katie Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 PLEASE HELP!!! I am desperate! My husband and I take our 17 month old son, Christopher, to church once to twice a week. This being said, HE IS HORRIBLE IN CHURCH!!! We bring nice, quiet bible books and blocks, etc. We sit near the front where he can see what is going on. We also bring his comfort object along. All to no avail. The moment that we whisper a "No, you cannot pull the hair of the nice lady in front of us" he lets out an almighty yell that the angels can hear. I proceed to take him to the side foyer (we do not have a cry room) Where I hold him because I don't want it to be fun time to be out of church. (he hates to be confined). We then attempt to reenter church when he has calmed down, only to have him begin screaming again before the responsorial psalm begins. Today was the worst day ever! During the petitions (he had already been taken outside twice at this point) He dropped his yellow toy that proceeded to role 4 pews ahead of us. When he whined that he wanted it back, I told him no, it was gone and we would get it after church, he screamed the worst scream that is imaginable....It was like in the movies....The lector QUIT saying the petitions...Fr. and Deacon both turned and looked....everyone turned and looked at us.....I left as quickly as possible with him. I broke into tears when, after mass, 5-6 people, including Fr. came over and said that it was ok. Some moms said that they keep their kids at home during church. Others say to keep bringing them. I feel that Church is for family and we are a family and should be there together. I don't want to split up, but I don't know how to solve this situation. DO YOU HAVE ANY TIPS FOR HELPING KIDS AND MOMS IN CHURCH? I am a stay at home mommy, and he does not act like this very often at home. When he does, I place him in time out, and continue to place him back there like on Super Nanny. He does not talk much, so reasoning does not work at this point. thank you very much for any ideas and PRAYERS!!!! God bless ps I am 2 months away from my due date, and am nervous as to how he will react to Dad having to take him out of church instead of me....so far, he acts worse for dad.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 I understand where you are, I had 3 babies in 5 years. Right now he is running the show. Bring him to Church at times other than the Mass and praise him for being quiet. He can have one church book or church toy with him which he only gets at church when he is quiet. As soon as he acts up tell him he has to go stand where the babies stand. Plan on attending Mass from the foyer, and establish your stuff in the last row. Explain to him that you cannot go inside because he doesn't use his quiet voice. You and your husband can hand him back and forth until he gets the idea. Going inside the church is a treat - where the big boys get to go.
homeschoolmom Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 Please take heart in that you are certainly not the first person to have this dilemma. Also please accept the comments of people who were trying to encourage you. 17 month olds are impossible to reason with. It just not something they've mastered yet. He's too young to understand what's going on and too old to hope he will fall asleep during mass. It's a tough age all around! IT WILL GET BETTER! Continue to try to keep him quietly engaged during mass and take him to the back when he cannot stay quiet. That's just about all you can do. He will get the idea. (The back should not be more fun than mass, just less intrusive for others). It gets better, just stay with it. You may get a from time to time. Just ignore them if your son is being fairly quiet.
homeschoolmom Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 Another thing you might do as he gets [i]a little bit older[/i]... You could bring a camera to the church sometime when there is no one there and take pictures of vairous items-- the tabernacle, different candles, windows, ambo etc. Maybe even take a picture of Father in vestments. Then take the pictures and make a little book (stick each picture in a ziplock bag and staple them together). There are hundreds of images you could use (and make several different books). He can look for the things (Just remind him AGAIN to use his inside voice).
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 11, 2009 Posted January 11, 2009 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1748858' date='Jan 11 2009, 06:43 PM'] Please take heart in that you are certainly not the first person to have this dilemma. Also please accept the comments of people who were trying to encourage you. 17 month olds are impossible to reason with. It just not something they've mastered yet. He's too young to understand what's going on and too old to hope he will fall asleep during mass. It's a tough age all around! IT WILL GET BETTER! Continue to try to keep him quietly engaged during mass and take him to the back when he cannot stay quiet. That's just about all you can do. He will get the idea. (The back should not be more fun than mass, just less intrusive for others). It gets better, just stay with it. You may get a from time to time. Just ignore them if your son is being fairly quiet.[/quote] Total agreement. I've got 3 children and #4 in utero. That is a very difficult age which goes beyond the usual wiggliness of little kids having to sit still for an hour. One thing I have always done is to keep a mini notepad in my purse along with a pen just for my tots to use during Mass. Coloring helps keep them quiet for awhile and usually gives me a few minutes to actually pay attention to the Mass. We usually sit towards the back to make this easier, my older girls are better and I can point out things during Mass so they learn more and pay attention better (which sitting near the front would make easier) but with a 2 year old and me pregnant the back works best for us. Since you are due so soon I would begin having your husband be the primary "taker-outer" of your son when he acts up. It will be better to get him used to the new routine sooner rather than later. From the start my husband and I had shared that duty, but now with more kids he gets to take the worst offender(s) out while I stay in the pew with the other kids. Occasionally I will take them if it's easier, but usually I get his attention and give the nod and he scoops the child up and takes them out until they can behave. They don't get toys or books while they are out--they are being naughty and getting to play is like a reward. Books or a toy are for when they are being good.
