Guest nvzbl Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [url="http://artlaction.com/release/20081012/john-mccains-tragic-pro-abortion-record"]http://artlaction.com/release/20081012/joh...abortion-record[/url]
Winchester Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 They're all pro-gettingreelected. That's all [i]any [/i]of them care about.
Tinkerlina Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1757092' date='Jan 20 2009, 10:54 PM']They're all pro-gettingreelected. That's all [i]any [/i]of them care about.[/quote] Too true. -Katie
MithLuin Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 It's a matter of degree. McCain was certainly [i]not[/i] 100% pro-life (though Palin may very well have been). McCain, however, was 'mostly' pro-life, and would only be considered 'pro-choice' in comparison to, say, Huckabee. In a comparison between McCain and Obama (based on voting records), McCain was clearly the pro-life candidate. Not as pro-life as, say, Santorum was, though. When speaking of specific bills, there is often a lot of variation among politicians - they don't always vote consistently on life issues, for various reasons.
Guest nvzbl Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 wondering, what bills was it that obama voted on in reference to abortion? versus mccain?
rkwright Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 Obama was either a co-author or co-sponser of a bill called the freedom of choice act. An act that would greatly increase funding and access to abortions. I don't know anything off the top of my head of what he voted for, but the above alone puts him strongly at odds with the pro-life movement. You may try the election section of these boards, they might still have that info there.
Guest nvzbl Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 no, but my point was, who were we suppose to vote for if both candidates were pro-choice? the better one?
MithLuin Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 The one who wasn't really pro-choice. McCain had a mixed record - he voted for some legislation that was viewed as pro-life, and some that was viewed as pro-choice. Whereas Obama - strictly voted pro-choice, no matter how extreme. So, the born-alive infant thing...a bill that was meant to say that a baby born after an abortion (really - induced labor before viability) should be treated as any other patient in the hospital, not left in a room to die. Did Obama vote for this? No. Consistently. The website you linked above was trying to make the point that there was 'no difference' between McCain and Obama's stances - it was very misleading. Look into the actual voting record of each at a more reputable site, and you'll see the difference.
dairygirl4u2c Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 he said he wanted Roe preserved, cause the alternative would be women in back allys. he said this on several occasions within a few years apart. he's also said that people who vote on abortion only, are making and "unintelligent" decision. he wanted prochoice VPs as his first two picks, when running, but only picked Palin cause of party pressure.
CatholicCid Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 Bishops' Vann and Farrell released a joint letter to their Dioceses, which dust had on the front page, discussing such a situation: [quote]5. Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship, in paragraphs 34-37, addresses the question of whether it is morally permissible for a Catholic to vote for a candidate who supports an intrinsic evil – even when the voter does not agree with the candidate's position on that evil. The only moral possibilities for a Catholic to be able to vote in good conscience for a candidate who supports this intrinsic evil are the following: a. If both candidates running for office support abortion or "abortion rights," a Catholic would be forced to then look at the other important issues and through their vote try to limit the evil done; or, b. If another intrinsic evil outweighs the evil of abortion. While this is sound moral reasoning, there are no "truly grave moral" or "proportionate" reasons, singularly or combined, that could outweigh the millions of innocent human lives that are directly killed by legal abortion each year. To vote for a candidate who supports the intrinsic evil of abortion or "abortion rights" when there is a morally acceptable alternative would be to cooperate in the evil – and, therefore, morally impermissible.[/quote] [url="http://www.prolifedallas.org/pages/Joint_Statement"]http://www.prolifedallas.org/pages/Joint_Statement[/url]
Guest nvzbl Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 (i honestly) dont know the difference in who voted for what. (im asking questions more than anything) i know obama is pro-choice. i dont know every specific bill he voted for. but i always figured mccain was pro-life since everybody hated obama instead. but mccain isnt the next best available option either tho. (it seems like)
Guest nvzbl Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1757272' date='Jan 20 2009, 11:48 PM']Bishops' Vann and Farrell released a joint letter to their Dioceses, which dust had on the front page, discussing such a situation: [url="http://www.prolifedallas.org/pages/Joint_Statement"]http://www.prolifedallas.org/pages/Joint_Statement[/url][/quote] so is it mccains inconsistency what triggered Catholics to vote for him? as in the bills he voted for didnt follow a certain or prolife or prochoice?
