Lil Red Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 +J.M.J.+ [url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1116602/Why-face-truth-Having-autistic-child-wrecks-life-.html"]From the Daily Mail[/url] [quote]In any case, that is a difficult question after the event: it is hard for a mother retrospectively to wish away a living child who, come what may, she loves. But looking on, as a relatively dispassionate observer; looking at the damage done, the absence of hope and the anguish of the poor child himself, do I think that everyone concerned would have been better off if Tom's had been a life unlived? Unequivocally, yes.[/quote]
dominicansoul Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 (edited) There are three autistic children in my life. One of them is my oldest brother's son. He has severe autism and hasn't spoken a word since he was born 21 years ago. But their family would never have been what it is today without him. Another one is 19, and my late brother's son. Again, if he had never been born, my sister-n-law would be all alone right now... Jo-Jo has been her strength, and as she once told me, "Gives me meaning in my life..." And lastly, the youngest of them all, is 4 years old and the less severe of them all. Eric is learning to say a few words, can understand everybody around him, but he gets into little fits and gets "lost" in his autism for brief moments and spells. I dont' think my Sister and her husband, who now can not conceive except for this one child of theirs, would ever wish him away.... the gal who wrote this article sounds like a selfish jerk....and if anything, shows that autistic children have much more class than she ever could... Edited January 15, 2009 by dominicansoul
Brother Adam Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 rooted in the Protestant principle of the depravity and worthlessness of man rather than the Catholic principle of inherent dignity of man and his creation in God's image and likeness.
CatherineM Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 If a special needs child is wrecking their lives, why did they have children in the first place. Children aren't little clean, sweet smelling statues that never disrupt things. They are chaos at times. Sounds more like they are wrecking their child's life.
LouisvilleFan Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1751963' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:58 PM']rooted in the Protestant principle of the depravity and worthlessness of man rather than the Catholic principle of inherent dignity of man and his creation in God's image and likeness.[/quote] Total Depravity is the "T" of Calvin's TULIP, so that's specifically a Calvinist doctrine, and Calvinism is only one of the several varieties of Protestantism. It's rooted in the doctrine of original sin, but like most heresies, it's error is exhalting one truth above others. Worthlessness of mankind is a nihilist doctrine. Edited January 15, 2009 by LouisvilleFan
mamalove Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 (edited) [quote name='CatherineM' post='1751964' date='Jan 15 2009, 12:59 PM']Sounds more like they are wrecking their child's life.[/quote] Sounds like it to me. The writer never said anything about exactly what the parents are doing to try to help their son other than a fleeting mention of a special school. It sounds to me like they keep trying to make him conform to [i]their[/i] lives instead of really looking at [i]his[/i] needs and how he reacts to the world arouind him and learning ways for everyone to cope. A contraversial topic in itself, but have they ever thought about medication? We were very reluctant to go that route ourselves for Peter, but have found that they make all the difference in the world sometimes. No more throwing chairs at other children. No more hitting and kicking the teacher. No more spitting in others faces or throwing scissors. He still has his "outbursts" but he gets over them faster and we are able to communicate with him enough now that he can learn coping techniques. It's hard to parent these kids. I am so thankful that Pete's case is nowhere near the level of this little boy. However, it still sounds to me like they need to look a little closer at their son and focus less on enabling him and more on helping him. IMHO Edited January 15, 2009 by mamalove
MithLuin Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 (edited) To compare a potential test for autism to a test for Downs Syndrome is absurd. The reason we can test for Downs is because it's a case of trisomy - you have an extra chromosome in every single cell in your body (kinda hard to miss!) That too has a bit of a spectrum, with some children being much higher functioning than others. But autism - while we suspect that it is genetic (you are born with it), symptoms don't appear in the beginning, so we aren't entirely sure. Until we isolate a gene that causes it, the test would be worthless. Since autism is a spectrum, I highly doubt it is something as simple as a single gene, and thus it's going to be very difficult to capture in a test. And considering the wide range of outcomes, are people really going to be able to predict whether this child will be like 'Tom' or rather have a mild case of Aspergers? Of course, the idea that you should test your kids in advance and then abort them if they happen to test positive is horrible. If there were a genetic test, the responsible thing to do would be to test the parents, so you would know if you are at risk before you decide to have children. Then you can make an informed decision on whether or not to become parents at all (like is currently done for those at risk for Tay Sachs.) What Tom needs is help, not for people to wish him dead. What Tom's parents need is assistance. Killing everyone does tend to eliminate problems, but it can hardly be viewed as a solution. I know a woman whose autistic son is institutionalized; it is very difficult for her family, but if you [u]cannot[/u] cope, that is what you have to do. Edited January 15, 2009 by MithLuin
CatherineM Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 Autism and genetics argument is very similar to the one being done for schizophrenia. They think it is partially genetic, such as a susceptibility to get it, but it requires a trigger. For children at risk, there are therapies that can be done, and life style changes/choices that can be made to lessen the risk of developing full blown schizophrenia. There are scientists who think autism is actually a form of schizophrenia. If we start testing for these genes they are finding that could be responsible, then you are talking about a lot of abortions. How many parents would continue with a pregnancy if they were told that there is a possibility of autism, schizophrenia, bipolar, etc? A lot wouldn't.
