lost_in_this_world Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 so i am very pro-life but i cannot understand this concept and maybe you guys can explain it. when a doctor becomes a doctor, they take the hippocratic oath correct? that states that they will not kill people in summary. so how can they take this oath and then perform abortions or terminate life in any form? it just doesnt make sense. to me.
dominicansoul Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 it's become a [i]hypocritic[/i] oath now...
LouisvilleFan Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 For one, the abortion clause is no longer included in the modern Hippocratic Oath. Thus, the ethics of abortion and related procedures depends on each doctor's opinion of when life begins. I suppose they perform some similar logic gymnastics for euthenasia.
HisChildForever Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 [quote name='lost_in_this_world' post='1746241' date='Jan 8 2009, 03:12 PM']so i am very pro-life but i cannot understand this concept and maybe you guys can explain it. when a doctor becomes a doctor, they take the hippocratic oath correct? that states that they will not kill people in summary. so how can they take this oath and then perform abortions or terminate life in any form? it just doesnt make sense. to me.[/quote] Correct me if I am wrong, but since abortion is legal (for the most part), it is not considered murder. The same applies to euthanasia because this is "mercy killing" and the patient (or willing victim I should say) signs the papers so the doctors or hospital does not get into trouble. By "they will not kill people in summary" I think they mean if a drunk driver comes into the ER, along with the two children he hit along the way, and the children end up dying, the doctor cannot withhold treatment or do anything to prevent saving the driver's life (in other words cannot take justice into their own hands or respond subjectively).
CatherineM Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 The doctor's who perform abortions don't think they are taking a life, or they just don't care. Either way, they aren't worried about their oath. Lawyer's take oaths too, but lots violate them.
StColette Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1746247' date='Jan 8 2009, 03:17 PM']For one, the abortion clause is no longer included in the modern Hippocratic Oath.[/quote] Yep [quote name='CatherineM' post='1746286' date='Jan 8 2009, 03:45 PM']The doctor's who perform abortions don't think they are taking a life, or they just don't care. Either way, they aren't worried about their oath.[/quote] Exactly!
dominicansoul Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 i find it totally hard to believe that these educated men of science and biology DO NOT think they are taking a life! they know EXACTLY what they are doing! that's what makes abortion so evil. they know it is the taking of life, but they have found a way to justify it in their own minds and souls... (and mostly in their wallets...)
CatherineM Posted January 8, 2009 Posted January 8, 2009 It is about money. Morgentaller here in Canada is a prime example. He's a Holocaust survivor, doing to women what the Nazi's had done to his people. He says he fought for abortion rights all for the sake of women. He once lost his license to practice medicine (which should have automatically disqualified him for the Order of Canada, but that's another fight). He lost it because he got caught re-using disposable medical supplies. Why would any doctor re-use a disposable product? Easy, to save money. Who is hurt? The women he keeps saying he is so interested in helping. He risked the health of his patients for money. That tells you everything you need to know. By the way, I'm not talking about paper gowns either, I'm talking about things that are disposable for a reason in an OB practice.
lost_in_this_world Posted January 8, 2009 Author Posted January 8, 2009 lol thanks and sorry for the misspelling
cmotherofpirl Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1746249' date='Jan 8 2009, 04:18 PM']Correct me if I am wrong, but since abortion is legal (for the most part), it is not considered murder. The same applies to euthanasia because this is "mercy killing" and the patient (or willing victim I should say) signs the papers so the doctors or hospital does not get into trouble. By "they will not kill people in summary" I think they mean if a drunk driver comes into the ER, along with the two children he hit along the way, and the children end up dying, the doctor cannot withhold treatment or do anything to prevent saving the driver's life (in other words cannot take justice into their own hands or respond subjectively).[/quote] It doesn't matter if its legal or not, it doesn't change the fact it is murder.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 If I become a doctor (as has been my dream and intent for many years now), will I be required to perform abortions? Or even to learn about them? I hope not... but knowing our (lack of) abortion law up here... I'd have to have some sort of protest. Anyone wanna join...? In five years or so?
CatherineM Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1746840' date='Jan 8 2009, 11:21 PM']If I become a doctor (as has been my dream and intent for many years now), will I be required to perform abortions? Or even to learn about them? I hope not... but knowing our (lack of) abortion law up here... I'd have to have some sort of protest. Anyone wanna join...? In five years or so?[/quote] That's a good question. I wonder if you could morally object. I wonder if the procedure is taught in med schools attached to catholic universities? The problem is the a basic D&C is also standard for some other regular gyn problems. Kind of like the pill being used for other stuff. I guess you could go into dermatology.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1746849' date='Jan 8 2009, 11:29 PM']That's a good question. I wonder if you could morally object. I wonder if the procedure is taught in med schools attached to catholic universities? The problem is the a basic D&C is also standard for some other regular gyn problems. Kind of like the pill being used for other stuff. I guess you could go into dermatology.[/quote] My dream/goal is ophthalmology... which is pretty far removed. Only troble is I have to go through all four years of med school before specializing. They try to teach a bit of everything in those four years, as far as I know. ...but in any case, the current plan doesn't even have anything to do with Catholic universities. I'm not interested in leaving home quite yet; want to be more self sufficient first. So maybe I'll have to check this out. I'd find it repulsive even learning how to do the procedure on grapefruits and garbage like that.