CatherineM Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 My oldest foster son was a chemical exposure baby. He would normally sit unmoving for long periods of time, but for some reason mass just made him nuts. I finally worked out a deal with a family that went to the later mass. I dropped him off at their house on the way to mass. After mass, I waited 15 minutes, and they appeared with my problem child and theirs, and I took them both home with me. They picked theirs up on the way home from mass. We did that about 6 months, and both boys hated getting excluded that they were willing to make any bargain to get to go back to church. He was an angel after that. He was a bit older, 4 years old at the time. We would do the switch off about once every other month after that just to keep them honest, and I think to give that other couple an opportunity to worship together now and then.
katie Posted January 12, 2009 Author Posted January 12, 2009 Thank you all so very much! I guess that we will try the back of church for a month or so and see if it will help my sanity any. The pen and paper is so simple, yet I never thought of it...so thanks! Also, the picture book is brilliant! I have seen families with prayer cards, but actual pictures of church is wonderful..he may be young, but I think that I will try it. Hopefully we will be able to have this controlled before he is old enough to try some of the other tactics, however, we will definitely keep them in mind. It will be dificult for me, but I think you are right that I should start having my husband take Christopher outside...If my attention needs to be on the newborn, he will need to do that, and it is better if Chris is used to it. I have one more question: How do you make going to the back of church something he will not like? He LOVES just walking around..being free....any ideas? When we hold him, he just screams louder, and the doors are NOT sound proof. THank you all again for all of your answers...I let you know if we make any progress!
Luigi Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 He does not talk much, [i]so reasoning does not work at this point.[/i] That's the key. He has not reached the age of reason, so there really is no reason to bring him to church at all. The Church doesn't require it of him (or you), and the church is not set up as a kid-friendly space. I know you consider it family time, but does he? He doesn't get to play with you, talk to you, interact with you in any way - it doesn't sound like family time to me. He is distracting you (and your husband) from the religious experience you want and need. You're leaving church embarrassed to tears instead of at peace - is that why you go to church? Are you getting the prayer time, the recollection, the community that you need during all of this? If you want to go to church with your husband - and that probably is very important to both of you, especially as you prepare for the birth of your new child - hire a babysitter, or trade babysitting with another young couple who go to a different Mass. Raising children is frustrating enough on its best day; don't add to your own frustration by setting expectations of a child who simply has not reached the stage of development where he can meet them. Take him to church when he's old enough to concentrate, pay attention, listen to your reminders about behavior. The Church, in its wisdom, knows what the little ones can - and can't - do. Peace to you - and to your kiddo.
eagle_eye222001 Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Luigi' post='1749280' date='Jan 11 2009, 11:31 PM']He does not talk much, [i]so reasoning does not work at this point.[/i] That's the key. He has not reached the age of reason, so there really is no reason to bring him to church at all. The Church doesn't require it of him (or you), and the church is not set up as a kid-friendly space.[/quote] I respectfully disagree with this. Do you have a citation for this? I would cite the third commandment on keeping holy the Lord's day. I don't recall the Church exempting those below the age of reason however if I am wrong please show me. Matthew 19:14 [i]14 but Jesus said, 'Let the little children alone, and do not stop them from coming to me; for it is to such as these that the kingdom of Heaven belongs.' [/i] [quote]I know you consider it family time, but does he? He doesn't get to play with you, talk to you, interact with you in any way - it doesn't sound like family time to me. He is distracting you (and your husband) from the religious experience you want and need. You're leaving church embarrassed to tears instead of at peace - is that why you go to church? Are you getting the prayer time, the recollection, the community that you need during all of this? If you want to go to church with your husband - and that probably is very important to both of you, especially as you prepare for the birth of your new child - hire a babysitter, or trade babysitting with another young couple who go to a different Mass. Raising children is frustrating enough on its best day; don't add to your own frustration by setting expectations of a child who simply has not reached the stage of development where he can meet them. Take him to church when he's old enough to concentrate, pay attention, listen to your reminders about behavior. The Church, in its wisdom, knows what the little ones can - and can't - do. Peace to you - and to your kiddo.[/quote] Again I respectfully disagree. By keeping the children from mass are you not actively keeping them from Christ? I have not had any kids, however, I am the oldest of 8, and I have seen my parents deal with my siblings and endure the looks. My mom has responded to those people by looking back at them . They generally never look again. The question that needs to be asked is why bring children to mass in the first place? Is there any reason to? Besides the bible verse already mentioned, when you bring a young unreasoning child to mass, you are including the child in your religious community identity. The child becomes used to the parents beliefs and religious identity. In essence you are teaching the child what you believe. That mass is important. So the kid may not pick up that the gospel was taken from Luke and centered on the Nativity or the the priest talked about forgiveness in his homily, however children need to be taught that mass is a place to where we thank and worship Jesus. And this is not accomplished by holding the children at home and waiting until they are older. If anything, you are probably only delaying the bad behavior. My parents have talked about masses where they missed most of it because they were dealing with someone, however after reflecting on it, they are glad they pushed us through it. Mass is a family time because you are spending time worshiping the Lord at mass as a family. Family time does not mean you are directly talking to people in your family but rather family time can mean that the whole family is doing the same thing together. While it may seem that mass is just an exhausting chore with no fruitful benefits...that is becuase the benefits come later when the child learns and begins to hold the same reverence for Jesus as their parents do. I can only say, please do not stop bringing your children to mass. You would be neglecting your role as parents in teaching the faith by leaving them at home.
