Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Preemptive Strike On The Fairness Doctrine?


Recommended Posts

Posted

(I continued this in a thread I started on the debate table.)

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1746669' date='Jan 8 2009, 10:55 PM']Regulating on basis of political content is contrary to the entire spirit of the free speech clause of the first amendment, which was intended to guarantee free [i]political[/i] speech against government regulation and censorship (which was actually a revolutionary idea at the time).[/quote]

That right is firmly established, but the public also has a right to regulate their airwaves. There is an important difference between Michael Savage spewing his vitriolic hatred against minorities in a book (despicable but protected) and the public airwaves to do it, to force that group to subsidize their savage demonization




[quote]If he was really so racist, it seems he would have been pulled by now - note how one racially-insensitive slip-up apiece got Don Imus and Doug "Greaseman" Tracht respectively yanked off the air.[/quote]

lol, have you ever listened to him? Forget about racism however about his hateful diatribe about children with autism?

[quote]The internet's also "public" - as in its accessible to the general public without special payment.
Would you support similar government regulation of political websites and blogs?[/quote]

internet is quite different, and no, no I would not.



[quote]We'll grant for argument's sake that Savage (whom I'm not that familiar with) is every bit as vile and offensive as you claim.
That still doesn't make the so-called "Fairness Doctrine" right on principle.
The FD isn't about censoring racism, but specifically about regulating the political content of programming - ensuring that every programming voicing political opinion must also contain opposing views or go off the air.[/quote]

Yes, it's about protecting the public's airwaves from being used as a means to spew angry political propaganda.

[quote]The FD wouldn't just take Michael Savage off the air, but [i]every[/i] conservative (or liberal, for that matter, at least in theory) talk show host. Thus the FD being nick-named the "Hush Rush Bill" in the '90s. (And no, unlike you, I don't consider all conservative talk-show hosts to be racist bigots.)[/quote]

I don't consider all conservative talk show hosts racists, what's with all the assumptions about me and liberals on this thread? Who nicknamed it the "Hate Rush Bill"?

Posted

[quote]I don't have a problem with the FCC censoring offensive or racist language per se, but I [i]do[/i] have a problem with government regulation of the political content of radio and television programming[/quote]

Racist language is political content. If I went on the air, not XM radio but the public airwaves, should you be forced to subsidize my advocacy of rounding up Catholicons and putting them in concentration camps?


[quote]The public already has the power to regulate content by what they choose to listen to.[/quote]

Yep, and per the FCC they also have the power to regulate it directly. Why you find this somehow inferior to some indirect, sluggish indirect coercion I don't understand.

[quote]Talk radio simply fulfills consumer demand. Rush Limbaugh, etc. became big in talk radio because a lot of people liked listening to him. Commercial radio's based on ratings. If people like to listen to a show, ratings will be high, and it stays on the air. If the people don't want to listen, ratings will drop, sponsors will withdraw, and the show will be off the air.
Free speech through free markets is in fact much more "democratic" and responsive to public demand than having government officials dictate what political content can and can't be on the air.[/quote]

So if a NBC "30 Rock" show breaks out in angry, hard core gay pornography you'd be fine with it as the public can indirectly regulate the content of their own airwaves through viewer aversion? I doubt it.

[quote]Your idea of the "will of the people" seems to come straight out of Soviet Russia.[/quote]

Only if you don't understand the difference between the two government structures. One is an elected representative, subject to impeachment and reelection and limited term lengths and responsive to public opinion, and the other is a dictatorship of the proletariat, unaccountable to the public through popular elections, establishing to what it contends to be the will of the people or what is for their own good even if they don't understand how.

Posted

[quote]Who determines what is "propaganda," what is "hatred," and what is "angry"? (Geez, is the [i]emotional[/i] content of radio programming now also to be regulated by the government?)[/quote]

It's a popular judgment

[quote]Obviously, we, and many other people will strongly disagree on this very subjective matter.
Perhaps it's for the listeners, not the government, to make such decisions.[/quote]

No, it's for the public at large to decide, not a small subset of the population. The show is not accountable to the popular will, but simply needs the support of enough individuals to make them economically viable, which is a small subset of the population.

