 2008, 05:08 PM']Anything from the Archbishop of New Orleans about this? It's a bit concerning that 67% of viewers in one of the countries most "Catholic" regions are in favor of this. Not surprising, of course, but concerning.[/quote] I haven't heard anything yet from the Archbishop, but I know of him and know him to be orthodox from what I know of him. And it's not one of the countries most "Catholic" regions. Most of the "Catholics" there are dwindling in numbers greatly to Evangelical churches. You must also take into account that the majority of these people are poorly catechized given the time period in which they were raised or are being raised. Also many of these people are desperate for help given the situations down there and throughout the state. This is being viewed by them as a means to help people in a bad situation. I've seen first hand what these people live in and it's not pretty. New Orleans has tent cities up all over the place and not just because of Hurricane damage. It's a very sad existence for them and now someone is giving them what seems to be a little hope, though completely the wrong type of hope. What this person has not taken into account that sterilization could also cause a great rise in STDs which are rampant enough as they are. Sadly, southern Louisiana is not what it once was.
StColette Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 From Archbishop of New Orleans Archbishop Alfred Hughes on Thursday denounced a Metairie lawmaker's proposal to pay poor people to undergo sterilization as "an egregious affront to those targeted and blatantly anti-life." "Our lawmakers would do better to focus on policies that promote education and achievement to counteract poverty and the bigotry of low expectations, " Hughes said in a statement. Hughes spoke out in response to a proposal by state Rep. John Labruzzo, R-Metairie, to combat poverty by offering poor women and men $1,000 to undergo reproductive sterilization and vasectomies. In addition, the lawmaker said he is considering whether to propose tax incentives for college-educated people to have more children. Hughes appears to be the first major local clergyman to take a public stand on the issue, which Labruzzo broached Tuesday. Archdiocesan spokeswoman Sarah Comiskey said the Catholic Church would oppose Labruzzo's plan in Baton Rouge if he turns it into legislation. Hughes based his opposition on two elements of Labruzzo's proposal: the technique of direct sterilization and the underlying purpose of manipulating the birth rate to reduce certain populations as a matter of public policy. Catholic teaching holds that tubal ligation and vasectomy are wrong, because they rob sexuality of one of its main purposes, the transmission of life. More broadly, the plan "would also constitute a form of eugenics that the church and this country have always condemned, " Hughes said. [url="http://www.nola.com/news/index.ssf/2008/09/hughes_sterilizing_the_poor_bl.html"]http://www.nola.com/news/index.ssf/2008/09...he_poor_bl.html[/url] " The Catholic Church has consistently taught that direct sterilization is seriously wrong ... The recent proposal of Rep. LaBruzzo not only would make sterilization our public policy and require tax payers to pay for it, but would also constitute a form of eugenics that the Church and this country have always condemned as an egregious affront to those targeted and blatantly anti-life." [url="http://www.daylife.com/article/0gktgo3bQicX3"]http://www.daylife.com/article/0gktgo3bQicX3[/url] A day after state Rep. John LaBruzzo, R-Metairie, made a buzz in the New Orleans area by proposing $1,000 for woman on welfare to have their Fallopian tubes tied, Archbishop Alfred Hughes blasted the idea, calling it “wrong” and against the ideals of the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church, according to Hughes, cannot support LaBruzzo’s proposal, which among other things called for the voluntary sterilization of women who are on welfare, offering them a $1,000 incentive to have the procedure. LaBruzzo said that he was studying the idea because constituents in his district were tired of paying women who cannot support their families and continue to have children. “The Catholic Church has consistently taught that direct sterilization is seriously wrong,” said Archbishop Hughes in a statement. “The recent proposal of Rep. LaBruzzo not only would make sterilization our public policy and require tax payers to pay for it, but would also constitute a form of eugenics that the Church and this country have always condemned as an egregious affront to those targeted and blatantly anti-life.” While LaBruzzo said that his office was flooded with phone calls and emails, many in support, “Our lawmakers,” said Hughes, “would do better to focus on policies that promote education and achievement to counteract poverty and the bigotry of low expectations.” The ACLU of Louisiana also panned LaBruzzo’s idea, echoing Hughes' stance. “The is solution to figure out what they (poor people) need, so they can improve their circumstances, not by the government dictating or influencing who should and who should not have children,” said Majorie Esman of the organization. [url="http://www.wwltv.com/topstories/stories/wwl092508mlbishop.b051e50c.html"]http://www.wwltv.com/topstories/stories/ww...p.b051e50c.html[/url]
Lil Red Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1664421' date='Sep 26 2008, 03:27 PM']this country have always condemned, " Hughes said.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ that hasn't always been true - especially overseas.