CatholicCid Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 On the pro-life issues, I would consider him the lesser of the two major candidates when it comes to supporting abortion. McCain might not have an extremely or entirely pro-life record, but it seems to be much better in comparison to Obama's record. Or, in reference to Point a of what I quoted, voting for McCain seemed to be attempting to limit evil in the subject of the intrinsic evil of abortion. He might not be the most pro-life, but his stance was much better on this issue then compared to the other major candidate.
Saint Therese Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='nvzbl' post='1757201' date='Jan 20 2009, 11:01 PM']no, but my point was, who were we suppose to vote for if both candidates were pro-choice? the better one?[/quote] I'd vote for Mother Angelica.
havok579257 Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 mccain only changed his views to get the conservative vote. he was not pro-life. Obama is worse but Mccain is bad. I always hated the term, the lesser of the two evils. There are more than just 2 canidates in elections. If every Catholic, christian, morman, juhova's witness, latter day saint, amish and so on who are all pro-life voted for a TRUE pro-life canidate, even if he was a 3rd party canidate, would make a huge impact. Maybe not win the election, but set in montion for a 3rd party, true pro-life cnaidate to win the presidency a few years down the road.
CatholicCid Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 That's why I stated "two major candidates." I also always found it interesting that the letter I quoted referred to "both candidates", not "all candidates". I believe one could rightfully vote for a 3rd party candidate if they believe the person has an actual chance at winning the election, but I just did not believe that for any of the 3rd party candidates. So, if it comes down to bad or worse, I think I'll go with bad if I must choose.
Archaeology cat Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1757429' date='Jan 21 2009, 06:17 AM']I always hated the term, the lesser of the two evils. There are more than just 2 canidates in elections. If every Catholic, christian, morman, juhova's witness, latter day saint, amish and so on who are all pro-life voted for a TRUE pro-life canidate, even if he was a 3rd party canidate, would make a huge impact. Maybe not win the election, but set in montion for a 3rd party, true pro-life cnaidate to win the presidency a few years down the road.[/quote]
Didacus Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1757092' date='Jan 20 2009, 10:54 PM']They're all pro-gettingreelected. That's all [i]any [/i]of them care about.[/quote] Long live democracy.
princessgianna Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1757414' date='Jan 21 2009, 01:07 AM']I'd vote for Mother Angelica.[/quote] Nice!
dairygirl4u2c Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) that quote, mind you, above about how to vote, is just some texas bishops giving their opinions. voting based on what they said alone would lead to some very messed up situations, even, i'd argue, for someone who's attempting to be fully and faithfully catholic and that is their desire. here's a thread post i did here once, explaining that: [quote]Intrinsic Evil, Prudential Judgment the proper discussion about abortion isn't to start with, "it's intrisically wrong no matter what to vote for them when you vote despite them being prochoice, cause abortion is too large of a problem" the proper discussion, debate, is whether there's a significant liklihood that abortion's going to change. if you assume it's high enough, the liklihood is going to change, then you can go back to the instrinsic arguments, and it's not an unreasonable position, but your argument isn't so much about it being intrinsically wrong end-of-dicussion per se but that it's intrinsically wrong if abortion is significanlty likely to change. i don't have a beef with that argument. but if your position is that it's intinsically wrong, and that's all that matters, i believe you are mistaken. (not unreasonably so, but mistaken) here why: scenarios that illustrate that i find it hard to beleive you have to vote for the abortion change if it's not going to change (or you don't think it will, if that's the sitaution): notable flaws with the instrisic argument: -if a politician is prolife, but for sake of argument abortion isn't going to change..... do we have to vote for him if the counter politician is for stopping promotion of gay marriage and is likly to change? abortion is a whole lot bigger than gay marriage. isn't it justifying the means to vote for the person wanting