Madame Vengier Posted November 19, 2008 Posted November 19, 2008 This is the same court that granted "marriage" rights to California gays by defying the will of the majority of Californians, who had already spoken with their vote against it. Now, they will hear the case AGAIN and probably AGAIN defy the will of the people. [url="http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/11/19/gay.marriage/index.html"]http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/11/19/gay.marriage/index.html[/url]
doe-jo Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 If I could, I'd move out of this state. This is getting ridiculous. In 2000, prop 22 passed (60+% voted yes on it) and defined marriage as between a man and a woman but it wasn't put in the state constitution. This year, 4 judges legislated from the bench (something they can't do and shouldn't have done). This month, 52% of CA voted yes on prop 8. And now this again? When will this end? I have a feeling CA will just get tired of these pro-gay marriage people and will give in to them. I hope not. I pray it'll do the opposite and get Californians fired up about this issue.
Justin86 Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 (edited) I don't know how the California Surpreme Court could overturn this. Wasn't Prop 8 a state constitutional amendment? Now the US Surpeme Court could overturn, and if they did that would overturn the bans in all states. This sounds like what they're trying to do. Edited November 20, 2008 by Justin86
guitarfreak Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 Isn't the courts job to interpret the constitution? Not to author it?
doe-jo Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='guitarfreak' post='1705026' date='Nov 19 2008, 06:23 PM']Isn't the courts job to interpret the constitution? Not to author it?[/quote] exactly. They can't legislate. But that's what the four judges did this summer.
Brother Adam Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 I'd be interested in hearing from our lawyers at PM if it is possible for a court to throw out a constitutional amendment, and under what circumstances that you could.
Justin86 Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1705035' date='Nov 20 2008, 10:32 AM']I'd be interested in hearing from our lawyers at PM if it is possible for a court to throw out a constitutional amendment, and under what circumstances that you could.[/quote] That's the thing. The whole purpose of constituional amendments is to override Surpreme Court descions. It's a part of checks and balances.
eagle_eye222001 Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Justin86' post='1705038' date='Nov 19 2008, 08:35 PM']That's the thing. The whole purpose of constituional amendments is to override Surpreme Court descions. It's a part of checks and balances.[/quote] But CA is overriding "rights." Don't get me wrong, I am completely against gay marriage and all its forms (civil unions etc), however that is the argument that will be used for the court to overturn proposition 8. Not saying it is a solid argument...because I don't think it is. However, that is the mindset and argument that will be used to in an attempt to overthrow prop 8. Although what is interesting is that from my understanding, prop 8 was designed to avoid the meddling of judges...since the judges are even looking at it....spells doom for 8. Below is a couple key paragraphs from the CNN article. [i] In its May 15 ruling legalizing gay marriage in California, the justices seemed to signal that a ballot initiative like Proposition 8 might not be enough to change the underlying constitutional issues of the case in the court's eyes. The ruling said the right to marry is among a set of basic human rights "so integral to an individual's liberty and personal autonomy that they may not be eliminated or abrogated by the legislature or by the electorate through the statutory initiative process."[/i] Given the language of the article... Wish my wing was better, I would fly out and attack those justices. Don't tell me that love thy neighbor stuff..that applies to humans...I am sure there is something in the bible that gives eagles a moral pass. Edited November 20, 2008 by eagle_eye222001
XIX Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='guitarfreak' post='1705026' date='Nov 19 2008, 09:23 PM']Isn't the courts job to interpret the constitution? Not to author it?[/quote] You presuppose that liberal judges are interested in defending the constitution?
johnnydigit Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 at least we tried, that's all God asks. and keep trying.. i wonder if God would let us know first if he lights us up like Sodom again..
Socrates Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1705175' date='Nov 19 2008, 11:29 PM']at least we tried, that's all God asks. and keep trying.. i wonder if God would let us know first if he lights us up like Sodom again..[/quote] He'll give warning - just don't let your wife look back when you get out. Liberal activist judges make me sick. Liberals are only for "democracy" when coincides with their own leftist agenda. When democracy fails, there's always the all-powerful courts to set the poor huddled masses straight (though, of course, "straight" never has anything to do with it!).
CatherineM Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 I have slept a few times since my last constitutional law class, but laws that are passed, that violate a provision of the constitution can be overturned from the bench as "unconstitutional." I can't recall off the top of my head a federal constitutional amendment being found to be unconstitutional. Amendments have to be repealed. What they could find is that some part of the process invalidates the election. I believe there have been some state constitutional amendments found to violate the US constitution, but that would be decided by the US Supreme Court, and not the state supreme court.
Didacus Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote]Did you know my face is beautiful enough to be worth $5000?[/quote] I love that movie! A classic! Back to you Bob...
rkwright Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 Like some others have said, I don't see how the CA Supreme Court could overturn the Amendment based on their constitution. The purpose of constitutional amendments is to check the courts. The earlier statute, prop 22 was overturned because it was unconstitutional. But how can a constitutional amendment (prop 8) be constitutional? So they shouldn't be able to overturn it on those grounds. However - The CA Supreme Court could say that Prop 8 violates the US Constitution - and is thus unconstitutional. That would be appealed to the US Supreme court for further argument. It gets tricky then. Does the US Constitution say anything about marriage? No... So then let the states decide? Probably... But then again what about privacy? I would fear another 5-4 decision based on Privacy in which the gay rights activists would win.
Socrates Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1705189' date='Nov 19 2008, 11:51 PM']Oye! Bring back the Union Jack![/quote] Well, England's even more pc-leftist than the US.
Socrates Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='rkwright' post='1705213' date='Nov 20 2008, 12:17 AM']Like some others have said, I don't see how the CA Supreme Court could overturn the Amendment based on their constitution. The purpose of constitutional amendments is to check the courts. The earlier statute, prop 22 was overturned because it was unconstitutional. But how can a constitutional amendment (prop 8) be constitutional? So they shouldn't be able to overturn it on those grounds. However - The CA Supreme Court could say that Prop 8 violates the US Constitution - and is thus unconstitutional. That would be appealed to the US Supreme court for further argument. It gets tricky then. Does the US Constitution say anything about marriage? No... So then let the states decide? Probably... But then again what about privacy? I would fear another 5-4 decision based on Privacy in which the gay rights activists would win.[/quote] Activist judges have never been ones to let constitutional amendments stand in their way.
Winchester Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='guitarfreak' post='1705026' date='Nov 19 2008, 08:23 PM']Isn't the courts job to interpret the constitution? Not to author it?[/quote] Judicial Review is a fiction.
rkwright Posted November 20, 2008 Posted November 20, 2008 [quote name='Socrates' post='1705216' date='Nov 19 2008, 11:20 PM']Activist judges have never been ones to let constitutional amendments stand in their way.[/quote] Well if a State supreme court said that a state constitutional amendment violated a state constitution... that would be the first I've ever heard of that. If they say it violated the US constitution, that would be different.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now