cheryl Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 (edited) I had posted a similar question [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=87355"]elsewhere[/url], but it was suggested that I post it here. It was a good idea, because I came up with a better way to word it. My question: Does Catholicism teach that Christ made satisfaction for the sins of the whole world? That said satisfaction (payment/the satisfying of a debt), is irrevocable? Meaning that the debt even unbelievers owe to God has been paid, but that some do not accept Christ's satisfaction on their behalf and so remain unregenerated ect? Thanks Edited November 15, 2008 by cheryl
MissyP89 Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 If I'm reading you right, the answer is yes. Christ's sacrifice happened once for all. Though, as Protestants teach, that sacrifice needs to be accepted and acted upon in order to achieve salvation.
cheryl Posted November 15, 2008 Author Posted November 15, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1701613' date='Nov 14 2008, 10:18 PM']If I'm reading you right, the answer is yes. Christ's sacrifice happened once for all. Though, as Protestants teach, that sacrifice needs to be accepted and acted upon in order to achieve salvation.[/quote] How do I have a reply and no reviews lol. That's funny. Okay, just so we're not misunderstanding one another (which I hope we're not, cause I'm ready to jump out of my seat with glee ), Christ took away the sins of the whole world (Behold the Lamb of God....), He's forgiven everyone (Father, forgive them...), but some do not accept that forgiveness and thus do not allow it to transform their lives?
cheryl Posted November 15, 2008 Author Posted November 15, 2008 (edited) Can the Moderators delete or close this thread and it's cousin [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=87355"]here[/url]. I need to repent of trying to come to terms with the things that bother me, through books, arguments ect. So I might as well start here. Thanks. Edited November 15, 2008 by cheryl
MissyP89 Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1701658' date='Nov 14 2008, 11:07 PM']How do I have a reply and no reviews lol. That's funny. Okay, just so we're not misunderstanding one another (which I hope we're not, cause I'm ready to jump out of my seat with glee ), Christ took away the sins of the whole world (Behold the Lamb of God....), He's forgiven everyone (Father, forgive them...), but some do not accept that forgiveness and thus do not allow it to transform their lives?[/quote] That's right! The difference between other Christians and Catholics though is that we believe salvation is a lifetime process, and not just a single event. I am saved, but I am also being saved every day that I choose Christ over sin. I need to choose Him every day if I want to go to Heaven.
cheryl Posted November 15, 2008 Author Posted November 15, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1702247' date='Nov 15 2008, 06:09 PM']That's right! The difference between other Christians and Catholics though is that we believe salvation is a lifetime process, and not just a single event. I am saved, but I am also being saved every day that I choose Christ over sin. I need to choose Him every day if I want to go to Heaven.[/quote] I'm having a hard time believing what I'm hearing. lol Lutheranism always gave me the impression that...well....catholics don't believe this. Maybe I'm missing a subtlety here. Well...okay...here's what they believe in a nutshell (This is THE GOSPEL for them): Man fell into sin and thus was condemned under the law and at odds with God. Christ comes and takes that condemnation upon Himself. He does this for everyone (the whole world). So now, (from God's end), there is no condemnation. Although people can reject that. To use a quick illustration. Let's say that the mob who accused so and so of adultery and were about to stone her, represents the Law and condemnation. Christ comes does away with the mob and asks the girl, "Is there anyone here who condemns you?" She answers, "No my Lord". To which He replies, "Then neither do I condemn you". God, according to Lutheran teaching, has done away with condemnation through Christ and no longer accuses the world of sin. Although like I said, people can reject that and then we get into other stuff. But that basic premise....would catholics agree?
mortify Posted November 16, 2008 Posted November 16, 2008 On a somewhat related topic: [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/most/getwork.cfm?worknum=96"][b]Jesus paid for all[/b][/url]
Apotheoun Posted November 16, 2008 Posted November 16, 2008 The Eastern Christian tradition holds that Adam brought death upon himself and upon all his descendants by cooperating with Satan, and that the eternal Logos came, as a man among men, in order to heal humanity by destroying death and by giving everlasting life.
