cheryl Posted January 9, 2009 Posted January 9, 2009 (edited) The previous thread can be found [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=88974&pid=1740771&mode=threaded&start=#entry1740771"]here[/url]. "Ziggamafu" asked me if I could, [quote]"detail Church teaching on salvation and the Judgment as you understand it so that we can see if something needs to be corrected?".[/quote] I thought given the nature of my response to his question, as well as others asked in the same thread, it might be better to begin a new thread. I want to begin by saying, that I am not wanting to argue or change anyone else's mind. All I want for myself is the freedom to obey my conscience. This doesn't mean that I am thus free from engaging Church teaching in the hope that my conscience may be put to rest. I've realized having spoken with my priest, reading authors like John Henry Newman, and praying these past few weeks, that being Catholic runs much deeper than mere issues of doctrine. When I asked my priest, "What makes a person Catholic as opposed to not?" He smiled, "Mary has a hold on you...you've experienced a mother's love....it's in your bones." As an analogy, I belong to my family, even on those days I flatly disagree with my mother on a particular matter. I don't cease being her daughter and she doesn't cease being my mother (with all the authority that entails) and usually we can work things out. I had always wanted to be Catholic. To say, "I am Catholic" is analogous to saying, "I am me". It is not something external to me. It is who I am, but I felt as if I had to check off on such and such doctrines in order to truly be Catholic. I had to agree with everything--knowing that I was not yet at that point spiritually. I lamented that fact--I pushed myself past my own limits. If I have learned anything, I have learned that no amount of books, arguments, ect can make one this or that---not truly. It may help in some small way--but only grace, infused into one's soul, can create a person. One doesn't decide to become Catholic, like someone decides to move from the congested city to the open air of the country. One is made Catholic, by the hand of the Almighty Creator through grace. Even when one is confused and their conscience is ill at ease, this too is part of the creative process--this too is necessary. I have learned that it's best to just let things be--don't retreat from what you are being molded into by saying, "I can't become Catholic"--to become anything worthy is a matter of grace--not willpower. And don't try to rush ahead saying, "I'll buy this book...this will help...I'll think on this...then I'll see." Remain where you are---only God knows what kind of Catholic He wants to make you. Just know, that it's enough to say, "I'm becoming Catholic". Indeed, no one is truly Catholic this side of heaven. We are all in the state of "becoming". I think this post is worth pondering: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=88974&pid=1744268&mode=threaded&start=#entry1744268"]"johnnydigit"[/url] ---------- In direct answer to ""Ziggamafu" question. The Church's teaching of salvation and judgment encompasses, grace, freewill/cooperation, divine providence, purgation, communion (of friends and family (both earthly and heavenly)) ect. To say more than that would be overwhelming, there is so much that can be said. The Church's teaching is inexhaustible, continually giving rise to new insights and questions. That's why we ought to be gentle with ourselves when it comes to the issue of personal assent. There will always be something that doesn't seem quite right until new light is shed. In reading the responses of the previous thread, one of the things which concerns me, is the affirmation of certain doctrines at the expense of others. For example, freewill is true enough, but it must be understood in light of divine providence and visa versa. The doctrine of divine providence was never really mentioned (with the exception of possible illusions by some). We can't isolate any doctrine from the whole. A particular example is "frenchfry's" response: [quote]The way that I see it, it's not about finding a church with doctrines that make you feel good - it's about finding one that has the truth, [u]like it or not[/u]. When I converted, I went along for a certain amount of time examining one doctrine after another, but after a certain point I realized that I was never going to accept certain teachings on any argument but the authority of the Church. So it came down to, does it or doesn't it have this authority? If it does, you must accept everything as coming from the Holy Spirit. [u]Even if you don't like it - especially if you don't like it[/u]. For me, it was a matter of humility and realizing that there may be something out there bigger than my little brain and my little heart who could direct them both.[/quote] (emphasis mine) Here, Church authority is being defended (which is good), but seemingly at the expense of the Church's teaching on the nature and role of conscience (which is not good). I'm actually at a loss trying to understand how one can truly assent to something, "that they don't like". I tried that for many years actually-the emotional and spiritual damage it caused is still something I am recovering from. Regarding the specific doctrinal issues which gave rise to the previous thread, let me back up a bit. We were discussing two to be exact. 