Lounge Daddy Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 Or let me put it this way: Our Founding Fathers established this Union as a Republic, and gave us a Constitution that reflects this. Our government is trying to run this country as a Democracy, which is a form of Socialism--and they have been doing this to an increasing degree for about 100 years now. I think the damage is too great to rectify. So we may as well at least have a foundation that reflects the political structure that sits upon it. At least that would be a bit more honest.
Galloglasses' Alt Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 (edited) LD your missing something, if a Constitutional Convention is called it would be worse for the US, take into fact that there would A: Be alot more people argueing points in a new Constitution, most of them influenced by agendas. B: The vast majority of these people have party or ideological affiliations whereas the Framers had little other then individual liberty and despised the idea of parties, nowadays we have every ideology and its grandmother shooting around, would you really want Enviromentalism having a say on a new Constitution? C: If the Government is not following the original constitution, they sure as hell won't follow a new one. Think about it, the genius of the current constitution is its advocacy of federalism adn the seperation of Powers, it is so short as to not act as a straight jacket and purposefully difficult to change. It's a simple fact give tthe chance to draft a new Constitution the things that made the American Government great asnd stable would be out the window in favour of heaven knows what else. D: The last thing we want is for America to have a chance under the Obama administration to turn from a Republic to a Democracy. (Yes Hassan, we know the Reps are currently in power, but if any Convention is going to be called it'd surely be after W. is out), The damage is not so great to rectify, after all, we are still in the middle of a culture war, (Europe is too but our side is in a more sorry state over here), adn the damage is to be rectified at a social level as well as a political one. Edited January 11, 2009 by Galloglasses' Alt
Lounge Daddy Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Galloglasses' Alt' post='1748776' date='Jan 11 2009, 03:19 PM']A: Be alot more people argueing points in a new Constitution, most of them influenced by agendas. B: The vast majority of these people have party or ideological affiliations whereas the Framers had little other then individual liberty and despised the idea of parties, nowadays we have every ideology and its grandmother shooting around, would you really want Enviromentalism having a say on a new Constitution?[/quote] That's happening right now, but in regard to a legal system that completely ignores the existence of the US Constitution. At least a Convention would force them to revisit what is supposed to be the legal foundation of this Republic.
Lounge Daddy Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 To get our government back to following the US Constitution, quite a lot would need to happen. To put it briefly, according to the US Constitution, if it is not explicitly laid out in that document, the Federal Government has no business with it at all. In other words, if it's not in there then it's not the Federal Government's business. Everything that we see today that has become screwed up, from the economy to health care, and from to government-run schools to this stupid "[url="http://loungedaddy.us/?p=1470"]digital tv entitlement[/url]" (talk about pandering to the poor for votes!) is: #1) ...because of Federal Government Involvement. #2) ...nowhere found in the US Constitution. To follow the Constitution the Federal Government would have to scale way back and operate within very tight confines. But I can't see that happening. Can you? Instead the inevitable thing is, as I see it, one of these three things: A) Rewrite the document that isn't being followed anyhow, and give us something that they at least agree to be held accountable to. B) A bloody revolution. C) Both.
princessgianna Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 dUSt can I change my vote? I did not mean to vote 'Yes'.
rkwright Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1748805' date='Jan 11 2009, 03:39 PM']To get our government back to following the US Constitution, quite a lot would need to happen. To put it briefly, according to the US Constitution, if it is not explicitly laid out in that document, the Federal Government has no business with it at all. In other words, if it's not in there then it's not the Federal Government's business. Everything that we see today that has become screwed up, from the economy to health care, and from to government-run schools to this stupid "[url="http://loungedaddy.us/?p=1470"]digital tv entitlement[/url]" (talk about pandering to the poor for votes!) is: #1) ...because of Federal Government Involvement. #2) ...nowhere found in the US Constitution. To follow the Constitution the Federal Government would have to scale way back and operate within very tight confines. But I can't see that happening. Can you? Instead the inevitable thing is, as I see it, one of these three things: A) Rewrite the document that isn't being followed anyhow, and give us something that they at least agree to be held accountable to. B) A bloody revolution. C) Both.[/quote] The federal government has the right to regulate interstate commerce - and in an age when nearly everything affects interstate commerce, it looks like they can regulate nearly anything. Seems like the current constitution is working just fine. Just no one in 1776 ever envisioned things like the internet.