[quote]And do you really trust government officials to be completely unfair and unbiased in their own decisions?
If so, I find your naivete charming, if sad.[/quote]

Are you under some impression that such officials exist in a political vacuum with no accountability to the larger public?

[quote]Quite frankly I do not want Obama, or his appointees, determining what political programming is and isn't fit for me to hear. (Any more than you'd want the Bush adminstration determining the same for you, I'm sure).[/quote]

That’s not what they are determining, but the content of the public airwaves.


[quote]And I'm sure millions of talk-radio fans would strongly disagree about the USSC representing the "will of the people"![/quote]

They do not represent "the will of the people" but a subset of it. If the elected representatives, supported by the larger public, reinstate the FD then by definition it is the "will of the people".


[quote]Obviously, I disagree with the decision of the USSC.[/quote]

Why? You don't deny the government has a right to regulate the public airwaves, you simply don't like this regulation.



[quote]Liberals are usually the first to defend "free speech" (usually if involving offensive sexual content) from censorship of any kind, yet are quick to demand government regulation of political speech they disagree with.[/quote]

And many liberals don't agree with this. I very much disagree with my very liberal Public Policy and the Media professor who very much disagreed with the fairness doctrine.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hassan' post='1745755' date='Jan 8 2009, 12:25 AM']Conservatives all make sweeping, unsubstantiated statements and can be assigned universal agency because there are a homogenous body with no differences amongst them.

:unsure:[/quote]
how is what you say on a e-forum, like this alright and talk radio is not?
talk radio free speech
e-forum is free speach
is this a fairness or a censorship doctrine

Edited by apparently
Posted

[quote name='apparently' post='1746767' date='Jan 9 2009, 12:09 AM']how is what you say on a e-forum, like this alright and talk radio is not?
talk radio free speech
e-forum is free speach
is this a fairness or a censorship doctrine[/quote]


I was saying that satirically

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hassan' post='1746771' date='Jan 9 2009, 12:14 AM']I was saying that satirically[/quote]

[quote]public airwaves should not be used by extremists to propagandize.[/quote]
really!

Edited by apparently
Posted

[quote name='apparently' post='1746789' date='Jan 9 2009, 12:29 AM']really![/quote]

i don't understand your point

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1746751' date='Jan 8 2009, 11:45 PM']That right is firmly established, but the public also has a right to regulate their airwaves.[/quote]
Meaning: The State has the right, even the duty, to regulate public speech.

By your reasoning if someone wanted to organize a public rally for, lets say some anti-war cause, the State should first require them to also organize a rally in support of the given conflict. After all, it's the public street or sidewalk that they wish to be assembling on.

Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1746813' date='Jan 9 2009, 12:53 AM']Meaning: The State has the right, even the duty, to regulate public speech.[/quote]

No, the state has a right to regulate the public airwaves.

[quote]By your reasoning if someone wanted to organize a public rally for, lets say some anti-war cause, the State should first require them to also organize a rally in support of the given conflict. After all, it's the public street or sidewalk that they wish to be assembling on.[/quote]

The constitution is on of enumerate powers and protections not decursive reasoning from a very few key assumptions. The right of individuals to petition their government for a redress of grievances is, and ought to be, a fairly sacrosanct right in American political discourse.

I see your point though and it is a very interesting one I will give a lot of thought to. Please take the above as simply provisional and we look at this.

Posted (edited)

I'd go a little further LD and say that yours is a really, really good point. It seems like the same logic. I'll really think about this a lot.

thanks

Edited by Hassan
Posted

I'm not as sure that's as good a point as I thought it was last night, but I also feel like my position is weaker than I thought it was last night.

so I'm still thinking it over. Have you ever read Robert Nozick?

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1747795' date='Jan 9 2009, 11:05 PM']Have you ever read Robert Nozick?[/quote]
No, I haven't. You recommend him?

Posted

I'm reading about Nozick right now, and I'm interested.

Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1747881' date='Jan 10 2009, 12:36 AM']I'm reading about Nozick right now, and I'm interested.[/quote]


yeah, I have skimmed some of his books. I've never really had time to sit down and study political philosophy but he seems interesting

Posted

I've posted my responses to Hassan in the Debate Table.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...