Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1754829' date='Jan 18 2009, 10:32 PM']I don't think hosts used today have 'crumbs.' If I were given a chunk of bread for communion, of course I would be very careful not to lose crumbs of it. But examining your hands for tiny particles...where and when are we instructed to do that?

Eucharistic ministers are instructed:


If you see a host (or portion of a host) fall to the ground, then yes, you should not ignore it. Likewise, you should be very careful not to drop the host.



But I have never received any instruction to carefully inspect my hands, nor have I observed others doing this.[/quote]
there ARE 'crumbs' on hosts today, they're just really little. :)

my dad inspects his hands every time after he receives Communion and has done that for years. I remember being little and watching him after we got back in the pew and wondering why he would stare at his hands when he kneeled back down. on occasion he would bring his hand up to his mouth as if he was kissing it. I now understand that when he did that, it meant he found a particle from the host on his hands. though I didn't understand it when I was little, now I find it incredible that my dad has such a deep love and respect for the Eucharist - that he wouldn't want even a crumb to fall to the ground.

Roamin'Catholic
Posted

Follow Pope Benedict's lead: he only gives out communion on the tongue while the communicant is kneeling. You are not allowed to recieve communion from Pope Benedict in the hand.
This is not done by accident, but is very intentional. All priest and and extraordinary ministers should mimic the Holy Father in this respect.
Also, the reception of communion in the hand is allowed through one of the most egrigious of loop holes, and is supposed to be the exception, not the rule when it comes to receiving communion. (Unfortunately, it has become the rule and not the exception.)
If you've had your tongue surgically removed then perhaps it is appropriate to receive in ones hands.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1754847' date='Jan 18 2009, 11:45 PM']I would think that his opinion as a Saint, as well as a Father and Doctor of the Church, is more valuable on the matter than yours is. :)[/quote]

Well, it may be valuable and worthy of consideration in the context of when he lived and the culture of Church and society at that time and who his audience was. Advice intended for monks and nuns is usually not practical for husbands and wives. Still, saints are sinners before they get to heaven and sometimes they were wrong.

On the matter we're discussion, I'm not saying its wrong to inspect your hands after receiving Communion. I'm disagreeing with the logic of quoting a saint to "prove" one's position. Why not quote current Church teaching on the matter? Have any bishops or cardinals written on it? What does the Congregation for Divine Worship say?

In my opinion, it's very easy to become scrupulous in things like this. It's one thing if you inspect your hands out of a deep and sincere love for Christ. I agree that's very admirable and beautiful, but the beauty of it is the tenderness and love that are being given to Christ. To hold up that practice and say all laypeople need to do the same thing is stripping the action from the very heart of what makes it an admirable and beautiful devotion. Then it becomes empty and vain, and God doesn't look kindly on that kind of worship.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Roamin'Catholic' post='1755165' date='Jan 19 2009, 11:05 AM']Also, the reception of communion in the hand is allowed through one of the most egrigious of loop holes, and is supposed to be the exception, not the rule when it comes to receiving communion.[/quote]

On the other hand (pardon the pun), Desmond has said how the Church tried for nearly a century before Vatican II to encourage more frequent reception of the Eucharist among the faithful. In working towards that goal, the allowance of Communion in the hand did exactly what it needed to do. Of course, there have been other problems, and now people go to Confession like they used to receive Communion. But that's how things go... from one extreme to the other.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1755178' date='Jan 19 2009, 11:31 AM']On the other hand (pardon the pun), Desmond has mentioned how the Church tried for nearly a centry before Vatican II to encourage more frequent reception of the Eucharist among the faithful. In working towards that goal, the allowance of Communion in the hand did exactly what it needed to do. Of course, there have been other problems, and now people go to Confession like they used to receive Communion. But that's how things go... from one extreme to the other.[/quote]
Exactly. Each age seems to be a mirror opposite of the last. Do you think we could actually ready to go back to orthodoxy????? :smokey:

Posted

Receiving communion on the tongue is certainly very appropriate, especially if it can be done without dropping the host.

But receiving in the hand is also very much licit. To suggest that it is only appropriate if there is something wrong with your tongue is, quite simply -- wrong.

The 'loophole' you speak of was leaving it up to the discretion of the local bishops. Those in the US opted for communion on either the tongue or in the hand to be appropriate. If the US bishops decide to follow the lead of the pope, then yes, perhaps communion on the tongue will be the only appropriate way of receiving in the future. But that isn't the situation now. Allowing both species to be available is also something that was left up to the discretion of the local bishops. Or perhaps you'd rather the precious blood not be available at 'normal' masses?


To reiterate, receiving on the tongue is perfectly acceptable and appropriate, as long is it is done in a reverent way (ie, regularly dropping the host would be....bad).

