Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Should Faithful Catholics Be Affiliated With Parties?


Recommended Posts

HereticHunter10
Posted

I bring up this issue, not because I'm an independent (FYI: I plan to vote for John McCain).

I bring up this issue because it is one I think faithful Catholics, who believe that ALL the Chruch's Social Teachings should be upheld and acted upon, sometimes struggle with. I know I see it with the Catholics I socialized with (and I go to Catholic HS).

When you look at the two major parties in the US and their platforms, neither party has social issues in its platform. Meaning the Democratic Party does not stand for abortion and gay rights, rather Democratic Politicians stand for abortion and gay rights. Same with the Republicans, the Republican party is not pro life and pro family but GOP politicians are.

So, each party is made up of ideals on how to govern. Democrats prefer the use of government to provide stability to the working class generally. Republicans believe that when the government stays out of the lives of its citizens, all benefit; lower, middle, and upper class citizens.

So based on Catholic ideology and the parties ideology, a solid case can be made for both.

Example: The Church believes that governments should make it so that healthcare should be afforded to all---similar to the idea of universal healthcare, a traditionally liberal or Democratic ideal.

Also: The Church believes in the participation of all in the community, society, business place, so that all can succeed with out limits by governments. This is similar to the GOP or conservative ideal that ALL benefit when governments stay out of business and let the people participate with themselves, by themselves.

I could go on with many issues but I think you guys get the point.

Social issues aside, if this is the case, that Catholic teachings have merits in both parties, how is it possible that faithful Catholics can say that this issue is more important than that issue? Aren't all of equal significance? How is healthcare not as important as immigration reform according to Church teaching?

Catholics can be seen as liberal sometimes and conservative other times if they believe and act on Church Social Teaching.

So why belong to a party that is only one of those (conservative of liberal)? Is it, maybe, in some way wrong to belong to a party that is just conservative on all issues if you are liberal on some, and vice versa?

Shouldn't Catholics promote having an NPA on their voter card for what it symbolizes?

If not, then why not start, maybe, a Catholic political party. (Ex: America's Catholic Party)

A party that actually includes social issues like cap punishment and abortion in its platform. A party that is liberal on immigration and healthcare but conservative on gay marriages and education. A party where all Faithful Catholics can be a part of and endorse fully.

Any comments? Questions?

Saint Therese
Posted

I'm not much of a party person.

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682214' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:27 PM']I'm not much of a party person.[/quote]


don't be anti-social :topsy:

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682216' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:28 PM']don't be anti-social :topsy:[/quote]

I prefer to stay home and read and pray ( although I do sometimes go and visit my friend).
I guess that's why I"m going to be nun.

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682221' date='Oct 20 2008, 09:34 PM']I prefer to stay home and read and pray ( although I do sometimes go and visit my friend).
I guess that's why I"m going to be nun.[/quote]
I don't like parties either. I don't drink and it's no fun being the only sober person in a room full of drunks :unsure:

which order are you going to be?

have you considered

[img]http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/Pics/her%20franciscan%20friars.jpg[/img]

...just a suggustion :unsure:

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682228' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:38 PM']I don't like parties either. I don't drink and it's no fun being the only sober person in a room full of drunks :unsure:

which order are you going to be?

have you considered

[img]http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/Pics/her%20franciscan%20friars.jpg[/img]

...just a suggustion :unsure:[/quote]
Cloistered Dominicans.. although the the Fransicans of the Renewal are awesomeness!

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682229' date='Oct 20 2008, 09:40 PM']Cloistered Dominicans.. although the the Fransicans of the Renewal are awesomeness![/quote]


I knows.

I think I'm still on their mailing list :unsure:

I have several e-mail accounts which I always fail to check and I don't remember which one I gave them :wacko:

Posted

when are you joining the clostered dominicans?

I met some cloistered Passionists several times in Pennsylvania.

And I'm glad I had those chances because you don;t see a lot of cloistered nuns walking around these days :o

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682236' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:46 PM']I knows.

I think I'm still on their mailing list :unsure:

I have several e-mail accounts which I always fail to check and I don't remember which one I gave them :wacko:[/quote]
Whatever happened to you discerning with them?

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682240' date='Oct 20 2008, 09:48 PM']Whatever happened to you discerning with them?[/quote]

what do you mean?

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682242' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:50 PM']what do you mean?[/quote]
Weren't you discerning with them?..... :unsure:

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682246' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:52 PM']Weren't you discerning with them?..... :unsure:[/quote]

oh yeah, duh: p

Yes I was discerning them a bit ago.

I respect a group of grown men who arn't afraid to year socks with sandals :))

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682253' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:57 PM']oh yeah, duh: p

Yes I was discerning them a bit ago.