1)The distinction between mortal and venial sin. 2) Christ's descent into hell. As for the first, let me say in response to some, that on some level, I believe there to be a distinction of sin. I think we can all agree that a child disobeying their parents is not on the same level as Hitler's concentration camp. But here I feel it necessary to interject two very important components to this issue. 1) mortal and venial sin, are not, as St Aquinas would put it, "two species of one genus". In other words, we are not dealing with a category called, "sin" which is then divided into the greater and lesser. 2)It's fairly popular to assert (although I don't know if this is more than pious opinion) that one cannot know for certain whether they have committed mortal sin, because no one but God truly knows our hearts-He penetrates deeper than even we ourselves can. The problem I experience with the issue of mortal sin (and also the loss of salvation) has less to do with theology** and more to do with practicality (although the practical informs my theology-hence my struggle). I am not at all sure how to incorporate the distinction of mortal and venial sin into my everyday life-into my personal spirituality. When I am in the presence of God, or the saints, especially the Eucharist, all recollection of sin has disappeared. I don't even think about sin, much less the distinctions thereof. And when I do sin, I immediately resolve to go to Confession, so it's a non-issue. My focus is not to rid myself of mortal sin, but to rid myself of all sin. Distinctions don't matter, it's enough to know I have sinned and that I need to be cleansed. In fact, the closer I come to Christ, the more horrible even everyday sins become. In light of Christ's perfection, all sin is so very repugnant to me. The question of whether one can loose their salvation is a very complicated one for me--one which extends way beyond the issue of freewill. In fact I will go so far as to repeat the sentiment of some that loss of salvation is not the use of freewill (properly so-called), but the abuse of that freedom. For instance both God and the saints in heaven possess freewill, and yet we can be assured that they will never sin. So although freewill does in some sense enter into the question of, "Can one loose their salvation?" It is not a logical syllogism. Again, on the practical level, the closer to Christ I become the more I see him in others (this to me is grace-even sanctifying grace, although the person themselves may be unaffected by it). In fact, as odd as it sounds, the worse the sinner, the greater I see Christ (albeit the suffering Christ, taking on their sins as they are committing them). Before I ask, "Can one loose their salvation?" I must determine what salvation is. Since I believe salvation is in part to be in the presence of Christ, I must consider the additional question, "Can someone not be in the presence of Christ and still be a "someone"?" This is part of what gives rise to my struggle with the idea of an existence in hell (when hell is defined as complete separation from God). Due to our creatureliness (our dependence on the Creator for our existence), it would seem that to whatever degree any one exist anywhere, to that degree the Creator must be present (and indeed even in mortal sin, Christ still exist in the person, as St. Therese of Avila tells us in, "The Enterior Castle"). Which leads me to the issue of Christ's descent into hell. The question for me is not, "Can there exist a person who remains at odds with God for eternity?" Indeed that's between them and God. Although, it is hard to imagine, since we were created for God, and since sin is not a substance, but the deprivation of the justice of God in the soul. My question is rather this, "Deadly sin, is called such, because by it, the person dies to the grace of God (although I would say that the grace of God does not die to that person). In this life, grace is of such a nature that without destroying the nature of the recipient, it can breathe new life into that person, so that they again live to the grace of God. What happens when a person dies, that makes them incapable of receiving God's grace?" Some say, it's because the afterlife is fixed, but if that were true, purgatory wouldn't be possible. Some say, it's because these individuals are in hell and that Christ did not descend into this hell, so His grace does not extend there either, but we know that God is in some sense everywhere, even in hell. The Psalmnist says, "Where can I go from your presence....behold even in hell you are there." Regarding Bishop Hilarion's essay. I don't believe he is confusing sheol/hades with gehenna, as "Apotheoun" contends. Rather I see him saying that the afterlife is not compartmentalized. It was (and still is to some degree) common in the west, to think of hell as comprising: 1)purgatory 2)limbo of the fathers 3)limbo of infants and 'good' pagans 4)abode of the damned. For whatever reason, the first two could be freed, but not the latter two. Although the limbo of infants and 'good' pagans, was never officially adopted by the Church and