Laudate_Dominum Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 (edited) [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Mar 14 2004, 03:54 PM'] I'll post. I'm one who thought your earlier post was quite uncharitable to Protestants. As a convert, there is nothing I like hearing less than how Protestantism is responsible for all of the ills in society. I was told by someone that the bikini clad rock and roll beer bashes that they hold every year at our basilica is due to Protestantism. (If you ever went anywhere near a Baptist church, you'd know there'd be no bikinis or beer bashes and no secular rock and roll there to be sure!) I agree with some of the idea of the "spirit of Protestantism" being responsible for some of the chaos... but please... a little charity. We aren't satanic... :pitchfork: [/quote] I certainly don't think protestantism is responsible for all the ills of society and I don't recall saying that. My post was very summary and certainly was not watered down so I'm not surprised some people were offended. But why is it that when protestants bash the Catholic Faith it's not a big deal but if someone criticizes protestantism they are all of a sudden being a derogatory jerk? There seems to be a double-standard. Maybe we are just so used to being put on the defensive around here we just expect the Faith the be attacked. Anyway, while I certainly think protestant people do a great amount of good in society, I also believe that many ideologies and social phenomenon can clearly be shown to have roots in the protestant tradition. There is a big difference between criticizing a tradition of ideas and criticizing individuals on a personal level. And I certainly was not doing the latter. and what do you mean by have charity? I think I was being charitable, perhaps I was too blunt though. Edited March 14, 2004 by Laudate_Dominum
homeschoolmom Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 I certainly don't mean to get into an arguement... Let me clarify myself and if you can see where I (and many others here) am coming from, you can see why your post was somewhat upsetting. I'm a convert-- a recent decision by my husband and me. We are now constantly having to defend the Catholic faith against anti-Catholics and so I realize that there is a great deal of misunderstanding on the faith. Protestants also must watch what they say... I know full well, there are many uncharitable Protestants. It seems to me that this thread has turned into a debate and belongs on the debate table. Reading this: A well known convert from protestantism captures it well: Individualism and divisiveness, the dichotomous nature of protestant thought, protestantism as the root cause of secularization, the liberalizing tendency of protestantism, pragmatism, theological relativism, ecclesiological anarchism, the privatization of religion, accommodation to the spirit of the age and moral fadism, etc.... before heading off to Mass this morning made me want to not go. I did go in spite of this. But those of us who are in between, who don't feel welcome at either church (being sent out of Mass every week is a little bit discouraging... ) just cringe at these kinds of posts. Obviously, you don't know what I mean. You've probably never been in this situation. As for your well known convert person above.... I'm pretty sure I know who he is... I know that he could be so much more effective at teaching people about the Catholic faith if he didn't come off so smug. Understand that when you are asking sincere devout Protestants to leave their churches and become Catholic, it's like peeling off a huge scab (ew, gross)... just please be careful not to pour a bunch of salt in the wound... thank you. done rambling now...
BLAZEr Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 Laudate and Theo (tokos, not logian in training) I just want to help you guys realize something because both of you are relatively new. Both Mulls and Bro Adam have been on the board a long time. Most of us here at Phatmass have seen both their good intentions, and their honesty and charity in these discussions. Neither are Catholic, but I know that both are sincere and very respectful of the Church. I also think that more often than not, a patient and respectful approach to the explaining Catholic teachings and devotions is more effective than the "bazooka blaster" approach. Oh, and no amount of CAPS will make something more evident.
mulls Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 i appreciate that blazer and for the record i did make the disclaimer that i didnt want to offend anyone by posting in this thread....that's why i offered bro adam to continue this privately. not trying to start a war here, but i'm also not going to concede anything that i don't agree with. besides, this thread should be about bro. adam and what he is dealing with right now. we all want whats best for him, as God sees fit.