MissyP89 Posted November 16, 2008 Posted November 16, 2008 That's pretty much it. In my PERSONAL understanding, there is still the condemnation of God, but Christ will stand up for us before the Father as our advocate. Knowing Christ means He'll stand for you...rejecting Him means He'll say that He never knew you. There are specific ways that Catholics live out that belief, and THAT is why non-Catholic Christians get so upset over us. We do things differently then most Christians, and many of them believe we are in error by doing what we do. The truth is that we are using [i]everything[/i] Christ gave to His followers, and not just some things as most Christians do. Does that make sense? Keep the questions coming.
cheryl Posted November 17, 2008 Author Posted November 17, 2008 I could be wrong but I think pretty much all Christians believe that.
cheryl Posted November 17, 2008 Author Posted November 17, 2008 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1702802' date='Nov 16 2008, 05:54 PM']That's pretty much it. In my PERSONAL understanding, there is still the condemnation of God, but Christ will stand up for us before the Father as our advocate. Knowing Christ means He'll stand for you...rejecting Him means He'll say that He never knew you. There are specific ways that Catholics live out that belief, and THAT is why non-Catholic Christians get so upset over us. We do things differently then most Christians, and many of them believe we are in error by doing what we do. The truth is that we are using [i]everything[/i] Christ gave to His followers, and not just some things as most Christians do. Does that make sense? Keep the questions coming. [/quote] Yep....it makes sense. I came to a realization this morning as to why I am feeling as if I have to choose between Mary and Christ. What's the difference now, as opposed to before when thinking I had to choose between the two was the furthest thing from my mind. It touches on that whole "lived out" thing. But it's a story in and of itself. So I'd like to wait and write about it later on, in a new thread. Thanks Missy for taking the time to talk to me.
missionseeker Posted November 18, 2008 Posted November 18, 2008 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1702771' date='Nov 16 2008, 05:14 PM']The Eastern Christian tradition holds that Adam brought death upon himself and upon all his descendants by cooperating with Satan, and that the eternal Logos came, as a man among men, in order to heal humanity by destroying death and by giving everlasting life.[/quote] And that differs from the Western ... how...?
Apotheoun Posted November 19, 2008 Posted November 19, 2008 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1704069' date='Nov 18 2008, 10:10 AM']And that differs from the Western ... how...?[/quote] Anselm's penal satisfaction theory had no impact on Eastern theology, and so as I pointed out in a post some time ago: [size=3]In Byzantine Catholic theology death, disease, and the corruption effecting the cosmic order, are not seen as a punishment inflicted upon man by God; instead, they are seen as a consequence of man's own voluntary withdrawal from the power of God's uncreated energies. In other words, it is man who, in cooperation with the devil, brings about the disordered desires that wound humanity, along with all the various physical and spiritual diseases afflicting mankind, and of course, it is man who brings about his own death, both the death of the body and of the soul; while it is the eternal Logos who comes in the flesh in order to heal and restore what man and the devil have damaged [cf. John 1:14]. Therefore, it is not God who inflicts suffering upon man; instead, it is man who inflicts suffering upon himself, and he has done this through his rejection of the gift of the divine life given to him at the time of his creation in the Garden of Eden, and he perpetuates it through his own malice and selfishness throughout human history. God is not the cause of death [cf. Wisdom 1:12-16]; instead, He is the Great Physician, for it is He who heals, restores, and perfects man, by giving him once again a share in the divine nature [cf. 2nd Peter 1:4].[/size]
missionseeker Posted November 19, 2008 Posted November 19, 2008 And in the Western God is only the cause of the punishment as He is the cause of the punished. [b]As appears from what was said (1), the evil which consists in the defect of action is always caused by the defect of the agent. [i]But in God there is no defect, but the highest perfection, as was shown above (Question 4, Article 1). Hence, the evil which consists in defect of action, or which is caused by defect of the agent, is not reduced to God as to its cause. [/i] But the evil which consists in the corruption of some things is reduced to God as the cause. And this appears as regards both natural things and voluntary things. For it was said (1) that some agent inasmuch as it produces by its power a form to which follows corruption and defect, causes by its power that corruption and defect. But it is manifest that the form which God chiefly intends in things created is the good of the order of the universe. Now, the order of the universe requires, as was said above (22, 2, ad 2; 48, 2), that there should be some things that can, and do sometimes, fail. And thus God, by causing in things the good of the order of the universe, consequently and as it were by accident, causes the corruptions of things, according to 1 Samuel 2:6: "The Lord killeth and maketh alive." But when we read that "God hath not made death" (Wisdom 1:13), the sense is that God does not will death for its own sake. Nevertheless the order of justice belongs to the order of the universe; and this requires that penalty should be dealt out to sinners. And so God is the author of the evil which is penalty, but not of the evil which is fault, by reason of what is said above. [/b] If we didn't choose it, it wouldn't be because that's not God's intention. Things only fail because of human choosing of imperfection.
