Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='jckinsman' post='1685559' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:13 PM']Full knowledge, full consent! I personally think that it is mean to birth a baby up to the neck,jam an instrument in the head and smell of elderberries out the brains. I think its mean to lie to millions of women about the effects of abortions. I think that it is mean to disagree with infanticide and support the very canidate that supports it,because you THINK you will have a better life. Have fun explaining that one to God. I am glad that I won't have too![/quote]
Don't ask me what happened there about "smell of elderberries" :unsure: The word was to be "suction" That was weird because I read it when it was done.

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1685548' date='Oct 24 2008, 09:09 PM']That's an insane statment.

That's the equivalent of saying intercourse isn't the totality of adultery, just the main part of it.[/quote]
Pro-life includes all life, not just [i]in utero[/i] life. That means that being anti-abortion alone is not fully pro-life. To be fully pro-life, we must also be against euthanasia and the death penalty.

This is my only issue with Keyes (who I only like because I'm black). Keyes is 100% anti-abortion, but he supports the death penalty.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685609' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:43 PM']I think anyone should vote pro-life all the time. And that is what I tried to do. The question is if McCain is "pro-life" because he suddenly found religion about abortion in time to get elected.

McCain is lukewarm on the issue, he will be a moderate working with a democratic supermajority, abortion will not be an issue where progress can be made.

Climate Change, health care, makeing generic drugs avaliable for children over seas, a more diplomatic foreign policy etc.

These are issue tha will be relivant, not because I say so but because that is what all the data suggusts. Looking at the issues that will be relivant, where the views of the cannidate really do matter, I felt Obama was more in the pro-life camp.

Now. I do not know if there is a God or not, if there is he may judge me as some people have suggusted. I hope he would take into account my human falibility and honest attempt to vote morally.

I guess this goes to the heart of why I posted this. I honestly did not know who I would vote for untill the last second and even as I was submitting the ballot I did not feel confident I was right. I, unlike you all, to not have a mandated answer. I guess what I wanted was for you all to consider the moral ambiguities involved in voteing when you don't have a Bishop to instruct you. I see people constantly talking about a culture that does not appreciate life, but for those of us you do not have any mandates it is morally ambiguious how to be "pro-life" and I wanted some of that to come out here.[/quote]
Okay lets go at this backwards,Obama gets in and there is a totally democratic house and senate. Any radical abortion movement made,do you think that it could go through easier????

and here is the things you weighed over killing babies, "climate change,healthcare,generic drugs for overseas,foreign policy" and not to mention you thought Obama was more in the pro-life camp then McCain.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685631' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:57 PM']McCain's lip service was better on the matter of abortion in my eyes.

However, and you all have still failed to adress this but simply parrot the same lines over and over

1-Abortion is not the totality of being pro life
2-Abortion is not going to be something McCain could seriously affect even if he wanted to which I doubt because of the external factors I mentioned and what the trends suggust the major isues over the next few years will be.





You have charged me with this twice now. I know from previous threads that you have no problem assigning sinister motives to individuals without any proof but let's see if this is any different. What issue was I voteing on for my personal well being.

name one.[/quote]
By 1# Are you saying that abortion it is not the only pro-life issue? If that is what you mean, I agree.

As to #2 like I said before radical movements could at least be stopped.

I think that all of the issues you stated above you voted on trumped the prolife issue for you. You are genuinely concerned about other things. I am genuinely concerned about life first,so that is how I evaluate my decision.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685555' date='Oct 24 2008, 11:12 PM']If I outlaw abortion but allow infanacide am I "pro-life"?[/quote]
Abortion IS infanticide.

Posted

[quote name='jckinsman' post='1685654' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:19 PM']Okay lets go at this backwards,Obama gets in and there is a totally democratic house and senate. Any radical abortion movement made,do you think that it could go through easier????

and here is the things you weighed over killing babies, "climate change,healthcare,generic drugs for overseas,foreign policy" and not to mention you thought Obama was more in the pro-life camp then McCain.[/quote]


Those things are part of being "pro-life"

reducing patent covers for life saveing drugs so cheeper generic drugs can be avaliable to save countless lives in the developing world is a pro life issue. A climte srises that is going to disproportionally affect that part of the world which can afford it least, makeing sure children's parents can see their children survive without going bankrupt, makeing sure their children can live is a pro life issue, a foreign policy that ensures that all people have a right to peace, security, and dignity is a pro-life issue.