jckinsman Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 Realize that this is just a part of the bigger picture. Know that God wants you and your kids there. I always start at the front of the church between the ages of newborn and 3 1/2 -4 and slowly during mass work my way back to the back of the church. Somedays I actually can make it through a whole mass up front. My youngest is now 2 1/2. She is a bit more ansy then the next one up. A little walking around in mass, in the back (this is our child area) is okay, running around freaking out is clearly not. If it gets to be over the top just pick the child up and if the baby sceams walk slowly to the bathroom talking calmly. You come out when they are done. We do quiet snacks. We do a pen and paper. We have a picture book on the mass. There are good days and bad days. We have a church plum full of "seasoned" citizens. I try to be respectful of that. I retreat early to the back if I can anticipate the disruption. Just play it by ear. Thats why God gave you two. Keep trying to move it forward into the church. Don't lose sight of why your there,just do your best. Don't worry either about the "looks" you may get. This is such a short time in your life. If you don't get a chance to hear everything,spend a few moments after mass,in the church reading the readings,or if its been particularly tough,Just say some quiet prayers for all mothers experiancing this also (when your husband has the child,and is eating the donut) Good Luck!
Archaeology cat Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 eagle_eye - I completely agree with you. As a parent, I refuse to not bring my son to Mass with me (he's almost 14 months). The only times I go without him is if he's not awake yet for daily Mass. There have been times I've had to take him to the back for him to calm down. He loves the Pieta in the back of our parish and will look at that for quite a while (for a toddler). He's to the stage right now where it's loads of fun to run down the aisle. He doesn't really want to sit in my lap, but I have had some success getting him to sit in the aisle with a toy at daily Mass (we sit in the very back, so we're not blocking anyone). I second the suggestion of taking him at a different time, when there isn't a Mass, and praising him for being quiet. Do you think he'd do well at a daily Mass, when it's quieter? I've recently started trying to take Kieran to Mass almost every day, and he's running around less now because it's just become our routine. We get up & eat and then go to Mass (provided he's actually awake). So he doesn't see it as that big of a deal anymore. He still runs around a little at first (I try to get there early so he can explore before Mass actually starts; doesn't always happen, but it's my plan). I know this may not be possible for you, especially with your due date coming up. Icey - I love that idea about the picture book! I might have to do that sometime.
T-Bone _ Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 There is no reason to [i]not[/i] bring your kid to Mass. He needs to know that going to Mass is a regular part of life. It is unfortunate that you don't have a cry room. You could just start off there, and there wouldn't be a problem. You could always drug him.
Didacus Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 Back in the days my oldest was horrible in church I would sit in the back and as soon as he would 'act up' I would walk around with him at the back of the assembly. Took my mind off church but it worked - after a while he settled down and paid attention regularly (although it took a couple of years, maybe he needed to grow up a bit too?)
Brother Adam Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 I'm sorry your parish doesn't have a cry room, but grateful your parish family is so understanding. Either does ours. The oldest generation who saw our current church built decided they did not want a space like a cry room because they wanted everyone in the main part of the Church - but now they give nasty looks and give off comments to families with little kids who make any noise.