Justin86 Posted November 19, 2008 Posted November 19, 2008 (edited) [quote name='missionseeker' post='1704069' date='Nov 19 2008, 02:10 AM']And that differs from the Western ... how...?[/quote] It doesn't. Apotheon just likes to start paragraphs with "The Eastern Christian tradition holds..." Edited November 19, 2008 by Justin86
Apotheoun Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='missionseeker' post='1704691' date='Nov 19 2008, 08:50 AM']And in the Western God is only the cause of the punishment as He is the cause of the punished. . . . If we didn't choose it, it wouldn't be because that's not God's intention. Things only fail because of human choosing of imperfection. [/quote] Man is the cause of his own punishment. Predestination does not concern man's personal choices, which are always free; instead, predestination -- as St. Maximos says -- involves man's nature. Edited November 20, 2008 by Apotheoun
Apotheoun Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Justin86' post='1704705' date='Nov 19 2008, 09:26 AM']It doesn't. Apotheon just likes to start paragraphs with "The Eastern Christian tradition holds..."[/quote] Below is a non-exhaustive list of theological and liturgical differences between East and West: [size=3](1) As many people already know, the East and West differ over the use of leavened or unleavened bread in the Eucharist, and this difference really is of only minor importance, but as Jungman explained in his magnum opus on the Roman liturgy, the West only began using unleavened bread in the 9th century (cf. Jungman, Mass of the Roman Rite, 2:33-34), and so the older practice of the Church is to use leavened bread. (2) Westerners and Easterners make the sign of the cross somewhat differently, with Easterners making the sign from forehead to the center of the torso, and then from right shoulder to left shoulder. The West began making the sign of the cross ending on the right shoulder beginning at some point around the 12th to 13th century. (3) The use of the filioque in the creed. The creed as it was originally written did not include the filioque, but the West added the filioque to the Niceno-Constantinopolitan creed beginning in Spain around the 7th century, with the filioque finally being added at Rome itself at some point during the early part of the 11th century. (4) The East holds that grace is uncreated, while the West holds that grace is created. In the East grace is divine energy (energia), which means that grace is God Himself as He exists for us, that is, as He exists outside of His incommunicable essence (ousia). There are of course different schools of thought in the West on the nature of grace, but the Augustinian and Thomistic schools tend to dominate Western theology. That being said, Eastern theologians do not believe that there is any need at all for a doctrine of grace as a created habitus; and moreover, they deny that there is such a thing as a "created supernatural," because in the metaphysics of the Eastern Church the supernatural is by definition uncreated. But it must be borne in mind that not all Western theologians subscribe to the Scholastic position on the nature of deifying grace. (5) East and West view the Trinity somewhat differently. The West tends to follow St. Thomas Aquinas and the Augustinian tradition, which looks upon the persons (hypostases) of the Trinity as mere relations within the divine essence (ousia), and which holds that it is the unity of the divine essence (ousia) itself that establishes the fact that there is only one God. While the East holds that the three divine persons (hypostases) are really distinct from each other, not because of their relations per se, but because of their origins. Thus, the person (hypostasis) of the Father is distinct from the person (hypostasis) of the Son and the person (hypostasis) of the Spirit, because the Father is the unoriginate cause of all divinity, while the Son is eternally generated by the Father, and the Holy Spirit is eternally projected from the Father alone as sole personal (hypostatic) cause of divinity. In other words, the person (hypostasis) of the Father is unbegotten, and the person (hypostasis) of the Son is begotten by the Father, and the person (hypostasis) of the Holy Spirit is spirated by the Father alone through procession. Consequently, in the theology of the East there is only one God because there is only one Father from whom all Godhead originates. (6) In the West, God is held to be pure act (actus purus), and as such there are no real distinctions within the Godhead, because even the three divine persons (hypostases) are only distinct in relation to each other, and not to the divine essence (ousia). Thus, in Western theology essence (ousia) and person (hypostasis) are identical in God (cf. Summa Theologica, Prima Pars, Q. 39, art. 1); while in Eastern theology, essence (ousia) and person (hypostasis) are really distinct from each other. Moreover, in addition to the real distinction between essence (ousia) and person (hypostasis) in Eastern triadology, it is held that the divine essence (ousia) itself is completely unknowable, because God, in His essence (ousia), is hyperousios and hypertheos. As a consequence, God does not reveal Himself in His essence (ousia); instead, He reveals Himself tri-hypostatically through His uncreated energies. (7) From the what has been said in point number five above, it becomes clear that the West and the East understand the divine simplicity differently. The West holds that in God there are no real distinctions between, what