jckinsman Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1678726' date='Oct 15 2008, 11:08 PM']As some might know, that "you should have ran against him four years ago" statement was so funny I gave it it's own thread on the lame board. Probably one of the best zingers I've heard since Lloyd Bentsen said "you are no Jack Kennedy" back in 1988. I do think that McCain should have done this in the first debate. I think the way he handled the financial crisis by calling for campaign suspensions and trying to delay the debates may have cost him the race. Only time will tell. I'm heavily favoring a vote for Joe the Plumber, though.[/quote] Mine was when McCain called Obama"MR.GOVERNMENT" I snickered. His whole health care plan scares me. Talk about expanding Government.
jckinsman Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1678726' date='Oct 15 2008, 11:08 PM']As some might know, that "you should have ran against him four years ago" statement was so funny I gave it it's own thread on the lame board. Probably one of the best zingers I've heard since Lloyd Bentsen said "you are no Jack Kennedy" back in 1988. I do think that McCain should have done this in the first debate. I think the way he handled the financial crisis by calling for campaign suspensions and trying to delay the debates may have cost him the race. Only time will tell. I'm heavily favoring a vote for Joe the Plumber, though.[/quote] Palin/plumber 2012. Edited October 16, 2008 by jckinsman
Justin86 Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1678679' date='Oct 16 2008, 12:48 PM']So given a hypothetical situation where you had to choose between a "competent" Judge who has had a record of generally supporting abortions "rights" or an "incompetent" (or, less qualified) Judge who is what you'd call "pro-life," who would you choose?[/quote] Your hypothetical runs into problems when you consider historically prior judicial experience is NOT a must have for Supreme Court Justices. The last last man appointed to the Court without prior judicial experience was William Rehnquist. Trying to gauge whether or not a lawyer is "competent" or "qualified" for the Supreme Court is something like trying to determine if there's saminlia in your fruit just by looking at it. There really isn't a litmus test per se, although these days all of them seem to have studied Constitutional Law at Ivy League schools. Personally, I think just being a Constitutional lawyer no matter where it you got your degree qualifies someone for the Court.
kenrockthefirst Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1678726' date='Oct 15 2008, 11:08 PM']As some might know, that "you should have ran against him four years ago" statement was so funny I gave it it's own thread on the lame board. Probably one of the best zingers I've heard since Lloyd Bentsen said "you are no Jack Kennedy" back in 1988.[/quote] I disagree. The vehemence of McCain's disavowal said to me that Obama's linking McCain with Bush is working, and it's really getting under McCain's skin. His demeanor when he made the statement was "angry old man." In addition, it provided the perfect opening for Obama to come back and say, "gee, John, I'm sorry I had you confused with Bush there for a minute. It's just that you supported all his policies and, indeed, represent a continuation of those policies." McCain certainly seemed more genuine during this debate. Unfortunately for him, it's too little, too late. On a final note, when they were talking about campaign advertising and how each side has gone negative, McCain noted that the Obama camp claimed that he was against federal funding for stem cell research, and then claimed that he wasn't. What should we make of that vis-a-vis McCain's stance on "life" issues?
Fidei Defensor Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='rkwright' post='1678792' date='Oct 15 2008, 10:51 PM']I think McCain is very clear on this. Its not so much that hes pro-life as much as hes a federalist. He supports Judges who are strict constitutionalists. 99.99% of those are going to be pro-life on the issue of abortion. Hes not going to say heres a pro-life judge, I'll appoint this one... He's going to find the strict constitutionalist judge, who in turn would also overturn Roe v. Wade. Your hypothetical presents a false choice - there are certainly competent judges who don't support Roe v. Wade.[/quote] Forgive me, but I'm just feeling confused about this. You guys are the ones who would vote for the crappiest candidate if he was the pro-life choice and the other was the pro-choice candidate, but you don't find it disturbing at all that McCain didn't specifically say he would ensure a pro-life candidate? "Qualified" and all the other words he used to describe who he would choose don't mean anything. It's all subjective.
