Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[url="http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech_and_web/article5516511.ece"]http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/ne...icle5516511.ece[/url]

this is really really sad.

Posted

Well isn't that just lovely. :rolleyes:

Fr. Antony Maria OSB
Posted

This really saddens me...I don't understand why people my age, and younger!, would do this kind of thing. Why don't they see they're only demeaning themselves and others by doing this kind of thing?! :sadder:

Posted

The temptation is there, and it seems you can 'get away with it' - people still think the internet is anonymous and cell phones are private, despite all the evidence to the contrary. Digital pictures can be taken and distributed without being developed, so the embarrassment of sending off a roll of film that will doubtless be seen by other people is eliminated. Very sad, though.

Posted

I think the idea of this is demeaning and wrong, but frankly the local law agencies are going completly overboard here. Charge 13 year old boys and girls with having child pornography. That is just messed up. What next, should we charge 5 year old boys and girls with lewd conduct and obsenity laws when they show each other their private parts? This is just stupid.

I understand its wrong but to charge children with a crime you charge adults with is assinine. Suspend them from school, kick them out of school, but don't lock them up and ruin their life and have them branded a SEX OFFENDER for the rest fo their life for something stupid they did with other people their own age.

Posted

^ agreed. if a 16 year old has sex with another 16year old it isnt called child abuse or paedophilia.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1751540' date='Jan 14 2009, 08:14 PM']I think the idea of this is demeaning and wrong, but frankly the local law agencies are going completly overboard here. Charge 13 year old boys and girls with having child pornography. That is just messed up. What next, should we charge 5 year old boys and girls with lewd conduct and obsenity laws when they show each other their private parts? This is just stupid.

I understand its wrong but to charge children with a crime you charge adults with is assinine. Suspend them from school, kick them out of school, but don't lock them up and ruin their life and have them branded a SEX OFFENDER for the rest fo their life for something stupid they did with other people their own age.[/quote]
These 13 year olds should know far better than to be taking explicit pictures of themselves.
Of course it would be ridiculous if they got prosecuted to the full extent of child porn charges, but I'm all for charging them with something.
I wouldn't go so far as to call them a sex offender, but maybe make a new distinction, if you will, somehow related to public indecency.

Besides that, it's frankly dangerous. These pictures can end up on the internet just like that. Then it is child porn, and these kids are at serious risk of being exploited.

Kids need to be taught what's right and wrong, and what's so ridiculously wrong we should even have to say. Except we do. This is one of those things. It's for them, in the end.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1751578' date='Jan 14 2009, 09:56 PM']These 13 year olds should know far better than to be taking explicit pictures of themselves.
Of course it would be ridiculous if they got prosecuted to the full extent of child porn charges, but I'm all for charging them with something.
I wouldn't go so far as to call them a sex offender, but maybe make a new distinction, if you will, somehow related to public indecency.

Besides that, it's frankly dangerous. These pictures can end up on the internet just like that. Then it is child porn, and these kids are at serious risk of being exploited.

Kids need to be taught what's right and wrong, and what's so ridiculously wrong we should even have to say. Except we do. This is one of those things. It's for them, in the end.[/quote]

Why do we not charge adults who look at adult porn on the internet then? Cause they are looking at other adults. The minute they look at someone who is considered a minor, it is a crime. Its a crime because the person looking at the child porn is an adult and the porn is of a minor.

A 13 year old should know better? Well that is true, but why then do we treat them as adults here but other spects of law as a minor. If a kid commits theft he is usually sent to juvi, where as an adult is sent to prision. If a kid commits murder, he is not always tried as an adult. Yet if an adult commits murder, he is always tried as an adult.

Should we now arrest teens for having sex since they are having sex with a minor? Its the same basic principle. So why don't we do this? Then they to can be branded as a sex offender for having sex when they were 16 with another 16 year old.

Sending them to jail on child porn charges is not for them, its for us as a society. Sending a child, a minor to jail and ruining their life for a stupid mistake of sending naked pitcuters to their girl/boy friend is not for them.

Also why not suspend the child from school or expell them or ban all phones from school property. No, lets jump to the most harsh of punishments and send them to jail. That makes no sense. YOu screw up in your teenage years. We all did. Most of us messed up worse in our teens years than in our adult years. We made mistakes and we learned from them because people helped teach us right from wrong. We didn't learn from them by being thrown in jail.

How many adults in this world have commited adultry. Should we throw them in jail then to because almost every single state has adultry as a crime on their books. If we're going to get so technical on the law, then should we not throw every adultrus adult into jail also.