to stop gay marriage? maybe not: at least in this situation, both are intrinsically evil, if you are going to vote for the gay marriage thing and disregard the abortion thing. i think it's justifying the means though, if you want to be techincal about it all. (and the only way around it is to say that sometimes it's okay to justify the means) -but if you did that, dont' all politicians believe something that's intrinsically evil, where that belief is unique to them? if that's the case, can't you justify voting for the prochoice if the one thing that's unique to them has a liklihood of change but the other larger bad stuff (all the hot button issues like gay marriage and abortion) like abortion doesn't? imagine a politician wanting to promote masturbation/contraception as a healthy lifestyle but is prolife, but abortion is gonig no where. the prochoice candidate is the hall mark of virtue in eveything else and perfect economically etc. if you can justify voting for a smaller intrinsic evil as per the earlier notion of abortion v. gay marriage, then you could here too with less hot button issues, ie vote against masturbation/contraception promotion despite voting for the prochoice person. the point being, beyond this hypotheitical, is that all politicians have something that they promote that's intrinsically evil that is unique to them. and so you could vote for hte prochoice person despite them prochoice if abortion isn't going to change-if you'd be for stopping that pro masturbation president, then you shouldn't be for stopping other smaller intrinsic evils if the larger won't change or don't think they will. -if you wouldn't be for voting against the promasturbation president, or against the progay marriage president, even though both are intrinsically evil, are you satisfied and do you seriously think it's wise to vote for an issue that's not going to change even though lots of other evils are changeable? are you saying you wouldn't vote to stop the smaller genocides in africa if we could, cause abortion is a lot lot larger genocide, even if abortion isn't going to change but africa would? are people seriously saying that is wise? the point, isn't so much per se that you can vote for them cause of the degree of intrinsic evil is high or low, it's that you can vote for them cause of hte liklihood of change is high enough to vote despite prochoice, or whatever intrinsic evil is being weighed. the point is i think definitely made: "abortion is the worst thing so that's all that matters" is not the rule like some catholic would have you believe (not voting to stop smaller genocides would be idiotic, sorry, but that's what i think). the rule depends on liklihood of change, at least insofar as comparing intrisic evils. intrinsic evil v. prudential judgment: i'd argue the rule depends on liklihood of change, for other things too. if you can justify voting against hte promasturbation president and the progay marriage president... it's only a small step more to say that you should be able to vote for a president who is prochoice but has everything else in line like prudential matters like economics (even if we assumed not all presidents have something uniquely instircally evil that they promote). -i'm someone who says it's okay to justify the means in certain situations, so it wouldn't matter to me even if it was justifying the means. (i don't think most people really believe the ends don't justify the means, even if they say it. if they had to kill someone innocent or lie or whatever to save millions, most would do it) -i don't think it's evil to begin with anyway. it's "remote cooperation with evil unless proporational reasons" according to the catholic church, to vote for the prochoice president despite prochioce. abortion not changing and the president being perfect in everything else is enough of a proportionate reason. you're not voting for them for their stance, it's not even a question of justifying the means. (and this is how a catholic could in good conscious vote for obama if they don't think abortion will change) -see, it's not wise to let the entire economy collapse, if that's what a prochoice president wanted and could fix, when abortion or some intrinsic evil wasn't going to change anyway. so at any rate,,, i think the hard and fast rule is shown to be flawed. the debate should be in liklihood of change for intrinsic evil X and Y. if you think the liklihood is high enough and not really a matter of debate, at least you presuppose liklihood matters, and i have no beef with you, as i said. only a beef with those who say liklihood doesn't matter.[/quote] Edited January 22, 2009 by dairygirl4u2c
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now