Galloglasses' Alt Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1748805' date='Jan 11 2009, 04:39 PM']To get our government back to following the US Constitution, quite a lot would need to happen. To put it briefly, according to the US Constitution, if it is not explicitly laid out in that document, the Federal Government has no business with it at all. In other words, if it's not in there then it's not the Federal Government's business. Everything that we see today that has become screwed up, from the economy to health care, and from to government-run schools to this stupid "[url="http://loungedaddy.us/?p=1470"]digital tv entitlement[/url]" (talk about pandering to the poor for votes!) is: #1) ...because of Federal Government Involvement. #2) ...nowhere found in the US Constitution. To follow the Constitution the Federal Government would have to scale way back and operate within very tight confines. But I can't see that happening. Can you? Instead the inevitable thing is, as I see it, one of these three things: A) Rewrite the document that isn't being followed anyhow, and give us something that they at least agree to be held accountable to. B) A bloody revolution. C) Both.[/quote] There is nothing that is the fault of the US Constitution, as you say it is the Government's fault and increasing Federal Level encroachment, which I agree with you on, the Federal Government needs a rollback of its power and influence. [b]Its not the constitution that needs changing. At all.[/b] [quote]A) Rewrite the document that isn't being followed anyhow, and give us something that they at least agree to be held accountable to.[/quote] Won't happen, they'll never agree to anything that they haven't manipulated for their benefit. [quote]B) A bloody revolution.[/quote] Not neccesary. There already is a clause, (or a right, I forget which part of the original document it was in, the Bill of Rights or the articles), that the people have a right to change their Government should they see that it is not serving the Constitution faithfully enough. This is not so much a bloody revolution asa it is kicking everybody who is in office out of it. [quote]C) Both.[/quote] See, this is what happened when the King of France tried to deliniate more power to his legislature. They got what they wanted, ran with it, spurred the growing discontent and what we got was the French Revolution. Hardly a good thing to happen again. Don't get me wrong I hold the same greivances as you do but I am argueing about your proposed support for a constitutional Convention. Think about it, in the current powerplays in Washington, political Climate, the liberal influence, how can you honestly think drawing everyone's attention to the constitution will not make it be rewritten as to FAVOUR central Government? I need not point you to Europe to see how this carry on leads us to.
Era Might Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 I think the Constitution still works. We get the leaders we vote for. If we want different leaders, we just have to vote for them. I don't think the problem is with the Constitution. The problem is with the American people. For example, abortion could be outlawed very easily if the American people would stand up and demand that it be outlawed. I think creating a new Constitution would just lead to an unstable political system.
Galloglasses' Alt Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Era Might' post='1748824' date='Jan 11 2009, 04:26 PM']I think the Constitution still works. We get the leaders we vote for. If we want different leaders, we just have to vote for them. I don't think the problem is with the Constitution. The problem is with the American people. For example, abortion could be outlawed very easily if the American people would stand up and demand that it be outlawed. I think creating a new Constitution would just lead to an unstable political system.[/quote] You just basically summed up what I was trying to say.
Lounge Daddy Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='princessgianna' post='1748807' date='Jan 11 2009, 04:42 PM']dUSt can I change my vote? I did not mean to vote 'Yes'. [/quote] Those butterfly ballots are confusing?
Lounge Daddy Posted January 11, 2009 Author Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='Era Might' post='1748824' date='Jan 11 2009, 05:26 PM']The problem is with the American people.[/quote] Once people realize that they can use their vote to vote themselves other people's money, it's the beginning of the end. And our politicians know this. Here's an idea; how about not allowing people receiving government welfare to vote?
Socrates Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1748772' date='Jan 11 2009, 03:07 PM']I think that a Constitutional Convention is entirely necessary. We do not follow the US Constitution at all right now. So simply put, to force our government to revisit it would: #1 - Remind them of what the US Constitution lays out for our Federal Government #2 - They would openly admit they are not following that document; and then entirely re-write a lot of the Constitution, or write an entirely new one, and then follow that. I know that many people have many different motives for calling a Convention--and now all of them are in the best interest of the Individual. But it would be best in the end to have a legal foundation to point to and follow; which is something that we no longer have. Government has gotten away from us. Unless you think that it is still possible to get back to governing by the US Constitution that our Founding Fathers gave us?[/quote] I'm afraid I'd have to disagree with you about the wisdom of calling a Constitutional Convention. We don't need a new Constitution - we need to follow the one we have. (I know, good luck with that!) Given that our country has elected Obama president, and seems to care little for our traditional values, rights or freedoms, I shudder to think of what a modern-day new Constitution would look like.
Lounge Daddy Posted January 12, 2009 Author Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Socrates' post='1748995' date='Jan 11 2009, 09:41 PM']I'm afraid I'd have to disagree with you about the wisdom of calling a Constitutional Convention. We don't need a new Constitution - we need to follow the one we have. (I know, good luck with that!)[/quote] Ya, you're right. Of course I love the current Constitution (could do without the 17th Amendment, though) and the wisdom of the Founding Fathers. Sometimes I think that they need to either follow the constitution or get a new one. But my problem honestly is with the current socialist government, and the current ignorant and lazy electorate that the Statists in Washington have managed to bribe into supporting them.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now