Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Insurance Settlement Offer... Advice Needed


Recommended Posts

Posted

In April of 2008 I was involved in an accident that forced me to miss a week of college, purchase a new car, left with a bruised vertebrae, memory loss (even still to this day) and other various ailments.

I recently received the Insurane Companies offer for a settlement and I think it is rather low, maybe I'm wrong, but they offered me $5,000.00

I'm wondering if this is a bit low or what I should do from here, should I counter offer?

I made a post a while back about this issue and finally a resolution is coming fruition, here is the thread I started a while back: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=80921&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...c=80921&hl=[/url]

Your advice in this situation would be greatly appreciated so I am not taken advantage of.

Thanks,

Ed Looney

Posted

My concern about accepting a judgment that you feel is too low, is that the kind of injury that you received, can get worse, or escalate later. I was injured in 1991, but didn't end up in a wheelchair because of it until 1996. I worked full time for the first year, and the brain injury went down hill until I was basically unable to work at all by 1994. I don't feel like I really began to recover from the brain injury and get better until just a couple of years ago. Everyday, I start to feel more like my old self, but I still have limits.

Have you consulted an attorney? You can get a free consultation, and they would be much more up on what the maximum you could expect by taking it to court. Even giving half of any future settlement to the lawyer, you may end up coming out on top. Plus, you could get a provision in the settlement to revisit the amount in case of future complications. I'd be surprised if 5000 would even really cover your actual monetary damages.

Posted

Did you have medical expenses?

I understand you missed a week of school and were forced to buy a new car, but I'm not really sure if insurance is supposed to compensate you for that.

I would look at these factors... What exactly is your insurance covering and what would be an objective, fair amount?

If your bruised vertebrae is pretty bad and you sought medical attention, $5,000 might be low...

One last thing... keep your eye on the limitations period. In Texas you only have 2 years after the accident to file suit. It may be different where you live, but there is a time constraint. If you're nearing that line and haven't reached an agreement, file a suit if only to hold your options open. You can file a suit without a lawyer btw... but I wouldn't suggest actually trying it without one...

Posted

I don't understand how you still owe so much money on your new car unless you bought a new car that was significantly more expensive than the car you had. In this case, it would not be the fault or responsibility of the insurance company.

So, with the car a non issue at this point (since they already paid for your old car), you would only be trying to get injury related expenses. Have your medical bills exceeded $5000 yet? Will they?

Posted

Dont settle. It is the aim of insurance companies to get you to take the quick out so they don't really have to pay what is coming to you justly. Get a lawyer immediately and let him be your advocate.


In Christ,

Fr. Pfex

Posted

Get a lawyer.

How much is it worth to you? I know everyone is out to get everything they can. Is what you suffered worth more than $5000? Do you feel it is justified? It isn't necessary too always get the other guy for whatever you can. I think that is probably too low of an amount, but that is my opinion solely based on what you said.

That being said, my hubby went through something like this. He was rear ended, and was in physio for over a year. He couldn't even pick up his 6 month old daughter for a while.

The insurance company offered him $5000 (maybe that is a standard amount). He went and got a lawyer. He was told to do certain things (keep a daily diary of pain levels and how the accident has affected his life, etc.), continue with physio. etc.

The thing is, at least in Alberta, if you have a lawyer, they will not take the other party to court until ALL of the injuries are completely healed. If that takes 5 years, it will take 5 years to settle (at least).

I know a lot of people may think I am crazy, but I really think that too many people are too greedy about stuff like this, and in the end, they end up unhappy, and we all pay for the greed in increased rates. I TOTALLY think that law suits and things are necessary, I just think sometimes people get caught up in the "how much can I get" and lose sight of the "how much was my loss worth?".

Good luck! :)

Posted (edited)

I have to agree with prose on this one.

$5,000 may be too low, but you know your injuries. On the other hand, be fair. Think of it this way: if you took your case to a jury what would they think is fair for you. If the insurance is offering something near this amount, take it and avoid the legal fees.

I'll give an example. I saw 4-5 personal injury cases this summer. The insurance company won every single one, and the plaintiff got nothing. Maybe thats the juries in Houston... but I really think the point is that asking for too much offends the average person, and you won't get anything. So be fair... whatever your medical expenses are should be included in the settlement. Maybe a little bit of pain and suffering, but don't push it too far...

I mean really the purpose of lawsuits is to put you back to how you were before the accident, not a get rich quick thing.

Edited by rkwright
Posted (edited)

I'd say ask for more than $5k. If you had to take out a $9k loan, you need to have at least $10k minimum. I might add that I have no legal experience, etc...

Edited by scardella
Posted

One more thing to remember, lawyers charge upwards of 30-40% of your settlement. So if you settle for 10 000 you will only really pocket 6000-7000.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1682589' date='Oct 21 2008, 10:12 AM']I don't understand how you still owe so much money on your new car unless you bought a new car that was significantly more expensive than the car you had. In this case, it would not be the fault or responsibility of the insurance company.

So, with the car a non issue at this point (since they already paid for your old car), you would only be trying to get injury related expenses.[/quote]

Yup.

Posted

Yes, I did buy a car that was significantly more than the value of my old car. That was essentially because my old car was a 1998 Sunfire, and in order to buy a car that would have been covered completly I would have had to buy a car that was both older than my 1998 car with more miles than my old car had, thus I upgraded.