it calls, His attributes and His essence (ousia), thus all of the divine attributes are identical with the divine essence. While in the East, divine simplicity is understood as the co-inherence (perichoresis) of the divine essence in the multiplicity of God's uncreated energies; and so, each energy is distinct from every other energy (e.g., the divine will is distinct from divine love, which is distinct from truth, which is distinct from mercy, which is distinct from justice, etc.), but the divine essence (ousia) is present as a whole in each one of the distinct energies. This means that the divine essence is indivisibly divided among the personalized (enhypostatic) energies of the three divine persons (hypostases). A note of clarification is necessary at this point, because although the uncreated energies correspond in some sense to what the West calls attributes, to identify these two terms (attributes and energies) can lead to theological confusion. In the West the divine attributes are normally held to be distinct only in a noetic sense, that is, they are held to be distinction merely mentally (i.e., in the mind); and that is why the East avoids this term when referring to God's uncreated energies, because that would undermine the real distinction that exists between essence (ousia) and energy (energia) in God, reducing it to an epistemic distinction. Moreover, to reduce the distinction between the divine essence and the uncreated divine energies to something that is merely epistemic leads to major theological problems in connection with the doctrine of divinization (theosis). (8) As indicated above, the East makes a further distinction, without a separation, in the Godhead, between the divine essence (ousia) and the uncreated divine energies. The divine essence (ousia) is completely incommunicable and transcendent, and as such it is hyperousios; consequently it cannot be known, not now or even in the eschaton. God is revealed only in His uncreated energies, which flow out from the three divine persons (hypostases) as a gift to man. Moreover, it is only by his participation in the divine energies that man can truly possess an experiential knowledge of God, an experience that can be understood in two ways: first, at the level of nature by the sustaining of man's created existence; and second, at the level of the supernatural through the elevation of man's being into the life and glory of the Triune God. (9) The East holds that divinization (theosis) is brought about by an ontological participation in God's uncreated energies, and that through the divine energies man truly participates in the divine life and glory. The uncreated energies are God as He exists outside of His incomprehensible essence (ousia), and so the divine energies are distinct from the divine essence, but without being separated from it. (10) The Eastern understanding of predestination also differs from that of the West. The East holds that all men at the level of nature are predestined to redemption through the incarnation of the Son of God. In other words, through the incarnation of the eternal Logos all of nature has been freed from corruption and the dissolution into non-existence brought about by Adam's fall from grace, and has been given the gift of redemption to everlasting existence. But salvation, on the other hand, concerns the integration of the human person (hypostasis) with his natural virtues through the power of God's uncreated energies and the activity of his own created free will. Salvation requires that a man enact his will through grace in doing good and avoiding evil. If a man lives a good life through the power of his will restored by grace, he may enter into the beatific vision, but if he fails to integrate his natural virtues into his person (hypostasis), he damns himself. Thus, in Eastern theology predestination is the universal redemption of all men and of the whole of creation itself from corruption and non-existence, while salvation involves the integration of man's natural virtues with his personal (hypostatic) existence through the power of God's uncreated energies and his own free will. (11) In the Eastern Churches married men can be ordained to both the diaconate and the priesthood; but like the Latin Church, only celibate men can be consecrated as bishops. (12) In Byzantine sacramental theology the priest is the minister of the sacrament of matrimony, and so his blessing is necessary for the validity of the sacrament. This also means that a deacon cannot officiate at an Eastern Catholic wedding. (13) In Eastern theology the bread and wine of the Eucharist are held to be consecrated into the body and blood of Christ by the prayer of epiclesis. (14) Because the Eastern Churches use the Septuagint (Greek) Old Testament they have a somewhat larger canon of scripture than the Latin Church. As an example, the Byzantine Church recites the "Prayer of Manasseh" as scripture during Great Compline. (15) In the Eastern Churches icons are always two dimensional images, and so one will rarely if ever see statuary in an Eastern Church. (16) In the Eastern Churches the sacraments of initiation are not separated, and so, babies are baptized, chrismated with holy myron (confirmed), and receive first communion all at the same time.[/size] Taken from the thread entitled: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s=&showtopic=34879&view=findpost&p=652378"][u]East and Wet, Byzantine and Latin[/u][/url] Edited November 20, 2008 by Apotheoun
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now