fides quarens intellectum Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='Norseman82' post='1678644' date='Oct 15 2008, 10:22 PM']McCain did manage to slip in a remark something to the effect that judges who openly supported Roe vs. Wade did not meet the qualifications (federalist, "strict constructionist"). That was EXACTLY the way to phrase it, IMHO.[/quote] iawtc [quote name='rkwright' post='1678792' date='Oct 15 2008, 11:51 PM']I think McCain is very clear on this. Its not so much that hes pro-life as much as hes a federalist. He supports Judges who are strict constitutionalists. 99.99% of those are going to be pro-life on the issue of abortion. Hes not going to say heres a pro-life judge, I'll appoint this one... He's going to find the strict constitutionalist judge, who in turn would also overturn Roe v. Wade. Your hypothetical presents a false choice - there are certainly competent judges who don't support Roe v. Wade.[/quote] again - well put. [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1678819' date='Oct 16 2008, 12:08 AM']This frustrates me about Republicans (in general) to no end ... the text book definition of a Republican (mind you, not what individuals think, nor even a trend) is that a Republican should want the issue to go to the states. Which will fracture the movement, and lead to situations where someone just needs to cross state lines in order to obtain an abortion. Abortion is wrong is wrong is wrong ... no matter what state it is in. I feel as though we need a federal banning of abortion, not just a wimpy relegation of the decision to the states.[/quote] "Text book" states' rights people i know wouldn't have a problem with it being outlawed at the federal level by means of a constitutional amendment. In the meantime, we need to overturn the ridiculous Roe decision, though. [quote name='jckinsman' post='1678902' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:17 AM']Mine was when McCain called Obama"MR.GOVERNMENT" I snickered.[/quote] "Senator Government" - that was classic. [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1678921' date='Oct 16 2008, 07:25 AM']On a final note, when they were talking about campaign advertising and how each side has gone negative, McCain noted that the Obama camp claimed that he was against federal funding for stem cell research, and then claimed that he wasn't. What should we make of that vis-a-vis McCain's stance on "life" issues?[/quote] He didn't specify adult vs. embryonic - as far as i know, McCain doesn't have a problem with adult stem cell research (and neither does the Church).
fides quarens intellectum Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1678955' date='Oct 16 2008, 10:15 AM']Forgive me, but I'm just feeling confused about this. You guys are the ones who would vote for the crappiest candidate if he was the pro-life choice and the other was the pro-choice candidate, but you don't find it disturbing at all that McCain didn't specifically say he would ensure a pro-life candidate? "Qualified" and all the other words he used to describe who he would choose don't mean anything. It's all subjective.[/quote] There is no way he can "ensure" anything about a justice - someone already brought up how effective "ensuring" has been to presidents in the past. What he was saying is: 1) He's pro-life. 2) SCOTUS justices should be strict constitutionalists, not bench legislators. Thus, i, and it appears others on this board, inferred that the kind of judges McCain would nominate are exactly the kind we need to overturn Roe.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1678621' date='Oct 15 2008, 11:13 PM']I want McCain to elaborate more about what he said about nominating Justices based on qualification and not stances. He mentioned he voted to approve Justice Ginsberg, the liberal, pro-choice Justice... Interesting.[/quote] It isn't right that litmus tests be applied to judges up for the Supreme Court. They should be voted on based on their abilities as judges, not as lawmakers. If they are approved because they want to rewrite the meaning of the Constitution, for good or for bad, then they are not going to make honest justices. That having been said, if they are good justices, they will uphold the Constitution and natural law, which are both entirely pro-life.
kamiller42 Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1678955' date='Oct 16 2008, 11:15 AM']You guys are the ones who would vote for the crappiest candidate if he was the pro-life choice and the other was the pro-choice candidate, but you don't find it disturbing at all that McCain didn't specifically say he would ensure a pro-life candidate? "Qualified" and all the other words he used to describe who he would choose don't mean anything. It's all subjective.[/quote] If he said what you think he should say, that he would nominate someone only if he/she is pro-life, you would be the first in line to point out his hypocrisy. That would be a litmus test which he said he want do. He gave a good, solid answer. Point McCain.
kamiller42 Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1678819' date='Oct 16 2008, 01:08 AM']This frustrates me about Republicans (in general) to no end ... the text book definition of a Republican (mind you, not what individuals think, nor even a trend) is that a Republican should want the issue to go to the states. Which will fracture the movement, and lead to situations where someone just needs to cross state lines in order to obtain an abortion. Abortion is wrong is wrong is wrong ... no matter what state it is in. I feel as though we need a federal banning of abortion, not just a wimpy relegation of the decision to the states.[/quote] The abortion issue falling back to the states would be a huge step forward for the pr-life movement. Fracture? More like "divide and conquer." It would make the pro-life movement more powerful because resources spread across 50 states could coalesce around the few remaining pro-abortion states. To all, In regards to the debate, I thought McCain had a slight win in debate 1, tie in debate 2 (the snoozer), and clean Obama's clock in debate #3. His pro-life answers were fantastic. His economic plan makes much more sense (and cents!) than Obama's. Obama's solution are government centered. McCain's are centered around the people with the assistance of the government when necessary.