Kids make mistakes and throwing them in jail for this mistake will teach them nothing, other then throw their future away.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1751569' date='Jan 14 2009, 09:48 PM']^ agreed. if a 16 year old has sex with another 16year old it isnt called child abuse or paedophilia.[/quote]

No but it could be a sexual assault in some states.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1751678' date='Jan 14 2009, 11:06 PM']Should we now arrest teens for having sex since they are having sex with a minor? Its the same basic principle. So why don't we do this? Then they to can be branded as a sex offender for having sex when they were 16 with another 16 year old.[/quote]
There are some states that see it that way. I've seen a 19 yr old go to prison for having consensual sex with a 16 yr old. The 16 yr old didn't have a problem with it, even on the day he was sentenced. The mom did though...


[quote]How many adults in this world have commited adultry. Should we throw them in jail then to because almost every single state has adultry as a crime on their books. If we're going to get so technical on the law, then should we not throw every adultrus adult into jail also.[/quote]

I don't think this is true.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1751729' date='Jan 14 2009, 10:39 PM']There are some states that see it that way. I've seen a 19 yr old go to prison for having consensual sex with a 16 yr old. The 16 yr old didn't have a problem with it, even on the day he was sentenced. The mom did though...[/quote]

I think that law applies here (in CA) It's because it's considered 'rape' since the 19 year-old is and adult and the 16 year-old is a minor

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1751729' date='Jan 15 2009, 12:39 AM']There are some states that see it that way. I've seen a 19 yr old go to prison for having consensual sex with a 16 yr old. The 16 yr old didn't have a problem with it, even on the day he was sentenced. The mom did though...




I don't think this is true.[/quote]


That is completly different because the 19 year old is an adult and the 16 year old is a minor. Thats the same as a 40 year old and a 16 year old. I am talking if both are minors.


Actually point number 2 is true. Adultry laws were put back in effect when women were not allowed to vote and were not equals. They have never been taken off the books because what poloticion in their right mind would agrue that adultry is good and would fight to take the law off the books when it is never enforced.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1751728' date='Jan 15 2009, 12:36 AM']No but it could be a sexual assault in some states.[/quote]


but so technically could it be if two 5 year olds flash each other. A minor does not have the same rights as an adult so why on earth should they have the same punishments. Minors by law are not allowed to make their own decisions, yet we are saying even though they don't have the mental compacity to make their own legal and medical decisions, they have the legal capability to make adult decisions of right and wrong when it comes to sex. Not to mention when hormones are racing as they hit puberty. You can't have it both ways. You cant say a person is a minor in some aspects because they are not capable of acting like and adult but then the next thing say they are an adult because they should be making adult decisions. If your are saying they should be punished as an adult in the case, then they should have the right at that age to make their own decisions about smoking, about their medical issues, about all their own legal issues and about drinking.

Your setting up a double standard here that says when I say you have to act like and adult, you have to, but when I say your a minor, then I will treat you as a minor. Double standard.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1751678' date='Jan 14 2009, 10:06 PM']Why do we not charge adults who look at adult porn on the internet then? Cause they are looking at other adults. The minute they look at someone who is considered a minor, it is a crime. Its a crime because the person looking at the child porn is an adult and the porn is of a minor.

A 13 year old should know better? Well that is true, but why then do we treat them as adults here but other spects of law as a minor. If a kid commits theft he is usually sent to juvi, where as an adult is sent to prision. If a kid commits murder, he is not always tried as an adult. Yet if an adult commits murder, he is always tried as an adult.

Should we now arrest teens for having sex since they are having sex with a minor? Its the same basic principle. So why don't we do this? Then they to can be branded as a sex offender for having sex when they were 16 with another 16 year old.

Sending them to jail on child porn charges is not for them, its for us as a society. Sending a child, a minor to jail and ruining their life for a stupid mistake of sending naked pitcuters to their girl/boy friend is not for them.

Also why not suspend the child from school or expell them or ban all phones from school property. No, lets jump to the most harsh of punishments and send them to jail. That makes no sense. YOu screw up in your teenage years. We all did. Most of us messed up worse in our teens years than in our adult years. We made mistakes and we learned from them because people helped teach us right from wrong. We didn't learn from them by being thrown in jail.

How many adults in this world have commited adultry. Should we throw them in jail then to because almost every single state has adultry as a crime on their books. If we're going to get so technical on the law, then should we not throw every adultrus adult into jail also.

Kids make mistakes and throwing them in jail for this mistake will teach them nothing, other then throw their future away.[/quote]
I think I made a distinction, but in case I wasn't clear enough, I'll say it again.

