Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Modernizer Leads Contest To Head Russian Church


Recommended Posts

Posted

[size=2][b]Modernizer leads contest to head Russian Church[/b][/size]
[i]Sun Jan 25, 2009 2:01pm EST

FACTBOX: Three contenders for next Russian Patriarch

By Dmitry Solovyov[/i]

MOSCOW (Reuters) - Senior clergy from the Russian Orthodox church backed a modernizer who favors closer ties with the Vatican Sunday in the first round of voting to choose their first new patriarch since the fall of the Soviet Union.

Metropolitan Kirill of Smolensk and Kaliningrad, one of the most senior Russian clerics to have met the Roman Catholic pontiff, won the most votes in the church's Council of Bishops and enters the next round of voting as favorite.

But two other nominees were shortlisted for the final vote, which gets underway Tuesday, and religious scholars have said Kirill could face a backlash from traditionalists who may rally around another candidate to block him.

The Russian Orthodox church has been without a patriarch since Alexiy II -- who was chosen for the role in the dying days of the Soviet Union and oversaw a dramatic revival of the faith after Communism ended -- died last month.

Alexiy's critics accused him of allowing the church to fall under the sway of the Kremlin. Former President Vladimir Putin was regularly shown at the patriarch's side and the church held back from publicly criticizing the failings of Russia's leaders.

The new patriarch will lead a church of about 165 million believers worldwide and determine whether to repair ties with the Vatican that have been strained since a schism in 1054 split Christianity into eastern and western branches.

DIVINE GUIDANCE

Kirill, the church's 62-year-old top diplomat who raised hopes of a rapprochement by meeting Pope Benedict in the Vatican in December 2007, won 97 of the 197 valid votes cast.

Metropolitan Kliment of Kaluga and Borovsk, a 59-year-old head of the church's economic affairs widely regarded as the traditionalists' favored candidate, polled 32 votes.

Belarussian-based Metropolitan Filaret had 16 ballots. The 73-year-old cleric has good relations with the large Catholic community in Belarus and is also close to President Alexander Lukashenko, accused in the West of crushing democracy.

Earlier Sunday, the church's most senior clergy gathered in the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour, rebuilt on the site of an open-air swimming pool after the Communists blew up the original building.

"Thousands of churches and hundreds of monasteries across all our land have risen from ruins in less than 20 years, largely thanks to the devoted work of our deceased patriarch," said Kirill, who is acting head of the church.

"We cannot but understand the greatness of the task that faces us to be worthy of the memory of this great luminary of the Russian church," Kirill told the gathering of bearded senior clerics, dressed in black robes and cylindrical hats.

Voting in the final round could differ dramatically from the first ballot because it will be held in the church's Local Council -- which unlike the Bishop's Council includes laypeople and monks.

Alexiy II often accused the Vatican of trying to convert people with an Orthodox background to Catholicism and though he sent delegations to the Vatican, he himself resisted an historic meeting with the Pope.


Link: [url="http://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSTRE50O1CI20090125"][u]Modernizer leads contest to head Russian Church[/u][/url]

Posted

Cool!

I pray that whoever is elected will do a good job of leading the Russian people.

While I personally am hoping for more rapport between Russian Orthodoxy and the Vatican, I realize there are other concerns as well.

Posted

We should all pray for someone who will have the vision and courage to lead his people home.

Posted

while I want reunion, I wonder if there is anything more to this "modernizer" name given him than just his position on ties with the Vatican... I wouldn't support him if he was going to wreckovate his rite.

Posted

[b]No compromise of faith in dialog with other confessions[/b] - Metropolitan Kirill

Moscow, January 27, Interfax - The Russian Orthodox Church will not make any compromise with other Christian confessions as far as faith is concerned, and will hold a dialog with the most sensible of them, Patriarchal Locum Tenens Metropolitan Kirill said.

"I would like to emphasize that there can be no question about compromise of faith with other confessions... On the contrary, many other confessions are attracted particularly by our firmness in our Orthodox belief, our endurance under the pressure of various forces willing to weaken the Christian presence in the modern world," Metropolitan Kirill said while presenting his report to the Local Council at the Christ the Savior Cathedral on Tuesday.

