Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

What exactly constitutes a "personal attack"?

Posted

+J.M.J.+
from the guidelines (posted and pinned at the top of every phorum ;) )
[quote]Personal Attacks
A post or comment that has nothing to do with the topic, but is specifically meant to upset or criticize another person or group of people. This includes, but is not limited to, calling people "heretics" (used in a derogatory manner), "democrooks", etc.

"Never reprimand anyone while you feel provoked over a fault that has been committed. Wait until the next day, or even longer. Then make your remonstrance calmly and with a purified intention. You'll gain more with an affectionate word than you ever would from three hours of quarreling. Control your temper." - St Josemaria Escriva[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1729050' date='Dec 15 2008, 11:41 PM']+J.M.J.+
from the guidelines (posted and pinned at the top of every phorum ;) )[/quote]

Thank you. What about commenting on someone's comments, claiming an idea they promote or express? I suppose that's where I am not clear.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1729066' date='Dec 15 2008, 11:44 PM']Thank you. What about commenting on someone's comments, claiming an idea they promote or express? I suppose that's where I am not clear.[/quote]


What don't you understand about this part, Hassan?

[b]This includes, but is not limited to, calling people "heretics" (used in a derogatory manner), "democrooks", etc.[/b]

Calling me a bigot (repeatedly--granted, in the past) and referring to my comments as "vulgar and supremist" (about 15 minutes ago), see...that falls into the category described above.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
depends on how you are commenting on them. critically taking apart someone's argument is different from attacking them as a person.

i.e.: your argument fails because of x,y, and z.

vs.

your argument fails because you stink as a person (you are stupid, etc.)

btw, if you have a question about your warnings, i do suggest you take that up with dUSt at phatmass@gmail.com. God bless you :)

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1729121' date='Dec 15 2008, 11:56 PM']What don't you understand about this part, Hassan?

[b]This includes, but is not limited to, calling people "heretics" (used in a derogatory manner), "democrooks", etc.[/b]

Calling me a bigot (repeatedly--granted, in the past) and referring to my comments as "vulgar and supremist" (about 15 minutes ago), see...that falls into the category described above.[/quote]

The comments say "calling people...."

There is a difference between saying X is a bigot, and saying X's comments are bigoted, that is they espouse or pormote bigotry.

Now I have insulted you personally in the past. I've admitted that and asked your forgiveness for them and have tried, albeit without success, to do better. That having been said I think my distinction is valid. Although I will curb the latter reguardless.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1729126' date='Dec 15 2008, 11:58 PM']+J.M.J.+
depends on how you are commenting on them. critically taking apart someone's argument is different from attacking them as a person.

i.e.: your argument fails because of x,y, and z.

vs.

your argument fails because you stink as a person (you are stupid, etc.)

btw, if you have a question about your warnings, i do suggest you take that up with dUSt at phatmass@gmail.com. God bless you :)[/quote]

I have no dispute with any of my warnings. They have all been earned.

but thank you. I would appreciate it if you could clarify below, my response to Madam V. That is where my confusion lies.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[quote name='Hassan' post='1729148' date='Dec 15 2008, 09:05 PM']alright, thanks[/quote]
re-opened because i just saw the below.

[quote name='Hassan' post='1729147' date='Dec 15 2008, 09:05 PM']I have no dispute with any of my warnings. They have all been earned.

but thank you. I would appreciate it if you could clarify below, my response to Madam V. That is where my confusion lies.[/quote]
there is a difference between criticizing someone's comments and criticizing the person. it is a fine line, to be sure. [u]but for the most part[/u], criticizing someone's comments is not [u]usually[/u] considered a personal attack because you are criticizing someone's comments and not them personally. again, it goes back to arguing that someone's post fails because of 1, 2, and 3 reasons versus arguing that someone's post fails because they themselves are stupid, inconsiderate, rude, bigoted (y'alls word, not mine), heretics, etc.

i guess what i'm saying is if you have a problem with someone's post, attack their post, not their character.
does this clarify?

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1729162' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:10 AM']+J.M.J.+

re-opened because i just saw the below.


there is a difference between criticizing someone's comments and criticizing the person. it is a fine line, to be sure. [u]but for the most part[/u], criticizing someone's comments is not [u]usually[/u] considered a personal attack because you are criticizing someone's comments and not them personally. again, it goes back to arguing that someone's post fails because of 1, 2, and 3 reasons versus arguing that someone's post fails because they themselves are stupid, inconsiderate, rude, bigoted (y'alls word, not mine), heretics, etc.

i guess what i'm saying is if you have a problem with someone's post, attack their post, not their character.
does this clarify?[/quote]

Right, but it's one thing to say refer to someone's comments as "ridiculous" (not an attack), but it's another thing totally to refer to someone's comments as "hateful", "bigoted", "vulgar" and "supremist". This is the issue.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1729179' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:16 AM']Right, but it's one thing to say refer to someone's comments as "ridiculous" (not an attack), but it's another thing totally to refer to someone's comments as "hateful", "bigoted", "vulgar" and "supremist". This is the issue.[/quote]

why do you feel that "rediculous" is not an attack but "bigoted" is with reguard to the nature of the comments?