StColette Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1664434' date='Sep 26 2008, 05:30 PM']+J.M.J.+ that hasn't always been true - especially overseas. [/quote] Given the time during which Archbishop Hughes grew up I would say it was true then.
Don John of Austria Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 Can we pay the members of NOW, Planned Parenthood, etc 4,000 dollars to be sterilized? Then in 30 or 40 years this garbage would all be over.
picchick Posted September 26, 2008 Posted September 26, 2008 [quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1664448' date='Sep 26 2008, 05:37 PM']Can we pay the members of NOW, Planned Parenthood, etc 4,000 dollars to be sterilized? Then in 30 or 40 years this garbage would all be over.[/quote] They wouldn't choose to do so
Didacus Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 [quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1664448' date='Sep 26 2008, 05:37 PM']Can we pay the members of NOW, Planned Parenthood, etc 4,000 dollars to be sterilized? Then in 30 or 40 years this garbage would all be over.[/quote] The immoral will always be amongst us; or so the saints tell us. This is all just like Vlad the Impaller; you know, that fun guy called 'Dracula' as in son of Dracul? Once Vlad wanted to rid his kingdom of the poor, so he gathered them all for a feast in one of his castles. during the feast he set the castle on fire and killed them all! Yet, tried as he did, he could never be rid of all the poor. Poverty is a question of distribution of ressources, not of quantity of people living in a nation. Besides, the poor will always be with us - the Lord Himself told us that one.
Don John of Austria Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1666150' date='Sep 29 2008, 08:00 AM']The immoral will always be amongst us; or so the saints tell us. This is all just like Vlad the Impaller; you know, that fun guy called 'Dracula' as in son of Dracul? Once Vlad wanted to rid his kingdom of the poor, so he gathered them all for a feast in one of his castles. during the feast he set the castle on fire and killed them all! Yet, tried as he did, he could never be rid of all the poor. Poverty is a question of distribution of ressources, not of quantity of people living in a nation. Besides, the poor will always be with us - the Lord Himself told us that one.[/quote] Immoral of course they will always be amongst us---- we are all sinners, but these kinds of people have not always been amongst us.... and we should no put up with them when they are. I will have to check on the story about Vlad..... that really doesn't sound like him. I mena he was mean enough for htat, I just can't see him doing that to the poor. Nobles who ticked him off, sure, poor people, not his style. But it's possible, still everybody picks on Vlad.
CatherineM Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 There is something so invasive about talking about sterilizing people. When my husband was first diagnosed with schizophrenia, one of his aunts told him to get sterilized. His mom, great-grandmother, and several cousins also have/had the disease. I think that upset him more than anything because he mentions it the most. Alberta just paid the last of the settlements for people who were sterilized in homes decades ago.
princessgianna Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 [quote name='Majella' post='1663274' date='Sep 24 2008, 11:16 PM']Must be a friend of Margeret Sanger:Get rid of the poor, the blacks, and the insane! Incidentally, Margeret Sanger was a great admirer of Adolf Hitler( until he became too obvious in what he was doing)![/quote] wow another person actually has heard of that besides me (i have had friends tell me that that was a lie and she was a good person !
rkwright Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 you should take a look at the case Buck v. Bell. Supreme Court in the 20's-30's decision saying that forcefully sterilizing mental patients was ok and not a violation of their constitutional rights. That case is still on the books - never been overturned.