Abortion is not the only part of being pro-life.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

there's also the question of whether getting rid of roe would end abortion, or just make the other states pick up most of the slack.
surely it'd cause it to go down some. but if not much, that makes other intrinsic evils etc a lot harder to weigh.

(philosphical point: X is for killing Y, and X is running for president, but is perfect in everything else. Z is not for killing Y but terrible in everything else, but nothing else is intrinsically evil though. abortion and other issues are not factors in this hypothetical. is it wrong to vote for X if he's the only candiate to choose from other than Z?)

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1685677' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:40 PM']Abortion IS infanticide.[/quote]

no it's not. By definition it is not.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685609' date='Oct 24 2008, 11:43 PM']I think anyone should vote pro-life all the time. And that is what I tried to do. The question is if McCain is "pro-life" because he suddenly found religion about abortion in time to get elected.

McCain is lukewarm on the issue, he will be a moderate working with a democratic supermajority, abortion will not be an issue where progress can be made.

Climate Change, health care, makeing generic drugs avaliable for children over seas, a more diplomatic foreign policy etc.

These are issue tha will be relivant, not because I say so but because that is what all the data suggusts. Looking at the issues that will be relivant, where the views of the cannidate really do matter, I felt Obama was more in the pro-life camp.

Now. I do not know if there is a God or not, if there is he may judge me as some people have suggusted. I hope he would take into account my human falibility and honest attempt to vote morally.

I guess this goes to the heart of why I posted this. I honestly did not know who I would vote for untill the last second and even as I was submitting the ballot I did not feel confident I was right. I, unlike you all, to not have a mandated answer. I guess what I wanted was for you all to consider the moral ambiguities involved in voteing when you don't have a Bishop to instruct you. I see people constantly talking about a culture that does not appreciate life, but for those of us you do not have any mandates it is morally ambiguious how to be "pro-life" and I wanted some of that to come out here.[/quote]
But you didn't vote pro-life. You voted for the candidate who thinks that half delivering a baby and sucking its brains out is ok. You voted for the candidate who thinks that if a baby survives the abortion, it still has to die as not to traumatize the doctor. You chose "Climate Change, health care, makeing generic drugs avaliable for children over seas, a more diplomatic foreign policy etc." as more important than human life. You didn't have to vote for McCain, you could have written in any one of the 6 billion OTHER people who live on this planet, but you picked the one person who has vowed to protect baby-killing. WHERE is the ambiguity, seriously WHERE???
Even when I was an atheist, I voted pro-life. You don't have to believe in God to vote against the slaughter of children. You simply have to believe that human life is important enough to protect.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1685677' date='Oct 24 2008, 11:40 PM']Abortion IS infanticide.[/quote] :scratchhead:

Edited by jckinsman
Posted

[quote name='jckinsman' post='1685676' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:40 PM']I think that all of the issues you stated above you voted on trumped the prolife issue for you. You are genuinely concerned about other things. I am genuinely concerned about life first,so that is how I evaluate my decision.[/quote]


Those issues are part of being pro-life. Makeing sure a cell can develop into a fetus and eventually be born an is not important if that infant will die of a preventable disease becuase Pharm. Corporations extend their patents preventing generic drugs to shore up their profit margins.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685609' date='Oct 25 2008, 11:43 AM']I think anyone should vote pro-life all the time. And that is what I tried to do. The question is if McCain is "pro-life" because he suddenly found religion about abortion in time to get elected.

McCain is lukewarm on the issue, he will be a moderate working with a democratic supermajority, abortion will not be an issue where progress can be made.

Climate Change, health care, makeing generic drugs avaliable for children over seas, a more diplomatic foreign policy etc.

These are issue tha will be relivant, not because I say so but because that is what all the data suggusts. Looking at the issues that will be relivant, where the views of the cannidate really do matter, I felt Obama was more in the pro-life camp.

Now. I do not know if there is a God or not, if there is he may judge me as some people have suggusted. I hope he would take into account my human falibility and honest attempt to vote morally.

I guess this goes to the heart of why I posted this. I honestly did not know who I would vote for untill the last second and even as I was submitting the ballot I did not feel confident I was right. I, unlike you all, to not have a mandated answer. I guess what I wanted was for you all to consider the moral ambiguities involved in voteing when you don't have a Bishop to instruct you. I see people constantly talking about a culture that does not appreciate life, but for those of us you do not have any mandates it is morally ambiguious how to be "pro-life" and I wanted some of that to come out here.[/quote]
dUST has posted over, and over again all the things Bush has done to scale back abortion. No, he never promised that he was some Messiah destined to end all abortion. He himself said that hearts have to change before laws. By voting for Obama over McCain, you've just agreed to undue everything Bush has accomplished for the pro-life movement in the past eight years. McCain would have at least held up the status quo. I hope your proud of yourself.

