johnnydigit Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 anyone familiar with the National Catholic Reporter? i stumbled on this article and i find it appalling to be on a "Catholic" website. "Authors say church got it wrong by emphasizing crucifixion By DOUGLAS TODD, Religion News Service" [url="http://ncronline3.org/drupal/?q=node/2369"]http://ncronline3.org/drupal/?q=node/2369[/url] " SAVING PARADISE: HOW CHRISTIANITY TRADED LOVE OF THIS WORLD FOR CRUCIFIXION AND EMPIRE by Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Ann Parker Beacon Press,592 pages, $34.95 "It took Jesus a thousand years to die. Images of his corpse did not appear in churches until the tenth century." Those are the provocative opening sentences of the new book, Saving Paradise: How Christianity Traded Love of This World for Crucifixion and Empire (Beacon Press), by Protestant scholars Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Ann Parker. Saving Paradise turns upside down the history of the church's view of Jesus' crucifixion and its stress on the importance of suffering. The authors attempt to show that for the first thousand years of its existence, the Christian church placed much more emphasis on the resurrection and paradise than the crucifixion. "
Archaeology cat Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 (edited) nvm Edited January 6, 2009 by Archaeology cat
Maximilianus Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 Ah, the National Catholic Distorter... See [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/reviews/view.cfm?recnum=60&repos=2&subrepos=0&searchid=383457"]THIS[/url]
StColette Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 Reporter - Bad Register - Good [url="http://www.ncregister.com/"]http://www.ncregister.com/[/url]
MithLuin Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 I agree that the book shows (according to this review) woeful ignorance about Christian history. However, I do not see why a controversial book cannot be [i]reviewed[/i], simply that it should not be reviewed so uncritically. The review seeks to inform the reader of what the book claims, but makes little (read [i]no[/i]) effort to analyze any part of this thesis. For that, it is sloppy journalism. As for the point, it is certainly true that the first millenium of Christianity spent its time near the transcendental pole, while in the second millenium the pendulum has swung towards the incarnational pole. But at NO POINT in Christian history was either the death or resurrection of Jesus ignored. Martyrdom was cherished specifically because it sped you towards your heavenly home in early Christianity - thus, it was not the happiness of this life the Christians valued, but that of the next life. It was not Charlemagne who made martyrdom popular; that predated him by several hundred years. Say, 800 . Here is what I have posted on the comments there: [quote]Yes, their comment on the content of the art is correct, but their interpretation of why it is that way (or what is attributed to them according to this review) is not correct. The emphasis in the first millenium of Christianity was on the Transcendant, Christ Resurrected and returning in power. So, if he were depicted crucified, it was as a triumphant lord. Read anything written in the early medieval period and you will see this depiction. The idea of a 'weak God', one who allowed himself to suffer or be killed, did not work in a constantly warring society (or in attempts to convert the pagans of northern Europe). So the emphasis was on the Resurrection and Heaven - not this life, but the next one. Jesus may not have been depicted as dead on the cross, but he *was* depicted on his throne in Judgement. About the year 1000, there was a shift towards emphasis on the Incarnation. Jesus was a human being, not just a transcendant God. (Obviously, he is both, and orthodox Christianity has always affirmed both points - it has only ever been a matter of emphasis). From this point on, we start to see a suffering and dying Jesus on the Cross, but we also get St. Francis' nativity scene. It was okay to think of Jesus as a baby, or as someone who stumbled on his way to the cross. Martyrdom has been praised (and practiced) since the beginning of Christianity, and certainly has nothing to do with Charlemagne. If either the Transcendental or the Incarnational are ignored or distored, the practice of Christianity suffers (and presumably, the artwork). The goal is not to swing towards one extreme or the other, but to retain what is helpful from both aspects of our concept of Christ (divine and human) while avoiding the errors particular to one side or the other.[/quote]
cmotherofpirl Posted January 6, 2009 Posted January 6, 2009 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1744247' date='Jan 6 2009, 02:19 AM']anyone familiar with the National Catholic Reporter? i stumbled on this article and i find it appalling to be on a "Catholic" website. "Authors say church got it wrong by emphasizing crucifixion By DOUGLAS TODD, Religion News Service" [url="http://ncronline3.org/drupal/?q=node/2369"]http://ncronline3.org/drupal/?q=node/2369[/url] " SAVING PARADISE: HOW CHRISTIANITY TRADED LOVE OF THIS WORLD FOR CRUCIFIXION AND EMPIRE by Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Ann Parker Beacon Press,592 pages, $34.95 "It took Jesus a thousand years to die. Images of his corpse did not appear in churches until the tenth century." Those are the provocative opening sentences of the new book, Saving Paradise: How Christianity Traded Love of This World for Crucifixion and Empire (Beacon Press), by Protestant scholars Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Ann Parker. Saving Paradise turns upside down the history of the church's view of Jesus' crucifixion and its stress on the importance of suffering. The authors attempt to show that for the first thousand years of its existence, the Christian church placed much more emphasis on the resurrection and paradise than the crucifixion. "[/quote] National Catholic Reporter is not known to be faithful to the Church.