Receiving on the hand is [i]also acceptable[/i], again, as long as appropriate reverence is shown. Inspecting the hands is fine, though again, I don't see this as...necessary. I mean, sure, who doesn't look at their hands when bringing the host to your mouth?

Roamin'Catholic
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1755182' date='Jan 19 2009, 11:37 AM']The 'loophole' you speak of was leaving it up to the discretion of the local bishops. Those in the US opted for communion on either the tongue or in the hand to be appropriate.[/quote]

Lets take a look at the instruction 'Memoriale Domini' that was published in 1969, which allows for this "loophole".

After recalling the development of the reception of Communion on the tongue as a fruit of "a deepening understanding of the truth of the Eucharistic mystery, of its power and of the presence of Christ in it", the Instruction declares that "this method of distributing Holy Communion must be retained... not merely because it has many centuries of tradition behind it, but especially because it expresses the faithful's reverence for the Eucharist.

"The custom does not detract in any way from the personal dignity of those who approach this great sacrament: it is part of that preparation that is needed for the most fruitful reception of the Body of the Lord," it said.

It also warned: "A change in a matter of such moment, based on a most ancient and venerable tradition, does not merely affect discipline. It carries certain dangers with it which may arise from the new manner of administering Holy Communion: the danger of a loss of reverence for the august sacrament of the altar, of profanation, of adulterating the true doctrine."

And it published a survey of the world's bishops, which led it to conclude: "The vast majority of bishops believe that the present discipline should not be changed, and that if it were, the change would be offensive to the sentiments and the spiritual culture of these bishops and of many of the faithful."

For this reason it reported: "The Holy Father has decided not to change the existing way of administering Holy Communion to the faithful." So, given that Communion in the hand is now practically universal and younger generations know practically nothing else, what happened?

A "loophole" existed. The Instruction contained the provision for bishops' conferences to make a decision to allow Communion in the hand in places where "contrary usage... prevails". And over the coming decade or so this loophole was exploited.

Today, the Instruction's warnings about loss of reverence for, belief in and even the profanation of the Blessed Sacrament have - sadly - been vindicated. It is time to look again at the question of Communion in the hand.

There is, of course, no question that - as Memoriale Domini itself attests - it is "true that ancient usage once allowed the faithful to take this divine food in their hands and to place it in their mouths themselves".

This fact was much flaunted throughout the 1970s, together with talk about receiving Holy Communion as mature adults, and not as children. We were encouraged to return to the primitive purity of early Church practice as we emerged from centuries of supposedly corrupt accretion in the way we worshipped.

However, in our egalitarian excitement we ignored the sober facts that, the "organic development" of the practice of receiving Communion on the tongue is nothing other than "a fruit of the spirituality and Eucharistic devotion stemming from the times of the Fathers of the Church", and that the exclusion of kneeling for Holy Communion was a feature of the Protestant theological revolt of both Calvin and Zwingli.

Indeed, no less a scholar than Klaus Gamber points out that the reception of Communion in the hand "was in fact abandoned... from the fifth or sixth century onwards".

The Church as she proceeds through time accrues wisdom. Her Sacred Liturgy, developed in tradition, is a privileged repository of the same. All but the most partisan liturgists today recognise that many of the hasty decisions taken in respect of liturgical reform and practice in the Sixties and Seventies were infected by an antiquarianism that was at best naïve and at worst unbalanced. It is time to reconsider some if not many of those decisions and to take decisive steps to correct them where necessary. Communion in the hand is one such.

Archbishop Malcolm Ranjith, a true prophet of the liturgical reform of Benedict XVI, writes in the preface to the new book Dominus Est: "I think it is time to evaluate carefully the practice of Communion in the hand and, if necessary, to abandon what was never actually called for in the Vatican II document Sacrosanctum Concilium nor by the Council Fathers but was... 'accepted' after it was introduced as an abuse in some countries."


That receiving communion on the tongue only will provoke backlash is unfortunate, for the practice it advocates is a practice of love and of humility, one from which no one who truly adores Christ present in the Blessed Sacrament ought to recoil.

But perhaps today some controversy is necessary. Future generations, though, may well wonder why we took so long to realise that it is, indeed, the Lord, and once again to behave accordingly.

This is 2009. Benedict XVI is the Pope. The Holy Father has himself already reformed the manner of reception of Holy Communion at the Masses he celebrates. Let us follow his example. It accords with the teaching of Pope Paul VI.

Edited by Roamin'Catholic
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1754806' date='Jan 18 2009, 09:59 PM']Except at Communion, it's better to give more tongue...[/quote]


That's a bit gross...and I didn't laugh.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1755179' date='Jan 19 2009, 11:32 AM']Exactly. Each age seems to be a mirror opposite of the last. Do you think we could actually ready to go back to orthodoxy????? :smokey:[/quote]

When was the last time true orthodoxy prevailed? By that, I mean a heart-felt devotion to orthodoxy among laypeople, and not just the appearances of it that have plagued most of Western Catholicism since at least the Industrial Revolution?

