Justin86 Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1691282' date='Nov 2 2008, 11:39 AM']Murder is never the answer to suffering. I must admit that I am truly frightened by the attitude of those who wish to decide if a particular life is worth living, and who wish to play God in such matters, because as a person with physical disabilities I fear the day is coming when the government will say that my quality of life is not high enough to warrant the continuation of my existence. Euthanasia and abortion are crimes against humanity.[/quote] Well you're Catholic, so you must be stupid. Off with you then.
Apotheoun Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 Murder is not a sign of compassion; instead, it is a crime.
philothea Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 I feel very sad for the woman involved, but I believe the right thing to do would be to have taken her pregnancy to term, and allowed her child to have the what life it could. I know several parents with disabled children, and they love and cherish their children, and don't regret their existences at all. I must note that there are numerous errors in the article, which was obviously written prior to the last presidential election to try to stir up sentiment against Bush. There is, in fact, an explicit exception for the preservation of the life of the mother, and the exact procedure: "intact dilation and extraction" is also specified. While I don't really disbelieve the essentials of the story, seeing facts distorted which are so easily confirmed does make me a tiny bit suspicious.
Brother Adam Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1691282' date='Nov 1 2008, 11:39 PM']Murder is never the answer to suffering. I must admit that I am truly frightened by the attitude of those who wish to decide if a particular life is worth living, and who wish to play God in such matters, because as a person with physical disabilities I fear the day is coming when the government will say that my quality of life is not high enough to warrant the continuation of my existence. Euthanasia and abortion are crimes against humanity.[/quote] They are sins that cry to heaven for vengeance. The ends do not justify the means when those means are evil. Murder is not a just answer to suffering. Great suffering brings with it the capacity for even greater grace. If the suffering of Jesus brought eternal salvation, what grace and opportunity for God to work can the suffering of a mother or child bring?
rkwright Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1691282' date='Nov 1 2008, 09:39 PM']Murder is never the answer to suffering. I must admit that I am truly frightened by the attitude of those who wish to decide if a particular life is worth living, and who wish to play God in such matters, because as a person with physical disabilities I fear the day is coming when the government will say that my quality of life is not high enough to warrant the continuation of my existence. Euthanasia and abortion are crimes against humanity.[/quote] Well said.
jckinsman Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1691282' date='Nov 1 2008, 10:39 PM']Murder is never the answer to suffering. I must admit that I am truly frightened by the attitude of those who wish to decide if a particular life is worth living, and who wish to play God in such matters, because as a person with physical disabilities I fear the day is coming when the government will say that my quality of life is not high enough to warrant the continuation of my existence. Euthanasia and abortion are crimes against humanity.[/quote] This is very good,and well thought out.
Adrestia Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='philothea' post='1691288' date='Nov 1 2008, 09:43 PM']I feel very sad for the woman involved, but I believe the right thing to do would be to have taken her pregnancy to term, and allowed her child to have the what life it could. I know several parents with disabled children, and they love and cherish their children, and don't regret their existences at all. I must note that there are numerous errors in the article, which was obviously written prior to the last presidential election to try to stir up sentiment against Bush. There is, in fact, an explicit exception for the preservation of the life of the mother, and the exact procedure: "intact dilation and extraction" is also specified. While I don't really disbelieve the essentials of the story, seeing facts distorted which are so easily confirmed does make me a tiny bit suspicious.[/quote] [i]All[/i] children deserved to be loved unconditionally. Mothers facing difficult prenatal diagnoses need support in mothering, not in murder. [url="http://www.prenatalpartnersforlife.org/index.htm"]http://www.prenatalpartnersforlife.org/index.htm[/url]
jckinsman Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 My cousin adopted a baby,now I believe she is two,with this condition. She is the love of her life and yes very hard,many surgeries and many hurdles but she never regretted adopting her. Compassion is loving someone so much you are willing to tell them the truth,even when it is hard. I feel bad she missed out on this baby, I think she should have had this little one. I think that there is always a rainbow at the end of a storm. They were frightend and chose the wider road,How many of us would do that? "Us" meaning everyone in the USA. I think what's worse is just her trying to justify what she did as something good. It is simply not. Sad Story
Aloysius Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 You have the gall to accuse us of being heartless? You've basically just said that any one of us who has some relative or friend with spina bifida or abortion ought to have had their child KILLED in the womb. For goodness sake, shut the hell up you heartless jerkface (i'm censoring my words here)... obviously the woman is not a heartless killer, it was a gut wrenching decision for her, but it was the WRONG one. the doctors told my mother to abort me (for reasons far less severe than this one, of course). thank God she didn't listen to them. you make me absolutely sick to my stomach here, Hassan. that child was "put out of its misery" the way a dog would be. that is not human, that is not kind, that is not moral. that is the most horrific thing anyone could do; and I do not say there is a special place in hell for women like this (there is likely an especially merciful and healing place in purgatory)... but there is a special place in hell and by God I hope it's deeper than Lucifer's icey circle for those who convince people it is ok to murder the handicapped if they have little chance of surviving anyway and if they do might suffer greatly. Yes, there is an especially tortorous place in hell for such people... and sharing that circle of hell will be those who capitalize upon such tragedies of injustice for political purposes.
