Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Message From A Catholic In Israel


Recommended Posts

Posted

Message from a Catholic (Franciscan Grad) working in Israel. I asked him whether he thought Israel's actions constitute a just war. Given he is only miles from where rockets are falling, his opinion on the subject carries some weight.

[quote]As someone living about 40 miles away from where the rockets are falling – I would certainly say that it’s a just war. I’m really troubled by the number of Palestinian victims and the suffering that the war is bringing onto them, and angry that Hamas brought this on their own people with total contempt not only for Israeli lives, but for the lives of Palestinians too. The atmosphere is very heavy here, because it seems there will never be an end to this mess.

See the following two videos for a perspective on how the war is being fought and how Hamas is violating all rules of warfare according to international law.

[url="http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=42876108702&oid=41135539377&ref=nf"]http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=...9377&ref=nf[/url]

[url="http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?ai=58&ar=HamasExploitationofCiviliansV&ak=null"]http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?ai=...nsV&ak=null[/url]

As says Golda Meir at the end of the second video:

“We can forgive the Arabs for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us.”

I really recommend that you all subscribe to an email info service such as

[url="http://www.honestreporting.com/"]http://www.honestreporting.com/[/url]

or ICEJ News Service (Evangelical Christian)

It’s really important for Catholics to be in tune with what’s happening here, because it will eventually have repercussions on the whole world (it already is)

Blessings to all...[/quote]

foolishmortal
Posted

I guess the Israelis were nice when they gave the Arabs the Gaza area. I thought they just came back to Israel and, with international (mainly U.S.) support, shoved the Palestinians into a ghetto of an area. Can Golda forgive the Christian arabs for not making them (the Israelis) kill their (Arabs') children? It seems she doesn't know that area all that well. Still, I know the Israelis can't wait for the good ones to get out as Lot convinced God to do before He destroyed S&G.
I wonder if the Israelis could learn ninjitsu to take out those responsible when they have suspects. Don't they have some more Arab-looking Israeli citizens for modern spying and espionage and such, since they're all semitic people? Assassination might be against church teaching, I don't know, but less die than when bombs hit and the dead are more likely to be guilty. It's so sad so many probably won't see the face of God when they die in this way, not being baptized.

I know what people will say, but until dogma proves otherwise, we have to be real in that one not getting redeemed by baptism is a child of wrath. Better safe than sorry. For the just and innocent, the place they'd go is still a place of eternal happiness.

Anyway, I thought I heard that the Israelis mistreat even their Christian residents and I think it was EWTN, where I heard it. Is that true? That doesn't make Israel getting bombed by Hamas ok, but I don't think they're innocent lambs the media makes them out to be. Any nation with a lot of political power will abuse some people (their own and/or others) with it at some point.


[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748973' date='Jan 11 2009, 08:08 PM']Message from a Catholic (Franciscan Grad) working in Israel. I asked him whether he thought Israel's actions constitute a just war. Given he is only miles from where rockets are falling, his opinion on the subject carries some weight.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748973' date='Jan 11 2009, 10:08 PM']Message from a Catholic (Franciscan Grad) working in Israel. I asked him whether he thought Israel's actions constitute a just war. Given he is only miles from where rockets are falling, his opinion on the subject carries some weight.[/quote]

I'm glad to get his opinion on it, however I'm not sure how I feel about this. It seems like both parties have a lot of hatred for one another and I don't think either side will ever stop fighting unless, by some miracle, they can learn to forgive and put the past to rest. I have a problem with the fact that both the Israeli government and Hamas seem to be indiscriminate about bombing highly civilian populated areas. I also question the reasons why the US is so involved-it seems like we always have to "take sides" in things-personally I'd like to see humanitarian aid for both "sides" rather than military aid for one. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1749344' date='Jan 12 2009, 02:34 AM']I'm glad to get his opinion on it, however I'm not sure how I feel about this. It seems like both parties have a lot of hatred for one another and I don't think either side will ever stop fighting unless, by some miracle, they can learn to forgive and put the past to rest. I have a problem with the fact that both the Israeli government and Hamas seem to be indiscriminate about bombing highly civilian populated areas. I also question the reasons why the US is so involved-it seems like we always have to "take sides" in things-personally I'd like to see humanitarian aid for both "sides" rather than military aid for one. -Katie[/quote]

Israel deconstructing its settelments, acknowlidging the "right of return" (or just compensation) and withdrawing the the pre 1967 boarders would be a nice start and would also bring Israel in line with international law and numerous UN resolutions. Both sides must acknowledge the right of the other to exist in peace and security.

