browneyes106 Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 I am really hurting right now. My brother is getting married to a woman with four children. There are two boys and two girls. Since they announced the engagement in December '07 me and my sister were hoping that I would get asked to be in the wedding party. My sister has been in wedding parties before and she said that it was ok if she wasn't in the wedding party for my brother. She was hoping that I would get asked because I have never been in a wedding party before. Just a couple of days ago I found that the woman's four children will be in the wedding and they will each have partnered with a niece or nephew from my brother's gf's side. But her oldest daughter is 19 and is gay. Her partner is butch type who has really short hair and dresses like a man. She is going to be a "groomsman" in the wedding and partnered with the daughter. I can understand the four children being in the wedding but I'm upset that the daughter's "partner or whatever you call her and the nieces and nephews of the woman are going to be in the wedding. I talked to my brother about this and he told me that his fiance and her family are very close and that they deserve more involvement in the wedding. Since they started planning the wedding my brother's fianee has excluded my family from a lot of things. She is having her sister-in-law make the cake and one of her aunts is going to be the wedding photographer. My family and relatives have offered to do things like making decorations, food etc and my brother and his fiance have told us no and that her family is going to be doing a lot of stuff. I'm really hurt with my brother. I feel it isn't right that nobody from my family will be in the wedding party. I realize that it is their wedding but it justs there is no respect for my family and our feelings. They are planning to be married in our local church. My parents have arranged a meeting with the priest. I am really disgusted with their siutation and the fact that this woman wants to be married in church despite the history with her four kids.Please share any experiences or thoughts on this.
Sarah_JC Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 You can't force your brother's bride-to-be to let you in her side of the bridal party, and if your brother wants to give up his side as well, that's his choice. And having a child with same sex attraction does not preclude one from being married in the church. Although I don't think allowing the daughter's partner to participate in the wedding is the best thing for her spiritually, I'm sure they're doing it out of love. Relax and try to enjoy the wedding. Having a child with SSA must be a heavy burden, I bet they could really use your prayers.
Sarah_JC Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 (edited) oops, double post Edited December 27, 2008 by Sarah_JC
CatherineM Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 Weddings are about the bride and groom. It is actually the only sacrament that is conferred not by the priest, but by the bride and groom where the priest or deacon is only a witness. I've done a lot of work in the tribunal, and have been privy to the circumstances that lead to the church granting annulments. Investigating a couples' history is up to the due diligence of the priest officiating at the ceremony. If he is okay with the marriage, then you should accept that. I have five older brothers, and between them, they have had 12 marriages, so far. I have never been in any of their wedding parties in any capacity. I took pictures at two, but that was it. I was okay with that because I know being a member of the party is expensive, and a huge hassle. Marriages are very difficult under the best of circumstances. There may be so many things involved with this that you aren't aware of. Her family may want to do everything because they got excluded before, or are so happy that she has finally found the right man, etc. I have seen weddings where the best man was a female and the maid of honor was male, and today that isn't such a big deal, but I'd be surprised if your priest allows a gay daughter's partner to participate in a public manner. My only suggestion is to be happy for your brother, support him in any way you can. Offer to help, but understand if he doesn't require it. Taking on the responsibility of 4 stepchildren is a heavy weight, and there may be a time that he really needs to rely on you.
dominicansoul Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 [quote name='Sarah_JC' post='1736464' date='Dec 27 2008, 04:45 PM']You can't force your brother's bride-to-be to let you in her side of the bridal party, and if your brother wants to give up his side as well, that's his choice. And having a child with same sex attraction does not preclude one from being married in the church. Although I don't think allowing the daughter's partner to participate in the wedding is the best thing for her spiritually, I'm sure they're doing it out of love. Relax and try to enjoy the wedding. Having a child with SSA must be a heavy burden, I bet they could really use your prayers.[/quote] a lot of wrong things are done "out of love." And since this will be happening in a Catholic wedding, it would bring a great deal of scandal, too. You have to speak out against these things [u]out of love[/u] for GOD... I would be troubled, too. I wish one of your family members would address this with the priest. This shouldn't be happening at a Catholic wedding...