StColette Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Luigi' post='1749280' date='Jan 11 2009, 11:31 PM']He does not talk much, [i]so reasoning does not work at this point.[/i] That's the key. He has not reached the age of reason, so there really is no reason to bring him to church at all. The Church doesn't require it of him (or you), and the church is not set up as a kid-friendly space.[/quote] Age of reason in the Church is usually considered around age 7, which is when most kids make their First Communion. If a child doesn't go to Church regularly before this time it will be difficult to instruct him/her on what is going on during Mass and how one is to behave in Mass. I speak of this from experience since I'm the PSR teacher for First Communion at a parish and I know some kids don't attend Church often with their families or at all. They're very much behind on the basic, etc. The moment a person is baptized they become a member of the family of God, the Church, which means they are welcomed into the Church and though they might not be required to be their it is important that they grow accustomed to putting aside time for prayer. I've watched many children under the age of 1 come in an genuflect in front of the altar! This is because they've been brought to Church and instructed on what they are to do and how they are to behave. And yes, some kids are going to be a little more noisy, fussy, or whatever during Church but this does not mean that they do not belong. And how exactly is Church not a kid-friendly space? Is it because there aren't a ton of toys all around and a tv going? That's not kid friendly that's just a play room! Church is very kid-friendly if it is used properly! Little kids get very excited about seeing new things and looking at the pretty stained glass windows, or listening to the music. They just need to be engaged properly not distracted, though sometimes distraction is the only answer. At the parish where I work we have a mom who brings all 6 of her kids, from age 2 to 15, with her to Adoration. They're absolutely beautiful children. Sure they are a little loud every now and then, but what a wonderful thing to see them there before the Lord. Aaron has been with me at Mass since 2 wks old. There would be an absolute uproar from our priest and parish family if I didn't bring him. [b]"And they brought young children to Him, that He should touch them: and His disciples rebuked those that brought them. But when Jesus saw it, He was much displeased, and said unto them, Suffer the little children to come unto Me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God' (Mark 10:13-14)[/b]
Lil Red Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 +J.M.J.+ i would chime in that it is important to bring your child to Mass. i bring my toddler to Mass, and yes, it can get frustrating sometimes. i try to remember to offer my frustration to the Lord. she loves to sing (quite loudly sometimes), and she loves to watch the priest. keep trying and God bless you and your family!
Archaeology cat Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1749498' date='Jan 12 2009, 04:48 PM']+J.M.J.+ i would chime in that it is important to bring your child to Mass. i bring my toddler to Mass, and yes, it can get frustrating sometimes. i try to remember to offer my frustration to the Lord. she loves to sing (quite loudly sometimes), and she loves to watch the priest. keep trying and God bless you and your family![/quote] We should get her and Kieran together, as he also sings (loudly) during Mass. Thankfully our priest thinks it's funny. And the cantor tried to show Kieran how to play the piano.
StColette Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1749522' date='Jan 12 2009, 12:37 PM']We should get her and Kieran together, as he also sings (loudly) during Mass. Thankfully our priest thinks it's funny. And the cantor tried to show Kieran how to play the piano.[/quote] lol This weekend after singing the Hallelujah before the Gospel, a little one decided to shout Yay! at the end of the Hallelujah. lol It took Father several minutes to regain his composure in order to read.
prose Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 I didn't read all the tips, so sorry if this is a repeat. We have actually been asked by a priest to take our kids to the cryroom because they are too distracting to the deacon How frustrating. I don't believe that children learn how to behave by playing in what is essentially a toy room. At the Church we are currently a part of, there is also no cry room, which originally frustrated me, but now I am grateful. Children are a part of the community more so than when they are shoved in a cryroom, although sometimes it is terribly embarassing for me when they act up. What do we do? Well, first off, we always sit at the back, or at the side of a row for easy exits. Secondly, hubby ALWAYS takes them out. If I do, it seems like a good thing to them. It is like they get some sort of special attention from me for being bad, so we quickly stopped with me soothing them and hubby took over. And I should add that he takes them right out of the Church sometimes and puts them in time out. It is not soothing time. They are in time out, and that is final. It isn't time to negotiate and calm them down, he puts them into timeout until they are ready to behave. One time my stubborn kid sat in time out outside for most of Mass. I know it is frustration. I feel your pain. I think we have all been through it. The important thing to remember is that when your child acts up, it is not time to soothe them, it is time to discipline them. Believe it or not, they learn quickly. It is much nicer to behave in Mass than to stand in time out Good luck. Oh, and just so you know, I had a breakdown in Mass before too. I was crying and the whole bit. It was AWFUL. This too shall pass
CatherineM Posted January 12, 2009 Posted January 12, 2009 I was trying to remember how mass was when I was a kid. I know we had a nursery because when I was older, I helped with it. Maybe it was because this was at the tail end of the baby boom, and there were just so many babies. I don't remember acting up in mass, but I'm sure I did. I just wonder if our attention spans were longer. I wonder what an older priest would say from his perspective if kids are harder to handle now, or just seem so because there are fewer.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now