Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Receiving Communion On The Tongue: A Review


Recommended Posts

Roamin'Catholic
Posted

Here's two things I found recently on the reception of the body of Christ on one's tongue, and if possible, while kneeling. While the Eucharist is intended to be recieved in this manner, unfortunately several generations of Catholics now know nothing but recieving communion in their hand while standing. The Holy Father has stopped giving communion to people in their hands; hopefully his flock of bishops and priests will follow suit. These two pieces are interesting; any thoughts?:

[i]New Vatican prefect praises traditional manner of receiving Holy Communion
December 17, 2008
Cardinal Antonio Canizares Llovera, whom Pope Benedict appointed last Tuesday as prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, has praised the traditional manner of receiving Holy Communion. The comments, which were made during a telephone interview, were published Sunday in a Madrid newspaper.

During the interview, in which Cardinal Canizares Llovera is characterized as a man who combines commitment to principle with “exquisite tact and gentleness,” the prefect said, “What does it mean to receive Communion in the mouth? What does it mean to kneel before the Most Holy Sacrament? What does it mean to kneel during the consecration at Mass? It means adoration, it means recognizing the real presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist; it means respect and an attitude of faith of a man who prostrates before God because he knows that everything comes from Him, and we feel speechless, dumbfounded, before the wondrousness, His goodness, and His mercy. That is why it is not the same to place the hand, and to receive Communion in any fashion, than doing it in a respectful way; it is not the same to receive Communion kneeling or standing up, because all these signs indicate a profound meaning. What we have to grasp is that profound attitude of the man who prostrates himself before God, and that is what the Pope wants.” [/i]


Dr. Alcuin Reid has a review of Bishop Athanasius Schneider's book, Dominus Est, in this weeks edition of The Catholic Herald. Here is the text of that review:


[i]The little book that will cause a great storm
Alcuin Reid on a book endorsed by Cardinal Francis Arinze
19 December 2008


Dominus Est: It Is The Lord
By Athanasius Schneider
Gracewing £5.99

It was 1969. Paul VI was the Pope. The Congregation for Divine Worship issued an Instruction, Memoriale Domini, on the manner of receiving Holy Communion. It makes very interesting reading.

After recalling the development of the reception of Communion on the tongue as a fruit of "a deepening understanding of the truth of the Eucharistic mystery, of its power and of the presence of Christ in it", the Instruction declares that "this method of distributing Holy Communion must be retained... not merely because it has many centuries of tradition behind it, but especially because it expresses the faithful's reverence for the Eucharist.

"The custom does not detract in any way from the personal dignity of those who approach this great sacrament: it is part of that preparation that is needed for the most fruitful reception of the Body of the Lord," it said.

It also warned: "A change in a matter of such moment, based on a most ancient and venerable tradition, does not merely affect discipline. It carries certain dangers with it which may arise from the new manner of administering Holy Communion: the danger of a loss of reverence for the august sacrament of the altar, of profanation, of adulterating the true doctrine."

And it published a survey of the world's bishops, which led it to conclude: "The vast majority of bishops believe that the present discipline should not be changed, and that if it were, the change would be offensive to the sentiments and the spiritual culture of these bishops and of many of the faithful."

For this reason it reported: "The Holy Father has decided not to change the existing way of administering Holy Communion to the faithful." So, given that Communion in the hand is now practically universal and younger generations know practically nothing else, what happened?

A "loophole" existed. The Instruction contained the provision for bishops' conferences to make a decision to allow Communion in the hand in places where "contrary usage... prevails". And over the coming decade or so this loophole was exploited.

Today, the Instruction's warnings about loss of reverence for, belief in and even the profanation of the Blessed Sacrament have - sadly - been vindicated. It is time to look again at the question of Communion in the hand. This is precisely what a young bishop from Central Asia has done in Dominus Est.

Bishop Athanasius Schneider, a patristic scholar, appointed a bishop by Pope Benedict in 2006, has raised his voice in prophetic call for the western Church to recall the importance, if not the necessity, of returning to the previous discipline of the reception of Holy Communion kneeling and on the tongue.

There is, of course, no question that - as Memoriale Domini itself attests - it is "true that ancient usage once allowed the faithful to take this divine food in their hands and to place it in their mouths themselves".

This fact was much flaunted throughout the 1970s, together with talk about receiving Holy Communion as mature adults, and not as children. We were encouraged to return to the primitive purity of early Church practice as we emerged from centuries of supposedly corrupt accretion in the way we worshipped.

However, in our egalitarian excitement we ignored the sober facts that, as Bishop Schneider attests, the "organic development" of the practice of receiving Communion on the tongue is nothing other than "a fruit of the spirituality and Eucharistic devotion stemming from the times of the Fathers of the Church", and that the exclusion of kneeling for Holy Communion was a feature of the Protestant theological revolt of both Calvin and Zwingli.

Indeed, no less a scholar than Klaus Gamber points out that the reception of Communion in the hand "was in fact abandoned... from the fifth or sixth century onwards".

