Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Brisbane Church Faces Axe Over Liberal Practices


Recommended Posts

Posted

A Brisbane parish has until December 1 to overhaul its practices or face the prospect of being thrown out of the Roman Catholic Church.

Brisbane's Catholic Archbishop John Bathersby has written to Father Peter Kennedy at St Mary's in South Brisbane threatening to start a formal process if changes are not made.

The Archbishop's demands include an end to commitment ceremonies at St Mary's for gay and lesbian couples and the use of non-conventional terms during baptisms.

He insists the priests wear the traditional alb and stole during the mass and they use a Catholic Church-approved eucharistic prayer - not one developed by the community.

He also wants lay people to stop giving the homily. Parishioners have been meeting to formulate a response since being threatened with removal from the Catholic Church in August.

[url="http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/11/02/2407792.htm"]http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/11/02/2407792.htm[/url]

Posted

Submit or be shown the boot. Exactly how it should be.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1691470' date='Nov 2 2008, 06:49 AM']Submit or be shown the boot. Exactly how it should be.[/quote]

Although I know what you mean and I agree, I would search more cahritable words to express it.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1691478' date='Nov 2 2008, 09:15 AM']Although I know what you mean and I agree, I would search more cahritable words to express it.[/quote]
How about, "Fix up your parish or perish!" It isn't any more charitable, but at least it's catchy :sweat:

Posted

Charity can never be separated from truth. The following is a charitable and truthful prayer from the Vespers Vigil Service for the Feast of the Holy Fathers of the Six Ecumenical Councils:

[size=3]Despising the comprehension of the true light, * Arius was recompensed with a most extreme consequence for his sin, * for his bowels were rent asunder as if by a divine cleaver, * after which, like unto Judas, he gave up his body and soul * in a manner similar to Judas; * nevertheless the council that was held in Nicea, * proclaimed Thee, O Lord, to be the Son of God, * enthroned together with the Father and the Spirit. [/size]

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='cappie' post='1691466' date='Nov 2 2008, 06:43 AM']A Brisbane parish has until December 1 to overhaul its practices or face the prospect of being thrown out of the Roman Catholic Church.

Brisbane's Catholic Archbishop John Bathersby has written to Father Peter Kennedy at St Mary's in South Brisbane threatening to start a formal process if changes are not made.

The Archbishop's demands include an end to commitment ceremonies at St Mary's for gay and lesbian couples and the use of non-conventional terms during baptisms.

He insists the priests wear the traditional alb and stole during the mass and they use a Catholic Church-approved eucharistic prayer - not one developed by the community.

He also wants lay people to stop giving the homily. Parishioners have been meeting to formulate a response since being threatened with removal from the Catholic Church in August.

[url="http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/11/02/2407792.htm"]http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/11/02/2407792.htm[/url][/quote]

Who do these parishes think they are? Their own religion? After reading the article one can only think, "well duh."

Posted

THE Brisbane parish of St Mary's looks set to be excommunicated after the local priest, Peter Kennedy, said yesterday he would not change his ways despite being warned to do so by church authorities.

Father Kennedy was speaking after the inner-city parish received a letter from Brisbane Catholic Archbishop John Bathersby, who has given the parish until the end of the month to change several of its practices.

The South Brisbane church openly gives communion to gays, regularly has women giving the homily, and has a style of baptism that is not within the rules of the Catholic Church.

Neither Father Kennedy nor the other priest at the church, Terry Fitzpatrick, wear traditional priest's vestments.

The archbishop wrote to the parish in September drawing attention to practices that placed St Mary's "not in communion with the Catholic Church", and giving them until the end of the year to respond.

But in a letter last week, Archbishop Bathersby said several undertakings had not been honoured and that "games are still being played, as they were in the past".

"I am prepared to wait until December 1, but no longer. After that I will begin a formal process to address the situation," he said.

While the parish still has the rest of the month to respond to the archbishop, Father Kennedy indicated yesterday that the local people would not be changing their practices.

Father Kennedy said the practices at St Mary's had evolved over the years from the community. He strongly criticised what he called the hierarchical approach of the Vatican in dictating what should be said in every parish in the world.

He said St Mary's had been "white-anted" by people who were not regular members of the church and found some of the practices there offensive.

"There are vigilantes who've come into our church and written to Rome, and Rome has put pressure on John Bathersby. Bullies never have enough of bullying, and the Vatican is a bully," Father Kennedy said.

"Many communities are not sticking precisely to the rules of liturgy. Our problem is that we are a public community. The archbishop has known what we've been doing for all these years. But his model of governance is hierarchical, and that's his problem -- the church's governance is hierarchical."

Father Kennedy said that for many centuries, local people had chosen their own bishop.

"But Rome, particularly over the past couple of hundred years, has taken that authority away from the people to elect their own bishop, and they have this system whereby people are not in any way consulted."

Father Kennedy, 71, who has refused all media interviews until the weekend, said he was making a stand on behalf of what he called "recovering Catholics".

"They walked away from the church because they can no longer abide this institution which is so oppressive of women, of gay and lesbian people.

" We are one church community that is prepared to say enough is enough."

[url="http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24590919-5006786,00.html"]http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story...5006786,00.html[/url]

Posted

Such a sad situation.

Posted

I thought that they had agreed to try to clean things up before...if this is the same church.

Posted

Question: why excommunicate the whole parish instead of just transferring the priest to Antarctica and getting a priest who "toes the line" to take over?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1696808' date='Nov 7 2008, 01:14 PM']Question: why excommunicate the whole parish instead of just transferring the priest to Antarctica and getting a priest who "toes the line" to take over?[/quote]
Probably cause, if I were a parishoner there, I would have left long ago.