Posted

[quote name='foolishmortal' post='1749153' date='Jan 11 2009, 08:35 PM']Still, I know the Israelis can't wait for the good ones to get out as Lot convinced God to do before He destroyed S&G.[/quote]
It was Abraham, not Lot, who convinced God to spare Sodom and Gomorrah should there be just ten righteous men in the two cities.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1748973' date='Jan 11 2009, 09:08 PM']Message from a Catholic (Franciscan Grad) working in Israel. I asked him whether he thought Israel's actions constitute a just war. Given he is only miles from where rockets are falling, his opinion on the subject carries some weight.[/quote]


“We can forgive the Arabs for killing our children. We cannot forgive them for forcing us to kill their children. We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us.”

Yessssssssssssssssssssss! My ALL TIME favorite quote from Golda Meir.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='foolishmortal' post='1749153' date='Jan 11 2009, 11:35 PM']Anyway, I thought I heard that the Israelis mistreat even their Christian residents and I think it was EWTN, where I heard it. Is that true?[/quote]

No, it is not. There are numerous accounts of the generosity of the Israelis towards Christians. Their actions during the Muslim attack against the Christians in Lebanon in the 1970s was nothing short of saintly. They not only protected the Christians at the border of Israel (the ONLY place where the Christians could find safety and support) but they also opened their border to the Christians who were wounded and dying and treated them free of charge in their hospitals. There are untold numbers of stories of the Israeli graciousness towards Christians.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1749486' date='Jan 12 2009, 12:12 PM']No, it is not. There are numerous accounts of the generosity of the Israelis towards Christians. Their actions during the Muslim attack against the Christians in Lebanon in the 1970s was nothing short of saintly. They not only protected the Christians at the border of Israel (the ONLY place where the Christians could find safety and support) but they also opened their border to the Christians who were wounded and dying and treated them free of charge in their hospitals. There are untold numbers of stories of the Israeli graciousness towards Christians.[/quote]


They even provided them with illumination flares when they were slaughtering three thousand five hundred Palestinians!

:unsure:

Posted

If anyone is interested in a more balanced account of religious freedom in Israel they can find it here.

[url="http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2004/41723.htm"]http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2004/41723.htm[/url]

Israel like most countries has both good and bad, although I'd consider it pretty good for the region.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1749532' date='Jan 12 2009, 02:01 PM']They even provided them with illumination flares when they were slaughtering three thousand five hundred Palestinians!

:unsure:[/quote]

Hassan, stop telling lies here. There are people who are actually trying to learn about issues in the middle east and who are reading these posts to LEARN, not to engage in mudslinging against one side or the other. I cannot stand by and tolerate your unbelievable slanderous lies. If you want to accuse Israelis of "slaughtering" (which you don't seem to really understand the meaning of) Palestinians, then provide a web source. Otherwise, stop the slanderous outbursts. Childish!!!!!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1749541' date='Jan 12 2009, 02:25 PM']Hassan, stop telling lies here. There are people who are actually trying to learn about issues in the middle east and who are reading these posts to LEARN, not to engage in mudslinging against one side or the other. I cannot stand by and tolerate your unbelievable slanderous lies. If you want to accuse Israelis of "slaughtering" (which you don't seem to really understand the meaning of) Palestinians, then provide a web source. Otherwise, stop the slanderous outbursts. Childish!!!!![/quote]

I did not say the Israelis did the slaughtering. You were going on about how saintly the Israelis were to Lebanese Christians and I pointed out that they were even kind enough to provide the (largely) Christian nationalist party Kataeb with illumination flares when they slaughtered Palestinians somewhere between a few hundred and a few thousand Palestinians.

I assume that you know what happened at Sabra and Shatila?

[url="http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Foreign%20Relations/Israels%20Foreign%20Relations%20since%201947/1982-1984/104%20Report%20of%20the%20Commission%20of%20Inquiry%20into%20the%20e"]http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Foreign%20Relati...0into%20the%20e[/url]

The Minister of Defense, Mr. Ariel Sharon

The notice sent to the Minister of Defense under Section 15(A) stated that the Minister of Defense might be harmed if the commission determined that he ignored or disregarded the danger of acts of revenge or bloodshed perpetrated by Lebanese forces against the population of the refugee camps in Beirut and did not order the adoption of the withdrawal of the Lebanese forces from the refugee camps as quickly as possible and the adoption of measures to protect the population in the camps when information reached him about the acts of killing or excesses that were perpetrated by the Lebanese forces.

