Apotheoun Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='Brigid' post='1695430' date='Nov 5 2008, 10:56 PM']dang... couldn't you highlight the parts you want him to read, or something? that's kind of a lot. or just give the link. links are good. [/quote] The whole text should be read.
Brigid Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 I guess highlighting all of it would defeat the point.
Apotheoun Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='Brigid' post='1695435' date='Nov 5 2008, 10:58 PM']I guess highlighting all of it would defeat the point. [/quote] Yep. The whole text explains the Catholic position on this issue and should be read and assimilated by those who are faithful to the Church.
kujo Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1695426' date='Nov 6 2008, 01:44 AM']Kujo-I understand your view. I used to do legal partnership documents for gay couples. I never considered what they had to be a marriage, and told them so. I always refused to attend their union ceremonies, but I believe they are humans, with the same need for security that I have. I helped them with the documents they needed to ensure that they could inherit from each other, that they could be at each others death/sick bed. It was in working with them that really let me understand that what they have isn't a marriage. There was always something missing, and their relationships may have lasted for decades, but there was an underlying unhappiness. Doing the same estate planning for straight couples was completely different. So long as the state regulates marriage (and I don't necessarily think they should), there is no reason for them not to define what a marriage is. When I was younger, I might have felt differently, but I am willing to take what the church teaches on faith. I can yield to things that I don't completely agree with, or don't completely understand, because I am under the authority of the magisterium, and I accept the authority of my shepherd.[/quote] It may be my libertarian-leaning mindset, but I just think that there are minimal things the State ought to be involved in. Typically, this conversation segues into a discussion about whether the State has the right to "legislate morality," But I hope to bypass all that by saying that marriage is a sacrament that is holy, pure and Godly. Politics, and, by extension, the apparatus that is involved (i.e.- the State) is none of those and can only soil what it gets involved with. I'd rather leave marriage to the priests. [quote name='Brigid' post='1695427' date='Nov 6 2008, 01:50 AM']okay... I'm a little closer to understanding than I was before. I don't think I agree, necessarily, but nothing says we need to. so if, instead, you were voting on whether to make gay "marriage" legal or not, you would vote no, right? because you said you don't think it's something the goverment should get involved in. I'm just guessing how you would vote based on what you said before. please correct me if I'm wrong. so... if the government isn't "meddling in these matters" (that was your phrase - I didn't want to put too many words in your mouth.) than who is going to? I know that's not really a specific question, but... I guess I mean, if the government's not going to define marriage and allow or disallow gay "marriage", whose responsibility would that then be? haha, no problem. I don't like being mean. [/quote] I would vote "no" on any amendment, initiative or referendum that had to do with marriage. It's no one's business, least of all the State.
Apotheoun Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1695628' date='Nov 6 2008, 07:30 AM']I would vote "no" on any amendment, initiative or referendum that had to do with marriage. It's no one's business, least of all the State.[/quote] I voted yes on Prop 8, because the Church's Magisterium has called on all Catholics to resist the immoral agenda that tries to equate sodomy with marriage.
kujo Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1695643' date='Nov 6 2008, 10:52 AM']I voted yes on Prop 8, because the Church's Magisterium has called on all Catholics to resist the immoral agenda that tries to equate sodomy with marriage.[/quote] I understand. But I disagree.
Justin86 Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 My personal view on this is, if there was ever an all out ban on the government defining marriage I would vote "yes" but as long as the state is going to define it, I would vote for an amendment defining marriage between one man and one woman. Marriage of course has nothing to do with any legal contract, but as long as we as a society are going to pretend it does it needs to be between one man and one woman if only for our own preservation.
kujo Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1695657' date='Nov 6 2008, 11:05 AM']My personal view on this is, if there was ever an all out ban on the government defining marriage I would vote "yes" ... Marriage of course has nothing to do with any legal contract, but as long as we as a society are going to pretend it does it needs to be between one man and one woman if only for our own preservation.[/quote] IAWTC
CatherineM Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='kujo' post='1695628' date='Nov 6 2008, 08:30 AM']I'd rather leave marriage to the priests.[/quote] I definitely agree with you there.
kujo Posted November 6, 2008 Posted November 6, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1695666' date='Nov 6 2008, 11:16 AM']I definitely agree with you there.[/quote] Yay!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now