Most devout Catholics have most likely left and run for the hills already.

Antartica....funny :biglol:

Edited by Quietfire
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Wow...that priest's theology and view of Christian history is entirely off-base.

Saint Therese
Posted

I think its about time. What no one has said is how dangerous these parishes are. They pass on their cancer of heterodoxy etc. Better for them to be cut out than infect the rest of the body.

Posted

I'm pretty sure that the people who are still at the parish agrees with the views of the priest. and support them

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1691696' date='Nov 3 2008, 06:13 AM']Charity can never be separated from truth. The following is a charitable and truthful prayer from the Vespers Vigil Service for the Feast of the Holy Fathers of the Six Ecumenical Councils:

[size=3]Despising the comprehension of the true light, * Arius was recompensed with a most extreme consequence for his sin, * for his bowels were rent asunder as if by a divine cleaver, * after which, like unto Judas, he gave up his body and soul * in a manner similar to Judas; * nevertheless the council that was held in Nicea, * proclaimed Thee, O Lord, to be the Son of God, * enthroned together with the Father and the Spirit. [/size][/quote]
See, that's a lot more "uncharitable" than anything I said. Shame those Fathers, shame.

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1696808' date='Nov 8 2008, 03:14 AM']Question: why excommunicate the whole parish instead of just transferring the priest to Antarctica and getting a priest who "toes the line" to take over?[/quote]
This all goes back to my idea that the Church should call another Inquisition where any priest or religious found not to be fully submissive to Rome would be put in one of many new Monasteries built in the most remote and coldest regions of Alaska, where outside human contact comes once a month to bring food supplies. They leave Alaska if, and only if, they leave the Church or renounce their hereises. Catholic colleges would also be covered under this Inquisition, and the theology and philosophy departments would have to be staffed by faithful Catholics ONLY or they would lose all their funding from the Church.

If anyone thinks I'm joking, I'm not, and actually the Church does still have the authority to do just that. I believe it would have to be requested by the Bishops, but I'm no Cannon Law expert so who knows.

Edited by Justin86
Posted

I sincerely hope those priests are defrocked.

Posted

[quote name='Justin86' post='1698212' date='Nov 9 2008, 10:59 AM']This all goes back to my idea that the Church should call another Inquisition where any priest or religious found not to be fully submissive to Rome would be put in one of many new Monasteries built in the most remote and coldest regions of Alaska, where outside human contact comes once a month to bring food supplies. They leave Alaska if, and only if, they leave the Church or renounce their hereises. Catholic colleges would also be covered under this Inquisition, and the theology and philosophy departments would have to be staffed by faithful Catholics ONLY or they would lose all their funding from the Church.[/quote]

You'd probably give Alaska another congressional district....but why subject Alaska to that? That's why although Alaska originally came to mind, I chose Antarctica instead.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1696952' date='Nov 8 2008, 06:36 AM']Wow...that priest's theology and view of Christian history is entirely off-base.[/quote]

Reaffirming his commitment to Catholic doctrine, Coonamble priest, Fr Peter Dresser, has apologised for having "unwittingly scandalised so many people" with the publication of a manuscript that he describes as "explorative" rather than "credal".

"In light of the hysteria that the article in The Australian newspaper of October 29 has created which has caused scandal and hurt to so many, please consider publishing the following letter from me which hopefully will place everything into some kind of perspective for the good of the Church and the well being of so many Catholics who have been deeply hurt by the newspaper article in question," Fr Dresser wrote.

The letter "also represents an apology from me for having unwittingly scandalised so many people in what was meant to have been a refreshing and invigorating document," Fr Dresser says.

"I can understand why the article in The Australian has appalled so many people. It has caused scandal and anger, concern and anguish and has hurt me personally. It saddens me that such hysteria has erupted and I feel obliged as a Catholic priest to quell the tempest as best I can.

"At the outset I want to reaffirm my belief in the Divinity of Jesus, the Virgin Birth and the Resurrection of Jesus. This affirmation is entirely unsolicited and comes from the heart of a person who has cherished his Catholic religion from childhood and has no reason to repudiate or disparage its core tenets.

"The comments in the newspaper were taken from a manuscript I compiled prayerfully and reflectively over many years.

"In that document I attempted to go beyond doctrine and dogma and to discover God's magnificence and friendship in the world of science and evolution and in the immensity of the universe.

"It was not an arrogant attempt to spurn or scorn my Catholic theology. It was more an attempt to personalise and retheologise my Catholic faith and so allow my religion to provide greater nourishment for me in my spiritual journey.

"It was a very worthwhile and meaningful experience for me and for others with whom I shared it.

"The manuscript is not easy to read and so I can readily appreciate that many people have found its content confusing and indeed even 'heretical'", Fr Dresser said.

"Unfortunately people have not appreciated that my explorative theology is not a credal statement.

I also employed a jargon in the process which has made the document even more confusing for so many. My sole intention was to make our beautiful Catholic religion and its beliefs more meaningful in our contemporary world. I am distressed that I have caused pain and anguish instead.

"With hindsight it would probably have been wise not to have allowed random access to the manuscript. I requested that the website which hosted this document be closed down and this has happened.

"At this stage there is very little else I can do except to apologise to anyone who has been scandalised by what was meant to have been a refreshing and invigorating document," he concluded.

[url="http://www.cathnews.com/article.aspx?aeid=10047"]http://www.cathnews.com/article.aspx?aeid=10047[/url]

Posted

Is this the same parish that had invalid baptisms for a number of years?

Posted

Yes, but there are 2 stories here. The latest post concerns the priest and the "book" he wrote.

He does not come from St Mary's

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...