icelandic_iceskater Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 my little sister learned cursive in kindergarten. granted she already knew how to print pretty dang well by then. forming letters just came naturally to her. I learned it starting in 2nd grade. Still can't write cursive well. Apparently I hold a pencil the wrong way
MissyP89 Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 I learned in the 3rd grade, and it was pushed on me that cursive is faster...but honestly, I even print slow, and my printing is faster. It's also nicer looking.
T-Bone _ Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1672827' date='Oct 8 2008, 03:22 PM']I learned in the 3rd grade, and it was pushed on me that cursive is faster...but honestly, I even print slow, and my printing is faster. It's also nicer looking. [/quote] Same here. Although my handwriting has morphed into a somewhat cursive-eque form.
mcts Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 i learned in 2nd grade, but i never quite mastered it. It was so bad that my 5th and 6th grade teachers, who, before they saw my handwriting, said that EVERYTHING had to be written in cursive, agreed to let me write in printing because it was obvious that I was trying, but couldn't do it, and they couldn't read my writing.
Fidei Defensor Posted October 8, 2008 Posted October 8, 2008 I learned in 2nd grade, and the second graders who I work with after school are also learning it. How strange.
Nihil Obstat Posted October 9, 2008 Posted October 9, 2008 I was pretty awful, learning it in grade five. If my teacher had marked it, I definitely think I would have failed. Luckily I was passable enough to get through, then use printing when I needed to be legible. Then, a few years later, I went back to handwriting, but developed my own style that works far better than the weirdness out gr. five teacher tried to force down my throat.
Guest KateGladstone Posted October 9, 2008 Posted October 9, 2008 Re: "The children I taught usuallly had some form of dyslexia or dysgraphia. Cursive was taught from the beginning, due to the research related specifically to students with dyslexia." Please either cite this research or direct me to a web-page or other source whereon a citation appears. (The research I cited appears on the "Writing Rebels" page of my handwriting web-site at [url="http://www.HandwritingThatWorks.com"]http://www.HandwritingThatWorks.com[/url] .) If it matters: I have dyslexia, I have dysgraphia, and (like my late father and his cousin who had the same conditions) I did MISERABLY with cursive. NOTE: Dad and his cousin learned their cursive -- or tried to -- when they started school in the early 1940s, back in the cursive-only era of pure Palmer Method. This makes it hard for me to accept assertions that the "pure method" works as you claim with all us dyslexic/dysgraphic folks. Re: "There is strong research that cursive handwriting promotes brain development. It is particularly helpful for kineshtetic [sic] learners." Of all the people (literally hundreds) I've seen claiming this "strong research" over the years, not one has managed (when asked) to provide or identify this research. Please either cite the research or direct me to a web-site or other source giving citation. If "cursive promotes brain development," then you'll have to explain away Thomas Aquinas, the great thinkers of the Renaissance, and all the other pretty smart people who lived more than 3 centuries ago, back when the writing style we call "cursive" did not exist. Aquinas _et_al_. do not strike me as having suffered from undeveloped brains. Re cursive and kinesthetic learners in particular: I test out as a kinesthetic learner. (My father and his cousin showed every sign of the same.) As I say, cursive proved the opposite of "particularly helpful" in all our cases!
cmotherofpirl Posted October 9, 2008 Author Posted October 9, 2008 I learned Palmer in catholic school in the 60's, am left-handed and have lovely cursive, and printing. Its interesting while reading your web page to discover that when in a hurry [ not writing letters] I have developed the alphabet style in exactly the same way you have. I think most people who write a lot in long hand do. But I still think printing should be taught first, and teach cursive a year of so later when the child is physically able to do swirls and curves. Ben at 5 clearly cannot do this, and needs to stick to printing until that is mastered. Ideally you could present an alphabet with letters done both ways and have them master it over the course of several years, as some children acquire the fine moter skills sooner than others.