SpareTime Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1678819' date='Oct 16 2008, 01:08 AM']This frustrates me about Republicans (in general) to no end ... the text book definition of a Republican (mind you, not what individuals think, nor even a trend) is that a Republican should want the issue to go to the states. Which will fracture the movement, and lead to situations where someone just needs to cross state lines in order to obtain an abortion. Abortion is wrong is wrong is wrong ... no matter what state it is in. I feel as though we need a federal banning of abortion, not just a wimpy relegation of the decision to the states.[/quote] yes it is very wrong. what we need is a constitutional amendment, not a "give the issue back to the states" bandaid.
Hassan Posted October 16, 2008 Author Posted October 16, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Justin86' post='1678909' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:37 AM']Your hypothetical runs into problems when you consider historically prior judicial experience is NOT a must have for Supreme Court Justices. The last last man appointed to the Court without prior judicial experience was William Rehnquist. Trying to gauge whether or not a lawyer is "competent" or "qualified" for the Supreme Court is something like trying to determine if there's saminlia in your fruit just by looking at it. There really isn't a litmus test per se, although these days all of them seem to have studied Constitutional Law at Ivy League schools. Personally, I think just being a Constitutional lawyer no matter where it you got your degree qualifies someone for the Court.[/quote] I just had a test on Constitutional Law, the William Rehnquist reference just gave me flashbacks to all his damman oppinions I had to read He was brilliant though. And many of the most brilliant justices did not have formal education or juducual experience. Look at John Marshal or Warren (yes I like him, please let the beating be mercyfull ). I think you can tell to some extent. I mean the two judges I disagree with most are Scalia and Thomas. I really don't think Thomas is a very good justice. I've never found his oppinions particularly enlightening or insightfull. On the other hand, love him or hate him, Scalia is a very, very good judge (in my oppinion). I disagree with his politics but I don't think anyone can honestly deney his legal brilliance. Edited October 16, 2008 by Hassan
SpareTime Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='kamiller42' post='1679065' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:26 PM']The abortion issue falling back to the states would be a huge step forward for the pr-life movement. Fracture? More like "divide and conquer." It would make the pro-life movement more powerful because resources spread across 50 states could coalesce around the few remaining pro-abortion states.[/quote] i must disagree. giving the issue back to the states means 50 new problems. it makes much more sense to have a constitutional amendment defining life and rights as from the point of conception to natural death. otherwise, as already stated, abortion within certain states won't stop, it will just mean traveling out of state to get an abortion.
flip Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='kamiller42' post='1679065' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:26 PM']The abortion issue falling back to the states would be a huge step forward for the pr-life movement. Fracture? More like "divide and conquer." It would make the pro-life movement more powerful because resources spread across 50 states could coalesce around the few remaining pro-abortion states.[/quote] Umm, I think making Abortion an illegal federal law is WAY better than having the states decide. The goal is to stop abortion, not just move it around to different states.
eagle_eye222001 Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='kamiller42' post='1679065' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:26 PM']... In regards to the debate, I thought McCain had a slight win in debate 1, tie in debate 2 (the snoozer), and clean Obama's clock in debate #3. His pro-life answers were fantastic. His economic plan makes much more sense (and cents!) than Obama's. Obama's solution are government centered. McCain's are centered around the people with the assistance of the government when necessary.[/quote] It may be too late unfortunately. Although time will tell.
kamiller42 Posted October 16, 2008 Posted October 16, 2008 [quote name='SpareTime' post='1679081' date='Oct 16 2008, 02:39 PM']i must disagree. giving the issue back to the states means 50 new problems. it makes much more sense to have a constitutional amendment defining life and rights as from the point of conception to natural death. otherwise, as already stated, abortion within certain states won't stop, it will just mean traveling out of state to get an abortion.[/quote] Do not ignore the "conquer" portion of "divide and conquer." The ultimate goal is the abolishing of abortion at the federal level, but in the meantime.... To get an amendment passed take a lot of work, a lot of support. We can get that support state by state. Too many states avoid the issue with the excuse of "well, Roe is the law. Our hands are tied." That excuse will go away. And when one states adopts a pro-life stand by amendment or proposition, some of that state's resources be poured into another state.
Madame Vengier Posted October 17, 2008 Posted October 17, 2008 (edited) [quote name='flip' post='1679285' date='Oct 16 2008, 06:20 PM']Umm, I think making Abortion an illegal federal law is WAY better than having the states decide. The goal is to stop abortion, not just move it around to different states.[/quote] The goal is also to punish those who do it. Abortion will never stop. It's been going on from the start, in every culture and every age, and there are tons of ways to do it. The problem is that it's shameful for any country to sanction it, which is what they are effectively doing by making it legal. And then the same country has the nerve to complain about their crime rate. Abortion is the ultimate crime against humanity. At least if abortion is illegal someone will be punished if they are caught. Edited October 17, 2008 by Madame Vengier
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now