Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Lesbians And Gays Get Pregnant!


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1730359' date='Dec 17 2008, 01:33 PM']Some of it could stem from kids feeling so different, and unloved, wanting to have something to love.

I always dislike it when a problem that can be traced to personal responsibility is blamed on society or some distinct part of society.[/quote]

I'm not sure they were though. I mean I agree that these kids are ultimatly responsible for their actions, but the external contributing factos shouldn't be ignored should they?

Posted

Homosexuals have been playing the victim card for decades. It is difficult to see how the pro-gays wouldn't use this in favor of their 'cause'.

I will admit the possibility that some teenagers force themselves into sexual relationships to deny to themselves and otehrs their orientation. (any idea on an expalnation on the bisexual ones? I mean, all they really have to do is be quiet about it no?)


Who said the kids were the ones to defend against? I would more readily blame the media for their bias because they should know better, than a bunch of confused kids who are trying to figure themselves out.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1730375' date='Dec 17 2008, 10:55 AM']Who said the kids were the ones to defend against? I would more readily blame the media for their bias because they should know better, than a bunch of confused kids who are trying to figure themselves out.[/quote]


agreed!

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1730375' date='Dec 17 2008, 01:55 PM']Homosexuals have been playing the victim card for decades. It is difficult to see how the pro-gays wouldn't use this in favor of their 'cause'.[/quote]


And in many instances it is warrented as they are the victims of peer torment and social ostracization. The Church says that homosexuals are to be treated with dignity and respect, this study shows the adverse happinings when this Church teaching is not followed by everyone, reguardless of their religion, so why is this a problem for you?

[quote]I will admit the possibility that some teenagers force themselves into sexual relationships to deny to themselves and otehrs their orientation. (any idea on an expalnation on the bisexual ones? I mean, all they really have to do is be quiet about it no?)[/quote]

Confused, they don't want anyone to think they are a "homo" in any capacity


[quote]Who said the kids were the ones to defend against? I would more readily blame the media for their bias because they should know better, than a bunch of confused kids who are trying to figure themselves out.[/quote]

hm?

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1730378' date='Dec 17 2008, 01:57 PM']agreed![/quote]


:bigshock:

Is that really possible?

:lol:

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1730390' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:07 PM']And in many instances it is warrented as they are the victims of peer torment and social ostracization. The Church says that homosexuals are to be treated with dignity and respect, this study shows the adverse happinings when this Church teaching is not followed by everyone, reguardless of their religion, so why is this a problem for you?


[snip][/quote]

I see your popint.

Have you consider, as mentionned in one of my former posts, that these teenagers are simply saying they are homosexual so they have an excuse for being pregnant? Can teenagers be trusted with telling the truth on an opinion poll?

Back in my highschool days, it was cool for teenage girls to be pregnant and just 'cause that was the 'in' thing, over 10% of 9th graders were pregnant this one year. A nursery had to open at the high school for crying out loud.

Maybe being gay and the victim is the cool thing this time of year? From what I see, it is far more difficult and ostricizing to be faithful to the Catholic Church than being gay.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1730398' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:12 PM']I see your popint.

Have you consider, as mentionned in one of my former posts, that these teenagers are simply saying they are homosexual so they have an excuse for being pregnant? Can teenagers be trusted with telling the truth on an opinion poll?[/quote]

"yes mom, I'm pregnant, but don't worry I'm also gay!"

I don't see how that helps things.

[quote]Back in my highschool days, it was cool for teenage girls to be pregnant and just 'cause that was the 'in' thing, over 10% of 9th graders were pregnant this one year. A nursery had to open at the high school for crying out loud.

Maybe being gay and the victim is the cool thing this time of year? From what I see, it is far more difficult and ostricizing to be faithful to the Catholic Church than being gay.[/quote]

it was a study of quite some years, and it's not a "fad". Kids should not be bothered if they want to be Catholics, but I carried my rosary with me everywhere and never had the slightest problem in igh School, save a few ignorant bigots (it was the South after all), I can't say the same for gay kids.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1730403' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:17 PM']"yes mom, I'm pregnant, but don't worry I'm also gay!"

I don't see how that helps things.[/quote]

Who said kids are logical or they make helpful or good choices? And by the way, getting to their parents is often precisely what a teenager wants to do and thus the above DOES sometimes help.



