Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What Are The Chances Of Proposition 8 Being Overturned?


The War on Gay Marriage  

32 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Okay, so we all know, or we should all know, that proposition 8 is being reviewed by the :bow: California Supreme Court :getaclue: <_<

Why I want to ask is what do you think is going to happen? I am looking for unbiased, or as unbiased opinions as possible. :unsure:

What are the chances of prop 8 being overturned? 10%? Coin flip? 80%? Why? What legal ramifications :unclesam: are going for the gay activists? For the Mormon/Christian crowd? Are there precedents that should worry us? :book: :mellow:


The CA Supreme Court :boink: will probably not make a ruling until May or June :coffee: so we have plenty of time to speculate and fill ourselves with false hopes :drunk: (hopefully not).

Basically I am trying to find the realistic picture of what is likely to happen and why. :graduate:

:birds:

princessgianna
Posted

First off-It is totally awesome to see you wanting to stand up to truth :sword:

though GIVE IT A REST DUDE!
whatever happens please eagle_eye222001 try to just calm down! we humans can't solve things by how hard we analyze it. Just please try to chill grab a :drpepper: get some :popcorn: and sit in front of the amazing simpsons :grandpa: :bart: and be :tvhappy: merry! or better yet some (most likely needed) rest :goodnight: or get an good :book:
I totally agree that we as Catholics need to stay in touch with the world though [b] let's not become so obsessed with how the world is shooting itself in the head- that we miss out on Christ's Love! [/b]

I understand where you are coming from however please CHILL DUDE! it's gonna be OK you DO NOT need to analyze everything under the amazingly hot sun! Seriously dude that is how people get sick! I would hate for you to get sick even for a day! Try to chill! RELAX! IT is in God's hands!

you seem to be a Conservative Catholic dude!! Lucky gal who gets you :marriage: however you aren't going to do her much good if you are so obsessed with the news that you get yourself sick from reading too much and affect your job/studies/whatever! :)

Don't feel like you have to DO IT ALL or FIGHT IT ALL RIGHT NOW :juggle: because when you have an overload everything in your life suffers and God will never give you too much so don't give yourself to much!!

So dude-get some friends (siblings would work :cool: ) and have a safe but still totally amazing time to chill and regroup :cheers: :breakdance: :biker: :rap: :soccer:

Pax~
God Bless :blowkiss:
princessgianna[u][/u]

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='princessgianna' post='1706606' date='Nov 21 2008, 12:44 AM']First off-It is totally awesome to see you wanting to stand up to truth :sword:

though GIVE IT A REST DUDE!
whatever happens please eagle_eye222001 try to just calm down! we humans can't solve things by how hard we analyze it. Just please try to chill grab a :drpepper: get some :popcorn: and sit in front of the amazing simpsons :grandpa: :bart: and be :tvhappy: merry! or better yet some (most likely needed) rest :goodnight: or get an good :book:
I totally agree that we as Catholics need to stay in touch with the world though [b] let's not become so obsessed with how the world is shooting itself in the head- that we miss out on Christ's Love! [/b]

I understand where you are coming from however please CHILL DUDE! it's gonna be OK you DO NOT need to analyze everything under the amazingly hot sun! Seriously dude that is how people get sick! I would hate for you to get sick even for a day! Try to chill! RELAX! IT is in God's hands!

you seem to be a Conservative Catholic dude!! Lucky gal who gets you :marriage: however you aren't going to do her much good if you are so obsessed with the news that you get yourself sick from reading too much and affect your job/studies/whatever! :)

Don't feel like you have to DO IT ALL or FIGHT IT ALL RIGHT NOW :juggle: because when you have an overload everything in your life suffers and God will never give you too much so don't give yourself to much!!

So dude-get some friends (siblings would work :cool: ) and have a safe but still totally amazing time to chill and regroup ([i]emoticons deleted to make room for mine as I figured if you really want to look at what emoticons were here you can look up at the original post.[/i])

Pax~
God Bless :blowkiss:
princessgianna[u][/u][/quote]

Thanks for your concern.......didn't answer my question.:soccer: :lol_sign: :D :lol_roll: :lol_pound: :lol:


..............but thanks!

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='princessgianna' post='1706606' date='Nov 21 2008, 12:44 AM']First off-It is totally awesome to see you wanting to stand up to truth :sword:

though GIVE IT A REST DUDE!
whatever happens please eagle_eye222001 try to just calm down! we humans can't solve things by how hard we analyze it. Just please try to chill grab a :drpepper: get some :popcorn: and sit in front of the amazing simpsons :grandpa: :bart: and be :tvhappy: merry! or better yet some (most likely needed) rest :goodnight: or get an good :book:
I totally agree that we as Catholics need to stay in touch with the world though [b] let's not become so obsessed with how the world is shooting itself in the head- that we miss out on Christ's Love! [/b]

I understand where you are coming from however please CHILL DUDE! it's gonna be OK you DO NOT need to analyze everything under the amazingly hot sun! Seriously dude that is how people get sick! I would hate for you to get sick even for a day! Try to chill! RELAX! IT is in God's hands!

you seem to be a Conservative Catholic dude!! Lucky gal who gets you :marriage: however you aren't going to do her much good if you are so obsessed with the news that you get yourself sick from reading too much and affect your job/studies/whatever! :)

Don't feel like you have to DO IT ALL or FIGHT IT ALL RIGHT NOW :juggle: because when you have an overload everything in your life suffers and God will never give you too much so don't give yourself to much!!