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 I must admit, I was acting in haste and carelessly fell into what BLAZEr called the "bazooka blaster" approach. I still think there is a double-standard here because I am constantly reading posts criticizing Catholicism that are often worse than what I typed and generally they are engaged and discussed. Whereas my post has simply been blown off and sneered at. Perhaps I should state my intent with the controversial post(s). When it comes to discussing the communion of Saints and devotion to Mary with protestants I find that verse slanging and things tend to go nowhere. It seemed appropriate to discuss the deeper issues. I believe that the deeper reasons for this stumbling block for protestants has to do with the philosophical roots of protestantism. As a sociological and historical phenomenon protestantism is a "protest" or revolt against Catholicism. This is not a derrogatory statement by any means. It is simply what the history books record. Also pointing out that the philosophical roots of protestantism tend to dichotomize reality is not derrogatory but only an observation. I am speaking of protestantism in a general and abstract way. Certainly I have known protestants who pray the Rosary and have devotion to Our Lady. This can be said of many of the early protestants and of some of the reformers themselves. But as a system of thought there are clear trends and dynamics which are at times the opposite of those present in Catholic thought. It seems important to discuss the underlying reasons for this because many protestants seem unable to see devotion to Mary as anything other than competition with God. There are fundamental psychological and categorical differences which are a barrier for communication that need to be addressed. A critical examination of protestantisms foundations would be a part of identifying the factors involved. This was more or less my main motivation in writing the post. Anyway, my intentions were good and frankly I don't see my post as being way out of line considering what I read and respond to on these forums on a regular basis. If I could go back in time I would revise my post in certain ways to make it less of a bazooka blast, but I believe the things I wrote and think it's an interesting subject for discussion.
the_rev Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 Right now I'm reading "True devotion to Mary" It talks about all our devotions to Mary, and descibes mroe what the church teaches.
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 [quote name='mulls' date='Mar 14 2004, 05:25 PM']i appreciate that blazer and for the record i did make the disclaimer that i didnt want to offend anyone by posting in this thread....that's why i offered bro adam to continue this privately. not trying to start a war here, but i'm also not going to concede anything that i don't agree with. besides, this thread should be about bro. adam and what he is dealing with right now. we all want whats best for him, as God sees fit.[/quote] cool. sorry mulls, I guess I got carried away. I'll keep in mind that you aren't looking for a war. I guess I missed that part. peace.
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 14, 2004 Posted March 14, 2004 Brother Adam, Here is my central point without all the supporting content which ruffled people's feathers: The essence of historical Christianity is not inherently opposed to the communion of Saints and of devotion to Mary, but on the contrary understands it naturally. The question to ask is why does protestantism tend to oppose these things? Why does the protestant conception of reality see God and Mary, or God and the Saints, as necessarily in competition? It would bother me if I thought that all the great Saints and so many great Fathers of the Church, men from whom we've inhereted the doctrine of the Trinity, men who stamped out the great heresies, were all commiting a terrible sin by loving Mary so much and praying to her. Even Martin Luther had devotion to Mary. When did Christians reject devotion to Mary? What were the discernable causes of this transition within certain branches of Christianity? I'm not trying to start a debate, I'm just proposing questions which may help in discerning your way through these matters.
willguy Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 Something rather off-topic but also rather fitting- One thing that strikes me about this board (Phatmass) is the love that exists among people that disagree. In other Christian boards that I have been at, the discussioin may start calm, but it usually escalates. Usually, no one steps in, and it just turns into one big bash-fest. Here, it seems that people are much more willing to admit when they're wrong and come back down. Just my $.02 We now return you to your regularly scheduled topic...
Brother Adam Posted March 15, 2004 Author Posted March 15, 2004 Thank you L_D. And thank you Mulls. And everyone else. You've given me what I need. I just need time now to sort it out on my own.
mom25angels Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 Hello, Brother. I had read your post earlier and while reading a Lenten devotional from the Contemplative Sisters of the Community of St.John I came across this quote that made me think of you When conquered, temptation affords an opportunity for holiness to increase. Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen God Bless You and His Mother, too. Sarah
Good Friday Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 Bro. Adam, remember that those who are dead to us may be alive in Christ, and that this certainly must be the case with Mary. Thus, you are not conjuring the dead, but speaking to someone who is very much alive -- asking her to pray for you, and nothing more, the same way you might ask your pastor to pray for you. Except that this is not your pastor, this is the woman who, 2,000 years ago, said "yes" to God on behalf of all humanity -- she said yes, cancelling the "no" that Eve spoke. Later, Christ would say "yes" to the Father, cancelling Adam's "no" and freeing us from Original Sin. I know you've heard this all before. I know you also know that the Letter of St. James says that the prayers of a righteous person are very efficacious (I'm paraphrasing). I fail to see how asking for the prayers of inarguably the most righteous human being -- besides Christ, of course, who was fully God and fully man -- could be sinful, if asking your pastor for prayers is [i]not[/i] sinful. I have always failed to understand it, even as a Protestant. I've never been able to understand what's so wrong with asking Mary, or the other saints, to pray for us when one can walk right up to one's pastor and ask him for prayers. I don't see the difference, except that those who are in Heaven are already perfected and thus much more righteous than anyone's pastor. All I know is that I would be a neo-pagan today if it were not for the prayers of Our Lady and St. Mary Magdalene. Ultimately, it was God who answered and dragged me, kicking and screaming, out of neo-paganism. But they were praying for me, they were the ones who said, "Hey God, help him," when I wouldn't even ask for help -- just like one's earthly mother might pray for a person his entire life, and that person may be converted later on (as was the case with St. Augustine and St. Monica). But I can say with certainty that I would still be bowing down and worshipping pagan gods if it were not for the prayers of the Blessed Virgin and St. Mary Magdalene. That's just personal experience, and not any kind of proof, but I thought it may help you.