Lil Red Posted September 29, 2008 Posted September 29, 2008 [quote name='rkwright' post='1666301' date='Sep 29 2008, 11:43 AM']you should take a look at the case Buck v. Bell. Supreme Court in the 20's-30's decision saying that forcefully sterilizing mental patients was ok and not a violation of their constitutional rights. That case is still on the books - never been overturned.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ edit: found it on [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buck_v_Bell"]wikipedia.[/url]
Didacus Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666285' date='Sep 29 2008, 12:03 PM']Immoral of course they will always be amongst us---- we are all sinners, but these kinds of people have not always been amongst us.... and we should no put up with them when they are. I will have to check on the story about Vlad..... that really doesn't sound like him. I mena he was mean enough for htat, I just can't see him doing that to the poor. Nobles who ticked him off, sure, poor people, not his style. But it's possible, still everybody picks on Vlad.[/quote] I will try to find the source a little later and pm you. Unfortunately, my source is not the internet, but a series of books that are currently in my storage until the 1st of december.
Don John of Austria Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1666802' date='Sep 30 2008, 08:29 AM']I will try to find the source a little later and pm you. Unfortunately, my source is not the internet, but a series of books that are currently in my storage until the 1st of december.[/quote] Ah believe me, i understand.
LouisvilleFan Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='StColette' post='1664415' date='Sep 26 2008, 06:24 PM']And it's not one of the countries most "Catholic" regions. Most of the "Catholics" there are dwindling in numbers greatly to Evangelical churches. You must also take into account that the majority of these people are poorly catechized given the time period in which they were raised or are being raised.[/quote] Sounds pretty Catholic to me... What I meant is that it's one of the most culturally and historically Catholic areas of the country. Of course, like most historically and culturally Catholics areas of the world, it's not so much today, but there are still many more practicing Catholics in New Orleans than Nashville.
StColette Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1666825' date='Sep 30 2008, 09:40 AM']Sounds pretty Catholic to me... What I meant is that it's one of the most culturally and historically Catholic areas of the country. Of course, like most historically and culturally Catholics areas of the world, it's not so much today, but there are still many more practicing Catholics in New Orleans than Nashville.[/quote] True, but it's not the Catholic land that everyone makes it out to be. Historically and culturally speaking New Orleans is very Catholic and it has had that label for some time now given it's past history. But, sadly just like what is happening in Central America many Catholics are switching to evangelical churches so the Catholic population there is dwindling rapidly.
desertwoman Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1664220' date='Sep 26 2008, 01:21 PM']+J.M.J.+ wouldn't his plan bring up a lot of bad memories in the South? correct me someone if i'm wrong, but didn't they forcibly sterilize black women in the South back in the 30s and 40s? someone help me out.[/quote] Yep. After we had a kid, the doctor would perform this against her will, and against her knowledge. I'm at work, but I will find more info about it for you...but here is a tad bit of information for you. [url="http://mississippiappendectomy.wordpress.com/2007/11/19/black-women-in-the-1960s-and-1970s/"]Sterilization of Women[/url]
Didacus Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666809' date='Sep 30 2008, 07:49 AM']Ah believe me, i understand.[/quote] Here is a quick reference to it: [quote]BURNING OF UNFORTUNATE ONES Vlad got upset at the increase of cripples, beggars, poor and vagrants upon his land. He was very obsessive regarding that all worked and contributed equally. So he offered up a great feast in a great hall in Tirgoviste, saying that no one should go hungry in his land. The people who were made up of those unfortunate souls that were poor and crippled ate and drank late into the night when suddenly Vlad made an appearance. He asked them "What else do you desire? Do you want to be without cares and lacking nothing in this world?". The crowd were fooled by his question and rose up and answered that they did indeed. Vlad then ordered the hall boarded up and set on fire. No one escaped. Vlad explained his actions saying he did it "in order that they represent no further burden to other men so that no one will be poor in my realm". I think Vlad was reincarnated later as Hitler.[/quote] [url="http://www.castleofspirits.com/vlad.html"]Link[/url] Thnk Hitler reincarnated again? Maybe not the man, but the spirit that drove him never ceases... Back to you Bob...
Didacus Posted September 30, 2008 Posted September 30, 2008 [quote name='desertwoman' post='1666832' date='Sep 30 2008, 09:15 AM']Yep. After we had a kid, the doctor would perform this against her will, and against her knowledge. I'm at work, but I will find more info about it for you...but here is a tad bit of information for you. [url="http://mississippiappendectomy.wordpress.com/2007/11/19/black-women-in-the-1960s-and-1970s/"]Sterilization of Women[/url][/quote] It does seem history is repeating itself. The similarities with 1920s Germany are almost eerie.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now