cmotherofpirl Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 [url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/persecution/pch0206.htm"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/...ion/pch0206.htm[/url]
Hassan Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1748252' date='Jan 10 2009, 04:37 PM'][url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/persecution/pch0206.htm"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/...ion/pch0206.htm[/url][/quote] With all due respect (and I mean that as I like you personally) I don't see much in this but one sided propaganda which is refuted both by past examinations of Israeli military action and current reporting by such organizations as the United Nations, Human Rights Watch, and Amnesty International. Hamas has committed human rights violations and does so to this very day but Israel’s tired excuses of blaming every Israeli wrong on Hamas’s maliciousness and provocation simply does not accord with the facts.
Hassan Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 Also the article has numerous misstatements of fact. If you wish I would be happy to point them out.
Hassan Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 (edited) never mind Edited January 10, 2009 by Hassan
CatherineM Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 I heard today on our news that the commentator felt like if Israel withdrew this time without the missile attacks stopping, then the government would fall. I guess that means the majority of Israelis are supportive of the action. I just don't know how they can withdraw without putting an end to it this time.
Hassan Posted January 10, 2009 Posted January 10, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1748295' date='Jan 10 2009, 07:00 PM']I heard today on our news that the commentator felt like if Israel withdrew this time without the missile attacks stopping, then the government would fall. I guess that means the majority of Israelis are supportive of the action. I just don't know how they can withdraw without putting an end to it this time.[/quote] I believe a majority does support it even through there is a contingent (activists and various human rights organizations such as [url="http://www.btselem.org/English/index.asp"]B'Tselem[/url] )supports the incursion.
Madame Vengier Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 (edited) With good cause the Israelis support this action. It's defense of their homeland, plain and simple. I can't imagine what citizens of what nation wouldn't support the defense of their homeland. People think Israel is over-doing and that's nothing new. I've said it before and I'll say it again: Israel can't afford to NOT over-do it. They cannot afford to take the chance of an Arab assault taking place on their land becuase they have nowhere to run but to the sea. This is the single and only reason they are so hardcore with their defensive assault when they are attacked at their border. Edited January 11, 2009 by Madame Vengier
Hassan Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1748337' date='Jan 10 2009, 08:05 PM']With good cause the Israelis support this action. It's defense of their homeland, plain and simple. I can't imagine what citizens of what nation wouldn't support the defense of their homeland. People think Israel is over-doing and that's nothing new. I've said it before and I'll say it again: Israel can't afford to NOT over-do it. They cannot afford to take the chance of an Arab assault taking place on their land becuase they have nowhere to run but to the sea. This is the single and only reason they are so hardcore with their defensive assault when they are attacked at their border.[/quote] An "arab assault"? Is Gaza going to overrun Israel with it's massive, highly trained army and tank divisions? Yes Israel is small with no where to "run". Like the UK or Japan. Also like the UK and Japan it is a major world power. It is also the super power of it's region, armed with Nuclear weapons, and enjoys the almost unqualified backing of the worlds sole super power.
Brother Adam Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote]United Nations, Human Rights Watch, and Amnesty International[/quote] Hardly reputable organizations. Just as one sided as the original website. If I walk up to my neighbor's house and punch in him the face every day eventually I am going to walk up to his house and he's going to kick the carp out of me, and I'll deserve everything I get.
Hassan Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748373' date='Jan 10 2009, 09:21 PM']Hardly reputable organizations.[/quote] That's one of the most absurd things I've ever heard. [quote]Just as one sided as the original website.[/quote] How? They have well documented and brought light to numerous violations of human rights and international law by Hamas and, HRW anyway, refuses to law blame on either side. [quote]If I walk up to my neighbor's house and punch in him the face every day eventually I am going to walk up to his house and he's going to kick the carp out of me, and I'll deserve everything I get.[/quote] Sure, that's an apt comparison of this conflict.