mulls Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 (edited) [quote name='Theologian in Training' date='Mar 14 2004, 10:20 PM'] Actually, I only posted once, and I don't believe what I said to be derogatory or condescending. I was merely pointing out how mulls seems to be approaching the idea of the Rosary with a preset bias that it is wrong to pray the Rosary, rather than what he calls "balance." I am not condemning him, nor am I trying to be condescending. I was merely pointing out what I believe his direction to be. Catholics also approach their belief in the Rosary with a preset bias as well, insofar as most find no difficulty in praying the Rosary. Therefore, in that sense, neither one of us can be completely "balanced" in our representation of the Rosary. Again, just my .02 God Bless [/quote] he was speaking to theotekos, i think, not sure. and what do you mean by preset bias? the fact that i don't agree with this stuff and everyone else on this thread does is balance. Edited March 15, 2004 by mulls
Laudate_Dominum Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 (edited) [quote name='mulls' date='Mar 14 2004, 09:34 PM'] the fact that i don't agree with this stuff and everyone else on this thread does is balance. [/quote] I've been thinking about everything and I just wanted to tell you that I truly appreciate your feedback and the fact that you are willing to speak up for what you believe despite the fact that it may be the underdog view on these boards. I really do apologize to you (and the others who may have been upset by my posts) if my rashness and lack of sensitivity have caused offense or bitterness. Peace of Christ. Edited March 15, 2004 by Laudate_Dominum
mulls Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 amen L.D. thanks for your appreciation, trust me you haven't offended me in the least bit. if i didn't expect people to disagree with what i said than i would have no reason for being here.
Theologian in Training Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 [quote name='mulls' date='Mar 14 2004, 09:34 PM'] he was speaking to theotekos, i think, not sure. and what do you mean by preset bias? the fact that i don't agree with this stuff and everyone else on this thread does is balance. [/quote] Alright, confusion settled. I deleted the post as I thought he was talking about me.
Ash Wednesday Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 I'm not joining in on the debate hubbub here. I just wanted to say Brother Adam I think your story is really awesome. I pray to God -- Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. But I always also ask my friends to pray for me. On earth and in heaven. Coz in heaven they aren't inactive and dead. They're more alive than we are! The mysteries of the rosary that we meditate on also in fact come from the bible, too. I'm a cradle Catholic but lemme tellya the rosary really makes things happen. Like the planets moving. It's amazing. Anyway I pray that God grant you peace and guidance on your spiritual journey.
marielapin Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 Bro. Adam, that's an awesome story. I know two people personally who used the Rosary, among other things, to help combat and defeat grave sins against purity. Jesus and Mary are amazing examples when it comes to purity. I used to put a picture of the Divine Mercy next to my bed and next to my computer when I was in school. I also kept a blessed Rosary with me at all times and had another one under my pillow. When certain temptations started to present themselves, all I would have to do was look at Jesus in the image of Divine Mercy and/or pull out my Rosary and start praying, and I would avoid that occasion to sin.
the lumberjack Posted March 15, 2004 Posted March 15, 2004 here's my two cents...which I hope don't get tossed back...hehehe when John fell before the angel that was his guide in Revelation, he was going to worship the angel for what he (John) has seen... what did the angel say? 10 And I fell at his feet to worship him. And he said unto me, See thou do it not: I am thy fellowservant, and of thy brethren that have the testimony of Jesus: worship God: for the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy. so not even the angels themselves could take worship...even it if were meant for God? hmmm....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now