jckinsman Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1691449' date='Nov 2 2008, 03:42 AM']You have the gall to accuse us of being heartless? You've basically just said that any one of us who has some relative or friend with spina bifida or abortion ought to have had their child KILLED in the womb. For goodness sake, shut the hell up you heartless jerkface (i'm censoring my words here)... obviously the woman is not a heartless killer, it was a gut wrenching decision for her, but it was the WRONG one. the doctors told my mother to abort me (for reasons far less severe than this one, of course). thank God she didn't listen to them. you make me absolutely sick to my stomach here, Hassan. that child was "put out of its misery" the way a dog would be. that is not human, that is not kind, that is not moral. that is the most horrific thing anyone could do; and I do not say there is a special place in hell for women like this (there is likely an especially merciful and healing place in purgatory)... but there is a special place in hell and by God I hope it's deeper than Lucifer's icey circle for those who convince people it is ok to murder the handicapped if they have little chance of surviving anyway and if they do might suffer greatly. Yes, there is an especially tortorous place in hell for such people... and sharing that circle of hell will be those who capitalize upon such tragedies of injustice for political purposes.[/quote] You would like "Father Corapis 11th hour election alert" I put it on another thread,I'll see if I can find it. If you haven't already heard it?
jckinsman Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 (edited) Here it is. [url="http://www.fathercorapi.com/election.aspx"]http://www.fathercorapi.com/election.aspx[/url] He is awesome! Edited November 2, 2008 by jckinsman
Didacus Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Hassan' post='1691199' date='Nov 1 2008, 08:24 PM'][i]Instead of cinnamon and spice, our child came with technical terms like hydrocephalus and spina bifida. The spine, she said, had not closed properly, and because of the location of the opening, it was as bad as it got. What they knew -- that the baby would certainly be paralyzed and incontinent, that the baby's brain was being tugged against the opening in the base of the skull and the cranium was full of fluid -- was awful. What they didn't know -- whether the baby would live at all, and if so, with what sort of mental and developmental defects -- was devastating. Countless surgeries would be required if the baby did live. None of them would repair the damage that was already done. I collapsed into Dave. It sounds so utterly naive now, but nobody told me that pregnancy was a gamble, not a guarantee. Nobody told me that what was rooting around inside me was a hope, not a promise. I remember thinking what a cruel joke those last months had been.[/i] she is nothing more than a heartless murdere to you?r[/quote] The CCC does state that the burden of sin is at times aleviated by circumstance. The severity of her choice is definately not in the leagues of those women who chose to have an abortion 'just because'. Her plight ressembled more 'mercy killing' or euthanasia rather than a common question of abortion.
Ziggamafu Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 In the following link, every conceivable method of supporting "pro-choice" politics is mercilessly destroyed in cold, hard, logical refutations. Any pro-choicer should feel obligated by conscience to thoughtfully consider the content of this speech: [url="http://media.podcastingmanager.com/0/7/6/7/1/126067-117670/Media/DrPeterKreeftonVoting.mp3"]http://media.podcastingmanager.com/0/7/6/7...eftonVoting.mp3[/url] I would be curious how someone would try to object to that.
Lil Red Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Hassan' post='1691165' date='Nov 1 2008, 06:52 PM']Another story of a sick women hell bent on killing babies that I thought you all might enjoy. It's some good red meat to really stir up some holy outrage about the abortion loveing moral degenerates in this country. [url="http://www.boston.com/news/globe/magazine/articles/2004/01/25/my_late_term_abortion/"]http://www.boston.com/news/globe/magazine/..._term_abortion/[/url][/quote] +J.M.J.+ my friends' baby will not live long past birth. there is no amniotic sac, which has meant that the kidneys did not develop at all. but they are praying for a miracle and have touched countless people around the world with their witness. to abort their baby would not lessen their suffering or pain. but to be able to see, touch, and hold their alive baby will make all the difference to them. the baby will not be in pain at all. see my previous topic post about it here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=85290"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=85290[/url] i'm not saying that this isn't a horrific and awful thing to face as a parent. but as a parent, i would love to hold my alive baby, even if for just a few moments. not to murder my baby.
