Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Want To Post About Poor Clares In Lost Altos Hills Ca


Recommended Posts

mom2threekids
Posted

Hi I am new here. I actually wanted to post something in the vocations folder because there is a topic about the Poor Clares in Los Altos Hills. I was there for 4.5 years but they told me it was not my vocation, I am now the mother of 3 beautiful children, married to a wonderful for over 8 years. I entered when I was 18 and I wanted to comment on the post in the vocations folder, but I can't post there. I actually know sister Bernadette who is in the website posted, she is no longer with the Poor clares also but we were in the novitiate together. If anyone wants to learn more about them please email me. To be clear, as a devout Catholic I can not recommend this order in good faith. Some thing were going on at that particular monestary when I was there, that I think people need to look carefully at before they enter. If anyone wants more information please feel free to email me.

puellapaschalis
Posted
:welcome:

I think you need a minimum of 10 posts to be able to post in Vocation Station.
icelandic_iceskater
Posted

welcome to phatmass! :bye:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='mom2threekids' post='1739407' date='Dec 31 2008, 02:50 AM']Hi I am new here. I actually wanted to post something in the vocations folder because there is a topic about the Poor Clares in Los Altos Hills. I was there for 4.5 years but they told me it was not my vocation, I am now the mother of 3 beautiful children, married to a wonderful for over 8 years. I entered when I was 18 and I wanted to comment on the post in the vocations folder, but I can't post there. I actually know sister Bernadette who is in the website posted, she is no longer with the Poor clares also but we were in the novitiate together. If anyone wants to learn more about them please email me. To be clear, as a devout Catholic I can not recommend this order in good faith. Some thing were going on at that particular monestary when I was there, that I think people need to look carefully at before they enter. If anyone wants more information please feel free to email me.[/quote]
The reason newbies can't post there is so we can see if someone is coming here to vent a grudge against a particular order or not. Problems with a particular order should be reported to that order's heirarchy, not spread around on various websites, so I glad whatever you want to discuss will be via mail and not here.

Snowflake3981
Posted

Welcome to phatmass! You should also introduce yourself in the "Check-In" thread pinned at the top of the board.

mom2threekids
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1739509' date='Dec 31 2008, 09:45 AM']The reason newbies can't post there is so we can see if someone is coming here to vent a grudge against a particular order or not. Problems with a particular order should be reported to that order's heirarchy, not spread around on various websites, so I glad whatever you want to discuss will be via mail and not here.[/quote]

Oh, okay that makes sence. I don't post online much anymore (I have 3 kids!!!!) so I don't have much time. I doubt I will have time to get to that many posts, oh those years in college where I could post that many posts in one day!!

The Poor Clare order is great btw! I have no complaints about Poor Clares but I would be happy to discuss my experience with that particular monestary if anyone wants to email me. I wish I had found someone who was willing to discuss it with me before I entered. I think before entering you should (obviously) talk to the monestary but also have a frank talk with people who are not there anymore. They may give you some insights that can help you.

For one I wish I had talked to someone who left and found they had a vocation to marriage. Maybe I would have found my vocation sooner! Or maybe not, I think being with the Poor Clares helped me find my wonderful husband, if I was not there maybe my life wouldn't be as happy and blessed as it is today.

Anyone interested feel free to email me, I don't get on boards much, my kids rarely give me a quiet moment these days!

mom2threekids
Posted

[quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1739709' date='Dec 31 2008, 02:04 PM']Welcome to phatmass! You should also introduce yourself in the "Check-In" thread pinned at the top of the board.[/quote]
Okay will do as soon as I can get the kids to give me a chance!!

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1739509' date='Dec 31 2008, 07:45 AM']The reason newbies can't post there is so we can see if someone is coming here to vent a grudge against a particular order or not. Problems with a particular order should be reported to that order's heirarchy, not spread around on various websites, so I glad whatever you want to discuss will be via mail and not here.[/quote]
ditto

and :bye: welcome!

Posted

[quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1739443' date='Dec 31 2008, 04:22 AM']:welcome:

I think you need a minimum of 10 posts to be able to post in Vocation Station.[/quote]


ah, that clears it up for me too, i had better get posting, i was wondered if i had done something wrong so thanx.

Posted

[quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1739709' date='Dec 31 2008, 02:04 PM']Welcome to phatmass! You should also introduce yourself in the "Check-In" thread pinned at the top of the board.[/quote]


is this one compulsory as i am a bit shy and wont be around for long? Is there any part of the site that mentions all these things?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='sine modo' post='1739852' date='Dec 31 2008, 04:34 PM']is this one compulsory as i am a bit shy and wont be around for long? Is there any part of the site that mentions all these things?[/quote]
what do you need to know?

DevotedtoHim
Posted

I would like to talk about this order because I have an upcoming time to visit them. Please PM me. Thanks,
Katherine

Posted

+Praised be Jesus Christ!

Yes, it is a good thing to want to speak members privately. Every person has their own experience and some end up having very strong feelings, especially if they were asked to leave. I think it is very kind you are willing to share your own story privately especially in the event if things are not as they should be. Important information for our girls, especially since this particular order has a low age requirement.

Information is always important; keep an open mind and be able to think critically! That doesn't mean "be angry" or "be critical" - it just means --- use your God given gift of thinking! Learn, be open, and listen...then decide!