Ash Wednesday Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 (edited) Traditionally, the bride's family pays for the wedding and/or it is often the case that the bride does a lot of the planning and decision-making, so it often is the case that she has the final word and throws the most weight around. When my oldest brother got married, all of my brothers were groomsmen. The bride's brother was a groomsman. Basically, all the family siblings were in the wedding party except one: me. The bride had all of her girlfriends as bridesmaids. But I wasn't one of them. Did I feel insulted and excluded? You bet. But I didn't say anything, and I have never brought it up. I figured it was their wedding, her decision, and I just left it at that. It still kind of annoys me when I think about it, but we weren't terribly close, and she probably figured I wouldn't want to wear one of those dresses anyway. But the irony is, years later we were discussing weddings. We had a maid of honor and best man, but no bridesmaids or groomsmen. I said it was more hassle than I could deal with, and she agreed. She said if she did it again she wouldn't have bothered. So much for that. But I do think the lesbian partnering in a Catholic wedding party is inappropriate. I'm surprised that the priest would allow the couple to do that in a church wedding party, in that it would appear to show tacit approval of that lifestyle and possibly be a situation of scandal. Maybe he isn't aware of their plans yet. If not, someone better let him know. Edited December 27, 2008 by Ash Wednesday
tinytherese Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1736487' date='Dec 27 2008, 05:56 PM']But I do think the lesbian partnering in a Catholic wedding party is inappropriate. I'm surprised that the priest would allow the couple to do that in a church wedding party, in that it would appear to show tacit approval of that lifestyle and possibly be a situation of scandal.[/quote] Agreed, definitely should be brought up with this priest.
Ash Wednesday Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 (edited) I get the feeling that it hasn't occurred to the bride that this, in all likelihood, will not be allowed. She could be in for a real shock if she wants a church wedding and the matter isn't addressed. People would be surprised at how many weddings are called off or plans were put in serious jeopardy because they didn't run things by the priest. Our priest told us of couples that didn't have the paperwork and had to call entire weddings off because they made ignorant assumptions about things like annulments, baptismal certificates, or (in the case here in the U.K.) -- not taking care of the civil end of it as well. That and people showing up to the altar drunk and the priest having to refuse to marry them because their vows aren't freely given of sound mind. People who assume a Catholic wedding can have flexibility for personal tastes, or can take place so easily like other churches and venues, will often find themselves getting quite a "rude" awakening. Prayers for the groom, his fiancee, and everyone involved. The bride probably isn't deliberately trying to be hurtful and the family politics involved probably have not even occurred to her. Planning a wedding is a real barrel of monkeys. I've been married 3 months and still don't feel fully recovered from the stress. Edited December 27, 2008 by Ash Wednesday
CatherineM Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 I'll agree with Ash. As someone who had her church wedding postponed by the priest 2 days before hand, I will testify to the fact that they can and will if anything comes up that they have concerns about. Ours was canceled after my sister in law called our priest and told him that my husband was off his meds and beating me. He required months more of pre-marriage counseling before he figured out he'd been lied to. On the other hand, we were never asked about our wedding party members, except about the two who would be signing the register. They needed to be baptized. The priest won't ask/know about a gay partner in the wedding party unless someone tells him.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 [quote name='browneyes106' post='1736446' date='Dec 27 2008, 04:52 PM']I am really hurting right now. My brother is getting married to a woman with four children. There are two boys and two girls. Since they announced the engagement in December '07 me and my sister were hoping that I would get asked to be in the wedding party. My sister has been in wedding parties before and she said that it was ok if she wasn't in the wedding party for my brother. She was hoping that I would get asked because I have never been in a wedding party before. Just a couple of days ago I found that the woman's four children will be in the wedding and they will each have partnered with a niece or nephew from my brother's gf's side. But her oldest daughter is 19 and is gay. Her partner is butch type who has really short hair and dresses like a man. She is going to be a "groomsman" in the wedding and partnered with the daughter. I can understand the four children being in the wedding but I'm upset that the daughter's "partner or whatever you call