I said that I DO NOT think they should be prosecuted to the full extent of child pornography charges. I think it would be easiest if there were to be a new section of the law similar to public indecency which could lay down some kind of consequences WITHOUT sending the kids to prison and branding them as sex offenders.
[quote]Why do we not charge adults who look at adult porn on the internet then? Cause they are looking at other adults. The minute they look at someone who is considered a minor, it is a crime. Its a crime because the person looking at the child porn is an adult and the porn is of a minor.[/quote]
I think 'adult' porn should be illegal too.
It's an entirely different situation though. Child pornography is illegal because of the rampant expoitation of children. Adults in theory (keyword there) should be responsible enough to not allow themselves to be expoited. Obviously it doesn't work that way, and I want it illegal anyway.
[quote]How many adults in this world have commited adultry. Should we throw them in jail then to because almost every single state has adultry as a crime on their books. If we're going to get so technical on the law, then should we not throw every adultrus adult into jail also.[/quote]
[quote]This is absolutely not the same situation. Now you're off on a tangent.
Also why not suspend the child from school or expell them or ban all phones from school property. No, lets jump to the most harsh of punishments and send them to jail.[/quote]
Yes, let's suspend them and ban cell phones. I NEVER ONCE said throw them all in prison.


Please don't do that again.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' post='1751540' date='Jan 14 2009, 10:14 PM']I think the idea of this is demeaning and wrong, but frankly the local law agencies are going completly overboard here. Charge 13 year old boys and girls with having child pornography. That is just messed up. What next, should we charge 5 year old boys and girls with lewd conduct and obsenity laws when they show each other their private parts? This is just stupid.

I understand its wrong but to charge children with a crime you charge adults with is assinine. Suspend them from school, kick them out of school, but don't lock them up and ruin their life and have them branded a SEX OFFENDER for the rest fo their life for something stupid they did with other people their own age.[/quote]

Yeah I really don't see the legal justification for this. If they're 13, and they have pictures of other 13 year olds, it shouldn't be considered a punishable offense. I mean...I don't want to get too graphic here so I'll put spoiler tags up on it. [spoiler]But when I first started fooling around with girls at around 13 or 14, why would I have been possibly breaking a law? I was 13, they were 13. So what's the legal issue here[/spoiler]. I just don't understand.

Posted

When I was 13, if I wanted to post nude photos of myself, they would have had to pass through the hands of a photo developer. Times have changed, and we are desperately trying to play catch up. Child porn laws are in place to protect children. The state has a fiduciary responsibility to protect kids, even from themselves. Sometimes cases like this are prosecuted, even when they know there is no chance that there will be a conviction, just for the public benefit. It made the news. People are talking about it, and hopefully parents who would never have considered the idea that their kids would do something like this, will be talking to their kids about it. Sometimes cases like this are prosecuted to simply force the parents to do more supervision. They can't charge the parents, but they can make supervision part of the parole/plea bargain agreement.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1751979' date='Jan 15 2009, 02:20 PM']When I was 13, if I wanted to post nude photos of myself, they would have had to pass through the hands of a photo developer. Times have changed, and we are desperately trying to play catch up. Child porn laws are in place to protect children. The state has a fiduciary responsibility to protect kids, even from themselves. Sometimes cases like this are prosecuted, even when they know there is no chance that there will be a conviction, just for the public benefit. It made the news. People are talking about it, and hopefully parents who would never have considered the idea that their kids would do something like this, will be talking to their kids about it. Sometimes cases like this are prosecuted to simply force the parents to do more supervision. They can't charge the parents, but they can make supervision part of the parole/plea bargain agreement.[/quote]

I guess.....still seems like too much government for me. How about making some PSAs or something instead of humiliating these select-few teens that have gotten caught? This seems like a drastic step that will do more harm than good for these scape-goats.

Posted

No one mentions what I think is my best point. :(

Why not just have a new law? No locking anyone up and throwing away the key. No sex offender status for the rest of their lives.
How about suspension or expulsion from school, confiscation of the phone, maybe a fine, mandatory clinics about... I dunno, you get what I'm saying, right?!?
There's no reason to go overboard, and there's no reason we just have to let it happen.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1752097' date='Jan 15 2009, 04:48 PM']No one mentions what I think is my best point. :(

Why not just have a new law? No locking anyone up and throwing away the key. No sex offender status for the rest of their lives.
How about suspension or expulsion from school, confiscation of the phone, maybe a fine, mandatory clinics about... I dunno, you get what I'm saying, right?!?
There's no reason to go overboard, and there's no reason we just have to let it happen.[/quote]

If you added a level of anonymity to this, I'd be down for it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...