So dude-get some friends (siblings would work :cool: ) and have a safe but still totally amazing time to chill and regroup :cheers: :breakdance: :biker: :rap: :soccer:

Pax~
God Bless :blowkiss:
princessgianna[u][/u][/quote]

Whoa, so many emotocons! :lol_roll:

icelandic_iceskater
Posted

haha to add with the unexpected emoticon theme of this topic...

will prob 8 be overturned?
:idontknow:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='princessgianna' post='1706606' date='Nov 21 2008, 01:44 AM']First off-It is totally awesome to see you wanting to stand up to truth :sword:

though GIVE IT A REST DUDE!
whatever happens please eagle_eye222001 try to just calm down! we humans can't solve things by how hard we analyze it. Just please try to chill grab a :drpepper: get some :popcorn: and sit in front of the amazing simpsons :grandpa: :bart: and be :tvhappy: merry! or better yet some (most likely needed) rest :goodnight: or get an good :book:
I totally agree that we as Catholics need to stay in touch with the world though [b] let's not become so obsessed with how the world is shooting itself in the head- that we miss out on Christ's Love! [/b]

I understand where you are coming from however please CHILL DUDE! it's gonna be OK you DO NOT need to analyze everything under the amazingly hot sun! Seriously dude that is how people get sick! I would hate for you to get sick even for a day! Try to chill! RELAX! IT is in God's hands!

you seem to be a Conservative Catholic dude!! Lucky gal who gets you :marriage: however you aren't going to do her much good if you are so obsessed with the news that you get yourself sick from reading too much and affect your job/studies/whatever! :)

Don't feel like you have to DO IT ALL or FIGHT IT ALL RIGHT NOW :juggle: because when you have an overload everything in your life suffers and God will never give you too much so don't give yourself to much!!

So dude-get some friends (siblings would work :cool: ) and have a safe but still totally amazing time to chill and regroup :cheers: :breakdance: :biker: :rap: :soccer:

Pax~
God Bless :blowkiss:
princessgianna[u][/u][/quote]

that was fun to read :smokey:

Edited by Guest
Posted

If proposition 8 were indeed overturned by the California Supreme Court, that would spell a very scary precedent in California law (US law, if the case went before the SCOTUS). If so, then even the constitution is under the command of the Supreme Court. Which would mean that the Supreme Court could simply dismiss the entire state constitution and establish an oligarchy, if it desired.

In a sense, the scariest thing about Prop 8 being overturned is not that it would legalize same-sex marriages again in California ...

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1716209' date='Dec 1 2008, 09:44 PM']If proposition 8 were indeed overturned by the California Supreme Court, that would spell a very scary precedent in California law (US law, if the case went before the SCOTUS). If so, then even the constitution is under the command of the Supreme Court. Which would mean that the Supreme Court could simply dismiss the entire state constitution and establish an oligarchy, if it desired.

In a sense, the scariest thing about Prop 8 being overturned is not that it would legalize same-sex marriages again in California ...[/quote]

Hmm, really? :unsure:

Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1716209' date='Dec 1 2008, 09:44 PM']If proposition 8 were indeed overturned by the California Supreme Court, that would spell a very scary precedent in California law (US law, if the case went before the SCOTUS). If so, then even the constitution is under the command of the Supreme Court. Which would mean that the Supreme Court could simply dismiss the entire state constitution and establish an oligarchy, if it desired.

In a sense, the scariest thing about Prop 8 being overturned is not that it would legalize same-sex marriages again in California ...[/quote]
Agreed.

I suspect they will overturn Prop 8, based on the idea that the majority cannot take away the rights of a minority.

And I further imagine that [i]that[/i] move will be overturned by the Supreme Court, based on the California justices overstepping their authority.

Going to continue to be a long and ugly battle, I think.

Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1716260' date='Dec 1 2008, 09:59 PM']Agreed.

I suspect they will overturn Prop 8, [b]based on the idea that the majority cannot take away the rights of a minority[/b].

And I further imagine that [i]that[/i] move will be overturned by the Supreme Court, based on the California justices overstepping their authority.

Going to continue to be a long and ugly battle, I think.[/quote]

<sarcasm target="gay_lobby">
Oh, I get it. You mean that the minority can take away the rights of the majority?
</sarcasm>

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1716209' date='Dec 1 2008, 08:44 PM']If proposition 8 were indeed overturned by the California Supreme Court, that would spell a very scary precedent in California law (US law, if the case went before the SCOTUS). If so, then even the constitution is under the command of the Supreme Court. Which would mean that the Supreme Court could simply dismiss the entire state constitution and establish an oligarchy, if it desired.