Archaeology cat Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1691247' date='Nov 2 2008, 01:52 AM']I have always believed that euthanasia (and it's partners in crime, aborting deformed or handicapped babies in utero after an ultrasound) is not truly about stopping the suffering of the victim, but about selfishly stopping the suffering of those who would have to care for the victim. It's not only about the discomfort of having to care for someone sick and dying or severely handicapped, but also the nearly unbearable suffering that we experience by having to watch others suffer while we remain helpless. But one of the things Jesus taught us is the redemptive nature of suffering and the sanctity of suffering. That's why people who believe in God, whatever their religious beliefs, are way less likely to commit horrible acts like abortion, euthanasia and suicide. Without a belief in the sanctity of suffering, all hope is lost.[/quote] Very much agreed. [quote name='tgoldson' post='1691377' date='Nov 2 2008, 04:55 AM'][i]All[/i] children deserved to be loved unconditionally. Mothers facing difficult prenatal diagnoses need support in mothering, not in murder. [url="http://www.prenatalpartnersforlife.org/index.htm"]http://www.prenatalpartnersforlife.org/index.htm[/url][/quote] Again, definitely agree.
Justin86 Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1691611' date='Nov 3 2008, 03:18 AM']+J.M.J.+ my friends' baby will not live long past birth. there is no amniotic sac, which has meant that the kidneys did not develop at all. but they are praying for a miracle and have touched countless people around the world with their witness. to abort their baby would not lessen their suffering or pain. but to be able to see, touch, and hold their alive baby will make all the difference to them. the baby will not be in pain at all. see my previous topic post about it here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=85290"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=85290[/url] i'm not saying that this isn't a horrific and awful thing to face as a parent. but as a parent, i would love to hold my alive baby, even if for just a few moments. not to murder my baby.[/quote] Well at least someone still has some sense left in this world.
MissyP89 Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 When my Mom was diagnosed with placenta praevia, I could have been stillborn, mentally retarded, and incontinent... I was born at 24 weeks. No, I didn't get through it unharmed (look up cerebral palsy), and I spent 81 very long days in the hospital before I came home for the first time, but nineteen years later, I'm working on my bachelor's degree, learning to drive, and am more or less completely independent. Should my mother have aborted me?
CatherineM Posted November 2, 2008 Posted November 2, 2008 My mom was supposed to abort me too, and that was well before Roe vs. Wade. They were convinced she'd die. As they were rolling her in to surgery, she felt me kick, and refused the procedure. She just had her 86th birthday, so we both obviously survived, and I have been kicking things ever since.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 3, 2008 Posted November 3, 2008 [quote name='Hassan' post='1691199' date='Nov 1 2008, 09:24 PM'][i]Instead of cinnamon and spice, our child came with technical terms like hydrocephalus and spina bifida. The spine, she said, had not closed properly, and because of the location of the opening, it was as bad as it got. What they knew -- that the baby would certainly be paralyzed and incontinent, that the baby's brain was being tugged against the opening in the base of the skull and the cranium was full of fluid -- was awful. What they didn't know -- whether the baby would live at all, and if so, with what sort of mental and developmental defects -- was devastating. Countless surgeries would be required if the baby did live. None of them would repair the damage that was already done. I collapsed into Dave. It sounds so utterly naive now, but nobody told me that pregnancy was a gamble, not a guarantee. Nobody told me that what was rooting around inside me was a hope, not a promise. I remember thinking what a cruel joke those last months had been.[/i] she is nothing more than a heartless murdere to you?r[/quote] So you think its better to simply chop the live baby up and throw it away, instead of letting it die peacefully in its mothers arms? Better for who? Certainly not the baby!! Yes, she would be murdering her baby, and those who counseled her to murder her child are criminals as well. Everytime you get pregnant, terror for something like this is in the back of your mind, whether acknowledged or not. And before you GET pregnant you should decide who is going to be more important - your feelings or your child's life. Motherhood is not for the faint-hearted!!!!
CatherineM Posted November 3, 2008 Posted November 3, 2008 Archbishop Sheen once said that the tragedy of life isn't what we suffer, but what we miss. I lost a nephew at 10 months due to a severe congenital heart defect. It was a horrible tragedy that just about destroyed my brother and his wife, but I don't think either of them would give up a moment of those 10 months in exchange for easing their pain.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now