[quote name='Hassan' post='1730403' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:17 PM']it was a study of quite some years, and it's not a "fad". Kids should not be bothered if they want to be Catholics, but I carried my rosary with me everywhere and never had the slightest problem in igh School, save a few ignorant bigots (it was the South after all), I can't say the same for gay kids.[/quote]

Back in my day, and I suspect the same today, gays were more 'protected' than faithful christians. It was Canada after all - same as the article.

Posted

We need to change the laws so that homosexuals can get pregnant by their homosexual partner.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1730410' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:22 PM']We need to change the laws so that homosexuals can get pregnant by their homosexual partner.[/quote]

Anything less is discrimination.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1730407' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:20 PM']Who said kids are logical or they make helpful or good choices? And by the way, getting to their parents is often precisely what a teenager wants to do and thus the above DOES sometimes help.[/quote]


I just don't see any validity to your reasoing. It's pure speculation that, by it's own admission is illogical, and has no scientific basis.





[quote]Back in my day, and I suspect the same today, gays were more 'protected' than faithful christians. It was Canada after all - same as the article.[/quote]

I don't see how. A majority of the population is Christian. That having been said no child, incluing Christians, should be tormented in school.

Posted

the distaste between homosexuals and christians is very mutual let me assure you."

Who made you spokesman for Christianity. I have a distaste for homosexual acts, not homosexual persons.

Posted

no one made me your spokesperson. i speak that in general the two groups dont much like each other. in your particular case, you despise their homosexual acts ie)gay sex, and what not, and they despise your christian acts ie)telling them not to.

are you seriously going to say that christianity(by this i really mean, christians, not scripture) as a whole, is not generally opposed to gays, and in many cases becomes an irrational act of hating the sinner and not the sin? no offense, but that is a bit like saying that your ancestors never owned slaves, therefore america had no connection to the slave trade and racism isnt prevalent in certain places.

i agree that not all christians dislike gay people.

back to the topic at hand, you certainly dont have to be christian to dislike homosexuals, that seems an almost universal thing with religion, and many atheists would share your sentiments.

[quote name='Didacus' post='1730392' date='Dec 17 2008, 11:08 AM']:bigshock:

Is that really possible?

:lol:[/quote]
it does happen occasionally! i am far from unreasonable ;)

Posted

Kids getting ostracized in high school isn't anything new. My husband was hounded mercilessly. He isn't/wasn't gay, he just had a mom with schizophrenia. He didn't run around impregnating girls, partially because none of the girls he went to school with were willing to get near him. If you'd met his mom, you'd understand. She is actually legally barred from entering any of the 3 Catholic churches in their small college town.

The issue here isn't discrimination against one group, it is bullying in general.

Posted

CatherineM,

You are a voice of reason. Some of the comments on this thread seem unnecessarily cruel. What about the children? I feel sorry for them if they have to face some of you because they didn't ask to be judged or have their parents judged. I have a friend who has gay dads and she is a great person, fully Catholic and she had a great upbringing. Her Dads adopted her because she was a crack baby and nobody else wanted to deal with all the medical problems she had as a kid (baby). I know, obviously, this is very different than "creating" a child. But after knowing my friend, and seeing her life, and also, knowing how much money and care she needed (not to mention all the extra help she needed as a teenager in school because of the problems the addiction caused her central nervous system) I have to say that I totally respect and love her dads. If it hadn't been for them, she would have stayed in that group home or even worse, she would have been passed around from foster home to foster home. Also, they are very kind, very "discreet" and also very good people. There is not a sin in being gay. None of us are supposed to be sexually active outside of the Sacrament of Marriage so it is possible that gay people can live together in close intimacy without the sexual part coming in. The only people who know are the people in the relationship and God. So I don't think we should jump to conclusions.

As to all those gay people who are so mean to the Catholic churches and people, I feel sorry for them, because surely they do not know what they are doing. I would be scared to be so vocal. But again, we cannot judge, just pray for them. Perhaps they are reacting out of a sense of rejection and pain. I'm not in that position, so I cannot say.

All in all, let's pray for everybody involved in this issue, it's not easy for anyone.

