the lords sheep Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 I can only answer quickly, but I'll be happy to give a more in depth answer later. I've read the VM as part of a presentation that I gave about the Catholic reaction to this kind of femminism when people wanted to present these on my campus. For now, two points will suffice. 1. While the VM proclaims to be promoting the cause to not abuse women (all proceeds from VM go to battered women's shelters), in actuality, the play does no such thing. Eve Ensler (the author) in her introduction to the book states something along the lines of "I wanted to discover my Vagina". As you continue to read, it becomes progressively clearer that this is not about women in general: it's her own perverted search for femininity. 2. The other main issue with this book is that the book is not about women. It's about vaginas. It was a vagina that was raped, not a woman. It was a vagina that was abused, used, and hated, not a woman. In an afterthought, Eve Ensler added a vagina that gave birth, but didn't really bother to mention of the mother who had just had a child. Our culture is so upside down that women are turning to this play and using it to define their femininity. They have no idea what their true dignity as woman is, so instead they let this pornographic piece of entertainment tell them! They are their vaginas. If you'd like, I have the speech that I delivered about the Catholic dignity of woman against the VM. I'd have to find it, but you'd be welcome to it. In Christ, Lauren ps- As far as things to do against it, try to counter their "good" with good. One of the main arguments is that "well, it's for a good cause." So whatever you do, associate a charity somehow with it. For example, show a movie and ask people to give a donation or sell candy with the proceeds going elsewhere.
Jesus_lol Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 ^wow, that was a quick reply? you must have machine gun fingers! cant wait to see the indepth.
Tinkerlina Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1755665' date='Jan 19 2009, 05:46 PM']I agree with Christopher West, too - disapproving of it is fine, but if all we do is say, "No," it isn't clear what we are saying "Yes" to. So, that's your club's job - to somehow spread the word that women have value and can be healed. Not sure how you go about doing that... I know you aren't a religious group, per se, so handing out pamplets of the story of the woman at the well (or a reflection on that passage) isn't necessarily appropriate. I don't know if there is another 'response' you could use.[/quote] Excellent response. I think many of the [i]intention[/i]s behind the Vagina Monologues are good. I think celebrating femininity is great and I think, although from what I've heard the play is unnecessarily explicit, I think that the idea of knowing one's body and not being ashamed/embarrassed is good too. I agree that the club should try to focus on positive things and show that the values your club embraces are pro woman. Good luck to you!-Katie
tinytherese Posted January 22, 2009 Author Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='the lords sheep' post='1758054' date='Jan 21 2009, 08:19 PM']Our culture is so upside down that women are turning to this play and using it to define their femininity. They have no idea what their true dignity as woman is, so instead they let this pornographic piece of entertainment tell them! They are their vaginas.[/quote] I totally agree. It's so sad how good intentions can go so awry. What I find disturbing, is that this one woman that works at the Moss House for battered women in town leads the youth group at the only catholic parish in town! So could you please send me your speech? Maybe if I show it to her and explain to her what these monologues are really all about then she won't accept the donations that it will raise. Well anyway, please pray for us.
Galloglasses' Alt Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) EDIT: Had no idea what I was talking about here. Edited January 22, 2009 by Galloglasses' Alt
the lords sheep Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 This is the second of two speeches given regarding the Vagina Monologues at my school. The time was meant to be a discussion between the Catholic voice and those who supported the VM, so it's very short as time was left for questions. I've also attached it so you could get the footnotes. ***** Our discussion today centers around The Vagina Monologues, a drama written by Eve Ensler, and the Catholic objections to the play’s content. As background, if you are unfamiliar with the work, the play is a series of acts which highlight events in the histories of a variety of vaginas. The principle characters of the monologues are, as the title suggests, vaginas: vaginas which think, feel, remember, and suffer. Through the course of the play, different vaginas speak in explicit detail of their sexual experiences with both men and women, the times when they were raped and abused, their preferences and fantasies, and their fears and desires. The play is performed throughout the world, allowing the vaginas to testify to their joys and traumas on a global scale while simultaneously raising money for victims of sexual and physical abuse. “So what,” you ask, “is the objection to the play? The premise is simple enough, and the organization does do good work by giving to charity.” My answer is this: the principle problem that Catholics find in Eve Ensler’s play, The Vagina Monologues, is not the immoral behavior such as promiscuity or homosexual relations which is graphically described throughout the performance. It is likewise not, as the organization which promotes it, V-day, believes, with the supposed vulgarity of the frequent references to the vagina, clitoris, and other parts of the female anatomy. While one cannot ignore the fact that the play could be classified as pornographic material, even this is not the source of our criticism. Rather, the Catholic objection to the Vagina Monologues lies in the ideology which pervades the entire drama, expressed succinctly by the V-Day Foundation’s website: “The word ‘vagina’ is indeed used frequently in the play – to break the silence and the censorship of a word that does indeed represent women both physically and metaphysically as a feminine being.” The “vagina…represent(s) women both physically and metaphysically as a feminine being.” An interesting premise. The play- and the entire movement which surrounds it- is promoting an