Hassan Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [url="http://www.btselem.org/English/"]http://www.btselem.org/English/[/url]
Madame Vengier Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748373' date='Jan 10 2009, 09:21 PM']Hardly reputable organizations. Just as one sided as the original website. If I walk up to my neighbor's house and punch in him the face every day eventually I am going to walk up to his house and he's going to kick the carp out of me, and I'll deserve everything I get.[/quote] And not only kick the carp out of you, but if he's smart, when he finally does kick back he's going to kick you harder and more prolonged than you ever kicked him, so you know not to try it again. That is what's happening with Israel. I really just don't know whether to laugh or cry when I read, over and over and over, Israel referred to as "the aggressor". Wow. I just read an article on the Korean online news Chosun Ilbo, where this was written also. All over the world, people are swallowing this koolaid. Besides all that, you really have to wonder why the world gets so fixated on this tiny country the size of New Jersey when they ignore places like Sudan. It's really something. Edited January 11, 2009 by Madame Vengier
Hassan Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1748739' date='Jan 11 2009, 12:51 PM']And not only kick the carp out of you, but if he's smart, when he finally does kick back he's going to kick you harder and more prolonged than you ever kicked him, so you know not to try it again.[/quote] Sure, just like Sharon was going to do to the PLO in Lebanon in the 80's. Just like Hezbollah was going to be "whipped out" by Israel in South Lebanon in 2006. Israel has decided it's going to "take the gloves off" and "finally take x terrorist group out" on numerous occasions throughout its existence. They have never succeeded because such attitudes ignore the legitimate grievances the populace has which gives rise to these terrorist organizations. Often the populace ends up supporting the "resistance fighters" more than before. Hamas was waning in their popularity; they could not govern Gaza properly and abused their power. I remember one stark instance when a large number of Gazan Muslims tried to pray outside the Mosque on Friday to protest against the Hamas attempt to use the Mosque to preach their political ideology. The political body of Hamas has ordered the police to allow them to pray outside, the police beat the protestors anyway. Not only did this darken Hamas' image in general it raised serious questions about how much control the government actually had over the police and militias. Hamas' popularity as a governing force had been waning. In fact the only times that Hamas can legitimize themselves to the larger populace is as "resistance fighters". Israel's activities now give Hamas precisely the legitimization they need to stay in control, or if t=not them groups of similar sentiments. [quote]That is what's happening with Israel.[/quote] lol [quote]I really just don't know whether to laugh or cry when I read, over and over and over, Israel referred to as "the aggressor". Wow. I just read an article on the Korean online news Chosun Ilbo, where this was written also. All over the world, people are swallowing this koolaid.[/quote] Have you even considered that you have swallowed the kool aid? [quote]Besides all that, you really have to wonder why the world gets so fixated on this tiny country the size of New Jersey[/quote] Because the conflict it has been involved with is the focal point of Middle East instability and has been so for almost a century. You keep reiterating that Israel is a "tiny county". Why is this important? It may be small in terms of geography but it is a massive country in terms of world influence and military power. [quote]when they ignore places like Sudan. It's really something.[/quote] Sudan has not been ignored, at least not totally, although it has shamefully slipped out of sight in recent times. This is largely because China prevents any serious international pressure or activity being brought to bear. We can agree that the international response to the genocide in Sudan is a disgrace.
Brother Adam Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 Terror is difficult to wipe out, but that does not mean Israel should allow terrorist to continue to lob rockets at their citizens and children. Israel as a sovereign state has every right to cripple Hamas and other organizations doing violence against them. War is at times just against an unjust aggressor. Yes, the analogy fits. You don't throw rockets into another nation over a long period of time and not expect serious retaliation. As you said even Muslims in the Gaza strip see the injustice of the Hamas ruled faux government. There is real promise that Israel could remove Hamas control from Gaza, saving the lives of both Palistinians and Israeli's in the future, and I hope they accomplish their goal. Also, no serious person takes the UN or other corrupt international organizations seriously.
Lilllabettt Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 Name something more useful than the United Nations .... a can opener? A package of EasyMac? toe nail clippers?
Galloglasses' Alt Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1748787' date='Jan 11 2009, 03:46 PM']Name something more useful than the United Nations .... a can opener? A package of EasyMac? toe nail clippers?[/quote] Mosquitos.
Madame Vengier Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Hassan' post='1748749' date='Jan 11 2009, 01:51 PM']You keep reiterating that Israel is a "tiny county". Why is this important? It may be small in terms of geography but it is a massive country in terms of world influence and military power.[/quote] Israel is NOT massive in terms of world influence and military power. Who else is Israel ever fighting with besides its Arab neighbors?? The Japanese? The Italians? The Nigerians? The Irish?If Israel wasn't constantly defending itself from its neighbors, it wouldn't have anyone to fight. Israel has no military clout anywhere in the world except in its own region for self-defense. If the Arabs suddenly left the Israelis alone and there was total peace in the region, do you think Israel would just get bored and go start a war with South Korea or India or El Salvador?
Hassan Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748782' date='Jan 11 2009, 03:41 PM']Terror is difficult to wipe out[/quote] Yes it is [quote]but that does not mean Israel should allow terrorist to continue to lob rockets at their citizens and children.[/quote] Sure, it would be nice if along the way they would stop brutalizing the Palestinian population. [quote]Israel as a sovereign state has every right to cripple Hamas and other organizations doing violence against them. War is at times just against an unjust aggressor. Yes, the analogy fits.[/quote] No it does not. I would be happy to go into detail but given the unfortunate habit of many here to simply make extraordinary claims about the conflict only to refuse to back up their sensational claims I would prefer not to address this in-depth unless I have some reason to believe you will be responsive to facts contrary to you dichotomous view of the conflict. [quote]You don't throw rockets into another nation over a long period of time and not expect serious retaliation.[/quote] How about if your neighbor keeps you imprisoned in his front yard and refuses to allow you access to adequate food, water, and medication? [quote]As you said even Muslims in the Gaza strip see the injustice of the Hamas ruled faux government. There is real promise that Israel could remove Hamas control from Gaza, saving the lives of both Palistinians and Israeli's in the future, and I hope they accomplish their goal.[/quote] Sure. [quote]Also, no serious person takes the UN or other corrupt international organizations seriously.[/quote] How is Human Rights Watch corrupt? How about B'Tselem?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now