As for letting the idea that the Democrats are going to get a supermajority in Congress this election influence your vote, you're just being ridiculous. No one has any idea what Congress will look like until election day, and the reality is we haven't had a supermajority in Congress for something like 60 years. I really don't think it's going to be any different this election just because a few, obviously skewed, polls say so.

Looks like you still have a lot to learn about how best to cast your vote.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1685684' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:50 PM']But you didn't vote pro-life. You voted for the candidate who thinks that half delivering a baby and sucking its brains out is ok. You voted for the candidate who thinks that if a baby survives the abortion, it still has to die as not to traumatize the doctor. You chose "Climate Change, health care, makeing generic drugs avaliable for children over seas, a more diplomatic foreign policy etc." as more important than human life. You didn't have to vote for McCain, you could have written in any one of the 6 billion OTHER people who live on this planet, but you picked the one person who has vowed to protect baby-killing. WHERE is the ambiguity, seriously WHERE???
Even when I was an atheist, I voted pro-life. You don't have to believe in God to vote against the slaughter of children. You simply have to believe that human life is important enough to protect.[/quote]


see above this post, I just got done taling about this

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote]You don't have to believe in God to vote against the slaughter of children[/quote]

Yes, good point.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1685677' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:40 PM']Abortion IS infanticide.[/quote]

Are you using "infant" to include children at all stages of gestation? The word "infant" does not normally include those individuals that are still [i]in utero[/i]. ...just want to make that I understand you.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1685688' date='Oct 24 2008, 10:52 PM']dUST has posted over, and over again all the things Bush has done to scale back abortion.[/quote]

Abortion also declined over the Clinton years.

[quote]No, he never promised that he was some Messiah destined to end all abortion. He himself said that hearts have to change before laws. By voting for Obama over McCain, you've just agreed to undue everything Bush has accomplished for the pro-life movement in the past eight years. McCain would have at least held up the status quo. I hope your proud of yourself.[/quote]

no, I have never said I was confident about my vote or that it was anything other than morally ambiguious.



[quote]As for letting the idea that the Democrats are going to get a supermajority in Congress this election influence your vote, you're just being ridiculous. No one has any idea what Congress will look like until election day, and the reality is we haven't had a supermajority in Congress for something like 60 years. I really don't think it's going to be any different this election just because a few, obviously skewed, polls say so.[/quote]

We'll see

[quote]Looks like you still have a lot to learn about how best to cast your vote.[/quote]


Sure, so do you.

Posted

[quote name='tgoldson' post='1685693' date='Oct 25 2008, 12:54 PM']Are you using "infant" to include children at all stages of gestation? The word "infant" does not normally include those individuals that are still [i]in utero[/i]. ...just want to make that I understand you.[/quote]
That's true. Technically speaking, "infant" is term that is used to describe children up to a year after they have been born. "Fetus" is the term the medically used term to describe the unborn, and it's not a bad word. It's Latin for "little one".

Posted

[quote name='Saint Therese' post='1685692' date='Oct 24 2008, 11:54 PM']Yes, good point.[/quote]


Obama is pro-choice not pro-abortion.

simply because Obama wishes to protect the legal right to an abortion does not mean abortions will increase. There is a strong corelation between abortion and poverty.

Saint Therese
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hassan' post='1685686' date='Oct 24 2008, 11:51 PM']Those issues are part of being pro-life. Makeing sure a cell can develop into a fetus and eventually be born an is not important if that infant will die of a preventable disease becuase Pharm. Corporations extend their patents preventing generic drugs to shore up their profit margins.[/quote]

You don't have to worry about medicine or disease if you're murdered in the womb.
If you don't have the right to live, what do all the other rights matter?

Obama is pro abortion.

Edited by Saint Therese
Posted

Hassan,

You claim to have bounced between libertarian, republican, and even writing in your own friend. Your drifting back and forth across these choices shows me you are intellectually rudderless. You throw non-issues up as issues (Is $4 generics at Walmart really too expensive?). There's really no point in discussing your foolishness because you will simply deceive yourself into think you made the right choice, a choice which you can't undo. Your friend would have been a better choice, and I don't even know him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...