Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[color="#000080"]I have asked so many this question and never have I gotten an answer that
would explain it to this exCatholic -now athiest/agnostic friend. Remembering, one can't quote the Bible to an atheist -it means very little. This is a question about the [i]Mind[/i] of God Almighty...what pleases Him, what appeases Him, you understand. No need wasting time with Bible quotes here. He needs logic for his mind to grasp a [i]reason.[/i] (He's a father himself and does not get it -and an animal lover.)

He wants to know 1.why does God want a blood sactifice at all? (Anyway)
Or

2.What kind of God/Father would want the shedding of blood from a goat or a Son?

or Another way he's asked - 3.If you are the Creator of life -why would a creator want you to kill an animal to "make Him happy" or to forgive you of something? It doesn't make sense to me.

My only response is -I'll ask others --and also, it's just the way He set it up -it's the "only game there is". I ask no questions. Which does not satisfy his mind obviously. ( He is not hostile.)

But this is a major point why my friend can't believe -he thinks it's stupid that a Father would want to have others kill anything in atonement.

Please, any links or insights? Also, what do they do with the animal -if they eat it -then is it a sacrifice at all? Now, if there is a direct verse ---My friend would STILL ask-- but why? Why does killing a sweet little animal appease Him?

You can see that I am confused and could use some help.

My friend is turned off with the dying (correct spelling) of animals and Jesus, His Son.

Thank you all so much,
Jon[/color]

Edited by Jon
Posted (edited)

A lot of what God does, He does to help us understand. Let's face it, God already gets it. He stoops down to our level to make it simpler for us.

God demanded sacrifices of animals because animals were extremely important to the life of the Israelites. Killing an animal on which their very life depended was a gesture of respect to God as creator and of trust in Him as provider.

There were different sorts of animal sacrifice practiced ... burnt offerings were the most common kind, and they were completely destroyed by fire, no part eaten ... sin offering and guilt offerings were partially destroyed by fire, the rest eaten by the priests ... there are other kinds, I believe.

Keep in mind that livestock were not kept just to be eaten, but for the value they offered over time ... offering an animal meant sacrificing all its future value, a "loss" even if some of it was eaten ...

Think about all that blood represents, just on a basic human level .. life, what is essential, etc. .... now think about all the times blood appears in the Old Testament ... sprinkling blood in the temple, blood over the doors at the Exodus, etc. ... Think about the Precious Blood. God could have decided to communicate His substance in hand lotion we rub on ... He chose to come as Blood because of what it represents to us as "flesh and blood" human beings.

God dramatizes spiritual truths for us in material ways, so that we'll understand. Spilling blood is a pretty dramatic representation of sacrifice. He doesn't need blood sacrifices ... ( one of the psalms has Him asking, rhetorically, "Do I eat the meat of bulls or drink the blood of goats?") He set up the system that way so that human beings could better understand.

Edited by Lilllabettt
Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

Well, I don't know as much about the sacrificing of animals, but I'll try explaining what I know about why Jesus had to die to atone us for our sins.

God is the Father and Creator of all, and as such He loves all of us and wants what is best for all of us. Now, when Adam and Eve sinned and man fell from grace, it was an infinate action, in that it affected not only Adam and Eve, but all of humanity from then on. The Fall, as an infinate action, had need for another infinate action to counter it, and this infinate action needed to come from a human, since it was a human who made humanity fall. However, humans are fallen in nature and so could not save themselves because they would not be able to go completely to God on their own. Therefore it was necessary that God come and save humanity, but salvation still needed to come from mankind, hence Christ became a human so as to save humanity.

Now we can get to why sacrifice is necessary. God is both fully just and fully merciful. As such, an infinate action which goes against God, the Fall, needed an infinate action in reparation for it, the Passion and Death of Christ. It seems to me that your friend has a problem with God's Justice, but it is a show of God's Mercy that He allowed His Son to come and die for the salvation of mankind. The question of why God would allow His Son to die then comes to the fact that God views all of us as His children and wants all of us to be with Him in heaven, since that is the greatest good for us as humans. The only way that this would be able to happen is by the sacrifice of an infinate, perfect human being, and since no human is perfect since the Fall, the human also needed to be God. This is why God had to become man in order to save humanity, so that humanity would be able to spend eternity with God in heaven.

I hope this makes sense. I wrote this in bits and pieces with some distractions in between, so if it doesn't make sense or is broken up, I'm sorry, but I do sincerely hope that this helps.

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

Posted

The life of something is in its blood, metaphorically and literally. To remove the blood is to do something that cannot be undone, thus illustrating something permenant, serious, and irrevocable.

Shedding the blood of animals - and finally Christ - illustrates the literal consequence of sin; without Christ, a single sin would mean separation from the God who is by nature all-Holy and the source of life. To be cut off from the source of life is to die in ever sense. Even the imperfection of the universe, now tainted by the sin of its inhabitants, means that until it is reborn on the Last Day, even strong theophanies (apparitions of God's glory) are seen in Scripture to rend stones and cause all sorts of upheaval in nature. When Isaiah sees a vision of God's glory, he screams out in fear, saying that he is "undone" or literally disentegrating util an angel purges him of his sin by means of a burning coal.

Back to the irrevocability of blood-shed, then; blood sacrafice both demonstrated the consequences and the solution of sin. A God who is Holiness is a God who is Justice; the wages of sin are death and the wages must be paid by the faithful. Since the death of Christ was the death of God, that wage applied infinitely and universally. Now we need only take advantage of it by means of the sacraments, the effecaciousness of which it won.

Posted (edited)

[color="#000080"]Well, it took days to get some posts back, I was concerned I'd have nothing for him next week.
Thank you all.
What I'm going to do is print these with typo corrections and see what he comes back with.
He is very smart - too smart for his own good sometimes. :) He has arguments about almost everything -never taking things at face value - a skeptic about most things - that kind of mind. Though he is the most consistently wonderful, happy person for the 20 years I've known him. Let's see what he relates to the most.

It is hard talking about God when he doesn't believe there is one. (Though went to Catholic school even.)

There were many talking points in each post but without them in front of me I'll have to pass asking some questions.

They were very thoughtful and I respect the time it took to write them. I read every word and will go back to re-read them.

I so understand the tithe. But, obviously, I myself don't totally understand the blood sacrifice - that's why I'm going to study each post again.

I hope more people post also. Different perspectives help so much.

God bless,
Jon[/color]

Edited by Jon
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Sorry all, I have seen him 2-3 xs and he said he would write something out - but he's a busy guy. Obviously nothing moved him enough to pursue it more. In other words, he was not impressed with anything that was said enough to even ask questions.
Oh well. We all can only try.

Thanks Jon ---maybe something later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...