her and the nieces and nephews of the woman are going to be in the wedding. I talked to my brother about this and he told me that his fiance and her family are very close and that they deserve more involvement in the wedding. Since they started planning the wedding my brother's fianee has excluded my family from a lot of things. She is having her sister-in-law make the cake and one of her aunts is going to be the wedding photographer. My family and relatives have offered to do things like making decorations, food etc and my brother and his fiance have told us no and that her family is going to be doing a lot of stuff. I'm really hurt with my brother. I feel it isn't right that nobody from my family will be in the wedding party. I realize that it is their wedding but it justs there is no respect for my family and our feelings. They are planning to be married in our local church. My parents have arranged a meeting with the priest. I am really disgusted with their siutation and the fact that this woman wants to be married in church despite the history with her four kids.Please share any experiences or thoughts on this.[/quote] There is an old quote that is applicable here: "A son's in your family til he takes a wife, a daughter's your daughter the rest of her life." He is still your brother, but he is now being absorbed into another family system, and they will take precedence from now on. Sorry, but that is what usually happens when a male marries. I am assuming the priest knows nothing about the oldest daughter and her partner, but I am sure that if it were known it would not go over well. Love your bro the best tyou can, it is probably going to be a stressful time, and be a good aunt to your newly acquired family.
Tinkerlina Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 It's a tough call but I can see the situation the family is in-for example, I have a cousin who is gay and we do include her girlfriend in a lot of things. The majority of my family doesn't believe in living a homosexual lifestye but we want her to know she is loved. I just treat her girlfriend as a friend, none of us bring up anything about their lifestyle or relationship. In my situation, I don't think anything would be accomplished by airing my views or excluding people-I just pray for them. That's just my two cents in my situation, though, pray about what to do in yours. Hope everything turns out OK. -Katie
browneyes106 Posted December 28, 2008 Author Posted December 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1736466' date='Dec 27 2008, 05:46 PM']Weddings are about the bride and groom. It is actually the only sacrament that is conferred not by the priest, but by the bride and groom where the priest or deacon is only a witness. I've done a lot of work in the tribunal, and have been privy to the circumstances that lead to the church granting annulments. Investigating a couples' history is up to the due diligence of the priest officiating at the ceremony. If he is okay with the marriage, then you should accept that. I have five older brothers, and between them, they have had 12 marriages, so far. I have never been in any of their wedding parties in any capacity. I took pictures at two, but that was it. I was okay with that because I know being a member of the party is expensive, and a huge hassle. Marriages are very difficult under the best of circumstances. There may be so many things involved with this that you aren't aware of. Her family may want to do everything because they got excluded before, or are so happy that she has finally found the right man, etc. I have seen weddings where the best man was a female and the maid of honor was male, and today that isn't such a big deal, but I'd be surprised if your priest allows a gay daughter's partner to participate in a public manner. My only suggestion is to be happy for your brother, support him in any way you can. Offer to help, but understand if he doesn't require it. Taking on the responsibility of 4 stepchildren is a heavy weight, and there may be a time that he really needs to rely on you.[/quote] I wouldn't mind paying money for a dress and other stuff. But I feel the bride and our her family really aren't respecting my family at all. Two of her aunts will do the readings for the mass and her dad and brother will be taking up the communion gifts. Two of her nephews will be ushers and one of her sister-in-laws will be the guest book attendant. There really isn't any respect for my family. My aunt owned a catering business for years and has many skills she offered services to them and was rejected. [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1736471' date='Dec 27 2008, 05:50 PM']a lot of wrong things are done "out of love." And since this will be happening in a Catholic wedding, it would bring a great deal of scandal, too. You have to speak out against these things [u]out of love[/u] for GOD... I would be troubled, too. I wish one of your family members would address this with the priest. This shouldn't be happening at a Catholic wedding...