[quote name='Roamin'Catholic' post='1755191' date='Jan 19 2009, 12:07 PM']Archbishop Malcolm Ranjith, a true prophet of the liturgical reform of Benedict XVI, writes in the preface to the new book Dominus Est: "I think it is time to evaluate carefully the practice of Communion in the hand and, if necessary, to abandon what was never actually called for in the Vatican II document Sacrosanctum Concilium nor by the Council Fathers but was... 'accepted' after it was introduced as an abuse in some countries."[/quote]

I'm sure he's right. That doesn't mean anything will happen soon, though. It's taken most of our lifetimes just to get a revised English Missal approved.

[quote name='Roamin'Catholic' post='1755191' date='Jan 19 2009, 12:07 PM']That receiving communion on the tongue only will provoke backlash is unfortunate, for the practice it advocates is a practice of love and of humility, one from which no one who truly adores Christ present in the Blessed Sacrament ought to recoil.[/quote]

Part of the reason there would be so much rebellion is the confusion that results from our bishops permitting something and then taking it back a few decades later. This is what some parishes in Louisville are complaining about. The archbishop is requiring kneelers in all parishes and a lot of people simply don't understand why they were allowed to worship without kneelers only three decades ago, allowed to build churches and install pews without kneelers, and now there's an about face. It leaves a lot of people dumbfounded, and we are talking about the kind of Catholics who aren't all that trusting of their bishops to begin with. So instead of building up what little trust remains, even that is damaged.

But at the end of the day, it's the bishops' call. I say this just to show that there are other considerations they need to keep in mind. These decisions are never as simple as we make them with our narrowly-focused agendas.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='walburga' post='1755211' date='Jan 19 2009, 12:41 PM'][quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1754806' date='Jan 18 2009, 09:59 PM']
Except at Communion, it's better to give more tongue...[/quote]


That's a bit gross...and I didn't laugh.
[/quote]

It's true though... you gotta stick that tongue out Mike Jaegger style if you don't want the host to fall.

I'm exaggerating, obviously, but doing it right just about feels that way when you're not used it.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1755368' date='Jan 19 2009, 03:17 PM']When was the last time true orthodoxy prevailed? By that, I mean a heart-felt devotion to orthodoxy among laypeople, and not just the appearances of it that have plagued most of Western Catholicism since at least the Industrial Revolution?



I'm sure he's right. That doesn't mean anything will happen soon, though. It's taken most of our lifetimes just to get a revised English Missal approved.



Part of the reason there would be so much rebellion is the confusion that results from our bishops permitting something and then taking it back a few decades later. This is what some parishes in Louisville are complaining about. The archbishop is requiring kneelers in all parishes and a lot of people simply don't understand why they were allowed to worship without kneelers only three decades ago, allowed to build churches and install pews without kneelers, and now there's an about face. It leaves a lot of people dumbfounded, and we are talking about the kind of Catholics who aren't all that trusting of their bishops to begin with. So instead of building up what little trust remains, even that is damaged.

But at the end of the day, it's the bishops' call. I say this just to show that there are other considerations they need to keep in mind. These decisions are never as simple as we make them with our narrowly-focused agendas.[/quote]

Is it better to let an abuse continue just because we have been doing it, or get back on the right track? Don't you think we had any anguish when this stuff was suddenly taken away from us??

Posted

Communion in the hand is not an "abuse." I realize that other changes/practices are, but this one is not.

Posted

Walburga,

Speak with your priest. That's the only advice I can give. The priest and deacons at my parish know that I receive on the tongue so they've gotten pretty used to it. If you can sit toward the front, first pew if possible, it may be less confusion for the priest if you are one of the first to receive. Priests, Deacons, and EMHCs can just get into the habit of everyone receiving in the hands in a communion line and then someone receiving on the tongue comes up and they get a little thrown off. If you are one of the first to go up some of the confusion could be avoided.


God Bless,
Jennie

Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1755407' date='Jan 19 2009, 03:45 PM']Walburga

I might talk to our priest. He's not confused at all. I belong to a very small parish in a very small town and it is also a very... um, 'traditional' sort of parish. Our pastor knows my personally. Many people in our parish receive Communion on the tongue. There is one woman who not only kneels on the floor, but after she receives Communion, crawls away on her knees. SHE sits in the front pew and that way, there is less chance of someone who may be unsuspecting, tripping over her. One of my best friends receives kneeling. I would too, but it's pretty awkward for the person behind you. The point is, in my parish, people receive Communion in a variety of ways. Our pastor has only been here two weeks and he's already got it down. As I say, there are really only a few of us! The problem is not that I don't know what I'm doing or that he doesn't know what I'm doing or that he doesn't know what he's doing... I think it is that the Host is too big. I believe where I was this summer the Host was generally smaller. For certain the priests Host was. When I recieve the very smallest part of the priest's host (usually on a day that I'm the cantor), it's no problem. When I recieve the regular Host or the larger part of the priest's host, there's a little danger. I think my mouth is just too small or something.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
have you tried practicing in front of a mirror? i know it's awkward, but it made me realize that i probably was not opening my mouth wide enough for the priest to put the Host on my tongue properly.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1755390' date='Jan 19 2009, 03:30 PM']Is it better to let an abuse continue just because we have been doing it, or get back on the right track? Don't you think we had any anguish when this stuff was suddenly taken away from us??[/quote]