CatherineM Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1746863' date='Jan 8 2009, 11:36 PM']My dream/goal is ophthalmology... which is pretty far removed. Only troble is I have to go through all four years of med school before specializing. They try to teach a bit of everything in those four years, as far as I know. ...but in any case, the current plan doesn't even have anything to do with Catholic universities. I'm not interested in leaving home quite yet; want to be more self sufficient first. So maybe I'll have to check this out. I'd find it repulsive even learning how to do the procedure on grapefruits and garbage like that.[/quote] My great-uncle was an eye, ear, nose and throat doctor, back before they split those specialties. He was basically a small town doctor in Kansas that did a bit of everything. He went to school in Austria. That was right after he served in WWI, so that's about as far away from the farm in Oklahoma as he could get. My grandmother, his baby sister, had a mole on her nose that looked like it could get cancerous, and he used to send her a chunk or radium to tape to her nose every now and then to get rid of it, by US mail. Man, have times changed.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1746875' date='Jan 8 2009, 11:51 PM']My great-uncle was an eye, ear, nose and throat doctor, back before they split those specialties. He was basically a small town doctor in Kansas that did a bit of everything. He went to school in Austria. That was right after he served in WWI, so that's about as far away from the farm in Oklahoma as he could get. My grandmother, his baby sister, had a mole on her nose that looked like it could get cancerous, and he used to send her a chunk or radium to tape to her nose every now and then to get rid of it, by US mail. Man, have times changed.[/quote] That is one of the more awesome things I've heard this week! I love eyes. Have no idea why. I'd also get to play with lasers. How neat! Something about performing surgery to save someone from or reverse blindness or potential blindness seems... almost miraculous to me.
Fidei Defensor Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1746606' date='Jan 8 2009, 08:15 PM']It doesn't matter if its legal or not, it doesn't change the fact it is murder.[/quote] Yeah, yeah. Same old drivel. Refusing to even acknowledge the other side doesn't mean you're right, it makes you a horrible critical thinker. You don't have to agree with the other point of view, but you do need to realize that there is another point of view outside your own. Edited January 9, 2009 by fidei defensor
LouisvilleFan Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1746286' date='Jan 8 2009, 04:45 PM']The doctor's who perform abortions don't think they are taking a life, or they just don't care. Either way, they aren't worried about their oath. Lawyer's take oaths too, but lots violate them.[/quote] If you've read "Swear to God" by Scott Hahn, there is a reason for the oaths and their relationship to the sacraments is pretty interesting. Still, I think most medical and legal professionals are exactly that: professionals. They want to do the right thing and obey their oaths because what they do for a living is more than a job or a career, it's a vocation that forms part of their identity. Doctors and lawyers get a bad rep because of the few who make headlines, but the vast majority are out there doing good work for society. [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1746319' date='Jan 8 2009, 05:24 PM']i find it totally hard to believe that these educated men of science and biology DO NOT think they are taking a life! they know EXACTLY what they are doing! that's what makes abortion so evil. they know it is the taking of life, but they have found a way to justify it in their own minds and souls... (and mostly in their wallets...)[/quote] It is entirely possible that educated people are blind to the truth. Philosophically speaking, nearly anything can be rationalized when you don't believe in the existence of eternal souls. I'm not sure if I buy the profit argument. I wonder if that isn't just a way to gain a few profit-hating liberals by degrading the industry more than the sin. Seems to me that an OB/GYN should be able to make just as much money or more without performing abortions. [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1746840' date='Jan 9 2009, 01:21 AM']If I become a doctor (as has been my dream and intent for many years now), will I be required to perform abortions? Or even to learn about them? I hope not... but knowing our (lack of) abortion law up here... I'd have to have some sort of protest. Anyone wanna join...? In five years or so?[/quote] They can take away your license, put you in prison, and they could even take your life, but they can't make you perform an abortion. [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1746863' date='Jan 9 2009, 01:36 AM']My dream/goal is ophthalmology... which is pretty far removed.[/quote] Oddly enough... the two medical practices sitting on each side of the abortion provider in Louisville are ophthalmologists. I can't help but wonder who really needs their eyes checked...
HisChildForever Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1746606' date='Jan 8 2009, 09:15 PM']It doesn't matter if its legal or not, it doesn't change the fact it is murder.[/quote] I am aware of that.
CatherineM Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1747109' date='Jan 9 2009, 09:46 AM']If you've read "Swear to God" by Scott Hahn, there is a reason for the oaths and their relationship to the sacraments is pretty interesting. Still, I think most medical and legal professionals are exactly that: professionals. They want to do the right thing and obey their oaths because what they do for a living is more than a job or a career, it's a vocation that forms part of their identity. Doctors and lawyers get a bad rep because of the few who make headlines, but the vast majority are out there doing good work for society.[/quote] When I was in law school, we were discussing the oath that people take before testifying. The professor said that its real purpose was to make the witness stop and realize the importance of what they were doing. He said in all the criminal trials he was involved in with the exception of girlfriends and moms, very few people lie outside of the defendants. I know the one time I was a witness, I had been in court many times, but when they went to give me that oath, I did catch myself stopping, and really reflecting on why I was there, and on what I needed to do. Even today, I haven't had a license to practice law in years, but I still follow my oath.
Winchester Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 Because people have free will. And they are jerks.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now