This is exactly how "they see the hope for the revival of the Christianity in Europe and the world," he said.

"Our dialog with other confessions is aimed at supporting those partners who are ready to oppose, together with us, the marginalization of religion, to speak out for believers' rights and to build one's life according to one's own principles, to defend the underlying meaning of morality in the life of an individual and society," the Patriarchal Locum Tenens said.

"Today, Christianity is, on the one hand, experiencing the pressure of aggressive and ungodly secularism, which dominates Western society. On the other hand, it is suffering from a number of attempts by Protestant communities to radically review Christianity and the Gospel morality, which in effect facilitates the aforesaid secularist pressure," the hierarch said.

Posted

[b]Icon starts streaming myrrh at Cathedral of Christ the Savior[/b]

Moscow, January 27, Interfax - The Softener of Evil Hearts Mother of God Icon at the Cathedral of Christ the Savior in Moscow has started streaming myrrh.

Vesti television channel reported citing evidence of numerous churchgoers that the icon was "streaming myrrh very intensively."

In line with a long-standing church tradition, the icon has been specially brought to the Church Council meeting currently being held in Moscow, at which over 700 of its participants earlier cast their ballots to elect a new Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia.

A tabulation commission member is expected to announce the result of the voting within minutes.

Posted

Remarkable!? What does this mean?

Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1763520' date='Jan 27 2009, 11:55 AM']Remarkable!? What does this mean?[/quote]
I think, based on the particular icon involved, it is being interpreted as a sign that the ongoing religious renewal in Russia will continue under the next Patriarch.

Posted

[b]Metropolitan Kirill elected Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia[/b]

Moscow, January 27, Interfax - The delegates to the Church Council meeting under way in Moscow have elected Metropolitan Kirill of Smolensk and Kaliningrad the 16th Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia.

Metropolitan Kirill garnered 508 (72%) out of the 702 votes during the election on Tuesday. To be elected Patriarch, a candidate had to be supported by more than half of the delegates.

Another 169 votes (24%) went to Metropolitan Kliment of Kaluga and Borovsk.

Metropolitan Filaret of Minsk and Slutsk, who was also nominated for Patriarch by the Bishops' Council several days ago, had withdrawn from the elections in favor of Metropolitan Kirill about two hours before the voting.

Posted

Awwrite. God be with him :sign: Blessings on his important pastoral role.

Thanks for keeping us on top of this, Apo.

Posted

Wonderful :)

I would hope that reunification between East and West would not involve a compromise of faith, so I think Patriarch Kirill is setting a good note for the dialogue.

Of course, if 200 people voted for the person who didn't want any dialogue at all, he has his work cut out for him.

Posted (edited)

Coming back to full communion with Rome... Would that really have to mean 'comprimising faith'?
I mean the Eastern Catholics aren't identical to the Roman Rite, as I'm sure Apotheoun can tell us all about. How big are the differences? Are they cultural, or doctrinal, or both?
What barriers are left in the way of full communion?

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted

Doctrinally, there are a few issues. Hopefully someone will correct me if I miss any:

[indent]1) the [i]filioque[/i] in the Creed - the West says the Holy Spirit procedes from the Father [i]and the Son[/i], while the East does not include that phrase.

2) dogmas declared in the West after the separation of 1054 - papal infallibility and the Immaculate Conception, certainly

3) the primacy of Peter in Rome, and an understanding of the relationship of the pope with the other patriarchs - what 'first among equals' means at the present time would involve a lot of politics [/indent]


Culturally, there are other differences beyond the liturgy, such as the calendar used (what day we celebrate Christmas and Easter). Whether or not those will be left seperate or synthesized would be up to the Churches to decide. I imagine they would be left seperate (like the discipline of allowing married priests in the East, if they are married prior to ordination).

Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1764113' date='Jan 27 2009, 08:42 PM']Doctrinally, there are a few issues. Hopefully someone will correct me if I miss any:

[indent]1) the [i]filioque[/i] in the Creed - the West says the Holy Spirit procedes from the Father [i]and the Son[/i], while the East does not include that phrase.

