Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group Ă—
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Eucharist And Real Presence


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have always had much trouble in the transubstanciation of the Eucharist. I don't know if that's the engineer in me or if its just 'me' for say.

I've given it a lot of thought. Yesterday, as I was driving back to work, this came to mind:


When a very close loved apsses away, it is not uncommon for people to describe sentiments thinking about that person. When they pick up objects that belonged to that person, (and old coat, a hat or ???) sometimes people describe how they can almost sense the person 'being there', some admitting they perceive a real presence.

Now I have at times felt something of the sort, but I must admit, I have not lost any so close to me as to describe something as above. But I believe people who account such situations.

Now Jesus gave us the Eucharist, as a reminder of Him, and the Eucharist is more than a reminder, it is His presence. Like when you put on an old coat of someone who has passed but you loved dearly and 'feel' the person around you, Catholics who truly love Christ recongnize the presence of the Lord in the Eucharist in a very similar way.


Like an old coat does not change its physical/chemical attributes but still conveys a different reality than another identical coat if that one coat belonged to a dearly departed, the Eucharist is the presence of God Himself, yet the physical/chemical attributes of the loafer does not change either.






Does this make sense? Am I getting it at all pham? I would appreciate comments and thoughts on this. As I said, I have been reflecting on this for some time, and I'm still struggling, but since yesterday I think, I just might, have started to genuinely understand and believe.
(now I can't wait to get back to Church all the sudden; strange huh?)

Galloglasses' Alt
Posted

You're making more progress then me, thats for a cert.

MIKOTHEFREAKSHOW
Posted

I think the significant different in your analogy with the coat is that the coat isn't the person, while the Eucharist IS Jesus Christ.

You can look at the coat, close your eyes and start talking to the person like "I miss you"

but when you look at the Eucharist, you don't need to close your eyes, you look STRAIGHT AT THE EUCHARIST and you can say "I love You Jesus"

that's a huge difference...

Posted

word MIKO.

Didacus that analogy is good for holy images i think.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1734317' date='Dec 23 2008, 10:44 AM']Does this make sense? Am I getting it at all pham?[/quote]

In all honesty brother, it doesn't fit into the doctrine of Transubstantiation.

We have difficulty understanding this doctrine because we are modernists by default. Owing to the way we are raised, we have a very poor concept of "substance."

Substance is something invisible to the senses yet knowable. It is physical and real but distinguished from the sight, taste, smell, and touch which are related to the [i]accidents[/i] of an object. The [i]accidents[/i] are apparently what our mind grasps of an object, the substance is what it really is. So although we see and taste the Host, it is really Christ we receive.

This is a reality that can only be known by faith.

Posted

This will help...

Quoting a portion of the article from: [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?id=2578&repos=1&subrepos=0&searchid=376660"][u]Transubstantiation and reason[/u][/url]

[quote][b]Substance And Accidents[/b]

If one thinks transubstantiation is repugnant to reason, this may be due to not having understood what substance is, and how it is related to accidents. We can't see a substance or touch it or taste it, so it may seem unreal. Perhaps we tend to think of it as an inert something, having no function except to support the active qualities shown by the senses. George Berkeley (1685-1753) declared material substance to be a meaningless term. He says: "It neither acts, nor perceives, nor is perceived: for this is all that is meant by saying it is an inert, senseless, unknown substance: which is a definition entirely made up of negatives, excepting only the relative notion of its standing under or supporting."4

That notion of substance is grotesque, but it does not seem so to an empiricist philosopher because of his reduction of all knowledge to sense knowledge; and it continues to influence some theologians when they think about transubstantiation. That is one reason for the widespread rejection of this dogma, and the substitution of transignification or transfinalization.

The truth is that denial of the reality of substance is a contradiction of common sense. For something must either exist in its own right, such as water, a tree, a cat: or else it must exist in something else, such as color or shape. What "stands on its own feet," as it were, is a substance; what exists in something else is an accident. Denial of substances leaves color, size, weight and so on without a subject of inherence: which implies a color which is not the color of anything, size which is not the size of anything, weight which is not the weight of anything.

The substance is the essence, the nature, of a thing which exists in its own right. It isn't inert, as Berkeley imagined, but dynamic, for it is the source from which all the powers and activities emanate. The accidents depend on it for their existence and their operation.

Take a stone, by way of example. We experience its hardness, its smoothness, its color, its shape. But the substance that has these attributes eludes our observation. Even were we to break the stone in two we wouldn't see the substance; if we broke it into a hundred pieces we would be no more successful. So we might try some scientific tests, but still the results would be in the order of phenomena.

The substance of the stone is material, but it is not sensible. Yet it is not unknown, for its accidents manifest it. From the accidents perceived by sight and the other senses, the intellect gains an insight into the essence (the substance). Therefore words like stone, water, tree, horse have meaning: each brings to mind the thing named, and we have in our intellect the essence of the reality in question, although never perfectly, for no substance can be perfectly understood through abstraction from sense knowledge.

The dogma of transubstantiation teaches that the whole substance of bread is changed into that of Christ's body, and the whole substance of wine into that of his blood, leaving the accidents of bread and wine unaffected. Reason, of course, can't prove that this happens. But it is not evidently against reason either; it is above reason. Our senses, being confined to phenomena, cannot detect the change: we know it only by faith in God's word.

