Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Doubt: Hoffman And Streep Movie


Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm sorry, I see no good reason to see this movie. It seems like the typical "controversial so it must be good" fanfare that comes around every year during Oscar season. You take the possibility of a sexually abusive priest, mix in an angry nun, and add a gay grade school kid and you've got yourself a hit. I'm sure the acting is stellar, but it's just not my cup of tea.

Posted

[quote name='YMNolan' post='1743323' date='Jan 5 2009, 12:31 PM']I'm sorry, I see no good reason to see this movie. It seems like the typical "controversial so it must be good" fanfare that comes around every year during Oscar season. You take the possibility of a sexually abusive priest, mix in an angry nun, and add a gay grade school kid and you've got yourself a hit. I'm sure the acting is stellar, but it's just not my cup of tea.[/quote]

Um....I think you are mistaking this movie for something else. There is no "gay grade school kid," nor is the nun particularly angry. She feels that she is right and that her interests are what is best for the young boy and the school as a whole. It's not controversial at all. You should see it. The abuse stuff is handled with a lot of class and doesn't make you feel uneasy at all. Again, I didn't even want to see it, but a priest friend of mine told me I should.

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1743360' date='Jan 5 2009, 01:42 PM']It's not controversial at all. You should see it. The abuse stuff is handled with a lot of class and doesn't make you feel uneasy at all.[/quote]

Agreed. I thought the film carried a good message on how "absolutism" has no place in our relationships with one another. There are few things that we can know for certain. Even these people who devoted their lives to the service of God and the Church (things those of us here at phat mass believe in with certainty) have no magical insight to the complexities of the motivations of others. So "doubt" will always have a place in our lives.

she_who_is_not
Posted (edited)

I saw the movie this weekend. I found it thought provoking and a good reminder that religious are human and struggle in their relationships with one another and God.

Edited by she_who_is_not
  • 2 months later...
Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1743360' date='Jan 5 2009, 01:42 PM']Um....I think you are mistaking this movie for something else. There is no "gay grade school kid,"[/quote]
You must have missed that scene. :blink:


I just saw it, finally.
I thought the acting was spectacular.
The subject matter/underlying message? Meh.

I noticed that they really didn't seem to know much about the Church (everyone kept referring to the "sermon", which didn't have anything to do with any conceivable gospel reading, the fact that the priest kept wandering out from behind the ambo during his homily, etc), and I actually found myself on the side of Streep's character (especially since the priest kept pushing for a "changing" Church).

All in all....hmm, 3 1/2 stars.

Posted

What's "Catholic basing"?

DemonSlayer
Posted

Basing stuff on Catholics or Catholicism?

Posted

I'll pass. It may not be Catholic bashing but it's pushing the whole progressive Catholic thing.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Isn't the Nun who is certain without proof, simply a metaphor for the Church? I think the Author is trying to say the Church should not be so certain. That's the way I saw it.

Brother Adam
Posted

I agree with the blu-ray reviewer on another website who said what makes the movie great is it leaves you completely uncertain in the end - there is no closure or answer. I've added it to my netflix queue

Saint Therese
Posted

I'm going to add it to mine as well. I want to make up my own mind.

  • 2 weeks later...
Saint Therese
Posted

I watched this movie yesterday. As far as the film itself goes it was only mediocre. I found the story line a little too ambiguous and unbelievable. There were numerous things about the life of the sisters which made it obvious that the creators of the film did only the most cursory research at best. You'd think they'd do more reasearch about the lives of religious since that was the subject of the film. The director in his commentary mentions several times how the sisters have "vow of silence" and other such nonsensicals. I didn't find it to be a direct attack on the Church. I think it was more a statement of pre-Vatican II Church was stupid and bad and the Church needs to be more liberal. Also there was a lot of feminist undertones. If you watch the short feature on the Sisters of Charity you'll see how it all ties in to their philosophy. What I found amusing was that the director obviously thought himself to be the greatest authority on Catholicism. Obviously he is not such a great authority.

  • 2 weeks later...
Brother Adam
Posted

I saw it tonight. I was impressed with the acting (Streep is an amazing actress, it took me half the movie to figure out the lead nun was her), overall good cinema. I believe that the movie can be used to have an enlightening discussion about the priestly sex abuse scandal and how many good priests have been slandered and their reputations destroyed on the unfounded suspicion of others. That's what made for a great ending - did he abuse the child? We simply don't know. The possibility is there, but since it is unfounded it is a grave sin to assume he did.

Other than that, while I agreed with the nun most of the time, it is clear the producers wanted to portray habited, strict orders as sinister and progressive liberals as saintly. The extras with the Sisters of Charity is simply depressing - and they wonder why liberal convents are empty. Even though they didn't mean it, in their "Second Vatican Council is so great because it meant change, change, change" they recognized their own failure in their 'liberalizing", in that they no longer experience the life of a religious order.

It's not a movie worth buying for me, but it was worth watching. 3 stars.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...