[/quote] [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1736487' date='Dec 27 2008, 06:56 PM']Traditionally, the bride's family pays for the wedding and/or it is often the case that the bride does a lot of the planning and decision-making, so it often is the case that she has the final word and throws the most weight around. When my oldest brother got married, all of my brothers were groomsmen. The bride's brother was a groomsman. Basically, all the family siblings were in the wedding party except one: me. The bride had all of her girlfriends as bridesmaids. But I wasn't one of them. Did I feel insulted and excluded? You bet. But I didn't say anything, and I have never brought it up. I figured it was their wedding, her decision, and I just left it at that. It still kind of annoys me when I think about it, but we weren't terribly close, and she probably figured I wouldn't want to wear one of those dresses anyway. But the irony is, years later we were discussing weddings. We had a maid of honor and best man, but no bridesmaids or groomsmen. I said it was more hassle than I could deal with, and she agreed. She said if she did it again she wouldn't have bothered. So much for that. But I do think the lesbian partnering in a Catholic wedding party is inappropriate. I'm surprised that the priest would allow the couple to do that in a church wedding party, in that it would appear to show tacit approval of that lifestyle and possibly be a situation of scandal. Maybe he isn't aware of their plans yet. If not, someone better let him know.[/quote] I agree with both domincan and ash about the partner being the wedding. My parents are hoping to meet with the priest sometime soon to tell him about her being in the wedding party.
browneyes106 Posted December 28, 2008 Author Posted December 28, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1736535' date='Dec 27 2008, 08:03 PM']There is an old quote that is applicable here: "A son's in your family til he takes a wife, a daughter's your daughter the rest of her life." He is still your brother, but he is now being absorbed into another family system, and they will take precedence from now on. Sorry, but that is what usually happens when a male marries. I am assuming the priest knows nothing about the oldest daughter and her partner, but I am sure that if it were known it would not go over well. Love your bro the best tyou can, it is probably going to be a stressful time, and be a good aunt to your newly acquired family.[/quote] The priest doesn't know yet. But knowing him he probably won't allow the girlfriend to be involved. As for the bride's children they aren't really friendly with me. Their ages are 20,19, 15 and 9. They only say hi and that's it. They pretty much ignore me.
IcePrincessKRS Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1736535' date='Dec 27 2008, 08:03 PM']There is an old quote that is applicable here: "A son's in your family til he takes a wife, a daughter's your daughter the rest of her life." He is still your brother, but he is now being absorbed into another family system, and they will take precedence from now on. Sorry, but that is what usually happens when a male marries. I am assuming the priest knows nothing about the oldest daughter and her partner, but I am sure that if it were known it would not go over well. Love your bro the best tyou can, it is probably going to be a stressful time, and be a good aunt to your newly acquired family.[/quote] I also agree with Ash. We don't always get what WE want, but ultimately someone else's wedding isn't about us or what we want. There have been plenty of times I wish I'd been included in a friend or relatives wedding and wasn't, and the times I have been I was honored to step in and give them my support. You should be supportive of your brother even if you're not in the wedding party. Honestly, aside from the lesbian groomsman, it doesn't really sound like your brother's fiance is doing all that much different than you'd find in most weddings. Chances are she relied on the people she knows first and when offers were made from your family those jobs had already been covered. When I got married all the planning was done by me and my mom (with a few consults with my husband), I included all of my siblings in the wedding as bridal party, servers, taking up the gifts, etc. My husband chose his groomsmen and didn't opt to ask any of his brothers, I asked one of his sisters to be a bridesmaid (he's one of 11, I am one of 12) because she was partly responsible for us meeting in the first place. His father did a reading, and so did one of his brothers. Basically, only THREE members of his entire family was directly involved with our wedding. My entire family was. It wasn't done that way to exclude anyone, we just turned to the people we knew first and thought would appreciate being involved. (His family was in a different state as well, so that was a factor in the decision making.) As someone who has planned a wedding I just don't think that what your brother and his fiance have done was with the intent to exclude or hurt feelings. And really, I think it IS more important that her children be involved over his siblings. He's going to be their father, this is a huge new step for all of them. If my husband had had children from a previous marriage I'd have definitely put them in my wedding party over my own siblings.