After the priest consecrates the bread and wine, their accidents alone remain, without inhering in any substance. They can't inhere in the bread and wine, for these no longer exist; nor do they inhere in Christ's body and blood, for they are not his accidents. The Catechism of the Council of Trent says: ". . . the accidents which present themselves to the eyes or other senses exist in a wonderful and ineffable manner without a subject."5 St. Thomas Aquinas teaches that God directly sustains the quantity of bread (or wine) in being, and that the other accidents inhere in the quantity.6 For quantity is the fundamental accident: the others, such as color, exist as quantified—as having extension. There is no such thing as a non-extended color.[/quote]

Posted

I understand/like that sentiment, but I agree it is more in keeping with holy objects than the Eucharist.

virginiancatholic
Posted

I see what you mean, but the analogy falls extremely short of the truth and oversimplifies. In order for the analogy to make sense, the substance of the person would have to dwell in the coat, which it most certainly does not, not just one's memories and connections of that person with it. Every time I hear wind chimes, I remember my great-granny. The memories of her old house in Richmond with chimes all over the porch is so strong, I can actually at times feel her rough hand on my cheek and hear her voice singing the old songs...it is so much like she's actually there...but it is only memories. Her essence/substance is not in the chimes...not even any part of her. They do not embody or become her.

Remember the distinction between substance and accident, so nicely listed above. A man, a tree, copper are substances, they exist in themselves. Contrariwise, color, height, physical and chemical reactions, thoughts, are called accidents because they require a subject (a substance) in which to reside. Thought does not exist by itself; it must exist in a thinking subject. Substance and accident are naturally united, yet they are distinct from each other. Accidents may also be called appearances, and it is through these appearances that we come to a knowledge of the substance. It is by looking at me, talking with me, and shaking my hand that one comes to know who I am. You might know me in a sense (how I look, sound, smell :wacko:) without knowing me really, that is my essence, my real self.

The Eucharist retains the accidents of bread and wine, but substance of Christ, His essence (some might call it "my true self") is present instead of the substance/essence of bread.

Posted

I think it is better to speak about [i]who[/i] is made present in the eucharist, rather than [i]wha[/i]t is made present.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1734450' date='Dec 23 2008, 05:09 PM']I think it is better to speak about [i]who[/i] is made present in the eucharist, rather than [i]wha[/i]t is made present.[/quote]

well played

Roamin'Catholic
Posted

Maybe this explanation helps:

[u]Different types of changes[/u]

A change of appearance: For example, a green apple grows to be a full, ripe, red apple.

A partial change of substance: For example, oil burns and changes into smoke. The appearances change also.

A complete change of substance: This is transubstantiation.
The only example of this kind of change is found in the Consecration of the Mass. The appearances of bread would also change into those of Christ if God did not prevent this by a miracle.
When the priest says, " This is My body," at Mass, you would immediately see Christ, and not the appearances of bread, if God did not prevent it by a miracle. He keeps the appearances of bread in existence to enable us to eat the flesh of Christ without difficulty.

Posted

[quote name='mortify' post='1734376' date='Dec 23 2008, 02:11 PM']This will help...

Quoting a portion of the article from: [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/view.cfm?id=2578&repos=1&subrepos=0&searchid=376660"][u]Transubstantiation and reason[/u][/url][/quote]

Thank you Mortify. Good reading - I'll finish it when I have a bit more time.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1734450' date='Dec 23 2008, 05:09 PM']I think it is better to speak about [i]who[/i] is made present in the eucharist, rather than [i]wha[/i]t is made present.[/quote]

*blush* I think you're correct.
Sorr :unsure: y bout that.

Posted

[quote name='Roamin'Catholic' post='1734746' date='Dec 24 2008, 10:44 AM']Maybe this explanation helps:

[u]Different types of changes[/u]

[snip]

A partial change of substance: For example, oil burns and changes into smoke. The appearances change also.


[snip][/quote]

Seems to me the 'change' is a change in chemical composition and no a change in the 'substance', but s said earlier, this may be due to my miunderstanding the term 'sbustance'. Get back to you on that one.

Posted

[quote name='MIKO' post='1734350' date='Dec 23 2008, 01:09 PM']I think the significant different in your analogy with the coat is that the coat isn't the person, while the Eucharist IS Jesus Christ.

You can look at the coat, close your eyes and start talking to the person like "I miss you"

but when you look at the Eucharist, you don't need to close your eyes, you look STRAIGHT AT THE EUCHARIST and you can say "I love You Jesus"

that's a huge difference...[/quote]

I am aware of this distinction.

For one, maybe I was all that clear in my opening post. Can I ask if it may be possible that the departed person is spiritually present when one close their eyes and says 'I miss you' and that the sentiment is actually perception of a real presence (although spiritual)?

I did not say it was the best analogy either, ony that there seemed to be some similarities. Of course Jesus is entirely present in the Eucharist, which is fr different than a spiritual-only presence, but one must note that if God would permit spirits to be present with loved ones, how much more will He permit Himself to be fully present with His loved ones?

I suppose I can sum my thoughts as follows; if one can relate and understand how a spiritul presence of a dearly departed may be possible, how much more of a stretch would it be for God Himself to be present, body and blood, inthe Eucharist?

Posted

Finallly I would like to thank everyone that posted. You've given me some tings to think further upon and some guidance.

I'll do a bit more reading at my end and return to the thread a little later with hopefully a bit more insight and better questions.

Posted (edited)

JM + JT

Try to think like a little child.

A mother gives her child a piece of bread saying, "This is bread." The child tastes the bread and associates the taste, sight, feeling, etc. of the bread with what is is called.

Christ gives us bread and we eat it and taste it, but instead of calling it bread He says, "This is My Body."

IDK... just what I came up with after thinking for a bit.

Edited by salterrae
Posted

[quote name='salterrae' post='1734802' date='Dec 24 2008, 01:03 PM']A mother gives her child a piece of bread saying, "This is bread." The child tastes the bread and associates the taste, sight, feeling, etc. of the bread with what is is called.

Christ gives us bread and we eat it and taste it, but instead of calling it bread He says, "This is My Body."[/quote]

The change is in the substance and not our minds.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...