Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Maybe some of the Phatmass philosophers can tackle this question. Is beauty objective? We don't all agree on what is beautiful. One person may find something beautiful that another person finds ugly. And sometimes we even find a certain beauty in ugliness.

God is beauty itself. The Catechism quotes St Augustine:

[quote]And St. Augustine issues this challenge: Question the beauty of the earth, question the beauty of the sea, question the beauty of the air distending and diffusing itself, question the beauty of the sky...question all these realities. All respond: "See, we are beautiful." Their beauty is a profession [confessio]. These beauties are subject to change. Who made them if not the Beautiful One [Pulcher] who is not subject to change?

--CCC #32[/quote]
St. Augustine seems to distinguish between earthly beauty (which can change), and the unchanging beauty of God. Is earthly beauty objective or subjective? Is it in the eye of the beholder, or is it in the thing itself? If earthly beauty is subjective, how does it relate to the unchanging beauty of God?

Posted (edited)

personally your boy thinks he's very beautiful. :cool:
although,
i cant usually get the females to get on the same line of thought. :ohno:


lame
i know

good topic
e-money

Edited by Guest
Posted

I don't have much time to post, but I'd recommend reading von Balthasaar

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

This is all my thought on this, so I don't know how much merit it holds, but I would say that there would be two levels of beauty in earthly objects: the physical beauty we behold and the created beauty that is innate within it because it was created by God Who is Beautiful. Since all of creation does reflect God in someway, everything in creation would have some beauty innate within it just because it is created by God. However, that could be different than the physical beauty that we see everyday. Take for example an old, starving man on the streets of Calcutta. He's bruised, mangled, starved, covered in his own filth, and hasn't had a bath in who knows how long: not a very pretty sight to behold. However, does that take away from the beauty of that man as a son of God and our brother in Christ? Of course not! God is present within him, and he reflects the beauty of God, but not necessarially physically. I think the same could be said for the rest of creation, obviously not on the same level as the example since man is the epitomy of creation, by I think the analogy works. I hope this makes sense and helps out some!

May God bless and protect you always in all of your endeavors!

Your Brother in Christ,

Joe

Posted

Speaking specifically about earthly beauty, I'd say that it's absolutely subjective.
We're talking physical and 'personality', even though personality starts to cross over into human dignity, which is, of course, objectively beautiful.
In terms of this 'earthly beauty' though, it's quite obvious. Some guys are more attracted to, for instance, blonde haired women, and some to brown hair. I know a girl who finds hands and necks especially attractive. It's just the way we see things. We don't really know why, and who needs to anyway?

This is, of course, assuming that the image and likeness of God in all mankind is explicity and consciously accepted already. :))

Posted

I do not feel prepared to debate my position, but I would be willing to discuss it and research it as the thread progresses.

Yes. Beauty is objective. Inasmuch as all beauty finds its source and standard in God, it may be measured. What may be measured may therefore be regarded with objectivity. I remember a lecture on Peter Kreeft's website dealing with this...

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I started reading a book some time ago (never finished it) that you might enjoy: The Evidential Power of Beauty by Fr. Dubay.

Just a recommendation.

And yes, beauty is objective intrinsically, though there are subjective elements. I would say that beauty is objective because, well, human eyes are always prettier than human feet. Sorry, but I think there's an objective fact to it. Human eyes do more to speak to the presence of personhood and therefore the dignity of personhood which relies on the call to communion with God. There's a whole theology to eyes. However, within that objective reality I think there is some room for subjective interpretation, i.e. what's more beautiful: blue eyes or brown? How about green? Hazel?

We tackled this question in one of my FUS classes. Our professor resolved it rather simply. She showed two movie posters for the Lord of the Rings, one with Frodo, Bilbo, Gandolf, Merry and Pippin, Legolas, etc. The other poster showed Sauron, Sarumon, Gollum, etc.

How many people would disagree with that comparison?

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1751838' date='Jan 15 2009, 11:32 AM']How many people would [s]disagree[/s] [i]honestly disagree[/i] with that comparison?[/quote]

Fixed that for you.

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1751633' date='Jan 14 2009, 11:35 PM']Yes. Beauty is objective. Inasmuch as all beauty finds its source and standard in God, it may be measured. What may be measured may therefore be regarded with objectivity. I remember a lecture on Peter Kreeft's website dealing with this...[/quote]

If this statement is true (I hear the author can be a real blockhead, you know), then it would seem that the degree to which something is beautiful corresponds with the degree to which "Beauty" itself is revealed; that is, the more a thing speaks of God, the more beautiful a thing is.

There is a subjective element here, to be sure. I'm not entirely unconvinced that a parallel could be drawn with discernment of culpability in moral thought experiments. The moral law is itself objective, but the degree to which one offends it varies from act to act, situation to situation, and person to person.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...