The Church as she proceeds through time accrues wisdom. Her Sacred Liturgy, developed in tradition, is a privileged repository of the same. All but the most partisan liturgists today recognise that many of the hasty decisions taken in respect of liturgical reform and practice in the Sixties and Seventies were infected by an antiquarianism that was at best naïve and at worst unbalanced. It is time to reconsider some if not many of those decisions and to take decisive steps to correct them where necessary. Communion in the hand is one such.

Lest we think that this young bishop - whose account of his formation in Eucharistic piety under Communist persecution in the first chapter is a spiritual treasure in itself - raises his voice alone, let us be clear that the book carries the approbation of the superiors of the Congregation for Divine Worship. Cardinal Arinze, who retired this month, states: "I have read the whole book with delight. It is excellent."

And Archbishop Malcolm Ranjith, a true prophet of the liturgical reform of Benedict XVI, writes in the preface: "I think it is time to evaluate carefully the practice of Communion in the hand and, if necessary, to abandon what was never actually called for in the Vatican II document Sacrosanctum Concilium nor by the Council Fathers but was... 'accepted' after it was introduced as an abuse in some countries."

This little book, a brief but insightful survey of the Fathers, the Early Church, the Magisterium and the Eastern and Western liturgical rites, is capable of creating a storm - not in a teacup, but in the minds of those unduly attached to the flawed external changes made to the liturgy in what can only be described as a peculiar period in the Church's history.

That it will provoke a storm is unfortunate, for the practice it advocates is a practice of love and of humility, one from which no one who truly adores Christ present in the Blessed Sacrament ought to recoil.

But perhaps today some controversy is necessary. Future generations, though, may well wonder why we took so long to realise that it is, indeed, the Lord, and once again to behave accordingly.

This is 2008. Benedict XVI is the Pope. The Holy Father has himself already reformed the manner of reception of Holy Communion at the Masses he celebrates. Let us follow his example. It accords with the teaching of Pope Paul VI.[/i]

Posted

I think receiving the Host on the tongue and not chewing is a venerable practice, but the Church has said it's ok to receive on the hand as well.

the lords sheep
Posted

Actually, if I'm not mistaken, I believe the right to receive either in the hands or on the tongue is a right guaranteed by Canon Law...
I prefer on the tongue personally, but I believe the right to choose your preference is guarded...

Posted

I have heard many people say that they don't think it is sanitary to receive it on the tongue. Don't jump on me, that's just what I have heard repeatedly. Our germaphobic society doesn't seem to want anyone's hand in their mouth. If you step back and think about it for a minute, also in our current society, most people eat out more than they eat at home now. They are okay eating a burger handled by a "hygienic" teenager, but not our Lord placed by a priest.

Posted

Is it really cleaner to receive the Host on your hand after you and the EM shook the hands of five people at the sign of peace?

Posted

[quote name='the lords sheep' post='1732015' date='Dec 19 2008, 01:39 PM']Actually, if I'm not mistaken, I believe the right to receive either in the hands or on the tongue is a right guaranteed by Canon Law...
I prefer on the tongue personally, but I believe the right to choose your preference is guarded...[/quote]


my understanding.

Posted

I wouldn't think so, but some people can be weird when it comes to their mouths.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1732069' date='Dec 19 2008, 03:14 PM']Is it really cleaner to receive the Host on your hand after you and the EM shook the hands of five people at the sign of peace?[/quote]


let see...good job. you shook the hands of 5 people. took the Host. ALSO had it placed in your hand. then gave up your soul to God.
However i cant judge. But in my opinion, yeah absolutely cleaner. ;)

Edited by nvzbl
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1732016' date='Dec 19 2008, 01:40 PM']I have heard many people say that they don't think it is sanitary to receive it on the tongue. Don't jump on me, that's just what I have heard repeatedly. Our germaphobic society doesn't seem to want anyone's hand in their mouth. If you step back and think about it for a minute, also in our current society, most people eat out more than they eat at home now. They are okay eating a burger handled by a "hygienic" teenager, but not our Lord placed by a priest.[/quote]

The funny thing is that those are the same people who advocate multitudes of people drinking out of the same chalice.

Posted (edited)

Well, I don't think sharing the cup possess a problem because it's alcohol.

In the East they use a spoon to deliver the Host into a person's mouth. I think for them and many Latins reverence for the Host is the most important thing.

Edited by mortify
Posted

The accidents of wine under which the Precious Blood is contained actually aren't as good of a disinfectant as one would like to think.

Love for life.
Posted

This is a huge inner debate I've been having lately. I don't want to draw attention to myself and make people think I'm trying to be "holier than thou", but it feels wrong to hold the Blessed Sacrament in my hand. What to do?

Servus_Mariae
Posted

For the sake of clarification, I am failrly certain that Canon Law does not address the issue. Rather, a response to a vote amongst Bishops by the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments (approved by Paul VI) is what permit the practice.

