cappie Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 Nottingham Bishop Malcolm McMahon, touted as a possible future archbishop of Westminster, says that with the influx of married Anglican clergy to the Catholic Church, it is unfair to maintain the rule against priests marrying. Bishop McMahon said there is no doctrinal reason preventing them from having wives, The Daily Telegraph reports. Catholic priests have been required to take a vow of celibacy for centuries, but he argued that this now seemed unfair following the influx of married Anglican clergy. His comments are set to reignite the debate over whether the Church should end the tradition in a bid to deal with the shortage of priests. While Bishop McMahon said changing the law would not solve the Church's problems in recruiting men for the priesthood, he said that there would be benefits to such a move. He claimed that clergy with a family could offer different gifts and it would enable men who did not feel called to celibacy to enter the priesthood. "There is no reason why priests shouldn't be allowed to marry," he told The Sunday Telegraph. "It has always been a matter of discipline rather than doctrine." Priests have had to take a vow of celibacy after a decree from Pope Gregory VII in the eleventh century, which was then confirmed by subsequent Popes in the following century. Bishop McMahon added: "It is a question of justice for those men who want to be priests and to have a wife. Marriage should not bar them from their vocation but they must be married before they are ordained. The justice issue also applies to communities which could be deprived of the Eucharist because there aren't enough priests." Married Anglican clergy who were opposed to the introduction of women priests have been allowed to join the Roman Catholic Church. The bishop said this had caused problems with some Catholic priests who found this unfair. "We were told to be generous to the Anglican priests who joined, but we were surprised when the special permission was extended and made available to some who joined the Church of England after 1994 [when women were ordained for the first time]. "This has undoubtedly caused some grievance," he said. Bishop McMahon defended the Anglicans who had crossed to Rome: "They bring a great experience of family life into the parish. I find that they are excellent at ministering to women." He warned, however, that such a radical step could present as many problems as solutions. In particular, the bishop expressed concern that supporting families would cause financial difficulties for the Church, which is already being forced to close churches to raise money. Bishop McMahon has emerged as one of the favourites to succeed Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor, who is due to stand down early next year. [url="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/religion/3406108/Catholic-Church-has-no-reason-to-stop-priests-from-marrying-says-leading-bishop.html"]http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics...ing-bishop.html[/url]
Apotheoun Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 Priests have never been allowed to get married, but married men have been ordained in the Western Church in the past, and married men are currently ordained in the Eastern Churches.
Apotheoun Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 The good bishop's argument from "justice" is irrelevant.
eagle_eye222001 Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 Like how the bishop's arguments fail to note or argue against [i]ORDINATIO SACERDOTALIS[/i] but instead says something like "There is no reason why priests shouldn't be allowed to marry." That quote is incorrect as it ignores the arguments the church uses and instead just says there are no arguments. I also like how at the end the bishop acknowledges the probable problems that would arise from such a privilege. Although he ignores, again, the Church's arguments. This bishop is supposed to be a favorite to replace a cardinal?
CatherineM Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 At least this is an area that is allowed to be publicly debated since it is only a matter of church discipline.
Apotheoun Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 (edited) [quote name='CatherineM' post='1699807' date='Nov 11 2008, 06:55 PM']At least this is an area that is allowed to be publicly debated since it is only a matter of church discipline.[/quote] The ordination of married men is open to debate, but allowing priests to get married is not, because that is forbidden by ancient tradition. Neither the East nor the West has ever allowed priests to get married. Edited November 12, 2008 by Apotheoun
Vincent Vega Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1699811' date='Nov 11 2008, 09:57 PM']The ordination of married men is open to debate, but allowing priests to get married is not, because that is forbidden by ancient tradition. Neither the East nor the West has ever allowed priests to get married.[/quote] Hmm, interesting to note the connotations of the wording. Not to be a radical, but I have to say I'm open to the idea of ordaining the married.
MissyP89 Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 The bishop makes a fair argument, IMO. I agree with Catherine, his opinion on this matter is perfectly acceptable.
jeffpugh Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1699749' date='Nov 11 2008, 07:50 PM']The good bishop's argument from "justice" is irrelevant.[/quote] [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1699811' date='Nov 11 2008, 08:57 PM']The ordination of married men is open to debate, but allowing priests to get married is not, because that is forbidden by ancient tradition. Neither the East nor the West has ever allowed priests to get married.[/quote] Amen to both. I wonder why [url="http://gkupsidedown.blogspot.com/"]Fr. Dwight Longenecker[/url] hasn't commented on this...