In his testimony before us, and in statements he issued beforehand, the Minister of Defense also adopted the position that no one had imagined the Phalangists would carry out a massacre in the camps and that it was a tragedy that could not be foreseen. It was stressed by the Minister of Defense in his testimony, and argued in his behalf, that the director of Military Intelligence, who spent time with him and maintained contact with him on the days prior to the Phalangists' entry into the camps and at the time of their entry into the camps, did not indicate the danger of a massacre, and that no warning was received from the Mossad, which was responsible for the liaison with the Phalangists and also had special knowledge of the character of this force.

It is true that no clear warning Was provided by military intelligence or the Mossad about what might happen if the Phalangist forces entered the camps, and we will relate to this matter when we discuss the responsibility of the director of Military Intelligence and the head of the Mossad. But in our view, even without such warning, it is impossible to justify the Minister of Defense's disregard of the danger of a massacre. We will not repeat here what we have already said above about the widespread knowledge regarding the Phalangists' combat ethics, their feelings of hatred toward the Palestinians, and their leaders' plans for the future of the Palestinians when said leaders would assume power. Besides this general knowledge, the Defense Minister also had special reports from his not inconsiderable [number of] meetings with the Phalangist heads before Bashir's assassination.

Giving the Phalangists the possibility of entering the refugee camps without taking measures for continuous and concrete supervision of their actions there could have created a grave danger for the civilian population in the camps even if they had been given such a possibility before Bashir's assassination; thus this danger was certainly to have been anticipated - and it was imperative to have foreseen it - after Bashir's assassination. The fact that it was not clear which organization had caused Bashir's death was of no importance at all, given the known frame of mind among the combatant camps in Lebanon. In the circumstances that prevailed after Bashir's assassination, no prophetic powers were required to know that concrete danger of acts of slaughter existed when the Phalangists were moved into the camps without the I.D.F.'s being with them in that operation and without the I.D.F. being able to maintain effective and ongoing supervision of their actions there. The sense of such a danger should have been in the consciousness of every knowledgeable person who was close to this subject, and certainly in the consciousness of the Defense Minister, who took an active part in everything relating to the war. His involvement in the war was deep, and the connection with the Phalangists was under his constant care. If in fact the Defense Minister, when he decided that the Phalangists would enter the camps without the I.D.F. taking part in the operation, did not think that that decision could bring about the very disaster that in fact occurred, the only possible explanation for this is that he disregarded any apprehensions about what was to be expected because the advantages - which we have already noted - to be gained from the Phalangists' entry into the camps distracted him from the proper consideration in this instance.

As a politician responsible for Israel's security affairs, and as a Minister who took an active part in directing the political and military moves in the war in Lebanon, it was the duty of the Defense Minister to take into account all the reasonable considerations for and against having the Phalangists enter the camps, and not to disregard entirely the serious consideraton mitigating against such an action, namely that the Phalangists were liable to commit atrocities and that it was necessary to forestall this possibility as a humanitarian obligation and also to prevent the political damage it would entail. From the Defense Minister himself we know that this consideration did not concern him in the least, and that this matter, with all its ramifications, was neither discussed nor examined in the meetings and discussion held by the Defense Minister. In our view, the Minister of Defense made a grave mistake when he ignored the danger of acts of revenge and bloodshed by the Phalangists against the population in the refugee camps.

We have already said above that we do not assert that the decision to have the Phalangists enter the camps should under no circumstances ever have been made. It appears to us that no complaints could be addressed to the Defense Minister in this matter if such a decision had been taken after all the relevant considerations had been examined; however, if the decision were taken with the awareness that the risk of harm to the inhabitants existed, the obligation existed to adopt measures which would ensure effective and ongoing supervision by the I.D.F. over the actions of the Phalangists at the site, in such a manner as to prevent the danger or at least reduce it considerably. The Defense Minister issued no order regarding the adoption of such measures. We shall not dwell here on what steps might have been taken; this we shall consider below. Regarding the responsibility of the Minister of Defense, it is sufficient to assert that he issued no order to the I.D.F. to adopt suitable measures. Similarly, in his meetings with the Phalangist commanders, the Defense Minister made no attempt to point out to them the gravity of the danger that their men would commit acts of slaughter. Although it is not certain that remarks to this effect by the Defense Minister would have prevented the acts of massacre, they might have had an effect on the Phalangist commanders who, out of concern for their political interests, would have imposed appropriate supervision over their people and seen to it that they did not exceed regular combat operations. It was related above that a few hours after the Phalangists entered the camps, soldiers at the site asked what to do with the people who had fallen into their hands, and the replies they were given not only did not bar them from harming those people, but even urged them to do so. It is a highly reasonable assumption that had the commanders who gave that reply heard from the Defense Minister or from higher Phalangist commanders a clear and explicit order barring harm to civilians and spelling out the damage this was liable to cause the Phalangists, their reply to these questions would have been different.

