Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Teacher Fired For Marrying Divorced Man To Sue Catholic School


Recommended Posts

Snowflake3981
Posted

I don't think I saw this posted anywhere on the phorums yet.


[url="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,474464,00.html"]http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,474464,00.html[/url]

[quote]A San Antonio teacher plans to sue her former employer, a Catholic high school, saying she was fired for marrying a man who had been divorced, a proceeding not recognized by the Catholic Church, the San Antonio Express-News reported Tuesday.

Marquis LaFortune, 25, filed a complaint with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission after her Nov. 22 ceremony. She claims that once the school found out her fiancé had been divorced, Deacon Patrick Cunningham told her she had three options: seek an annulment, resign or be fired.

“I would have resigned if I'd felt like I'd done something wrong,” LaFortune told the Express-News last week. “I couldn't get out of bed. It's just been this cloud. It was supposed to be the best week of my life, and I had to pull myself together for the ceremony.”

Central Catholic High School said federal law upholds the institution's decision.

“We have very clear policies on what we expect from Catholic people on our faculty, and there has been a violation of that,” Brother Peter Pontolillo told the Express-News. “When a person does something that is obviously contrary to everything that our Catholic school stands for, we cannot just look through our fingers.”

Raised in the Catholic faith, LaFortune had transferred to her fiancé's nondenominational church before the conflict unfolded, the Express-News reported.

Since Central Catholic High School regularly hires non-Catholic teachers, LaFortune argued that since she no longer attended a Catholic church, she should not be held accountable to the church's laws.

The school was not persuaded.

“Do you know what the definition of scandal is?” Pontolillo told the Express-News. “If I present myself as Catholic to an institution that's Catholic, and I practice that Catholicism in the institution by attending school Masses and receiving communion and then suddenly make a decision that is published that [I am] now going to go against that Catholicism.”

LaFortune found out on her honeymoon that her husband's previous marriage had, in fact, been annulled. She plans to fight the school's decision and file a lawsuit.[/quote]

If her new husband is non-denominational, assuming he got an annulment in a non-denominational church, I don't think that the Catholic church would automatically agree with the annulment.

I don't get the point she is trying to make with that last quote. Is she saying its scandalous that she left the Catholic church?

Has anyone else heard of this type of thing happening? A teacher at my Catholic high school was fired because she was living with her boyfriend, but she didn't sue. At my school they made the rules very clear when they hired people.

Archaeology cat
Posted

Looked like that last quote was from someone at the school, saying it was scandalous because she had presented herself as being Catholic before all this.

Snowflake3981
Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1739649' date='Dec 31 2008, 01:17 PM']Looked like that last quote was from someone at the school, saying it was scandalous because she had presented herself as being Catholic before all this.[/quote]


Ahhhh... that makes sense. Thanks!

Posted

I dont understand. If the husbands marriage was not in a Cahtolic church he would not need an annulmentbefore he married the teacher. Was their wedding even Catholic? Surely they do not fire teachers for "falling away."

Snowflake3981
Posted

[quote name='VoTeckam' post='1739683' date='Dec 31 2008, 01:38 PM']I dont understand. If the husbands marriage was not in a Cahtolic church he would not need an annulmentbefore he married the teacher. Was their wedding even Catholic? Surely they do not fire teachers for "falling away."[/quote]


It would be interesting to know more detail in this situation. I would think that the school had enough knowledge about the situation to make an appropriate decision, usually people are not fired on a whim, especially in a situation like that.

Posted

If he is Protestant, he is not required to have been married in the church before a priest. They are often more difficult to annul than Catholic marriages because Protestants are not required to jump through the hoops that Catholics are.

The scandal is not the marriage in my view, it is in her receiving communion in front of the children after marrying outside of the church. Attending the school masses, while refraining from joining in the Eucharist, would have been a lesson in humility and consequences for her students.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1739645' date='Dec 31 2008, 01:07 PM']If her new husband is non-denominational, assuming he got an annulment in a non-denominational church, I don't think that the Catholic church would automatically agree with the annulment.[/quote]

Protestant churches, at least non-denominational ones, do not grant annulments. I'm guessing, therefore, that it means that there was a Catholic declaration of annulment.

And I agree that receiving communion is a bigger issue, imho.

Posted (edited)

Why does this matter? I've been through Catholic School all my life. I think the institute is going too far. It's a bloody high school, if their theology teachers are worth anything, this wouldn't phase the kids at all. It's her life, as long as she's not attacking the church in the classroom, it should be fine.