Some Catholics felt that way, but the prevailing opinion appears to be in favor of the changes that happened.

Let the bishops take care of us. The best thing about being Catholic is we can let go of this kind of stuff. Besides, it's not like you are not allowed to receive Communion on the tongue or kneeling. Some priests may throw a hissy fit... if that bothers you, take your complaint to one of the martyrs in heaven. Or tell CatholicWing in Pakistan what a hard time you're having. I think all of us in America (myself included) are just plain spoiled.

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

As long as there are catechists that teach the beauty and the depth of the Eucharist in the first place, I think whichever way is fine, as long as it is reverent. I prefer to receive on the tongue just because I really don't feel worthy to hold Him in my hands. I was even an extraordinary Eucharistic minister for several years and I felt rather uncomfortable holding Christ in my hand. By the end of communion, my hands would be shaking!

Receiving Christ in the Holy Eucharist calls for reverence and deep love for Him. I don't think it matters which way you receive, as long as it is done in love and for reverence for Him.

Out of all the people who I know that receive on the hand (which is many) there has only been one through the years that would inspect her hands after receiving to make sure there was no fragment of Jesus left there. She is trying to start a religious community.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1756290' date='Jan 20 2009, 10:42 AM']Some Catholics felt that way, but the prevailing opinion appears to be in favor of the changes that happened.[/quote]


You obviously were not there when the changes happened or you wouldn't say this. People were very upset then their churches were "modernized". We were not given a choice, the priest/bishop simply went ahead and did it. The high altars were taken away, the altar rails removed, the statues of the saints removed. All the traditional activities disappeared - May Crownings, Forty Hours etc. New churches that were built looked like the local union hall with a crucifix. We weren't asked if we wanted Communion in the Hand or told that we could still receive on the tongue. It just was announced and it changed.
The prevailing opinion now agrees with it because they are the ones who didn't leave the church because of it or join the SSPX type people. Or they joined the orthodox, or gave up altogether. Between Humane Vitae and the all the changes there was a mass exodus of catholics.
I have been in the same parish for 50 years, and I remember what it was then and now. Only in the last couple of priests have the statues come back, and the large crucifix etc. Unfortunately I'm in the inner city and there are no young people left to see it. When we close we will have to go to one of those incredibly boring and ugly new buildings.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1755393' date='Jan 19 2009, 03:38 PM']Communion in the hand is not an "abuse." I realize that other changes/practices are, but this one is not.[/quote]
I was not referring to it as an abuse. I am simply lumping it with all the other progessive "changes" that fell upon the church.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1756337' date='Jan 20 2009, 12:15 PM']You obviously were not there when the changes happened or you wouldn't say this. People were very upset then their churches were "modernized". We were not given a choice, the priest/bishop simply went ahead and did it. The high altars were taken away, the altar rails removed, the statues of the saints removed. All the traditional activities disappeared - May Crownings, Forty Hours etc. New churches that were built looked like the local union hall with a crucifix. We weren't asked if we wanted Communion in the Hand or told that we could still receive on the tongue. It just was announced and it changed.
The prevailing opinion now agrees with it because they are the ones who didn't leave the church because of it or join the SSPX type people. Or they joined the orthodox, or gave up altogether. Between Humane Vitae and the all the changes there was a mass exodus of catholics.
I have been in the same parish for 50 years, and I remember what it was then and now. Only in the last couple of priests have the statues come back, and the large crucifix etc. Unfortunately I'm in the inner city and there are no young people left to see it. When we close we will have to go to one of those incredibly boring and ugly new buildings.[/quote]

I wasn't alive back then, so I can only go by what I've observed. If the majority of Catholics cared so much, why didn't they challenge their priests and bishops when these things happened? Why was it acceptable to challenge the Pope on [i]Humanae Vitae[/i] but not the parish priest when he removes the high altar? The math doesn't add up. I'm convinced the Church was in a bad way long before Vatican II. Seems every traditionally-minded Catholics points the finger at Vatican II yet it seems none will simply ask the next logical question, "Why was Vatican II called?" Ecumenical councils are called to address real concerns. So, what were those concerns?

Edited by LouisvilleFan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...