In a sense, the scariest thing about Prop 8 being overturned is not that it would legalize same-sex marriages again in California ...[/quote]
Oh yes, how very scary. Gay people you don't know and that have nothing to do with you getting the same rights from the state as a married couple :o

All of society is going to crumble and we're going to die.

Posted

Marriage isn't a "right", it is a divine institution that is reserved for a man and a woman only, not a man and a man, not a woman and a woman. Proposition 8, if upheld, will preserve the sanctity of marriage; rather than reducing marriage to what man wants.

Marriage wasn't instituted by man; rather, was instituted by God. The nuptial theme runs from the first page of the bible to the last (Genesis to Revelation) and everything in between (Leviticus, Psalms, Proverbs, Song of Songs, Wisdom, Isaiah, the four Gospels, Ephesians to name a few).

Posted

Marriage (according to the state) is a licsence, not a right. Saying gay people have a "right" to get married is like saying someone has a "right" to drive a car. It's propersteous.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1716390' date='Dec 2 2008, 12:33 AM']Oh yes, how very scary. Gay people you don't know and that have nothing to do with you getting the same rights from the state as a married couple :o

All of society is going to crumble and we're going to die.[/quote]

Erm ... Fidei ...

You [b]entirely[/b] missed the point of my post. Please re-read it, search out my thesis, and post in regards to it, rather than putting words in my mouth and mocking them. I never said that "gay marriage" was scary in the sense that you seem to have taken it to mean. I do, however, believe that a supreme court that is more powerful than the constitution is scary in that sense. Again, please re-read:

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1716209' date='Dec 1 2008, 09:44 PM']If proposition 8 were indeed overturned by the California Supreme Court, that would spell a very scary precedent in California law (US law, if the case went before the SCOTUS). If so, then even the constitution is under the command of the Supreme Court. Which would mean that the Supreme Court could simply dismiss the entire state constitution and establish an oligarchy, if it desired.

In a sense, the scariest thing about Prop 8 being overturned is not that it would legalize same-sex marriages again in California ...[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1716390' date='Dec 2 2008, 12:33 AM']Oh yes, how very scary. Gay people you don't know and that have nothing to do with you getting the same rights from the state as a married couple :o

All of society is going to crumble and we're going to die.[/quote]
What the heck? You totally missed his point.

What would be scary is the State of California justices taking it upon themselves to actually remove portions of California's constitution, when the definition of their duty is to uphold that constitution. That would be scary regardless of what specific amendment they removed.

Still all speculative, of course.

Posted

Didn't it get overturned already? I thought Ellen said it did on her show yesterday.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1716676' date='Dec 2 2008, 03:34 PM']Didn't it get overturned already? I thought Ellen said it did on her show yesterday.[/quote]
Just checked the news -- the only recent event is that some legislators in CA proposed a bill that would do something or other to undo Prop 8. I didn't look into the details. (Though really, legislators shouldn't be able to undo constitutional amendments either...?)

Posted

Out of curiosity, does anyone know the wording of prop 8? Can't seem to find it online.

Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' post='1716390' date='Dec 2 2008, 12:33 AM']Oh yes, how very scary. Gay people you don't know and that have nothing to do with you getting the same rights from the state as a married couple :o

All of society is going to crumble and we're going to die.[/quote]

I am not sure you are really willing to hear, that is consider, what I am about to say, that is type. :mellow:

But let me propose something drastic;

1. Homosexual Marriage continues a slide down a contraceptive path, and destroys the idea that Marriage, and sexuality, are for the sake of Children.

It seems that you may want to look into something called "demographic winter." When sexuality autonomous from the rearing and education of Children, not only does virtue suffer, but so does population growth. Without population growth, there is no economic growth. With out economic growth, there is no political stability.

2. If in principle the state has the authority to define marriage, apart from the nature of human persons, then the state is autonomous from the moral order. It may then on the same principle decide that for instance polygamy is moral as well as any other number of sexual perversions. Note that I am not saying same sex marriage laws would allow this, but the principle which allow the government to change the definition of marriage would allow a slippery slope.

3. If the gov. is autonomous from the moral order in this regard why is not autonomous in other "further" aspects, such as defining when a person has rights... o wait...

or how about when it is ok to torture...

...o wait...

or how about when then when it is ok to for the state to use the death penalty when it is not the last resort

... o wait ...

4. If the state were to call same sex unions marriages, then it would severally limit the religious liberty for a number reasons not limited to forced sex ed. The cases of this happening are numerable

Also, one day, we will indeed all die. I hope to die in the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1716706' date='Dec 2 2008, 04:49 PM']Out of curiosity, does anyone know the wording of prop 8? Can't seem to find it online.[/quote]
I don't know about what the ballot said, but if you mean the final result, the [url="http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/const-toc.html"]Constitution of California[/url] now says:

[quote]CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION

ARTICLE 1 DECLARATION OF RIGHTS

SEC. 7.5. Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or
recognized in California.[/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...