I respect a group of grown men who arn't afraid to year socks with sandals :))[/quote]
And dresses!!

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1682256' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:58 PM']And dresses!![/quote]


dresses can be preaty..... :unsure:


:D

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1682258' date='Oct 20 2008, 10:59 PM']dresses can be preaty..... :unsure:


:D[/quote]
The FFRs are really awesome. i saw Fishers of men on EWTN the other day.
And I love their show Parable on EWTN.
I think Fr. Groeschel is awesome and I've met Fr. Glen Sudano who used to be Servant of the Community.

Posted

The suggestion I came up with thanks to some friends here a while back:

[b]C[/b]atholics [b]R[/b]esenting [b]A[/b]merican [b]P[/b]olitics.

We have a Facebook group and everything...:mellow:

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1682307' date='Oct 20 2008, 11:33 PM']The suggestion I came up with thanks to some friends here a while back:

[b]C[/b]atholics [b]R[/b]esenting [b]A[/b]merican [b]P[/b]olitics.

We have a Facebook group and everything...:mellow:[/quote]
:lol:

Posted

I think any party based on Catholic principles, while really cool, would be pretty much doomed to failure in the election-winning-sense.

Christian ideals are pretty much the opposite of popular. By definition.

I'm not really a fan of democracy, but I guess we're stuck with it for now. I think we might be best off trying to influence the parties we've got. I don't think a successful political party can be anything but a collection of shared interests, most of which are evil.

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1682330' date='Oct 20 2008, 11:41 PM']I think any party based on Catholic principles, while really cool, would be pretty much doomed to failure in the election-winning-sense.

Christian ideals are pretty much the opposite of popular. By definition.

I'm not really a fan of democracy, but I guess we're stuck with it for now. I think we might be best off trying to influence the parties we've got. I don't think a successful political party can be anything but a collection of shared interests, most of which are evil.[/quote]
For now, soon to be on the way to totalitarianism. Very soon, I'd say.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='philothea' post='1682330' date='Oct 20 2008, 11:41 PM']I think any party based on Catholic principles, while really cool, would be pretty much doomed to failure in the election-winning-sense.

Christian ideals are pretty much the opposite of popular. By definition.

I'm not really a fan of democracy, but I guess we're stuck with it for now. I think we might be best off trying to influence the parties we've got. I don't think a successful political party can be anything but a collection of shared interests, most of which are evil.[/quote]
Back in the day,the catholic vote was what was sought after,the difference between winning and losing. It has only become "unpopular" after vatican two and the misinterpetation of what"a new springtime" meant to preists who sought after the approval of birth control. When this great event took place and our Holy Father put his Holy foot down on the matter. Silent and not so silent dissenters hit the church, and hit it hard they did. This fractioned us at a pivitol point in time, this tossing out the baby with the bath water,so to say (no pun intended). Abortion is now birth controls favored back up. Re-edgumacatin' young catholic's with a bunch of useless garbage. Whatever happened to teaching us the faith? (leaving soap box)
This is where your social issues come in. Some where along the way we put infanticide by the way side, because there are needy people out there that we have to take care of.
See, babies are disposable now, Hey but we can be like God,yet again, Gee that apple just wasn't good enough. With this lovely magic pill that will free women up from the bitter slavery of men,our families and our homes (or did this move enslave us further?...huh? dig deep?) With the fabric of society decaying now,.. What to do????
Got some simple news for you,those needy people will always be here, a new soul, that God gives us, won't be, if the mother chooses it. Harsh??? Try reading the bible. The poor will always be among us it says,...therefore it is OUR duty to care for them. Since when did it get to be the Governments job to create people dependant on the govenment to live??? What is more Loving??? Feeding them or teaching them how to grow the food for themselves???? What would YOU say is more Loving????...and mind you, how do you do that if you have fewer resources yourselves through heavy taxation?? YOU are to to the spreader of YOUR own hard earned wealth to the needy in YOUR communities and YOU are the one to choose with YOUR own money who and what social programs YOU want to support. I do not want to support groups that do not coinside with my principles. Acorn,Abortion etc.

The more Goverment provides,the more it has control over all of our lives. The more we grow into mindless robots because someone else has the remote. I want God to have my remote,not the government. Greed and politics mix like a martini,don't put the cherry in it by condoning both sides as having strong catholic values. They don't. Life is the affirmation of God's love for us. Without life we become a selfish society. Look at the damage of Abortion thus far.....Maybe just maybe our country deserves Obama.... Maybe the most loving thing is to let us sink so we see what is important.?????

Edited by jckinsman

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...