ideology which, in the name of promoting and protecting women, successfully reduces woman in her essence- her deepest self, her inmost core, her very soul- to nothing more than her feminine anatomy. It disgusts me that this organization believes that the essence of my femininity can be reduced to my genitalia. Furthermore, I refuse to present myself to others as my vagina, for I am so much more than that; I am a woman- a person who thinks, who feels, who dreams, who suffers, who gives love, and who is capable of receiving love in return. Yet, according the Vagina Monologues and the V-Day organization, I am my vagina! The self-defined purpose of The Vagina Monologues is to raise awareness and bring an end to the sexual violence. But the organization seeks to counter sexual violence by objectifying women according to their physiology. Do they not understand that sexual crimes are committed against women because women are seen by their violators as a means to an end? To her violator, a woman is merely a thing to be used, something to be dominated and taken advantage of and then cast aside because she has no value outside of the gratification she provides! Eve Ensler and the V-Day foundation fail to recognize their misjudgment, and instead they encourage women to embrace their vaginas, proclaiming, “[i]f you can't say [vagina], then you can't own it. If you can't own it, then you can't protect it. If it's violated, you can't protest or complain.” This distorted ideology actually posits my very right to protest against sexual violation lies with my ability to correctly and unashamedly identify the various part of my own anatomy. The answer to objectification by others is not self-objectification! The only response is to inhere in women, in our culture, a true sense of femininity and the very genius of woman. Embracing my femininity is not accomplished through claiming my own sexual organs or of the freedom to flaunt my sexuality, as those who propagate the Vagina Monologues might suggest. In fact, it cannot, because I am not a body, I am a person. The true essence of femininity, the dignity of woman, can only be discovered by examining woman’s origin and end: namely that woman was created by God (her origin) to receive love and to give love (her end). She is to give herself freely to others by loving them and offer herself wholeheartedly to others so that they may love her. Therefore, her dignity, her true femininity is not based in her physiology, but found in her selflessness, in her gift. The culture which has embraced the Vagina Monologues has been deceived. This drama will never successfully combat sexual violence against women, because it buys into the very ideology that allows women to be violated. The Catholic Church has taken a stance against the Vagina Monologues because it recognizes that a message which allows for and promotes objectification of women, even in the name of helping them, is a destructive message. Rather than charging her to claim her femininity through “becoming” her anatomy, the Church calls her to find her femininity by recognizing herself as the gift which God created her to be.
the lords sheep Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 (edited) TinyTherese, My pleasure. I can't seem to attach anymore, but I have 2 more documents that may interest you: one is a more theological version of the above talk, a second are my notes from another speech given in response to the VM. If you PM me your email address, I'll be sure to get them to you. In Christ, Lauren Edited January 23, 2009 by the lords sheep
DevotedtoHim Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 I think the speech by Christopher West was really good and profound. The idea of setting up something as an alternative is a really good one. You could either do something about searching for "real love" or something about the dignity of women. If you wanted to make it Catholic, you could say the Rosary or something along those lines. You could also have a pot luck dinner for the battered womens shelter since this is supposed to be a night of supporting women. Katherine
tinytherese Posted January 23, 2009 Author Posted January 23, 2009 (edited) I was thinking about that gospel story of the woman at the well and the Bridgegroom that her heart really longed for yesterday. I remember reading about this one guy who literally dressed up as God's gift to women for Halloween with a tag on him that said "To: Women From: God." But the real God's Gift to Women would be His Son Jesus who gave of Himself totally completely and unreservedly on the cross for all women (and men too.) I've been thinking, the first "boyfriend" that a girl should have is Jesus who is the one that gives her everything that she truly desires and needs. Setting the example of how men should treat her. "If He does not love you like I do, if he does not give up himself for you, if he is not willing to sacrifice and even die for you as I did fo you on the cross, if he does not treat you with dignity as a woman and as a child of God and if he does not remain faithful to you as I have, I who promise to be with you until the end of the age, then he does not truly love you." He should be the one that every woman should seek when looking for and choosing a husband. I'm concerned about how to go about talking to the woman at Moss House though. Maybe talking to Fr. about his will help and he'll have some advice. Edited January 23, 2009 by tinytherese
MithLuin Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 The way you talk to anyone - be respectful and do not condemn her or make any assumptions about what she might be thinking. But yes, getting advice is always good. Your post puts me in mind of a cartoon (not one that exists, but I mean, I thought of one when I read it): Jesus, as a young boy, proudly announcing to his mother, "I'm God's gift to the world!" and Mary responding with a very placid, "That's true, dear, but you still have to....."
tinytherese Posted January 24, 2009 Author Posted January 24, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1759485' date='Jan 23 2009, 06:04 PM']Your post puts me in mind of a cartoon (not one that exists, but I mean, I thought of one when I read it): Jesus, as a young boy, proudly announcing to his mother, "I'm God's gift to the world!" and Mary responding with a very placid, "That's true, dear, but you still have to....."[/quote] Aww, that is cute. All of the cute and funny stories that Mary could tell us about Him growing up.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now