Is it just intuitive or is there a hard distinction?

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1729162' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:10 AM']+J.M.J.+

re-opened because i just saw the below.


there is a difference between criticizing someone's comments and criticizing the person. it is a fine line, to be sure. [u]but for the most part[/u], criticizing someone's comments is not [u]usually[/u] considered a personal attack because you are criticizing someone's comments and not them personally. again, it goes back to arguing that someone's post fails because of 1, 2, and 3 reasons versus arguing that someone's post fails because they themselves are stupid, inconsiderate, rude, bigoted (y'alls word, not mine), heretics, etc.

i guess what i'm saying is if you have a problem with someone's post, attack their post, not their character.
does this clarify?[/quote]

Sure, more or less: )

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1729179' date='Dec 15 2008, 09:16 PM']Right, but it's one thing to say refer to someone's comments as "ridiculous" (not an attack), but it's another thing totally to refer to someone's comments as "hateful", "bigoted", "vulgar" and "supremist". This is the issue.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
:idontknow: i don't know what you guys want me to say. i said it's a fine line, and it is. any reports dealing with personal attacks are taken on a case by case basis by the mods. (well, every report is, actually.) if you think something is a personal attack, report it. we mods may not agree, or we may agree.

i would say in [u]my personal opinion[/u] (not as a mod, nor speaking for all the mods, nor speaking for dUSt): to call someone's comments hateful/bigoted/what-have-you doesn't necessarily make them a personal attack. it [u]could be[/u] (not saying is) if you just quoted someone and said "your comments are hateful" without dismantling their comments on [u]why[/u] they are hateful (because of x,y, and z reasons), but not necessarily.

but to turn around and call that poster hateful/bigoted/whatever would be for sure a personal attack.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1729200' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:26 AM']+J.M.J.+
:idontknow: i don't know what you guys want me to say. i said it's a fine line, and it is. any reports dealing with personal attacks are taken on a case by case basis by the mods. (well, every report is, actually.) if you think something is a personal attack, report it. we mods may not agree, or we may agree.

i would say in [u]my personal opinion[/u] (not as a mod, nor speaking for all the mods, nor speaking for dUSt): to call someone's comments hateful/bigoted/what-have-you doesn't necessarily make them a personal attack. it [u]could be[/u] (not saying is) if you just quoted someone and said "your comments are hateful" without dismantling their comments on [u]why[/u] they are hateful (because of x,y, and z reasons), but not necessarily.

but to turn around and call that poster hateful/bigoted/whatever would be for sure a personal attack.[/quote]

Sure, I will just be carefull. I ought to be nicer anyway.

Thank you for helping to sort this out.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1729202' date='Dec 15 2008, 09:27 PM']Sure, I will just be carefull. I ought to be nicer anyway.

Thank you for helping to sort this out.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
i try sometimes. but you made my head hurt from thinking and now owe me some phunny kitty pictures in the lame board. pay up. :hehe:

Posted

Yeah yeah yeah, blah blah blah...

It comes down to a very basic concept. Just be nice.

Mean = warning.
Nice = road to utter phatmass domination and supremacy.


I encourage the mods to not get caught up in technicalities and details. It really does just come down to common sense.

If person (A) has taken an uncharitable tone and is consistently mean in a thread, but "technically" hasn't broken a rule--and person (B) has been nice the entire thread, and then slips up for one post and "technically" breaks a rule... I will let person (B) off with no warning and [b]make up[/b] a reason to warn person (A).

Common sense. That's how we roll.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1729255' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:48 AM']Common sense. That's how we roll.[/quote]


[img]http://lukeaune.com/other/sighcycle.jpg[/img]


:detective:

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1729255' date='Dec 15 2008, 11:48 PM']Yeah yeah yeah, blah blah blah...

It comes down to a very basic concept. Just be nice.

Mean = warning.
Nice = road to utter phatmass domination and supremacy.


I encourage the mods to not get caught up in technicalities and details. It really does just come down to common sense.

If person (A) has taken an uncharitable tone and is consistently mean in a thread, but "technically" hasn't broken a rule--and person (B) has been nice the entire thread, and then slips up for one post and "technically" breaks a rule... I will let person (B) off with no warning and [b]make up[/b] a reason to warn person (A).

Common sense. That's how we roll.[/quote]


No wonder phatmass is always the happening place to be :think:

Posted

only because this is the only place where you are a queen. :rolling:

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1729189' date='Dec 16 2008, 12:20 AM']why do you feel that "rediculous" is not an attack but "bigoted" is with reguard to the nature of the comments?


Is it just intuitive or is there a hard distinction?[/quote]


If you don't see where words like "bigoted", "hateful", and "supremist" are words which attack a person's character, whereas "ridiculous" is just a negative criticism, then I can't help you understand any of this further, Hassan.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...