Lil Red Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 [quote name='browneyes106' post='1736807' date='Dec 28 2008, 10:00 AM']The priest doesn't know yet. But knowing him he probably won't allow the girlfriend to be involved. As for the bride's children they aren't really friendly with me. Their ages are 20,19, 15 and 9. They only say hi and that's it. They pretty much ignore me.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ perhaps because they don't know you? have you made an effort to get to know them? i am unsure of your age, so perhaps it isn't feasible, but could you take them to dinner or out to ice skating or something like that? perhaps they would appreciate getting to know you and your family better
jmjtina Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 (edited) My only advice is to love them and accept it. (not the part about the SSA girlfriend; def let your priest know. If he's anything like my priest, it won't happen) I have family that hates my guts. Ever heard of the "black sheep" of the family? My family is it. I think anyone who is a hardcore Catholic family knows what I'm talking about. You can't hold on to the hurt. Sometimes people are hurt and only wish hurt in return. Offer it up, love them and let it go. It may be a misunderstanding, but it may not. Offer everything to God, keep in prayer, because while we can't control what others do, we can certainly control and ask for the strength for how we react to it. Charitably and with love. My prayers are with you. God Bless. Edited December 29, 2008 by jmjtina
browneyes106 Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Lil Red' post='1736949' date='Dec 28 2008, 05:19 PM']+J.M.J.+ perhaps because they don't know you? have you made an effort to get to know them? i am unsure of your age, so perhaps it isn't feasible, but could you take them to dinner or out to ice skating or something like that? perhaps they would appreciate getting to know you and your family better [/quote] I'm 23 and I have tried making the effort. I have invited them to movies and college football games. Edited December 29, 2008 by browneyes106
cmotherofpirl Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='browneyes106' post='1737608' date='Dec 29 2008, 10:50 AM']I'm 23 and I have tried making the effort. I have invited them to movies and college football games.[/quote] And that is a good start . Do you know what interests each of them persue? Are they in sports- have you attended their games? Do they listen to music or play an instrument?
havok579257 Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='browneyes106' post='1736803' date='Dec 28 2008, 11:53 AM']I wouldn't mind paying money for a dress and other stuff. But I feel the bride and our her family really aren't respecting my family at all. Two of her aunts will do the readings for the mass and her dad and brother will be taking up the communion gifts. Two of her nephews will be ushers and one of her sister-in-laws will be the guest book attendant. There really isn't any respect for my family. My aunt owned a catering business for years and has many skills she offered services to them and was rejected. I agree with both domincan and ash about the partner being the wedding. My parents are hoping to meet with the priest sometime soon to tell him about her being in the wedding party.[/quote] Again, this is not your wedding so you can not expect anything. This wedding is not about you or your family, its about God and the bride and groom, that's it. The bride and groom should not be worrying about making other family members happy on their special day. This is there day and they should only be worrying about what God wants and what they want. A man and a women are only supposed to do this once in their life, so this is a big day. To many couples worry about what will make thier family on this special day and they spend more time cateering to their families and don't worry about what they want on thier wedding day. Not trying to sound harsh here, but you have no right to expect anything on thier wedding day. I understand your hurt, but you have to remmeber, its thier day. Just let them do what makes them happy on thier special day. Again, not trying to sound harsh.
Lil Red Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='browneyes106' post='1737608' date='Dec 29 2008, 07:50 AM']I'm 23 and I have tried making the effort. I have invited them to movies and college football games.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ that's great! perhaps they are shy or unsure of where they stand with your family though? i know when i married my husband, it took awhile to 'warm up' to them because their family dynamic was drastically different from my family's. in the meantime, to his sister, i seemed 'stand-offish' and 'stuck-up'. it wasn't how i really was/am, but i was keeping my distance. anyway, i hope that you continue making the effort - i am sure that they will respond once they see how genuine you are!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now