Had it become clear to the Defense Minister that no real supervision could be exercised over the Phalangist force that entered the camps with the I.D.F.'s assent, his duty would have been to prevent their entry. The usefulness of the Phalangists' entry into the camps was wholly disproportionate to the damage their entry could cause if it were uncontrolled. A good many people who heard about the Phalangists' entry into the camps were aware of this even before the first reports arrived about the massacre. The Chief of Staff in effect also held the same opinion, as emerges from his reply to a question whether he would have issued orders for additional measures to be taken or would have sufficed with the steps that were in fact taken, had it been expected that the Phalangists would commit excesses. He replied as follows (p. 1677):

"No, if I had expected that this was liable to happen, or if someone had warned me that this was liable to happen, they would not have entered the camps."

In reply to another question, whether he would have taken additional measures, the Chief of Staff said:

"They would not have entered the camps; I would not have allowed them to enter the camps."

Asked if he would not have allowed the Phalangists to enter the camps despite the aim of having them operate together with the I.D.F. and spare the I.D.F. losses, the Chief of Staff replied:

"Then maybe we should have acted differently, by closing the camps, by surrounding them, or bringing them to surrender in another week or in another few days, or shelling them with all our might from the air and with artillery. As for me, if I had anticipated that this is what would happen, or if such a warning had been given, they would not have entered the camps."

And the Chief of Staff added that if he had suspected or feared that what happened would happen, "they would not have entered the camps at all, they would not have come anywhere near the camps." We quote these remarks here in order to show that despite the usefulness of having the Phalangists enter the camps, that step should have been abandoned if a massacre could not have been prevented using the means in the I.D.F.'s hands.

We do not accept the contention that the Defense Minister did not need to fear that the Phalangists would commit acts of killing because in all outward aspects they looked like a disciplined and organized army. It could not be inferred from the Phalangists' orderly military organization that their attitude toward human life and to the non-combatant population had basically changed. It might perhaps be inferred from their military organization that the soldiers would heed the orders of their commanders and not break discipline; but at the very least, care should have been taken that the commanders were imbued with the awareness that no excesses were to be committed and that they give their men unequivocal orders to this effect. The routine warnings that I.D.F. commanders issued to the Phalangists, which were of the same kind as were routinely issued to I.D.F. troops, could not have had any concrete effect.

We shall remark here that it is ostensibly puzzling that the Defense Minister did not in any way make the Prime Minister privy to the decision on having the Phalangists enter the camps.

It is our view that responsibility is to be imputed to the Minister of Defense for having disregarded the danger of acts of vengeance and bloodshed by the Phalangists against the population of the refugee camps, and having failed to take this danger into account when he decided to have the Phalangists enter the camps. In addition, responsibility is to be imputed to the Minister of Defense for not ordering appropriate measures for preventing or reducing the danger of massacre as a condition for the Phalangists' entry into the camps. These blunders constitute the non-fulfillment of a duty with which the Defense Minister was charged.

We do not believe that responsibility is to be imputed to the Defense Minister for not ordering the removal of the Phalangists from the camps when the first reports reached him about the acts of killing being committed there. As was detailed above, such reports initially reached the Defense Minister on Friday evening; but at the same time, he had heard from the Chief of Staff that the Phalangists' operation had been halted, that they had been ordered to leave the camps and that their departure would be effected by 5:00 a.m. Saturday. These preventive steps might well have seemed sufficient to the Defense Minister at that time, and it was not his duty to order additional steps to be taken, or to have the departure time moved up, a step which was of doubtful feasibility.

Edited by Hassan
Posted

Madam V.

Has Israel ever wronged the Palestinians?

KnightofChrist
Posted

I would agree with the original post "Hamas is violating all rules" and this is a just war by Israel, not that she is prefect, but Hamas is the unjust aggressor clearly, and pretty stupid indeed by doing such things as legalizing Crucifixion.

Posted

Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem condemns Gaza violence
January 12, 2009

In an impassioned address yesterday at the conclusion of an annual children’s procession to Bethlehem, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Fouad Twal condemned “the violence in the Middle East and in a special way the attacks in the Gaza Strip. In two weeks these attacks have hurt Israel and the region more than all the rockets launched across the years … This violence has caused a huge loss of life and destruction of homes, schools and institutions, wreaking immense damage and bringing terrible suffering for the civilian population, especially to many innocent children.”

Echoing Pope Benedict’s words that “military options are no solution and that violence, wherever it comes from and in whatever form, must be firmly condemned,” the patriarch said that “we are a people who have suffered and continue to suffer from violence for 60 years. We are also re-born children of God, whose Son came here and who suffered so that all may hope in His victory.”

