Guest Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJhfQSspj2Q"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJhfQSspj2Q[/url] [mod]Title of the thread. --Era Might[/mod]
Maggyie Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 Bishop Williamson is Lefebvrist, not a Catholic.
Luthien Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 (edited) Woah woah, he is still a Catholic, just in schism. The Lefebvrists are just as Catholic as our Eastern Orthodox brothers. (The ones in schism, not the Byzantine rite). Just though I'd clear that up. Edited January 5, 2009 by Luthien
Nihil Obstat Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='Luthien' post='1743297' date='Jan 5 2009, 08:43 AM']Woah woah, he is still a Catholic, just in schism. The Lefebvrists are just as Catholic as our Eastern Orthodox brothers. (The ones in schism, not the Byzantine rite). Just though I'd clear that up. [/quote] We still consider those who are formally not in communion with the Church to still be Catholics? I didn't know that. How about the sede vacantists and stuff?
Luthien Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 They all still have valid sacraments as far as I know. They're not in full communion, but they are not totally seperate from the Church.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 He hasn't a clue, the schism has rattled his brain.
Didacus Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 My friend, who has been a priest for about 50 years told me once that all infants baptized are considered catholic since the sacrament of baptism is the only sacrament that is validly applied by protestant denominations. To my knowledge, once someone is baptized into the Catholic family, a sacrament being an indelible mark, they remain Catholic their entire lives wether they like it or not. No matter the schism within which they fall. May a Church Scholar correct me if I'm wrong.
Maggyie Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 Hmmm, I never thought of it that way... valid baptism = Catholicism... I know the Orthodox would be very deeply outraged if we called them Catholic... but being offended doesn't mean it's not true.
kujo Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 Ummm.....ya. No. Me thinks this good priest has spent too much time inhaling the incense.
CatherineM Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 I don't have fast enough speed to view youtube. Can someone explain why he thinks it was an inside job?
MichaelF Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Maggie' post='1743368' date='Jan 5 2009, 12:51 PM']Hmmm, I never thought of it that way... valid baptism = Catholicism... I know the Orthodox would be very deeply outraged if we called them Catholic... but being offended doesn't mean it's not true.[/quote] The Orthodox always describe themselves as catholic. Edited January 5, 2009 by MichaelF
CatherineM Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 There is a difference between saying all those Baptized according to the proper rite (father, son, holy spirit, not creator, redeemer, etc.) are properly baptized, and saying they are all Catholic. We don't re-baptized someone who was baptized as a child in the Methodist church when they join the Catholic Church, but we also don't automatically allow them to join without going through RCIA first. Someone who was baptized as a Catholic, is always a Catholic.
Deeds Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 It's been my observation that people in the SSPX tend to be very keen on conspiracy theories. Even by that standard, this guy is extreme. Has anyone else read his "ideas are not for true girls" letter?
HisChildForever Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='Deeds' post='1743455' date='Jan 5 2009, 02:14 PM']It's been my observation that people in the SSPX tend to be very keen on conspiracy theories. Even by that standard, this guy is extreme. Has anyone else read his "ideas are not for true girls" letter?[/quote] Something about women "distracting" men in university as one of the reasons why they should not attend, correct? A nice little letter which, if followed, would ensure a woman's complete dependence on men.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='Didacus' post='1743332' date='Jan 5 2009, 12:56 PM']My friend, who has been a priest for about 50 years told me once that all infants baptized are considered catholic since the sacrament of baptism is the only sacrament that is validly applied by protestant denominations. To my knowledge, once someone is baptized into the Catholic family, a sacrament being an indelible mark, they remain Catholic their entire lives wether they like it or not. No matter the schism within which they fall. May a Church Scholar correct me if I'm wrong. [/quote] This depends on the form of Baptism used. It has to be "I baptise in the Name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit".
Didacus Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1743462' date='Jan 5 2009, 03:23 PM']This depends on the form of Baptism used. It has to be "I baptise in the Name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit".[/quote] But that being done the rest as I stated would be correct? Once a Catholic, always a Catholic - that much I do know with certainty. One cannot deny their Catholicism once formally baptized Catholic; no matter what! (I may not know much, but that much I know)
cmotherofpirl Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='Didacus' post='1743491' date='Jan 5 2009, 03:57 PM']But that being done the rest as I stated would be correct? Once a Catholic, always a Catholic - that much I do know with certainty. One cannot deny their Catholicism once formally baptized Catholic; no matter what! (I may not know much, but that much I know)[/quote] Sure they can - simply get rebaptised in a protestant group or send a formal renunciation letter to your priest/bishop.
Guest Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1743382' date='Jan 5 2009, 01:59 PM']I don't have fast enough speed to view youtube. Can someone explain why he thinks it was an inside job?[/quote] im not really sure exactly. i didnt listen closely to the whole thing. i just got highspeed interent so i can finally watch youtube. lol some crazy stuff on here.
DevotedtoHim Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 I just found one of their churces is near me. Are we (meaning practicing Catholics in communion with the Church) allowed to go? I asked them and they said yes. Does anybody know?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 5, 2009 Posted January 5, 2009 Baptism, which belongs to the Catholic Church, makes a person Catholic, so long as it is done validly. The character of the sacrament remains whether a person practices the faith or not (this teaching goes back to the Early Church Fathers). So the question is whether by "Catholic" you mean "by character" or "by practice." For practicality's sake, I don't call someone a Catholic if they're not practicing, just the same as I wouldn't call someone in hell a Christian simply because they have the sacramental character (which is the ultimate end of the matter in question, afterall, without assuming judgment on any particular cases of individual souls). By character, they belong to the one, holy, catholic, apostolic Church. By practice, many SSPX schismatics do not believe in the whole faith (leaving behind things they consider falsely to be Vatican II innovations), and are therefore not catholic in the truest sense of the word, since "catholic" means "according to the whole," but that would be on a case-by-case basis.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now