2) dogmas declared in the West after the separation of 1054 - papal infallibility and the Immaculate Conception, certainly

3) the primacy of Peter in Rome, and an understanding of the relationship of the pope with the other patriarchs - what 'first among equals' means at the present time would involve a lot of politics [/indent]


Culturally, there are other differences beyond the liturgy, such as the calendar used (what day we celebrate Christmas and Easter). Whether or not those will be left seperate or synthesized would be up to the Churches to decide. I imagine they would be left seperate (like the discipline of allowing married priests in the East, if they are married prior to ordination).[/quote]
Hm... very interesting. Certainly challenges still.
The filioque I've never entirely understood, so I'll leave that for now. Biggest would probably be dogma that's been defined since then, since we're obviously not changing that.
Certainly tough. I can't even begin to speculate. I'll leave that to qualified people.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1764216' date='Jan 27 2009, 11:39 PM']Hm... very interesting. Certainly challenges still.
The filioque I've never entirely understood, so I'll leave that for now. Biggest would probably be dogma that's been defined since then, since we're obviously not changing that.
Certainly tough. I can't even begin to speculate. I'll leave that to qualified people.[/quote]
Honestly, I've never understood where we got the Filioque, and I'm not even entirely sure that I agree with the Church on it, but that's one of those things where I just submit and take the wisdom of those wiser than me, I guess.

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1764226' date='Jan 27 2009, 09:47 PM']Honestly, I've never understood where we got the Filioque, and I'm not even entirely sure that I agree with the Church on it, but that's one of those things where I just submit and take the wisdom of those wiser than me, I guess.[/quote]
I guess I know the most basic bit of it.........
but other than that it's entirely over my head. As far as I'm concerned, people far better than me have talked about it and will continue to talk about it, and it's never going to affect my own life.

Posted

It would probably take an ecumenical council of both Catholics and Orthodox to deal with 1 and 2. We have those because of councils they weren't really part of, so the only way to get them on board would be to have another council and redeclare those.

Assuming, of course, that the Orthodox would be interested in attending such a council. ;)

The [i]filioque[/i] has to do with an understanding of the roles of the three persons of the Trinity. Pretty significant, I guess. The Catholic understanding is that the Holy Spirit basically [i]is[/i] the loving relationship between the Father and the Son. That's why the Spirit is said to proceded from the Father and the Son. The Orthodox understanding is more like a triangle, with each point having a unique and distinct relationship to the other two persons. Having the Spirit procede from both the Father and the Son messes up the symmetry, and therefore is quite possibly philosophically messy.

I am certainly not a theologian, though, and probably have no business even talking about something so complex. [i]Way[/i] beyond me, and therefore doesn't really affect me at all. Honestly? If we decided to drop the [i]filioque[/i] it wouldn't upset me. I'd want the decision to be made for good theological reasons, though, not politics.

I don't think the Catholic Church is ready for another Council any time soon. We're still working out the last one from 50 years ago, and some people would see the opening of a new council as free reign to turn the faith upside down and inside out. But if we do enter into full communion with the Orthodox churches, I imagine the dialogue would have to reach that level...at some point. Unless we are willing to accept a bit of variation and diversity on some topics...like Marian dogma? Sounds unlikely.

But the practical issue of what the relationship between the churches in full communion would look like also has to be dealt with, and that probably is an area where an agreement can be reached between the bishops without a Council.

Posted

Pictures of the [url="http://www.mospat.ru/index.php?page=43988"][u]Opening of the Local Church Council of the Russian Orthodox Church[/u][/url].

Posted

Do you automatically get disqualified if you can't grow a BA beard?

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1764366' date='Jan 28 2009, 01:40 AM']Do you automatically get disqualified if you can't grow a BA beard?[/quote]


yes :mellow:

Everyone has a beard in Russia. A big bushy beard :unsure:


Anyone without one is shot on sight :shock:

I think the last fellow got attacked a lot for his deference tp Putin. Of course I'm not going to judge anyone who had to steer that Church through 90's Russia.

That and something about militias. :detective:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...