“We are not political leaders,“ the patriarch added, “but as we pray for Christ to come into our hearts, to strengthen us in our hope and faith, today we take on the mission of Christ, which knows no boundaries or borders. Let our love, sacrifices and prayers lead political leaders to building a civilization of love, reconciliation and security to everyone.”

[url="http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-twal/archives/2009/01/child-journey-bethlehem.html"]http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-t...-bethlehem.html[/url]

Posted

[quote name='cappie' post='1749711' date='Jan 12 2009, 07:09 PM']Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem condemns Gaza violence
January 12, 2009

In an impassioned address yesterday at the conclusion of an annual children’s procession to Bethlehem, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Fouad Twal condemned “the violence in the Middle East and in a special way the attacks in the Gaza Strip. In two weeks these attacks have hurt Israel and the region more than all the rockets launched across the years … This violence has caused a huge loss of life and destruction of homes, schools and institutions, wreaking immense damage and bringing terrible suffering for the civilian population, especially to many innocent children.”

Echoing Pope Benedict’s words that “military options are no solution and that violence, wherever it comes from and in whatever form, must be firmly condemned,” the patriarch said that “we are a people who have suffered and continue to suffer from violence for 60 years. We are also re-born children of God, whose Son came here and who suffered so that all may hope in His victory.”

“We are not political leaders,“ the patriarch added, “but as we pray for Christ to come into our hearts, to strengthen us in our hope and faith, today we take on the mission of Christ, which knows no boundaries or borders. Let our love, sacrifices and prayers lead political leaders to building a civilization of love, reconciliation and security to everyone.”

[url="http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-twal/archives/2009/01/child-journey-bethlehem.html"]http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-t...-bethlehem.html[/url][/quote]

well said on his part.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='cappie' post='1749711' date='Jan 12 2009, 07:09 PM']Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem condemns Gaza violence
January 12, 2009

In an impassioned address yesterday at the conclusion of an annual children’s procession to Bethlehem, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem Fouad Twal condemned “the violence in the Middle East and in a special way the attacks in the Gaza Strip. In two weeks these attacks have hurt Israel and the region more than all the rockets launched across the years … This violence has caused a huge loss of life and destruction of homes, schools and institutions, wreaking immense damage and bringing terrible suffering for the civilian population, especially to many innocent children.”

Echoing Pope Benedict’s words that “military options are no solution and that violence, wherever it comes from and in whatever form, must be firmly condemned,” the patriarch said that “we are a people who have suffered and continue to suffer from violence for 60 years. We are also re-born children of God, whose Son came here and who suffered so that all may hope in His victory.”

“We are not political leaders,“ the patriarch added, “but as we pray for Christ to come into our hearts, to strengthen us in our hope and faith, today we take on the mission of Christ, which knows no boundaries or borders. Let our love, sacrifices and prayers lead political leaders to building a civilization of love, reconciliation and security to everyone.”

[url="http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-twal/archives/2009/01/child-journey-bethlehem.html"]http://www.lpj.org/newsite2006/patriarch-t...-bethlehem.html[/url][/quote]

I'm confused, why do we never hear of any official in the Church speaking of Hamas as they do Israel? Hamas just recently legalized Crucifixion, has this or any Church Official spoken out about that?

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1749708' date='Jan 12 2009, 07:06 PM']I would agree with the original post "Hamas is violating all rules" and this is a just war by Israel, not that she is prefect, but Hamas is the unjust aggressor clearly, and pretty stupid indeed by doing such things as legalizing Crucifixion.[/quote]

This is not a just war. They cannot claim to be the "unblemished lamb lead to the slaughter" or hope to have any moral high ground until they stop brutalizing the Gazan population. That does not justify Hamas targeting Israeli civilians and their leadership need to be held responsible in the criminal court of law for their violations of the laws of war against Israeli civilians but so does the Israeli leadership.

Neither government can claim any clear moral superiority.

KnightofChrist
Posted

Israel would still be the lesser of two evils.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1749726' date='Jan 12 2009, 07:30 PM']I'm confused, why do we never hear of any official in the Church speaking of Hamas as they do Israel? Hamas just recently legalized Crucifixion, has this or any Church Official spoken out about that?[/quote]

.
Perhaps because there is such an asymmetrical relationship between the two sides in terms of power or resources.

Posted

I am fairly uneducated about all the different groups, histories, and personalities involved, but if the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem and Pope Benedict are against what is happening, I am certainly willing to accept interpretation of the situation. Since neither side would care what my opinion is on the matter anyway, all I can do is pray for peace.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...