has since fallen out of favor. Bishop Hilarion seems to be saying that hell is not compartmentalized. That everyone, good and bad went as it were to one "place", this can be demonstrated over and over again, via the Old Testament. Although their experiences there were different (aka Lazarus and Dives), it was the general place of the dead period. So when Christ descends into hell, He descended like all those before him into this general place of the dead and thus broke down the door so to speak for everyone who was there. It doesn't mean everyone followed him out, but that whoever is still there, is there because they freely choose (present-tense) to be there, not because they're locked in (wishing they could leave). CS Lewis in his book, "The Great Divorce" presents a similar picture of hell. Where the occupants are free to leave. Whoever does, this 'hell' was purgatory, and whoever remains, this 'hell' is the hell of the damned, for they "damned" themselves by remaining there. But we are told: "...a damned soul is nearly nothing: it is shrunk, shut up in itself. Good beats upon the damned incessantly, as sound waves beat upon the ears of the deaf, but they cannot receive it. Their fists are clenched, their teeth are clinched, their eyes fast shut. First they will not, in the end they cannot, open their hands for gifts or their mouth for food or their eyes to see. Then no one can ever reach them? Only the Greatest of all can make Himself small enough to enter Hell. For the higher a thing is the lower it can descend...only One has descended into hell. And will He ever do so again? It was not that long ago that He did it. Time does not work that way once ye have left earth. All moments that have been or shall be, were, or are, present in the moment of His descending. There is no spirit in prison to whom He did not preach. And some hear Him? Aye." But this seems to be in direct conflict with, "CC: 633: "...Jesus did not descend into hell to deliver the damned, nor to destroy the hell of damnation, but to free the just who had gone before him." that I quoted previously. Would CS Lewis have to reject such assertions as these in order to become Catholic? Is the "Great Divorce" promulgating false opinions according to the Catholic Church? As for the issue of universalism in general. If God desires that all be saved, then we must actively pray that all (every single person to have ever graced this planet) will be saved, otherwise how can we pray, "Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven"? In addition, if this desire of God will not be fulfilled-and we know this-then there is no point in praying as our Lady taught us, "Oh my Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell. Lead [u]all[/u] souls to heaven, [u]especially those in most need of thy mercy[/u]" and one begins to wonder, what other desires of God will ultimately not be fulfilled. Such a conundrum has given way to a dualistic world view for me. And if anything is a heresy, that is. So I must reject it. Freewill is irrelevant. If God saves all and we believe freewill exist, what then is there to conclude than that God will save all in agreement with man's freewill. What I am saying is that belief in freewill doesn't nullify an equally fervent belief that God's desire will come to fruition. This here is what is really at stake for me, that God's desires will not come to pass and that God is not in control. For the present, I won't go into whether or not universalism in general was condemned, that question is an issue in and of itself. It's popular to believe it was, but history may prove differently. ------------------- Notes: **There is a bit of ambiguity as to what exactly constitutes 'grave matter' since much (including everyday sins) if not in fact most or all sins fall under the auspices of the Ten Commandments. E.g. "CC: 1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: "Do not kill, Do not commit adultery, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Do not defraud, Honor your father and your mother." The gravity of sins is more or less great: murder is graver than theft. One must also take into account who is wronged: violence against parents is in itself graver than violence against a stranger." ---- I am not saying that universalism should become doctrine. There is a difference between allowing two differing views to co-exist in the Church, and making one of them doctrine, thereby annulling the other. ---- In his book, 'Spiritual Dimensions of the Holy Canon', Lewis Patsavos, speaking from an Orthodox perspective says, "The Canons do not make the scholastic distinction between mortal and non-mortal sins, in view of the fact that such a distinction includes the danger of a mortalistic and legalistic approach to sin. "Mortal sin" is the denial of repentance". I'm not sure I agree with his doctrinal assertion, although historically (canonically) he may be correct. I do think there is a danger of moralism and legalism here, but I question whether 1) the distinction is the sole invention of the scholastics (which had a lot of good things to say (I feel sorry for them, they get such a bad rep)) and 2) whether this danger is inherent to a correct understanding of such distinctions, and not the misunderstood and misapplication thereof. If "Ziggamafu"'s essay is ever posted at Phatmass, I encourage everyone to read it. It is definitely a piece to be placed on the shelf of this fascinating issue. ------------------------ Edited January 9, 2009 by cheryl