Edited by musturde
Posted (edited)

[quote name='musturde' post='1739931' date='Dec 31 2008, 03:54 PM']Why does this matter? I've been through Catholic School all my life. I think the institute is going too far. It's a bloody high school, if their theology teachers are worth anything, this wouldn't phase the kids at all. It's her life, as long as she's not attacking the church in the classroom, it should be fine.[/quote]

I don't agree. We are all held to a standard to set an example and I would be upset that a Catholic teacher at a Catholic school was not setting that example by his or her lifestyle. Just like police officers cannot break the law while off duty neither should a Catholilc teacher break God's law so blatantly without remorse or contrition.

In our Catholic Highschool we could be expelled if we were caught drinking or smoking on the weekends and teachers which included lay, Priests and Brothers would show up at parties to catch students. Kind of apples and oranges but still shows we are responsible for our behavior even off campus after school.

Edited by socalscout
Posted

[quote name='musturde' post='1739931' date='Dec 31 2008, 03:54 PM']Why does this matter? I've been through Catholic School all my life. I think the institute is going too far. It's a bloody high school, if their theology teachers are worth anything, this wouldn't phase the kids at all. It's her life, as long as she's not attacking the church in the classroom, it should be fine.[/quote]

Over 50% of Catholics voted for Obama in the last election. One may wonder how that could happen. It happens when we are not properly catechized, and when we do not properly form our consciences. The basis of both is in our Catholic education system. We are all called to set proper examples, and teachers in our school system have to be our first line of defense. The fact that you don't find a problem with her behavior illustrates my point perfectly.

Snowflake3981
Posted

[quote name='musturde' post='1739931' date='Dec 31 2008, 04:54 PM']Why does this matter? I've been through Catholic School all my life. I think the institute is going too far. It's a bloody high school, if their theology teachers are worth anything, this wouldn't phase the kids at all. It's her life, as long as she's not attacking the church in the classroom, it should be fine.[/quote]

I agree with socalscout & CatherineM, the behavior of teachers does matter very much. Since teachers hold the minds of our youth, they should be held to high standards, especially when teaching in a school affiliated with the Catholic faith. If the teacher doesn't agree with the expectations that the Catholic school administrators dictate, they can teach in public schools.

Roamin'Catholic
Posted

This is how I see it:
It says her husband who had previously been divorced is from a nondenominational church but that his first marriage was also annuled. So I guess this means he married a Catholic and then got divorced, and then that Catholic sought and recieved an annulment of this marriage. (What's with it with this guy marrying Catholics?) I'm pretty sure nondenominational churches don't have tribunals that issue decrees of nullity, but you never know since 16 new ones are created every 30 seconds. If this is true, his divorce shouldn't matter since the Church does not recognize that holy matrimony ever occured from that first marriage and he is free to marry again. But the problem seems twofold, both of which are related to the other: first she was not married to this nondenominational man in front of a priest/deacon with two witnesses. Unless a Catholic gets permission from his/her bishop, a Catholic cannot be married outside of the Church. She never sought and recieved this permission, one can only assume. Since the Church does not recognize the marriage performed, as whom ever performed it (whether civil authority, or nondenominational pastor, or other) lacked the necessary authority to witness such a marriage, she and her new husband were now living in sin, just as if they were boyfriend and girlfriend living together. But of course the Church is great because she was probably given an option to make it all right: not to live with her new husband, but to remove herself from the occasion of sin (or at the least remove onself from receiving communion while attending mass until the confession and marriage convalidation can occur) and to get immediately in pre-Cana, make a good confession and to have her "marriage" convalidated by a priest/deacon ASAP. Once the Church convalidated her marriage, she would be free to move back with her husband and to reap the benefits and responsibilities of holy matrimony.
But she obviously refused this difficult choice as it would mean she would have to live a chaste and single life or remove herself from receiving communion (which I assume she attended a lot of masses in which she was well known by fellow parishioners and students and would feel embarrased not recieving communion for an extended period of time as she would still be required to attend mass as the obligation does not go away just because you can't recieve communion) until the convalidation could occur. This is usually a timeframe of several weeks to several months in order for marriage preparation to occur and any other necessary arrangements; and it is of course an afront to her pride which may have been the larger stumbling block for her.
Now when given the option to make the illicit situation right, if she said, "Well now I'm a member of a nondenominational church, I am no longer in union with the Bishop of Rome, I no longer recognize his spiritual authority," this would have been another huge problem. Protestantism is heresy, and she was quickly catechized on the the matter and warned of the seriousness of falling into heresy. A person is only a heretic after they have been corrected on the matter, and it is clear that the school authorities corrected her rather quickly upon finding out. Once she continued in the nondenominational church after being corrected, then the school had to take action.
So, the problem seems that she has represented herself all this time as a good and faithful Catholic teacher in order to assume and maintain her leadership position who has started living in sin, and when confronted on this due to its extreme seriousness given her leadership role as a Catholic educator she now claims she is a heretic but feels she has a right to keep her leadership position as a Catholic educator even though she lives in sin, embraces heresy and refuses to return to a state of grace. This is absolute scandal. The Church and the school cannot stand by without action. It's one thing to hire non-Catholics as educators. These people never represent themselve as Catholic. There is no scandal. It's a whole other thing to do what she did.