Ziggamafu Posted January 7, 2009 Posted January 7, 2009 Good subscriptions: [i] New Oxford Review St. Austin Review First Things National Catholic Register This Rock[/i] Scott Hahn puts out an annual theological journal called[i] Letter & Spirit [/i]which is excellent. Others, like the [i]NCR[/i], [i]Catholic Digest[/i], and [i]America[/i] can have very good content, but more often than not seem to challenge or outright contradict Church teaching. I do enjoy them for educational purposes, however; it is good to know the mind and heart of a person with opposing viewpoints.
MithLuin Posted January 7, 2009 Posted January 7, 2009 I remember when [i]Catholic Digest[/i] did their story on the election of Pope Benedict, they (along with the mainstream secular media) ran to get Hans Kung's reaction. I was a little sad that they couldn't do any better than that.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 7, 2009 Posted January 7, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1744832' date='Jan 6 2009, 11:28 PM']I remember when [i]Catholic Digest[/i] did their story on the election of Pope Benedict, they (along with the mainstream secular media) ran to get Hans Kung's reaction. I was a little sad that they couldn't do any better than that.[/quote] That is typical and why I stopped reading them years ago.
johnnydigit Posted January 7, 2009 Author Posted January 7, 2009 [quote name='Maximilianus' post='1744295' date='Jan 6 2009, 03:06 AM']Ah, the National Catholic Distorter... See [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/culture/reviews/view.cfm?recnum=60&repos=2&subrepos=0&searchid=383457"]THIS[/url][/quote] thank goodness for that review site. "DANGER" list, and why [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resultslist.cfm?resourcetype=2&requesttype=sitebrowserate&fidelity=red&resources=0&useability=0"]http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resu...mp;useability=0[/url] i was surprised to see some sites on there, but the reasons seem valid. yikes, there's even some religious community sites there, some which i've been approached by already.. this list is hardcore! top rated list [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resultslist.cfm?resourcetype=2&requesttype=sitebrowserate&fidelity=green&resources=Excellent&useability=%2B"]http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resu...;useability=%2B[/url] are these in any of the resource lists or defense directory? these should be pinned!
CatherineM Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 To be honest, I haven't read the Catholic Digest or NCR in years. Just couldn't afford them anymore. I had no idea they had gotten so far left.
Innocent Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 At first I had trouble remembering which was the orthodox paper Reporter or Register. Then I read someone in one blog mention (just as Maximilianus has said) that he used as a mnemonic the fact that Reporter rhymed well with Distorter! Nowadays I don't pay attention to anything from the Reporter (unless it's written by John Allen Jr. - though it's certainly possible that there may be other orthodox staff on thr Reporter than John Allen. I just don't know about them yet.)
MithLuin Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 (edited) [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1745083' date='Jan 7 2009, 03:34 AM']thank goodness for that review site. "DANGER" list, and why [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resultslist.cfm?resourcetype=2&requesttype=sitebrowserate&fidelity=red&resources=0&useability=0"]http://www.catholicculture.org/search/resu...mp;useability=0[/url] i was surprised to see some sites on there, but the reasons seem valid. yikes, there's even some religious community sites there, some which i've been approached by already.. this list is hardcore![/quote] I agree, and think it is a bit too hardcore. For instance, [url="http://www.cnvs.org"]Catholic Network of Volunteer Services[/url] made the danger list, basically for not being strictly a Catholic group. But they don't make any claim that the volunteer organizations listed in their directory are all Catholic, and specifically mention the affiliation of each. If you want to search for Catholic groups using their Response Directory, you can. If you want to find other groups there, you can too. It's a network, so it makes sense that it has a broad scope. Basically, if you want to find a good orthodox group to do volunteer work with, you are going to have to put a bit of effort in to checking out the group - but you should do that anyway! Since they don't [i]claim[/i] to be a listing of groups that are hardcore Catholic, they are not dishonest or misleading, and probably shouldn't be on the danger list. I am willing to allow people to exercise their own judgement a bit more, I guess. Edited January 10, 2009 by MithLuin
johnnydigit Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 i bet they could find an error on vatican.va!
Brother Adam Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='johnnydigit' post='1748557' date='Jan 11 2009, 01:27 AM']i bet they could find an error on vatican.va![/quote] No.
MithLuin Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 No one is suggesting that there [i]is[/i] an error on the Vatican's webpage, merely that some of the criteria to make this list seems to be 'guilt by association', so the fact that controversial theologians who have been censored by the Vatican are named on their website (as part of the censure ) would seem to 'qualify' here. I see no problem with alerting Catholics to groups that are not faithful to Church teachings, etc. The NCR articles linked speak for themselves, and I do not question their inclusion on a list of ostensibly Catholic groups that are way off base. I just think that this particular list goes a bit beyond that scope to the point of 'groups we don't like/disagree with'.
Fr. Antony Maria OSB Posted January 14, 2009 Posted January 14, 2009 This doesn't have as much to do with this topic, but I'm fairly positive that I'm going to subscribe to the Register, and I was wondering what day it comes out? I'm moving back to college next week, so I don't want to order it and then have to change my address in time for the next issue, lol!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now