Apotheoun Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 (edited) I still think that hell and hades / sheol are being confused in this discussion, because Christ does not release anyone from damnation (i.e., [i]gehenna[/i]), and in fact the idea that He can do that, which is sometimes called [i]universalism[/i] (i.e., an understanding of [i]apokatastasis[/i] in line with Origen's teaching), was condemned at the 5th Ecumenical Council and is viewed as a heresy by both Eastern Orthodox Christians and Roman Catholics. Now as I pointed out in my original post in the other thread, since the incarnation of the Logos there is but one end ([i]telos[/i]) for man (i.e., both the saved and damned alike), and that end is God. Ultimately, the experience of the afterlife as heaven or hell (i.e., the vision of the face of God; see 2 Thessalonians 1:7-9) is determined by the manner of life of each individual person. In order to highlight my concerns, I am including a link below to an article on this topic written by an Eastern Orthodox Christian, which addresses some of the issues I raised about the confused use of terms like heaven, hell, hades, and sheol by Christians. [url="http://www.geocities.com/theomimesis/orthodoxy_and_the_afterlife"][u]Heaven and Hell in the Afterlife, According to the Bible[/u][/url] God bless, Todd P.S. - [i]The article above does contain some polemical comments about Protestant and Roman Catholic Christians, but is worth reading nonetheless.[/i] Edited January 10, 2009 by Apotheoun
tinytherese Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 Wow Cheryl, you say a lot of touching things about what it really means to be catholic.
cheryl Posted January 19, 2009 Author Posted January 19, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1747846' date='Jan 9 2009, 11:52 PM']I still think that hell and hades / sheol are being confused in this discussion, because Christ does not release anyone from damnation (i.e., [i]gehenna[/i]),[/quote] You'll have to point out exactly where Bishop Hilarion does this, because I don't see it. [quote]and in fact the idea that He can do that, which is sometimes called [i]universalism[/i] (i.e., an understanding of [i]apokatastasis[/i] in line with Origen's teaching), was condemned at the 5th Ecumenical Council and is viewed as a heresy by both Eastern Orthodox Christians and Roman Catholics.[/quote] Well, I don't want to get into the issue of what was condemned, if anything at the aforementioned council, as it is a subject in and of itself and having been sick, I'm still not up to the challenge. [quote]Now as I pointed out in my original post in the other thread, since the incarnation of the Logos there is but one end ([i]telos[/i]) for man (i.e., both the saved and damned alike), and that end is God. Ultimately, the experience of the afterlife as heaven or hell (i.e., the vision of the face of God; see 2 Thessalonians 1:7-9) is determined by the manner of life of each individual person.[/quote] Yes. I know that is the common opinion of the East. I'd be interested in knowing whether or not it is/was an universal one. [quote]In order to highlight my concerns, I am including a link below to an article on this topic written by an Eastern Orthodox Christian, which addresses some of the issues I raised about the confused use of terms like heaven, hell, hades, and sheol by Christians. [url="http://www.geocities.com/theomimesis/orthodoxy_and_the_afterlife"][u]Heaven and Hell in the Afterlife, According to the Bible[/u][/url][/quote] Thanks. I read it before actually. Thought it was a very well written and insightful article. [quote]P.S. - [i]The article above does contain some polemical comments about Protestant and Roman Catholic Christians, but is worth reading nonetheless.[/i][/quote] Yeah, I'll read over it again, when I get to feeling better.
cheryl Posted January 19, 2009 Author Posted January 19, 2009 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1749644' date='Jan 12 2009, 05:38 PM']Wow Cheryl, you say a lot of touching things about what it really means to be catholic.[/quote] I grew up in a very conservative Lutheran Church, where it was necessary to assent to everything the Confessions taught --they call it a "quia-subscription. I felt like I had to check off on every little thing and I knew I couldn't do it. (I never really came across anything like the Catholic position on developmental tradition or the role of conscience in my studies). I agonized over it for years and approached Roman Catholicism the same way. I'm very grateful to God that I am no longer subjected to such rigidity (although having been my practice for so long, it's still very easy for me to fall into). I hope that I am able to pass this help onto others who feel called to the Catholic Church, but who feel as I felt, that they have to check off some sort of list to become so. I know one person in particular, who is going through a similar struggle right now. May God grant me the grace to help him.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now