[url="http://www.ewtn.com/expert/answers/communion_in_hand.htm"]http://www.ewtn.com/expert/answers/communion_in_hand.htm[/url]

[url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/_INDEX.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/_INDEX.HTM[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Love for life.' post='1732214' date='Dec 19 2008, 06:25 PM']This is a huge inner debate I've been having lately. I don't want to draw attention to myself and make people think I'm trying to be "holier than thou", but it feels wrong to hold the Blessed Sacrament in my hand. What to do?[/quote]


Well, chances are people aren't going to be looking at you anyway. The people in line won't see what you do, and those in the pews would be praying.

Receive on the tongue if it makes you happy. I do. It's not like you're holding up a sign that says HEY, LOOK, NO HANDS! ;) It might also be an opportunity for you to share your reverence for the Eucharist to people who might ask you why you choose to receive that way.

Love for life.
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1732270' date='Dec 19 2008, 08:42 PM']Well, chances are people aren't going to be looking at you anyway. The people in line won't see what you do, and those in the pews would be praying.

Receive on the tongue if it makes you happy. I do. It's not like you're holding up a sign that says HEY, LOOK, NO HANDS! ;) It might also be an opportunity for you to share your reverence for the Eucharist to people who might ask you why you choose to receive that way.[/quote]

Haha that was funny about the sign part. That's true about people not looking, though (hopefully). Thank you!

Posted

[quote name='Love for life.' post='1732214' date='Dec 19 2008, 07:25 PM']This is a huge inner debate I've been having lately. I don't want to draw attention to myself and make people think I'm trying to be "holier than thou", but it feels wrong to hold the Blessed Sacrament in my hand. What to do?[/quote]

Just receive on your tongue, my friends and I do it all the time. No one should judge you and if they do it's their problem. Quite honestly, you'd be serving as a good example and might even inspire others to receive the same way :)

Posted

[quote name='Love for life.' post='1732349' date='Dec 19 2008, 11:30 PM']Haha that was funny about the sign part. That's true about people not looking, though (hopefully). Thank you![/quote]

If people look, let them look. Don't be ashamed of your piety.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1732166' date='Dec 19 2008, 03:11 PM']Well, I don't think sharing the cup possess a problem because it's alcohol.

In the East they use a spoon to deliver the Host into a person's mouth. I think for them and many Latins reverence for the Host is the most important thing.[/quote]
In the Eastern Churches only sacred ministers touch with their hands the consecrated elements.

Roamin'Catholic
Posted (edited)

[quote name='the lords sheep' post='1732015' date='Dec 19 2008, 02:39 PM']Actually, if I'm not mistaken, I believe the right to receive either in the hands or on the tongue is a right guaranteed by Canon Law...
I prefer on the tongue personally, but I believe the right to choose your preference is guarded...[/quote]
After recalling the development of the reception of Communion on the tongue as a fruit of "a deepening understanding of the truth of the Eucharistic mystery, of its power and of the presence of Christ in it", the Instruction declares that "this method of distributing Holy Communion must be retained... not merely because it has many centuries of tradition behind it, but especially because it expresses the faithful's reverence for the Eucharist.

"The custom does not detract in any way from the personal dignity of those who approach this great sacrament: it is part of that preparation that is needed for the most fruitful reception of the Body of the Lord," it said.

It also warned: "A change in a matter of such moment, based on a most ancient and venerable tradition, does not merely affect discipline. It carries certain dangers with it which may arise from the new manner of administering Holy Communion: the danger of a loss of reverence for the august sacrament of the altar, of profanation, of adulterating the true doctrine."

And it published a survey of the world's bishops, which led it to conclude: "The vast majority of bishops believe that the present discipline should not be changed, and that if it were, the change would be offensive to the sentiments and the spiritual culture of these bishops and of many of the faithful."

For this reason it reported: "The Holy Father has decided not to change the existing way of administering Holy Communion to the faithful." [b]So, given that Communion in the hand is now practically universal and younger generations know practically nothing else, what happened?

A "loophole" existed. The Instruction contained the provision for bishops' conferences to make a decision to allow Communion in the hand in places where "contrary usage... prevails". And over the coming decade or so this loophole was exploited.

Today, the Instruction's warnings about loss of reverence for, belief in and even the profanation of the Blessed Sacrament have - sadly - been vindicated.[/b] It is time to look again at the question of Communion in the hand. This is precisely what a young bishop from Central Asia has done in Dominus Est.

Bishop Athanasius Schneider, a patristic scholar, appointed a bishop by Pope Benedict in 2006, has raised his voice in prophetic call for the western Church to recall the importance, if not the necessity, of returning to the previous discipline of the reception of Holy Communion kneeling and on the tongue.

Edited by Roamin'Catholic
Posted

Receiving on the tongue was not always 'tradition'. In the early Church men would receive in the right hand, and then bow their head owards their hand to consume the Host. Women would have done the same except they put a corporal in the palm of their hand first. The rule was that they could not touch the Host with thr fingers.
I have a problem with people who seem to presume that those who receive in the hand are somehow less reverent than those who receive on the tongue.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...