Katherine

dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1730371' date='Dec 17 2008, 12:49 PM']I'm not sure they were though. I mean I agree that these kids are ultimatly responsible for their actions, but the external contributing factos shouldn't be ignored should they?[/quote]
of course not. not if you want every single factor to justify doing something wrong, as society does to excuse the criminal offenses and sins time and time again...it's called relativism...what's bad for some is not bad for others because of the circumstances surrounding the event.....

some phatmassers have this mind set, also...that every offense has an excuse, and we really can't call out the right or wrong of the situation, because then we are judging, or because "we don't know what they are going through..."

the lords sheep
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1730511' date='Dec 17 2008, 09:22 PM']Kids getting ostracized in high school isn't anything new. My husband was hounded mercilessly. He isn't/wasn't gay, he just had a mom with schizophrenia.

The issue here isn't discrimination against one group, it is bullying in general.[/quote]

I had to transfer from a Catholic elementary school because I was so terribly ostracized that the students in my classes would refuse to work with me or talk with me because they were afraid of the students who were bullying me.

However, I agree that the fact that just because I was bullied doesn't give me an excuse to do anything (or not do anything). I have to say, though, that had I had a different family or not been so welcomed by the next school I went to, I could have had lots of problems and made lots of bad choices.

I feel very deeply for all those people who are so starved for love that they are seeking anywhere they can to find it. It doesn't excuse or justify their actions, but it does make me feels sorry for them...

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1730441' date='Dec 17 2008, 02:38 PM']back to the topic at hand, you certainly dont have to be christian to dislike homosexuals, that seems an almost universal thing with religion, and many atheists would share your sentiments.[/quote]

Where has anyone here said they dislike gay people? There are also many gays and lesbians choosing to live celibate lives in accordance with Church teaching and Scripture. Do they hate themselves?

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1730320' date='Dec 17 2008, 12:11 PM']Perhapse High School jerks could stop turning gay kids lives into living hells.

that would be a nice reaction.[/quote]
Note - I'm not promoting bullying of any kind. Bullying is ALWAYS wrong.

HOWEVER, homosexual students are treated absolutely differently then straight kids, in my experience at least. For instance, at the school I attend, the PDA which is allowed is hand-holding and "light" hugging. If a heterosexual couple is seen making out or even just kissing on the lips, or going overboard with the hugging, and seen by a teacher, they are quickly told to knock it off (and rightly so).
However, there's a little pod of homosexuals that congregate on the periphery of the courtyard, in plain sight of whatever teacher is stationed at that corner. The things that go on there are nothing short of disgusting, and that's not because they're gay - if I saw the straight kids do the same thing, I'd be disgusted at that too. But, for whatever reason, they're let to do it. The kicker is, the teacher does nothing. I don't know if it's out of fear for getting 'in trouble' because of persecuting the gays, or what. I just know that they do nothing.

They also seem to like to share/flaunt their persuasion. They seem to like to come up to people, especially those that they've identified as religious, and share with you the details of their relations. I mean, I'm all for choosing what kind of life you'd like to lead - if God will let you do what you want, who am I to stand in your way? - but please don't force me to experience it.

Now, I know the fallacious logic in treating anecdotal evidence as fact and whatnot, but I find it difficult to believe that my school is the only high school in the nation in which things of this nature occur.

So perhaps this sort of scenario contributes to provoking the 'living hell' they experience (though from my point of view, it seems like they have more leeway than the rest of the students). I have heard people voice their opinions on the matter, and some people disdain them because they are allowed to get away with things that others are not, seemingly because of their orientation.
:idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1730511' date='Dec 17 2008, 03:22 PM']Kids getting ostracized in high school isn't anything new. My husband was hounded mercilessly. He isn't/wasn't gay, he just had a mom with schizophrenia. He didn't run around impregnating girls, partially because none of the girls he went to school with were willing to get near him. If you'd met his mom, you'd understand. She is actually legally barred from entering any of the 3 Catholic churches in their small college town.

The issue here isn't discrimination against one group, it is bullying in general.[/quote]

All bullying is not the same and it does not prodice different reactions. Your husbands situation was not specific to his sexuality as in the case of the gay kids.

I'd point out again that the study does not clame the peers, it simply highlights a phenomena. It does not justify the way the teens cope/hide, it simply describes one way they do.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...