Posted

[quote name='Roamin'Catholic' post='1741463' date='Jan 2 2009, 01:57 PM']So, the problem seems that she has represented herself all this time as a good and faithful Catholic teacher in order to assume and maintain her leadership position who has started living in sin, and when confronted on this due to its extreme seriousness given her leadership role as a Catholic educator she now claims she is a heretic but feels she has a right to keep her leadership position as a Catholic educator even though she lives in sin, embraces heresy and refuses to return to a state of grace. This is absolute scandal. The Church and the school cannot stand by without action.[/quote]

Hear, hear! What seems so weird to me is why she didn't just fix it in the first place! If his previous marriage really had been annulled.. they could have gotten married perfectly happily in the church and none of this would have ever happened. What does it mean she found out on their honeymoon? Did she not tell him any of this until then? Were they tanning on a beach somewhere and he suddenly piped up "hey honey, BY THE WAY... you could still have your job AND me if I'd told the truth! Haha! Gotcha! Now we get to sue a school!"

Sounds fishy.

Posted

Several things about this article sound fishy.

The only clear fact is that the school gave her an ultimatum, and when she failed to meet it, fired her.

Her main dodge seems to be "I'm not Catholic anyway, so it shouldn't matter," while the school's point is "Funny, you've been receiving communion at school masses as a Catholic..."

But whether or not the school can legally fire her on these grounds, it sounds like the whole situation could have been cleared up in advance if she had made any effort to do so.


I am a single teacher at a Catholic school, and if I were to do something scandalous, I am sure my boss would fire me immediately.

Posted

It's possible the teacher's contract included a morality clause, where she is required to live according to the teachings of the Church. If so, and she violated this clause through this marriage, they are within their rights to fire her.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1741616' date='Jan 2 2009, 08:43 PM']It's possible the teacher's contract included a morality clause, where she is required to live according to the teachings of the Church. If so, and she violated this clause through this marriage, they are within their rights to fire her.[/quote]
I would think that's entirely possible. I had considered subbing at a Christian school in FL, but to do so I would have had to sign an agreement that I would never drink or smoke in public, and that I agreed with all their articles of faith (which I didn't). Had I signed that and someone had seen me having a drink at a restaurant, they would have no longer allowed me to be a sub.

Posted

IMO as a cradle Catholic who went to public school, I do think Catholic school employees should be held to a higher standard. When you are in a public position like that and are responsible for the education of children (especially young ones), you need to set an example for the Faith in both what you teach [i]and[/i] how you live.

By getting remarried she is making a statement for her students. The Church may teach remarriage without an annulment is wrong, but if people who are supposedly living the Faith don't abide by that, it causes confusion and scandal. This also goes for the Eucharist, as arch Cat and others have said...you can't be flippant about it, particularly when you serve as a role model.

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1741624' date='Jan 2 2009, 02:24 PM']I would think that's entirely possible. I had considered subbing at a Christian school in FL, but to do so I would have had to sign an agreement that I would never drink or smoke in public, and that I agreed with all their articles of faith (which I didn't). Had I signed that and someone had seen me having a drink at a restaurant, they would have no longer allowed me to be a sub.[/quote]

There's a Christian School here, that the parents have to sign such an agreement for thier kids to attend.

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

And we don't know what she taught either. That is very important.

I agree... she should have been fired. I hope she is able to find another job, and I hope she comes back to the church.

Posted

If she's saying she's not Catholic anymore, and was receiving communion, perhaps the school should counter-sue for theft--of the consecrated Eucharist.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...