TradMom

Posted

[quote name='mom2threekids' post='1739407' date='Dec 31 2008, 12:50 AM']Hi I am new here. I actually wanted to post something in the vocations folder because there is a topic about the Poor Clares in Los Altos Hills. I was there for 4.5 years but they told me it was not my vocation, I am now the mother of 3 beautiful children, married to a wonderful for over 8 years. I entered when I was 18 and I wanted to comment on the post in the vocations folder, but I can't post there. I actually know sister Bernadette who is in the website posted, she is no longer with the Poor clares also but we were in the novitiate together. If anyone wants to learn more about them please email me. To be clear, as a devout Catholic I can not recommend this order in good faith. Some thing were going on at that particular monestary when I was there, that I think people need to look carefully at before they enter. If anyone wants more information please feel free to email me.[/quote]

In your spare time(!), you may wish to join the Catholic Answers Forum, which is huge, with a large Vocations section under the Catholic Living section . It's at [url="http://forums.catholic.com"]http://forums.catholic.com[/url] (no www.). There are a lot of people looking at vocations there. You can feel free to post your impressions on that site. The size of this forum makes it a bit more anonymous that phatmass, tho' there's a lot of crossover between the two groups.

I personally think that former members' "exit interviews" can be very worthwhile. Interested persons can take their personal impressions with a grain of salt, if need be.

Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='mom2threekids' post='1739407' date='Dec 31 2008, 01:50 AM']Hi I am new here. I actually wanted to post something in the vocations folder because there is a topic about the Poor Clares in Los Altos Hills. I was there for 4.5 years but they told me it was not my vocation, I am now the mother of 3 beautiful children, married to a wonderful for over 8 years. I entered when I was 18 and I wanted to comment on the post in the vocations folder, but I can't post there. I actually know sister Bernadette who is in the website posted, she is no longer with the Poor clares also but we were in the novitiate together. If anyone wants to learn more about them please email me. To be clear, as a devout Catholic I can not recommend this order in good faith. Some thing were going on at that particular monestary when I was there, that I think people need to look carefully at before they enter. If anyone wants more information please feel free to email me.[/quote]

I don't this is very appropriate.

DevotedtoHim
Posted

Saint Therese, actually I think this is appropriate because her experience might be valid. She didn't trash them. She offered to give her opinions privately. I for one am very interested because I am planning on visiting them and I would like to hear what she has to say. It doesn't mean that she is going to be bad just honest about her own life. I wish more people were honest.

I just found out how many people left a certain order last year (and it's one of the most popular ones! with tons of "young vocations") and I am really surprised. It has totally made me feel like something might be going on with the way they do things there and while they make a really big deal of their classes in September when all the girls join, they don't say anything about how many girls leave! I think this is important. I am really glad that "Mom" wrote in, I just really wish she would write in again or write to me personally before I get to Los Altos Hills.

Also, I think "Mom" was respectful and I like that and besides, this phorum is for people to be able to share and be open and have their opinions and things like that.

I really hope she will post again.

Thanks,
Katherine

Saint Therese
Posted

I don't think its appropriate to publicly trash a religious community, even if they are experiencing problems. Religious communities have SO MUCH trouble with trying to avoid scandal and having people, who are misinformed about the nature of the life, judge them without basis. No religious community is perfect, and there is always a danger that someone who was briefly a part of a community, and for some reason left, will speak in an imprudent way. We have no idea why this person left religious life.
It is possible( though I'm not saying this is what happening in this case) thata person who was briefly a member of a community but was asked to leave might bear a grudge, or have some issue such as mental illness.

Posted

+ Praised be Jesus Christ!

Rather than suggest she might be mentally ill, why not consider that the former member feels a sense of obligation out of her personal experience? I do not believe she said anything specific and was careful to mention her feelings were not about the Order in general. I believe listening is good; however to make a vocational decision based upon a stranger's post would be crazy! Take her experience with a grain of salt and know it is personal.

Saint Therese
Posted (edited)

If you'll read my post, you'll see that I specifically stated I was not suggesting she was mentally ill.

[quote]It is possible( though I'm not saying this is what happening in this case) thata person who was briefly a member of a community but was asked to leave might bear a grudge, or have some issue such as mental illness[/quote]

Edited by Saint Therese
Posted

[quote name='TradMom' post='1745722' date='Jan 7 2009, 09:53 PM']+ Praised be Jesus Christ!

Rather than suggest she might be mentally ill, why not consider that the former member feels a sense of obligation out of her personal experience? I do not believe she said anything specific and was careful to mention her feelings were not about the Order in general. I believe listening is good; however to make a vocational decision based upon a stranger's post would be crazy! Take her experience with a grain of salt and know it is personal.[/quote]

Here, here, TradMom.

All of the info can be transmitted by PM and email, but I think that it is important that discerners get feedback, good and bad, reliable and less so, about the orders they're discerning. Most discerners don't have the time or money to fly about the country visiting orders.

Re people leaving, I did note that one of the most popular orders had [i]one-third [/i]of its postulants become novices, in numbers large enough to be significant (not one postulant out of 3, for ex.) That suggests to me that the order isn't adequately screening postulants.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...