Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

What is the height of the Church? its greatness

What are the depths of the Church? its lowliness

What is the breadth and width of the Church? its extent on earth

Who is a member of the Church and who is not?

Posted

anyone want to give a try?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Since you brought it up and are enamoured of guessing games, why don't you?

Posted

Only Christ truly knows who is a member of his Church.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1748127' date='Jan 10 2009, 09:54 AM']Since you brought it up and are enamoured of guessing games, why don't you?[/quote]

Give the guy a break.

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1748134' date='Jan 10 2009, 11:38 AM']Give the guy a break.[/quote]
iawtc

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If you want to discuss a topic fine, but discuss it, don't play games with it. That is why we have a lame board.

HisChildForever
Posted

He's using the Socratic Method. :unsure: It worked for Aristotle.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1748144' date='Jan 10 2009, 12:18 PM']He's using the Socratic Method. :unsure: It worked for Aristotle.[/quote]
So when Aristotle shows up let me know.

puellapaschalis
Posted

Is this a debate or am I missing something?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1748145' date='Jan 10 2009, 12:20 PM']So when Aristotle shows up let me know.[/quote]
:rolleyes:




I'm looking forward to seeing what people have to say about this topic. I need these opportunities to inform my conscience.

Posted

Cmotherofpirl said:

[quote]So when Aristotle shows up let me know.[/quote]

You certainly cut through the fog with that one.

Only someone who has mastered a subject sufficiently to teach it can affectively utilize the Socratic method. Typically, the Socrative method in that hands of a dabbler serves up a double delusion;

1. the delusion/illusion that the dabbler is learned on the subject, and,

2. the person who falls for that illusion becomes confused as to truth.

All my love in Christ

Desmond

Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1747587' date='Jan 9 2009, 07:58 PM']Who is a member of the Church and who is not?[/quote]


1.) Those whose faith is not dead due to lack of good works. aka fruits
2.) Those who are in full communion with the Church
3.) Those who are in a state of grace.

Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1747587' date='Jan 9 2009, 06:58 PM']What is the height of the Church? its greatness

What are the depths of the Church? its lowliness

What is the breadth and width of the Church? its extent on earth

Who is a member of the Church and who is not?[/quote]
The Height was the last supper

The Depth was and still is sin

The church will exsist as long as the Father wills it to,the end of time for all to choose

All baptized in Christ are members of the Church

Posted

obviously these are open ended and profound questions. I posted them here because they are interesting to consider, and I wanted to see what people's insights would be. Here is my answer:

The height and greatness of the Church lies in the truth she was established by Jesus Christ who is God. That all of her true members in some way renew the life and death of Jesus Christ the God-man and in a collective way the Church passing through time renews the life, Passion and Death of Jesus Christ in a grand and global way. The Church reflects the glory of Christ. The Church is the mystical body of Christ. A Bride desiring to become like the Bridegroom Christ on the level of an individual and in a collective way. The greatness of the Church is that she has been entrusted the Deposit of Faith: Tradition and Scripture, and that through the exercise of Magisterium the Pope and Bishops, may teach infallibly and non-infallibly those truths drawn from Tradition and Scripture.

The depths of the Church are many. She is limited in fully understanding Christ. She only knows so much about Him, and so she must ever meditate and come to a deeper understanding of Him through Tradition and Sacred Scripture. And she cannot fully relive His glorious life, but she always strives to reflect and relive it in so much she can. She is made up of mere human members who often fall into sin. Some of her members suffer in Purgatory, and some of her potential members have failed to become full and true members unto the end, thus suffering in the depths of Hell.

The breadth and width, the extent of the Church on earth is that she offers salvation to all individuals, all nations, even to those who are not formal members. She is universal. The pope is the head of the Church and has authority over every human on earth and is responsible for all of them. Yet she cannot guarentee salvation to all, she can only lead all to salvation through the Sacraments, since each person has free will and may choose to accept or refuse the gifts of God.

Who is a member of the Church and who is not? There are a few ways to look at this. Certainly the Souls in Purgatory and the Blessed of Heaven are members of the Church, the Blessed being members in the fullest sense. The fallen angels and damned are truly the only non-members in the fullest extant.

I agree with the view that all humanity is in a sense a member of the Church, since we were all created through and for Christ. Everyone living is in a sense member. From there one could divide them into two parts the visible and invisible. The visible would be Baptised Catholics. The invisible would be those non-Catholics who are baptised either formally or non-formally. Another way to look at membership is who is in the state of grace and who is not. Saint Joan of Arc was excommunicated yet she remained in the state of grace.

Posted

It's a shame to see Christians carry a grudge from one topic to another. If there is anger or hostility in our hearts we need to take that in repentance to Jesus, try to leave it with Him and not renew it elsewhere. I don't see how this topic is a game or a joke or in any way lame. I don't know what the problem is with using the Socratic method. If the Debate table is just for the "experts" I better get off it, but I thought that's what the Q and A section was for.

What is the height of the Church? The saints

What are the depths of the Church? The extent to which its members are unfaithful to the Gospel

What is the breadth and width of the Church? Spiritually, since it extends into eternity, it has no determinable breadth or width... no limits

Who is a member of the Church and who is not? This is the really interesting one - you will get different answers depending on whether someone is coming at it from a canonical angle or a spiritual angle... obviously baptism and the other sacraments of initiation are required for one to canonically be a full member of the Church.

I read in another thread (can't remember which one) the idea that all babies baptized with the proper formula are automatically, spiritually speaking, Catholics, even if they are baptized in a Protestant ecclesial community. I wonder if anyone has insights into that...

Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1748306' date='Jan 10 2009, 06:17 PM']I read in another thread (can't remember which one) the idea that all babies baptized with the proper formula are automatically, spiritually speaking, Catholics, even if they are baptized in a Protestant ecclesial community. I wonder if anyone has insights into that...[/quote]
I think they could be considered Catholics until they commit the sin of actual heresy, which might occur many years later in their adult life. A big difficulty for them is the lack of the Confirmation, and the guidance of the Magisterium.

Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1748306' date='Jan 10 2009, 06:17 PM']I read in another thread (can't remember which one) the idea that all babies baptized with the proper formula are automatically, spiritually speaking, Catholics, even if they are baptized in a Protestant ecclesial community. I wonder if anyone has insights into that...[/quote]

I believe I learned that all Christians share a common baptism.

Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1748313' date='Jan 10 2009, 07:31 PM']I think they could be considered Catholics until they commit the sin of actual heresy.[/quote]

How do you commit the sin of heresy ?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...