I don't seek for the insurance settlement to cover that, but rather use any settlement towards paying that off. I am not saying I need to get X amount in order to pay my car off, I'm saying, what were my expenses that I had incurred and the pain and suffering and how might that pay off or significantly pay down my car loan. Today I owe 7,000 dollars on my car. I would however like to eradicate my credit card debt which is 2,000.00 so after that is taken care of I will then apply any surplus to the car loan. With 5,000; 3000 would be applied to the loan.

But, another thing that I've said to be, is I do not seek to be opportunistic, I don't think getting a lawyer would be helpful, I think I will counter the offer sometime this week, but also ask for clarification on what he is offering me is actually for, does that include me missing a week of a private college education? Because if it does, then we should be looking at a higher figure.

Thanks for the advice thus far.

Posted

Whatever they offer you is the total. Once you agree to settle, there is no turning back. So if you agree to $5000, that is what you will get a cheque for, and you can no longer sue for anything more.

Posted

[quote name='the_rev' post='1682631' date='Oct 21 2008, 01:13 PM']Yes, I did buy a car that was significantly more than the value of my old car. That was essentially because my old car was a 1998 Sunfire, and in order to buy a car that would have been covered completly I would have had to buy a car that was both older than my 1998 car with more miles than my old car had, thus I upgraded.

I don't seek for the insurance settlement to cover that, but rather use any settlement towards paying that off. I am not saying I need to get X amount in order to pay my car off, I'm saying, what were my expenses that I had incurred and the pain and suffering and how might that pay off or significantly pay down my car loan. Today I owe 7,000 dollars on my car. I would however like to eradicate my credit card debt which is 2,000.00 so after that is taken care of I will then apply any surplus to the car loan. With 5,000; 3000 would be applied to the loan.

But, another thing that I've said to be, is I do not seek to be opportunistic, I don't think getting a lawyer would be helpful, I think I will counter the offer sometime this week, but also ask for clarification on what he is offering me is actually for, does that include me missing a week of a private college education? Because if it does, then we should be looking at a higher figure.

Thanks for the advice thus far.[/quote]

I have two more thoughts...

First is the concept of insurance settlement. The insurance company is basically 'buying you off' so that you don't file a lawsuit. The purpose of the lawsuit is to make you whole, put you back where you were before the accident. Now when you say that you want to use the money for credit card debt or payment on the new car, a part of me does cringe. I guess, to me, it seems like thats not how the system should work... but then again I'm sure insurance has screwed many people, and after all you paid in so you deserve some of the money back when you're in need... do you see the underlying problem though? Oh well... they're offering it so take it I guess?

Second, I don't know all your financials, but make sure the settlement is for your injuries for tax purposes. IRS Code §104(a)(2) says..

(a) In general
Except in the case of amounts attributable to (and not in excess of) deductions allowed under section 213 (relating to medical, etc., expenses) for any prior taxable year, [b]gross income does not include—[/b]
(2) [b]the amount of any damages[/b] (other than punitive damages) [b]received (whether by[/b] suit or a[b]greement[/b] and whether as lump sums or as periodic payments) on account of [b]personal physical injuries[/b] or physical sickness;

I've never actually seen an insurance settlement, but if for some reason it wasn't for personal injuries you wouldn't want to get hit by the IRS at the same time.

Although I'm kinda a noob at tax law...

Posted

For the record, I don't think you are being greedy at all. I think it is reasonable and responsible to use any settlement money for debt repayment. If it is enough to pay off your car, great!

If I were you, I would contact a lawyer before going any further. It doesn't cost anything, and it may save you a lot of headache in the long run.

Posted

I can't think of a better way to compensate yourself for pain and suffering, and being in a wreck does lead to suffering, than by easing you concerns in another area of your life such as paying off debt. Anyone who has been in a bad wreck will tell you that there is no way to return you to the way you were before the wreck. You can get a new car, but you can't get that week back, you can't get the time back that you wasted trying to get a new car, dealing with the police, going to the doctor, and dealing with the insurance company. Most importantly, there is no way for any amount of money to sooth your nerves every time you hear screeching brakes, or when someone does a near miss or cuts you off. That shot of adrenaline and fear will be with you a long time. People who are worried you are being greedy must not have ever felt that.

Posted

I don't think anyone intended to call him greedy.

I know I certainly didn't.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1682739' date='Oct 21 2008, 03:50 PM']I don't think anyone intended to call him greedy.

I know I certainly didn't.[/quote]

I'm sorry if I came off that way. I certainly didn't mean to either. After all what is anyone going to do with pain and suffering money, pay the pain away?

Do what you can to get the best for you.

Posted

I'm just saying don't go around saying "I would like this much to pay off my new car and credit card debt", because technically, that isn't within the scope of the insurance company's responsibility.

I don't know how you would monetarily value a week of missing school either, since you most likely got make-up work or something, right? How would an insurance company figure out a dollar value for that?

I would focus on past, present, and future medical expenses related to the injuries. That is tangible. I've never been a big believer in getting something in return for pain and suffering, but if you think you can put a dollar amount on that as well, only you can know what the fair value of that would be.

I think it's a little foolish to not even talk to a lawyer though. I don't like them either, but you should at least try. Lawyers and insurance companies have a working relationship, and an experienced lawyer can most likely tell you what he could negotiate without even having to go to trial.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1682783' date='Oct 21 2008, 04:50 PM']I think it's a little foolish to not even talk to a lawyer though. [b]I don't like them either[/b], but you should at least try. There are relationships between lawyers and insurance companies, and a lawyer can most likely tell you what he could negotiate without even having to go to trial.[/quote]

:sadder: Dust doesn't like us catherine! :sadder:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...