she_who_is_not Posted October 9, 2008 Posted October 9, 2008 [quote name='KateGladstone' post='1673159' date='Oct 9 2008, 12:34 AM']Re: "The children I taught usuallly had some form of dyslexia or dysgraphia. Cursive was taught from the beginning, due to the research related specifically to students with dyslexia." Please either cite this research or direct me to a web-page or other source whereon a citation appears. (The research I cited appears on the "Writing Rebels" page of my handwriting web-site at [url="http://www.HandwritingThatWorks.com"]http://www.HandwritingThatWorks.com[/url] .) If it matters: I have dyslexia, I have dysgraphia, and (like my late father and his cousin who had the same conditions) I did MISERABLY with cursive. NOTE: Dad and his cousin learned their cursive -- or tried to -- when they started school in the early 1940s, back in the cursive-only era of pure Palmer Method. This makes it hard for me to accept assertions that the "pure method" works as you claim with all us dyslexic/dysgraphic folks. Re: "There is strong research that cursive handwriting promotes brain development. It is particularly helpful for kineshtetic [sic] learners." Of all the people (literally hundreds) I've seen claiming this "strong research" over the years, not one has managed (when asked) to provide or identify this research. Please either cite the research or direct me to a web-site or other source giving citation. If "cursive promotes brain development," then you'll have to explain away Thomas Aquinas, the great thinkers of the Renaissance, and all the other pretty smart people who lived more than 3 centuries ago, back when the writing style we call "cursive" did not exist. Aquinas _et_al_. do not strike me as having suffered from undeveloped brains. Re cursive and kinesthetic learners in particular: I test out as a kinesthetic learner. (My father and his cousin showed every sign of the same.) As I say, cursive proved the opposite of "particularly helpful" in all our cases![/quote] And as always, learning is an individual process. I was just explaining the rationale behindi teaching cursive at a young age. Are you familiar with the Orton-Gillingham method? Also, I will clarify and say that research has shown that cursive promotes greater brain development in creating stronger connections between graphemes and phonemes. I'm not saying that if you dont use cursive you will have an underdeveloped brain. That's ridiculous. But in my experience and the studies I read, there appeared to be a correlation between cursive handwriting and achievement in reading. Sorry, you had such a bad experience! I know that learning anything, considering the hostile environment many schools, is difficult when you have a learning disablity. I don't have access to the files in my office as I am in school in another state, but I assure the research does exist. I'd advise you check out the Orton-Gillngham method. Sorry! I do not support merely teaching cursive. I said that as used with the Orton method, children seemed to learn more quickly and with less frustration. However, it depends on the individual child.
Guest KateGladstone Posted October 9, 2008 Posted October 9, 2008 Re: [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1673323' date='Oct 9 2008, 11:05 AM']... printing should be taught first, and teach cursive a year of so later when the child is physically able to do swirls and curves .... Ideally you could present an alphabet with letters done both ways and have them master it over the course of several years, as some children acquire the fine moter skills sooner than others.[/quote] Why teach "both ways" (printing, then cursive) at all? Why not just teach simple letters first, then the simple ways to connect them ... instead of first printing, then cursive, and then hoping that the kid develops a high-efficiency style in spite of having survived those two other styles? (Why not just teach one high-efficiency style from the get-go, instead of two mutually contradictory and less efficient styles?) I ask those questions because the results I've seen (in schools that use the curricula designed to teach high-efficiency writing from the get-go) exceed the results I've seen elsewhere. For examples of such curricula, visit: [url="http://www.BFHhandwriting.com"]http://www.BFHhandwriting.com[/url] (one or two of the site pages include the writing of former students, now grown up) [url="http://www.cep.pdx.edu/titles/italic_series/excerpts.shtml"]http://www.cep.pdx.edu/titles/italic_series/excerpts.shtml[/url] (one of the downloadable graphics here -- "Children's Handwriting Sample" -- shows the writing of children grades 2 through 8 in such a program) [url="http://briem.ismennt.is/4/4.1.1a/4.1.1.1.quick.htm"]http://briem.ismennt.is/4/4.1.1a/4.1.1.1.quick.htm[/url] and [url="http://briem.ismennt.is/4/Worksheets.zip"]http://briem.ismennt.is/4/Worksheets.zip[/url] (and child/adult writing samples at [url="http://briem.ismennt.is/d/dd/dda/ddaa.htm"]http://briem.ismennt.is/d/dd/dda/ddaa.htm[/url] )
Guest KateGladstone Posted October 9, 2008 Posted October 9, 2008 Re: "Are you familiar with the Orton-Gillingham method?" I know people whom it definitely helped, and I know people whom it definitely harmed. Re: " ... research has shown that cursive promotes greater brain development in creating stronger connections between graphemes and phonemes." Who researched this? When? Where? Can you provide a citation (even just an author and title), or even a link to a web-page that has the citation (or even the original research)? Re: " ... in my experience and the studies I read, there appeared to be a correlation between cursive handwriting and achievement in reading." Which studies did you read that showed this? (Author? Title?) Did the studies (and your own experience/observation) compare the effects of cursive handwriting instruction with the effects of equal instruction in other styles of writing, or did the studies (and your own observations) just compare the effects of cursive instruction with the effects of no instruction? Sorry, you had such a bad experience! I know that learning anything, considering the hostile environment many schools, is difficult when you have a learning disablity. I don't have access to the files in my office as I am in school in another state, but I assure the research does exist. I'd advise you check out the Orton-Gillngham method. Sorry! I do not support merely teaching cursive. I said that as used with the Orton method, children seemed to learn more quickly and with less frustration. However, it depends on the individual child. [/quote]
melporcristo Posted October 10, 2008 Posted October 10, 2008 (edited) JMJ Yep - I'd have the little guy wait until 3rd grade. As much as my students want to learn cursive, they gotta start with the basics in writing and print helps them in their reading skills and letter recognition. Edited October 10, 2008 by melporcristo
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now