Archaeology cat Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 I personally hope the discipline isn't changed. Mainly because, growing up Baptist, I was raised having married pastors, and I can't name one of them who was able to successfully lead his congregation and lead his family. Of course, I don't know any priests who are married, so I don't know if the same holds true for them. But from my personal experience, I just don't see how it would help things.
Apotheoun Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1699919' date='Nov 11 2008, 08:52 PM']Not to be a radical, but I have to say I'm open to the idea of ordaining the married.[/quote] The Eastern Churches already ordain married men, and the Latin Church is free to do so with the approval of its Patriarch.
Vincent Vega Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1700026' date='Nov 12 2008, 05:46 AM']The Eastern Churches already ordain married men, and the Latin Church is free to do so with the approval of its Patriarch.[/quote] Yes, I realise this. I didn't want to say I support it, per se; the Holy Father will change it in good time, if he sees it apt to do so.
Aloysius Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1699811' date='Nov 11 2008, 09:57 PM']The ordination of married men is open to debate, but allowing priests to get married is not, because that is forbidden by ancient tradition. Neither the East nor the West has ever allowed priests to get married.[/quote] I believe the distinction is lost on the writer of this article, but not the bishop, as he is quoted in the article saying: "It is a question of justice for those men who want to be priests and to have a wife. Marriage should not bar them from their vocation but [b]they must be married before they are ordained[/b]..."
Madame Vengier Posted November 12, 2008 Posted November 12, 2008 [quote name='cappie' post='1699737' date='Nov 11 2008, 08:35 PM']Nottingham Bishop Malcolm McMahon, touted as a possible future archbishop of Westminster, says that with the influx of married Anglican clergy to the Catholic Church, it is unfair to maintain the rule against priests marrying.[/quote] Mutiny.
Apotheoun Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1700291' date='Nov 12 2008, 02:50 PM']I believe the distinction is lost on the writer of this article, but not the bishop, as he is quoted in the article saying: "It is a question of justice for those men who want to be priests and to have a wife. Marriage should not bar them from their vocation but [b]they must be married before they are ordained[/b]..."[/quote] The bishop's argument is still null, because there is no right to become a priest, and so justice plays no part in this issue. Edited November 13, 2008 by Apotheoun
Archaeology cat Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1700403' date='Nov 13 2008, 02:48 AM']The bishop's argument is still null, because there is no right to become a priest, and so justice plays no part in this issue.[/quote] Very good point.
prose Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1699919' date='Nov 11 2008, 09:52 PM']Hmm, interesting to note the connotations of the wording. Not to be a radical, but I have to say I'm open to the idea of ordaining the married.[/quote] Me too. Well, let me re-phrase that: I couldn't give a spit about whether they are or are not married. If the Church teaches that it is acceptable, it would not make an ounce of difference to me. I do however agree that it seems odd that SOME priests can be married, while others can not. The discrepancy seems weird to me. It really isn't a matter of fairness, it is a matter of consistency. Either the Church should or should not allow married priests. There shouldn't be a matter of "well, you can be married as long as you are a convert" That seems... what is the word I am looking for... unclear to people who are not Catholic, and perhaps even to those that are.
Slappo Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1700403' date='Nov 12 2008, 06:48 PM']The bishop's argument is still null, because there is no right to become a priest, and so justice plays no part in this issue.[/quote] That depends on what definition of justice one is using. If speaking of the virtue of justice, which is to give one what is due to him, of course there is no role of justice, but to look at a more common secular understanding of the word... justice |ˈjəstis| noun 1 just behavior or treatment : a concern for justice, peace, and genuine respect for people. • the quality of being fair and reasonable : the justice of his case. The quality of being "fair and reasonable". In which case this is a [b]question[/b] of justice. The question would then be, "is it fair and [b]reasonable[/b] to deny some married men ordination while allowing others who are equally fit for the ministry of Holy Priesthood." Is it reasonable, is there a rational to the judgment that has been made on ordaining married men? That is the question at hand and it is quite a valid question as opposed to your immediate judgment of it's nullity based on looking at precise wording as opposed to intention of the author.
Apotheoun Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Slappo' post='1700601' date='Nov 13 2008, 10:15 AM']That depends on what definition of justice one is using. If speaking of the virtue of justice, which is to give one what is due to him, of course there is no role of justice, but to look at a more common secular understanding of the word...[/quote] There is no "right" to be a priest. Thus, the Church is perfectly within her rights to require celibacy of any man who wants to be ordained. She is also free to dispense from this requirement when she deems it useful. There is nothing unjust about any of this. Edited November 15, 2008 by Apotheoun
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now