Dan Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 A couple Hermann and his wife had a son whom they feared would be retarted. His learning was painfully slow and he had an attitude about learning which was a bit hesitant. It was thought that his learning difficulties may have been linked to dyslexia. Had abortion been an option and if Albert Einstein's parents killed him, how profoundly different would be the world of science.
MithLuin Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 Isaac Newton was almost definitely on the autism spectrum (though clearly very high-functioning). He was hardly a social person. He lived with his mother. He had [i]one[/i] friend, whom he did not have good boundaries with. Basically, if socialization is the only thing that makes life worth living...then Helen Keller should have been left to her own devices? No one would wish a difficult child on anyone. I think everyone appreciates that the parents described in the article have a very tough time of it. But then [i]help[/i] them!
jkaands Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 [quote name='Dan' post='1752042' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:29 PM']A couple Hermann and his wife had a son whom they feared would be retarted. His learning was painfully slow and he had an attitude about learning which was a bit hesitant. It was thought that his learning difficulties may have been linked to dyslexia. Had abortion been an option and if Albert Einstein's parents killed him, how profoundly different would be the world of science.[/quote] Einstein was genetically normal. His parents concerns about him was that he was slow to learn to speak (prob thinking about what he wanted to say!) In another thread people have been talking about what would happen if 'a gene' were discovered for homosexuality. IF this 'gene' and others for autism were discovered and confirmed with hard science, there is [i]no question[/i] that testing for these genes and subsequent abortion would become very widespread.
T-Bone _ Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 [quote name='jkaands' post='1752072' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:18 PM']Einstein was genetically normal. His parents concerns about him was that he was slow to learn to speak (prob thinking about what he wanted to say!)[/quote] He was? You have that on good authority? I was unaware that his DNA had been tested for abnormalities...
icelandic_iceskater Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1751956' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:51 PM']And thus is the world we live in. [/quote]
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1751962' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:58 PM']the gal who wrote this article sounds like a selfish jerk....and if anything, shows that autistic children have much more class than she ever could...[/quote] That's what I was thinking. Re: genetic testing, things like this are why I deny ALL optional genetic tests. I'd probably punch my doctor if they dared suggest I get an abortion.
missionseeker Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 [quote name='Dan' post='1752042' date='Jan 15 2009, 03:29 PM']A couple Hermann and his wife had a son whom they feared would be retarted. His learning was painfully slow and he had an attitude about learning which was a bit hesitant. It was thought that his learning difficulties may have been linked to dyslexia. Had abortion been an option and if Albert Einstein's parents killed him, how profoundly different would be the world of science.[/quote] but we should stop think about Einstein and Mozart and think about every day people like Cath and John.
CatherineM Posted January 15, 2009 Posted January 15, 2009 I hadn't thought about that before, but I wonder how many parents would abort a child if they showed some gene supposed to cause SSA?
jkaands Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='T-Bone _' post='1752073' date='Jan 15 2009, 02:21 PM']He was? You have that on good authority? I was unaware that his DNA had been tested for abnormalities...[/quote] Einstein was normal. He was always viewed as normal, even when he was a genius. No one thought about aborting him. He had a normal childhood, except that he was slow to speak. He seemed to have been brilliant from the time he entered school, but didn't bother studying subjects that didn't interest him, languages among them, which required memorizing. He had no syndromes. He wasn't autistic. He was extremely handsome in his youth, and a ladies' man. He had a normal brain at postmortem, interestingly--in the 1950's.
homeschoolmom Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 I can hardly wait to live in a world were everyone is perfect. [/sarcasm]
Slappo Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1752091' date='Jan 15 2009, 01:42 PM']but we should stop think about Einstein and Mozart and think about every day people like Cath and John. [/quote] Too true, the einstein/mozart/bach argument against abortion is HORRIBLE as it is based on what that person can provide in talents as opposed to what that person is by nature, which is the image and likeness of God. Basically those arguments objectify people and are the starts of basing worth of a person on capability. "You could be aborting the guy that invents the cure for aids!" well... if you knew he wasn't does that then make it acceptable?.... bad argument.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now